Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this is outrageous from the school?

288 replies

HarryViles · 09/05/2023 21:42

DS is just 4. He is at pre-school attached to a private school. He had an awful first few months there - very unsettled and unable to concentate - to the point where he is now on waiting list for ASD diagonsis as the pre-school's recommendation.

However, the last few months he has been doing so well. They have always been a little cold but they are professional and followed the local authority's advice and he has responded very well. They tell me all the time how much progress he is making and friends/familiy comment on the incrase in confidence/verbal etc.

Long story short - I went to a meeting today to see about him going to reception to the school in Sep this year - I know they have places.

(He does have a space at a local state school which seems great - just big class sizes but lovely kids and teachers)

The private school told me they couldn't cater for him as well as the state system, and that 'kids like him are better suited in the state system because they have the resources'. They said 'those schools can do things like sensory rooms, breakout areas, and with additional funding can provide 121 support - we can't and won't do any of that as we simply don't have the resources' (the fees are £20k plus a year). The Senco then said "it's not our fault the government don't give us additional money for kids with challenges".

They also said "our governors want us to be more competitive academically, so they are going to invest in that, not support for kids who are strugglign. sorry to be blunt but that's the way it is"

Obviously I don't want him to go there now. We can't barely afford the fees by the way but he's really doing well there - he has friends, he runs in every day, he comes home and tells me what he's learnt - the change in his is enormous so would sell a leg to continue that if I could.

They keep telling me how bright and funny he is, and then when I say about him staying they say "no no, kids like yours aren't catered for here"

He's barely 4 years old.

Isnt' that discrimantory? I feel angry. I know he won't go there. But can private schools basically do what the F they like?

OP posts:
OrderOfTheKookaburra · 10/05/2023 04:23

Honestly? If the school doesn't want you then you are better off in the state system. I saw the students at my DC's private school that had additional needs. Mild additional needs they can cater for - and make you pay through the nose for. (Lots of paid for additional classes required). As soon as a student needed help with more than 2 subjects they were managed out of the school.

And the school absolutely lied in their school reports that they sent on to the next school (good friends with a parent this happened to).

Some private schools might choose to cater for additional needs, but I suspect if you are on the road to getting a diagnosis at age 4 then most of them will consider the needs too great.

swimmingintherain · 10/05/2023 04:21

II think the school are right and why would you want your dc to attend a school that honestly can't cater as well as a state school can?! My dc is at a private school but it is true that often unless it's a specialist school, state school provision is often superior for dc with sen. There are a number of parents at our school with one dc in private and their dc with sen at state for this reason. Our private school does say if you want to pay the salary of a 1-2-1 TA they allow this to help dc with sen. I don't know anyone that's chosen that route though. Why would you when state provision will still be better most of the time.

Our school would never refuse a dc with sen but the dc would definitely be worse off than at a state school. Our fees are £21k prep and is a non selective school.

Jemandthehologramsunite · 10/05/2023 04:20

Private schools are elitist, that is the point of them and why you're paying for "the best", so why would it be surprising that they're being selective 😐

SpidersAreShitheads · 10/05/2023 03:57

I've only skimmed the thread because it's a bit of a sensitive subject for me, but I'm sorry for you OP. I know it's shitty, and I wish I could say it's the only time you'll come across this attitude.

PP here have been well-meaning and said that your DS will "probably be better off" in a state school where his "needs can be met". The truth is that state school provisions barely - if ever - properly meet the needs of autistic children. It's all about coping with the best that's available, while having to manage in a class of 30.

What would be best is a small class of 8 or 9 children where tuition can be individually tailored. Guess who could provide that if they chose to? A private school.

State schools are woefully short on funding and it's an absolute fucking BATTLE to get what your child needs. I was the SEN school governor for many years, and I'm also the parent to two autistic DC - one in special school, one in mainstream with support. The state system is desperately, desperately underfunded for SEN children. And like private schools, there are plenty of state schools who really can't be arsed with autistic kids. Off-rolling continues to be an issue.

Some state schools are marvellous. Hopefully you've found one that will do everything in its power to manage to support your child well despite the dire lack of funding. It's not easy though, even at a wonderful state school because of the sheer size and the lack of resources.

The vast majority of private schools won't touch autistic or SEN children unless they're some kind of prodigy. They want top notch results and don't want anything to mar their reputation of being a school that produces high achievers etc. It's a snotty, shitty attitude. And it's not about the funding - most private schools wouldn't be willing to accommodate the child, even if the parent paid for any extra support etc. It's about their reputation - they just don't want SEN kids on their registers.

Have you considered independent, alternative schools in your area - like a Montessori school or similar? You might even find there's a small independent school that caters well for SEN children - they typically don't charge as much as "regular" private schools and the ethos is a bit more relaxed, more about inclusion. We have one, and there's only 20 children in the whole school - many of whom have SEN. Not every area has this type of school - and they might not suit your child. But it's worth having a dig around to see what's available? Have you got a connection with other SEN parents in your area? They're usually an invaluable source of advice about school placements.

Big hugs OP. I know it's hurtful - but I bet your DS absolutely rocks. As an autistic adult myself, I can tell you the most important thing is having a loving, supportive family who love and accept you for who you are - your DS is lucky to have you ❤️

GuestStars · 10/05/2023 02:51

I just saw a PP mentioning legal requirement to make “reasonable adjustments” for disability.

So there will be wide doors, access to all floors, disabled toilets….but it’s not going to extend to providing additional tuition in a private.

Our DC are at a prep school. It’s a charitable trust where the profits are reinvested into facilities and teaching etc.

Fees have increased 14.8% since last September!! None of the parents are going to be happy if their fees are going to pay for 1:1 support for someone else’s child. There are a few children where the parents pay directly for the TA support needed, but it’s not reasonable to expect the school (aka the other parents) to pay for this.

GuestStars · 10/05/2023 02:46

They’ve been open that they can’t provide additional dedicated support that your son may need. At least they’ve told you now, instead of you spending £20k a year and him floundering.

It’s a hard message to hear though.

Mumtum3 · 10/05/2023 02:39

Willyoujustbequiet · 10/05/2023 01:49

I'm a bit shocked at some of these replies. Equalities leglislation applies to all schools including private and legally they are not allowed to discriminate, they must make reasonable adjustments for disabled pupils.

I would also disagree with some comments made about results. SEN does not equate to less intelligent. Indeed some of the most successful people in the world have SEN. If there is an impact on results its perhaps due to poor quality of teaching in a particular school as many private schools manage perfectly well.

This is true when a child is actually disabled or has a diagnosis - OP’s son has neither which makes it much easier to take the approach they did.

GoldenAye · 10/05/2023 02:35

HarryViles · 09/05/2023 21:54

I knew they were selective in later years - and that there are entrance exams etc of course i kow that.

But at 4. to turn him down due to suspected neurodiversity. that i didn't expect. especially when they also tell me he's made amazing progress in all areas.

It's a weird one as I don't want him to go there anymore - their loss - but I feel angry and defensive over him.

They are being quite honest with you. They cannot offer the support your child might need, and they recognise he could struggle in that environment. Rather than place him there, it's better to know now and find a school that does suit him.

In my kids' private school, some learning support was provided in the foundation years for some children. However, this dropped off in high school. Some of these kids went elsewhere, dropped out or lingered at the the bottom of grades. At schools like this, academic success is the key driver, not the welfare of the children. They are businesses. Your child is absolutely better off elsewhere.

Mumtum3 · 10/05/2023 02:33

I’m so sorry, OP. I’d be feeling really upset and angry too but, once that eased a little, I’d be relieved too that they were so transparent about how they try to maintain a reputation to attract more parents with cash to splash. I’m a teacher and I wouldn’t want my own child in their care, no matter what their ability etc. They sound like one-trick ponies at best; don’t want the hassle of doing what so many skilled, inclusive teachers do when differentiating learning for a range of abilities; and like they’d be totally useless should a child’s learning needs come to light later on in their life and not even notice the signs to help diagnose, let alone teach according to a child’s needs.

I’m so glad your son has a great school lined up!

LiveAHappyLifeBePositive · 10/05/2023 02:28

Willyoujustbequiet · 10/05/2023 01:49

I'm a bit shocked at some of these replies. Equalities leglislation applies to all schools including private and legally they are not allowed to discriminate, they must make reasonable adjustments for disabled pupils.

I would also disagree with some comments made about results. SEN does not equate to less intelligent. Indeed some of the most successful people in the world have SEN. If there is an impact on results its perhaps due to poor quality of teaching in a particular school as many private schools manage perfectly well.

Many schools have entry requirements including state schools.
With grammars you have to pass the 11+. Other state schools also have individual entrance exams. With others it may be a certain religious requirement.
If the school has certain entry criteria that’s what they are going by.

EasterBreak · 10/05/2023 01:55

That's how it has always been. They don't want SEN kids they want kids who will achieve the top marks and make them look good. That school doesn't deserve your child op.

Willyoujustbequiet · 10/05/2023 01:49

I'm a bit shocked at some of these replies. Equalities leglislation applies to all schools including private and legally they are not allowed to discriminate, they must make reasonable adjustments for disabled pupils.

I would also disagree with some comments made about results. SEN does not equate to less intelligent. Indeed some of the most successful people in the world have SEN. If there is an impact on results its perhaps due to poor quality of teaching in a particular school as many private schools manage perfectly well.

itsrainin · 10/05/2023 01:26

also it comes across that the pre-school could have found it challenging to accommodate your son. Again, that’s not disrespecting your child or saying he’s done anything wrong - he hasn’t. But the school weren’t set up well, so that’s a failing on their part and it’s not a given that they are capable of continuing to support him as well in the private school. It’s just not a good match perhaps?

it’s normal for kids to go their separate ways after pre-school and again at primary school. Is there any support you can access to make the transition easier for him?

itsrainin · 10/05/2023 01:18

I think your mistake is assuming a private school automatically provides better specialist/1-1 support than state schools. Chances are, they aren’t set up well to continue to support your son. At a private school, the teachers may have significantly less experience of helping kids in this way and wouldn’t be able to always prioritise him. Don’t take that as a rejection of your son, but a failing of the school almost. I mean, you’ve already described his experience as awful and the staff as cold.

Their fees might be £20k but it isn’t a given that they use that money to invest in their SEND provision…that money will be earmarked elsewhere staff wages, school maintenance etc. You know it’s not necessarily value for money either, you are just lining the pockets of whatever the school’s key ethos/priorities are. They are allowed to be selective in this way compared to state schools.

Give the other school a chance. If you do have spare money that you’d like to invest in his education, you could try a tutor that can give him tailored 1-1 support. There are specialist tutors for kids with autism that have decades of experience and qualifications and could help continue this good trajectory.

Rubychews · 10/05/2023 01:07

They don’t offer the service ( resources) your son needs. Be thankful they have told you.

ScrollingLeaves · 10/05/2023 01:03

Redebs · Yesterday 21:44
Of course they can. They are about results and reputation, not getting the best out of children.

A few schools are the way you say, but others are very much about getting the best out of children! That’s why people send their children to them

OP, I am very sorry that this has happened when your ds is happy there. The school doesn’t sound very nice though, and your ds would still have had to move from a place he is used to. So try to look for a good alternative.

Strawberrydelight78 · 10/05/2023 00:47

Unless it's a private school specifically for special needs then they are selective and favour higher achieving children sadly.

Mariposista · 10/05/2023 00:42

Ouch that must have been hard to sit and take. Good for you for being so professional. Sadly a private school is like a private club, if your face doesn’t fit they don’t have to let you in. Imagine a football team as an example, they have the right to exclude less able players from membership. Take no notice, chalk it up to experience and your kid will do just fine in reception.

fdgdfgdfgdfg · 10/05/2023 00:35

This is what happens when you send your kid to school at a business. Your child will cost them more than a neurotypical child, and that'll eat into their profit margins.

They can afford to be picky, and so they'll choose the child that earns them the most profit, that's their only priority.

Labraradabrador · 10/05/2023 00:31

School is tough with Sen - lots of private schools cater to ‘light’ SEN , but there does seem to be a threshold where they just cannot support without significant additional funding from parents.

school ethos is key -mine have been very well supported in their private school. Lots of early interventions (some of which required additional payments), but in general have been really proactive and accommodating in y1, and feel we have had much better support than we would have had at state school. I see children in later years with Sen that are well provided for and supported. I also know that some children from nursery were not accepted for reception because they had Sen that the school did not feel like they could accommodate, so even in a Sen friendly school there are limits to what they can provide.

if they aren’t enthusiastic about your child, it is not a good fit, and though hurtful, better to know up front. State school may be a good option, but there might also be private schools that are more accommodating.

Tintackedsea · 10/05/2023 00:29

I worked in a state school near to one of the most prestigious and expensive schools in the UK. We had kids every year come from that school because they were dyslexic or had autism or adhd. Frankly I think the teachers there must have been a bit de-skilled because they never had to think of new ways to teach. No kids to prompt them into a new perspective. Lucky escape for your lovely wee one.

Piony · 10/05/2023 00:29

Yup, he was always going to be vulnerable to this. They can just turn round any time and decline to take your money without recourse. Better that it happened at 4 than 15, halfway through his GCSEs.

The really awful thing about this is that some parents see this as a positive of private school - that the "troublemakers" can be easily got rid of. Never mind fairness, or evidence, or discrimination, or the fact it's often those with unmet learning needs or mental health difficulties that fall into that bucket.

Do try state school. You might be pleasantly surprised by the skills, and the attitude that every child is part of the community and they'll do their best for them.

LiveAHappyLifeBePositive · 10/05/2023 00:27

Yazo · 10/05/2023 00:21

@Sailingaround private school isn't immoral but it is exclusionary in a way that no other school type, even the examples you list aren't. Even in the wealthiest catchments you'll have people on benefits, lost jobs, free school meals and children with disabilities.

Grammar schools are exclusionary…..by exam entry
Many religious schools too….by religion
Both of which are paid for by the state.

Yazo · 10/05/2023 00:21

@Sailingaround private school isn't immoral but it is exclusionary in a way that no other school type, even the examples you list aren't. Even in the wealthiest catchments you'll have people on benefits, lost jobs, free school meals and children with disabilities.

itsrainin · 10/05/2023 00:21

I don’t really see the issue here. You pay for private school for a better educational experience for your children, but the school is being upfront that they can’t provide that for him so you’re wasting your money. It’s a business transaction at the end of the day, you have to try to not take it as a personal insult. Would you rather they accepted him, paid zero attention to him and took your £20k to save face? You need to put your child’s needs first.