Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this is outrageous from the school?

288 replies

HarryViles · 09/05/2023 21:42

DS is just 4. He is at pre-school attached to a private school. He had an awful first few months there - very unsettled and unable to concentate - to the point where he is now on waiting list for ASD diagonsis as the pre-school's recommendation.

However, the last few months he has been doing so well. They have always been a little cold but they are professional and followed the local authority's advice and he has responded very well. They tell me all the time how much progress he is making and friends/familiy comment on the incrase in confidence/verbal etc.

Long story short - I went to a meeting today to see about him going to reception to the school in Sep this year - I know they have places.

(He does have a space at a local state school which seems great - just big class sizes but lovely kids and teachers)

The private school told me they couldn't cater for him as well as the state system, and that 'kids like him are better suited in the state system because they have the resources'. They said 'those schools can do things like sensory rooms, breakout areas, and with additional funding can provide 121 support - we can't and won't do any of that as we simply don't have the resources' (the fees are £20k plus a year). The Senco then said "it's not our fault the government don't give us additional money for kids with challenges".

They also said "our governors want us to be more competitive academically, so they are going to invest in that, not support for kids who are strugglign. sorry to be blunt but that's the way it is"

Obviously I don't want him to go there now. We can't barely afford the fees by the way but he's really doing well there - he has friends, he runs in every day, he comes home and tells me what he's learnt - the change in his is enormous so would sell a leg to continue that if I could.

They keep telling me how bright and funny he is, and then when I say about him staying they say "no no, kids like yours aren't catered for here"

He's barely 4 years old.

Isnt' that discrimantory? I feel angry. I know he won't go there. But can private schools basically do what the F they like?

OP posts:
Grimbelina · 10/05/2023 10:24

I was also advised by an (excellent) person at CAMHS to join local parenting groups, especially any SEN ones to hear the inside info. from parents who had actually experienced the schools we were considering.

Grimbelina · 10/05/2023 10:22

Missjkay private diagnoses which meet the threshold are acceptable for EHCP (most of our diagnoses/assessments were private).

ANonnyMice · 10/05/2023 10:22

It's always a shock when you get told these things - but they have probably done you a favour.

I cried when DD was turned down for a selective indie place - they were very keen on her for her specialist area, but told me that her degree of dyslexia was well beyond what they could manage.

Up till that point I'd always been told her dyslexia was mild. I called the primary HT in a complete state and they came back and hour later to say that actually it wasn't the case and she was moderately severe to severe.

Gave me the kick I needed to start getting things in place to actually help.

We ended up going with the state option and I am so incredibly grateful that the head turned DD away. With hindsight it would have been completely the wrong school for DD, and their rejection gave us the push to put all sorts of things in place to help.

It does feel miserable at the time though.

Only thing I will warn is that you will need to push and fight for every scrap of support. That is even more the case if they are clever and doing well enough to not flag concerns. DD is still failing to meet her potential but doing well enough that she gets no extra help at all bar what I can buy in for her.

Use the money you'll save on fees to pay for tutoring and other help.

Missjkay · 10/05/2023 10:19

You may be better looking at village schools as they have smaller reception classes generally. I’m not sure if a private asd assessment would be accepted for the ehcp. Also the ehcp process takes a long time. You may be better finding the right school, meet the senco, look at the building, think about his triggers and what may work for him. You may find he copes well in the right environment. I would try not to panic about the change, it could be a positive. Maybe contact asd support groups locally and see if they can recommend any schools. Also if he is a summer born you have the option of holding him back a school year.

berksandbeyond · 10/05/2023 10:09

Well yes they absolutely can. This is kind of what you sign up for with these schools, and you wouldn’t have been angry about another child being streamed out in this way, it’s only because it’s yours.

As an aside if you can barely afford the fees at preschool age, they’ve done you a favour anyway as no chance you’d be able to keep up with that for another 14 years.

Put your energy into your child and not this.

cantkeepawayforever · 10/05/2023 10:06

It would be worth looking at the % of children with identified SEN at your selected state school.

Nationally, the average is 13% and rising, so around 1 in 8 - around 4 in every class. EHCPs account fir about 1 in 4 of these BUT it us worth commenting that given the time it takes for needs to be identified and paperwork put in place, these overall statistics will understate the level of need.

A school with lower than these numbers may be better placed in terms of having time for each child with additional needs BUT very low numbers may indicate either lack of experience or an active policy of encouraging parents to look elsewhere. On the other hand, classes with 25%+ on the SEN register are not uncommon, and in such classes there nay be masses of expertise but far too little time and resource to truly meet the needs of each.

If the school was able to put you in touch with a parent of a child with ASD / suspected ASD who can talk about how their child was provided for, that would be particularly brilliant. You should certainly seek a conversation asap with the SENCo about transition into Reception, starting from now. Does that school have a nursery class or feeder pre-school which your child could spend sone time in over the coming few months?

whumpthereitis · 10/05/2023 10:01

Cheesecakeandwineinasuitcase · 10/05/2023 09:52

Starmer has already suggested adding vat to school fees and rightly so. I think he’s made his position clear.

Has he? Or has he thrown a bone to his base?

bigbabycooker · 10/05/2023 10:00

Honestly, I have seen state and private and PP is bang on - what you pay for in private is to have kids who are middle class and "easy" plus some glossier facilities and smaller classes.

I know lots of kids who have not been "a good fit" at private and have done very well at state - one I know at the moment who can do quadratic equations at 6, but who can't really write other than on a computer, for example. No one would ever say this child is "not academic", it's just that they don't fit a very standardised form of learning and the state system is doing really well with him. Our local non academically selective private school is able to teach a couple of years ahead to many of the "easy" kids because those kids make very even progress. Lots of kids, whether due to SEN or otherwise, make lumpier progress - need longer in some areas than others, or have areas of brilliance whilst struggling in others. Generally, unless specifically set up for this, private schools do not cope with these kids very well - they have a budget that is build on a particular type of standard child and can manage very well only inside these parameters.

You've clearly got a bit of extra disposable income, so I would embrace state and try to work out how to use that budget wisely to extend him in his areas of strength and support him in his areas of weakness. Your son is special and this rejection doesn't mean he won't have a good outcome from his education.

whumpthereitis · 10/05/2023 09:59

AuntieJune · 10/05/2023 09:49

Read between the lines though. No case for abolishing them - a good case for taxing them more. There are some very good ones - but plenty that are not so good, that need to be forced to change, open up to communities etc.

I was addressing the hope that they would be abolished.

Taxing then more is a separate issue that is far from simple, and by no means guaranteed to be achieved, if Labour does in fact have the appetite to attempt it. The government may make law but it is also beholden to it, and therein lies the rub. It’s very easy to make a promise knowing that it appeals to your base, but following through with it (if indeed you actually intent to) is another matter entirely.

Skybluepinky · 10/05/2023 09:59

It’s always been that way, they want well behaved academic students that look good on their prospectus.

Poopoolittlekitten · 10/05/2023 09:54

It's private school's losses that they want everyone yo look the same, act the same, be from the same background - so they can churn out little robots.

I can't fathom why anyone would want their children to go to schools that are so limited in experience - even if they do come with paddocks and golf courses

Cheesecakeandwineinasuitcase · 10/05/2023 09:52

whumpthereitis · 10/05/2023 08:59

“private schools add a huge amount to this country. "I think there are very good private schools, and there's no case for abolishing them”
-Keir Starmer

Starmer has already suggested adding vat to school fees and rightly so. I think he’s made his position clear.

AuntieJune · 10/05/2023 09:51

newusername2009 · 10/05/2023 09:29

Private schools don’t get funding to support additional needs so what they can do to support your child would be limited. In a state school you may get 1-2-1 time with a TA, this would not be funded at private schools. State schools will also get the funding to put in place sensory rooms etc, of course depending on how many children they are supporting with additional needs.

it’s not discriminatory - it’s being honest about what is best for your son rather than taking your £20k a year and disadvantaging him

I'm sure private schools have been in extended discussions with the government begging for more assistance so they can support pupils with SEN - not! They don't want them, plain and simple.

AuntieJune · 10/05/2023 09:49

whumpthereitis · 10/05/2023 08:59

“private schools add a huge amount to this country. "I think there are very good private schools, and there's no case for abolishing them”
-Keir Starmer

Read between the lines though. No case for abolishing them - a good case for taxing them more. There are some very good ones - but plenty that are not so good, that need to be forced to change, open up to communities etc.

AuntieJune · 10/05/2023 09:45

You're surprised that a private school that doesn't offer equal opportunities? That's what they're for! Parents pay so their kids don't mix with riff raff. The school has determined your child to be in the riff raff category.

Just like private healthcare only wants to treat nice predictable conditions like knee replacements etc, private schools want to have kids who are easy manageable, stable and will be capable of results that make the school look good. It's a business and they choose their raw material carefully. It's shit but so are private schools.

Stompythedinosaur · 10/05/2023 09:42

The private school system is built on discrimination, though. It's unpleasant to be in the group being discriminated against when you were hoping to be in the privileged group, but the system is what it is.

Tanith · 10/05/2023 09:39

I think perhaps you've had two nasty shocks: the implication that your child needs more specialist help than you had thought, and the fact that this school cannot provide that help, which seems like a rejection of your child.
I understand you haven't yet had a diagnosis? That will help to determine the school that will be best suited to your child.

This site may help to find a private school that deals in specific additional needs:
https://educationadvocacy.co.uk/sen-schools-map

There are also private schools that provide specialised learning support for children who need it. Eton is one of them. Your current school is obviously not.

SEN Schools Map | Find a specialist SEN school in your area

One of the big issues for parents of children with SEN is finding the right special school. To help you make an informed choice we have collated the schools

https://educationadvocacy.co.uk/sen-schools-map

SleepingStandingUp · 10/05/2023 09:37

Long term op he'll be happier in state.

He'll be in a school that accepts him, where he isn't the only one needing some extra support.
You won't be seeing everything to keep him in there and then not being able to keep up with the lifestyle anyway.

You're likely to find it easier to make school gate friends and that will help with play date and fostering friendships etc.

Of course you're upset, they don't want your perfect, beautiful boy. But use that indignation to get him settled at the new school. Speak to them now if your place is confirmed about if they do a settling in week etc before school starts.
Our kids all go up a year for a full week in July

silverbubbles · 10/05/2023 09:32

It is good that this school is telling you they are not the best option for your child. There are plenty of private schools who would welcome him. Start looking about.

ThreeImaginaryBoys · 10/05/2023 09:31

@HarryViles I'm so sorry that you have been made to feel this way about your son. What a repellent attitude on behalf of the school he is at.

I teach in a state primary and we have a very diverse cohort of children. The numbers of children with neurodiversity in our classrooms would probably surprise you. Yes, it is correct that state schools are good at supporting children with additional needs, mainly because we have to be. This does NOT mean that we have a magic money tree to support them, just that we do the best we can and know how the support system works.

Funding for additional support is contingent on assessments and getting an EHCP for your child. This is a lengthy process and there is a huge backlog. If your son started in Reception here, for example, it would be unlikely that he would get one before Y1. If the school he is at has TAs in Reception, they will provide the extra support. But bear in mind that schools are having to cut back drastically on support staff because of insufficient budgets, wildly escalating utility costs, and the lack of fully-funded pay from the govt (hence the current strikes ... not making this political, it's the truth). So bear that in mind when making your decision. Do give serious consideration to what the money you would be spending on fees could do for your son in a state setting (and DON'T take the advice not to mention your son's additional needs to the school ... the more we know beforehand, the more we can do and you won't be refused a state place on the back of it).

The sad truth, as PPs have said, is that some private schools maintain that they offer a 'better' education by simply refusing to take children that they consider to be undesirable or detrimental to their results. 'Nurturing environment' my eye.

I would advise you to come to the state sector. The water's warm :) Good luck.

cantkeepawayforever · 10/05/2023 09:31

The school have been honest about what they can’t (don’t want to) do, but entirely dishonest about what a state school might be able to do (even if they want to).

You may well find that your DS falls into the sizeable gap between ‘level of difficulty that a private school that focuses on results is unwilling to accommodate’ and ‘level of difficulty that attracts significant report in a state school’, and this is what you need to explore with the state school as a matter of urgency.

I have taught many children with ASD, both with a formal diagnosis and without. Almost all were on the SEN register but EHCPs were quite rare. Only 1 had funded 1:1 support in a mainstream class of well over 30 for ASD and ADHD alone, though some had funded 1:1 support for these conditions plus very high levels of learning difficulty or very challenging behaviour. Others had intervention from class TAs (but these are becoming very rare as funding problems bite in state schools) and as much support as is possible within the class and its many needs from the class teacher.

Be realistic about what your child will need, and what they will get in the state school. Become the expert, and a fierce advocate, because it us a sad fact that you will need to be. Consider all schools - those that are ‘best’ on paper are not necessarily the best for your DC. Be flexible - the school for next year may not be the school for the following year. Be cynical and canny - do not rely on others and research what boxes need to be ticked at every point. Good luck!

newusername2009 · 10/05/2023 09:29

Private schools don’t get funding to support additional needs so what they can do to support your child would be limited. In a state school you may get 1-2-1 time with a TA, this would not be funded at private schools. State schools will also get the funding to put in place sensory rooms etc, of course depending on how many children they are supporting with additional needs.

it’s not discriminatory - it’s being honest about what is best for your son rather than taking your £20k a year and disadvantaging him

Grimbelina · 10/05/2023 09:24

Also second a PP who says start getting all the assessments, investigations you need, especially if you can afford to go private and accelerate seeing an Ed Psych, SALT, OT etc. this will help support your DC. You do need to find good people though, we have had wildly different diagnoses and reports from different professionals.

Grimbelina · 10/05/2023 09:21

Unfortunately a difficult part of parenting any SEN child is finding out where they aren't wanted. However, in my experience you do actually need to find this out, and the sooner the better, so you can actually find a setting that does want your child. Much, much worse for them to be on the fence, not tell you and for your DC to limp along and get managed out later on when your options are limited.

Do make sure you have met with the SENCO's and head of any school you are now considering, state or private, so you can really get a feel of how inclusive they are and how much support they will put in place. Your DC's needs may well change over time so do do learn about specialist settings as some of these fill up early.

User1432423532 · 10/05/2023 09:19

They are institutionally ableist. It's appalling but your child is better off out of there.

Private schools cater for capitalism and everything about the capitalist world is also ableist. People who make most money are usually neurotypical with good physical health, social skills and mental resilience. Exceptions are made for neurodiversity if it's a form of ADHD/ASD that gives the individual socially recognised talents and they are functional enough in their daily life to bring credit to their school/employers/industry.