Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this is outrageous from the school?

288 replies

HarryViles · 09/05/2023 21:42

DS is just 4. He is at pre-school attached to a private school. He had an awful first few months there - very unsettled and unable to concentate - to the point where he is now on waiting list for ASD diagonsis as the pre-school's recommendation.

However, the last few months he has been doing so well. They have always been a little cold but they are professional and followed the local authority's advice and he has responded very well. They tell me all the time how much progress he is making and friends/familiy comment on the incrase in confidence/verbal etc.

Long story short - I went to a meeting today to see about him going to reception to the school in Sep this year - I know they have places.

(He does have a space at a local state school which seems great - just big class sizes but lovely kids and teachers)

The private school told me they couldn't cater for him as well as the state system, and that 'kids like him are better suited in the state system because they have the resources'. They said 'those schools can do things like sensory rooms, breakout areas, and with additional funding can provide 121 support - we can't and won't do any of that as we simply don't have the resources' (the fees are £20k plus a year). The Senco then said "it's not our fault the government don't give us additional money for kids with challenges".

They also said "our governors want us to be more competitive academically, so they are going to invest in that, not support for kids who are strugglign. sorry to be blunt but that's the way it is"

Obviously I don't want him to go there now. We can't barely afford the fees by the way but he's really doing well there - he has friends, he runs in every day, he comes home and tells me what he's learnt - the change in his is enormous so would sell a leg to continue that if I could.

They keep telling me how bright and funny he is, and then when I say about him staying they say "no no, kids like yours aren't catered for here"

He's barely 4 years old.

Isnt' that discrimantory? I feel angry. I know he won't go there. But can private schools basically do what the F they like?

OP posts:
Timeturnerplease · 11/05/2023 19:10

solidaritea · 10/05/2023 23:02

Not correct. State schools have no protected funding for SEND, except if a child has an EHCP (which they can get in state or private).

The fact that some/many private schools reject children with SEND is contributing to the staggering pressure that mainstream state schools are being put under.

Exactly this. State schools are drowning in the costs of catering to children with SEND /behaviour issues because of the lack of outside support unless they have an EHCP, which are like gold dust nowadays.

Bubbles90 · 11/05/2023 19:01

The reasons they are giving you are rubbish. The issue is with that school itself. It's not prepared to support your child. Private schools are better placed to support children with SENCO issues than state schools. Both of my children have SENCO needs and are in private school. Their schools have always provided excellent support. I did have them in state schools before but they were woeful. I had no choice but to go private to ensure that they got the right support.

Lovely13 · 11/05/2023 18:47

Paying for private education does not necessarily mean a better one. This school has told you that it’s primarily a business rather than a place that primarily cares about children.

Toomuchtrouble4me · 11/05/2023 18:44

There are some private schools that cater for the kids who are not academic but parents want private. In fact there’s a huge unmet demand for it in London at least. But most private pre and prep schools are setting kids up ready for the hugely competitive entrance exams for senior schools. And they know their stuff - your son wouldn’t be able to do what’s demanded of him in that school. Good that you’ve a great state place, more than many can say.

BuntyFayreweather · 11/05/2023 18:27

My advice would be never mourn a school who didn't want your child. My DD looked at 22 schools when she was bullied at her boarding school and she needed to leave. Five turned her down. They made spiteful assumptions regarding her SEN and I still think their behaviour was discrimination (my child is mixed race and LGBT). However what is factually correct is my DD is super clever and she is now at university studying for a medical degree. I will have the last laugh as she is top of her class. Nasty bullies exist in teaching faculties too, pick kindness and be there for your son. A special needs child will need you throughout their life. My DD is lovely, genuinely kind, decent and I am super proud of her. Some of the educationalists we met have no business working with children. Be honest with your chosen school and be prepared to advocate every day.

Feelingleftoutagain · 11/05/2023 18:10

It is typical of a private school, your child sounds bright and you will ensure whatever school they attend they will do well. ASD is nothing to fear, both my boys and myself have ASD, I was a teacher who retired early, one son is a HGV driver and the other has a degree in animal behaviour, I hope he enjoys his new school

Righthandman · 11/05/2023 09:47

@HarryViles I’m so sorry the school have discriminated against your son so blatantly. I have been there and your post has been on my mind ever since because it absolutely does hurt like hell. I remember also being so angry that schools can get away with it because of course, once they have made you feel so very unwelcome, you are hardly going to fight for your son’s place there.

You are not being unreasonable. It is discriminatory, and yes, many schools do whatever they like towards children with SEN. Some private schools get away with worse because the parents can be less informed, having had fewer battles up to the point where it goes wrong. Also state schools are -rightly- not allowed to have blanket policies excluding SEN, where as private schools get away with statements like ‘pupils are expected to be academic enough to keep up with the curriculum with a maximum of one hour additional support per week.’ But state schools can be terrible too- they cannot legally decline to offer a place to a child with an ehcp except in very specific circumstances but they will offer up many wildly inappropriate and hurtful excuses if they don’t want you in the hopes of pushing you away.

A few thoughts-

It is very likely some of the staff at your private school have ASD themselves. (A profession that requires a degree and significant interest in that subject for the rest of your career?) They may not be aware of it. Some of them may well have been very like your son at 4. How ironic! They are certainly not in a position to judge him and his future prospects.

Your son might grow up to achieve very well in particular subjects, or he might have siblings who do. It is the school’s great loss, in that case, that they won’t have the privilege of teaching your children and that you will not be recommending them to your friends regardless of how able their kids are.

In any case it’s the school’s loss, not yours. I’m sure your son has many lovely qualities regardless of academic ability. He has clearly persevered brilliantly at preschool despite being so little. You should be really proud of him.

They are not correct that the state sector has more funding or resources, but you will often find more knowledge and support. Many private schools badly let down kids with SEN because they don’t know what to offer. You should speak to the head and the Senco at the state school where you have a place, discuss your son’s current needs and see what they can offer. Hopefully you will be pleasantly surprised.

You should probably apply for an EHC needs assessment as soon as you can- it sounds as if the criteria would be met- and consider looking at other schools both mainstream and specialist. Especially if you don’t get good vibes from the head and senco at your meeting.

You should write down everything the private school said in your meeting. Possibly do it up as minutes and email asking them to confirm the record. This will be therapeutic I think for you to get it off your chest but also you can then use it to make a complaint if you want to.

Wishing you and your son all the best for September xx

Righthandman · 11/05/2023 09:13

I think @turnthetoiletpaperroundproperly and @itsrainin open up a well-worn but unhelpful line of debate, because they are essentially saying ‘oh those poor kids who grow up to be successful, how terrible for them to have had to share space with less fortunate kids once.’

It’s not ‘pandering’ to meet the needs of children with learning disabilities any more than it’s ‘pandering’ to build a wheelchair-accessible ramp. Would you feel comfortable saying you moved your kid from a school because you found the building works to improve physical access too disruptive?

Also if children are violent in class, that’s not the school ‘pandering’ or even ‘meeting needs’- it’s the school failing very badly to meet needs, for a number of complex reasons that may deserve more or less blame to the staff. So moving a child from that school may be valid on the grounds that it’s a poor school, but not on the grounds that those greedy disabled kids are hoovering up all the resources.

solidaritea · 10/05/2023 23:02

HurryShadow · 10/05/2023 10:26

Just think it's laughable tha the state school who are currently raising money to do up the school hall have some money pot waiting to use for kids like my son.

This is where state and private schools are totally opposite.

State schools have a protected pot of money that needs to be spent on the pupils that need it the most, but at the same time there is little money to be spent on the facilities.

On the flip side, a private school is a business and the best way to keep attracting new pupils is to have all singing and dancing facilities, not spend money on the minority of students.

For a student that needs some additional support, I agree that the state school will likely be better. If he needs one-to-one support, that will be made available to him, whereas in a results orientated private school, he would end up (in later years) being pressurised in to doing well which, if he's not academically minded, is not great. You only have to look in the news last week about the girl from Wycombe Abbey that had ASD and committed suicide after being given a detention.

Send him to the local state school, use the money you're saving to provide any additional support he needs and if it transpires he would be able to cope in private school you can always send him when he's a bit older.

Not correct. State schools have no protected funding for SEND, except if a child has an EHCP (which they can get in state or private).

The fact that some/many private schools reject children with SEND is contributing to the staggering pressure that mainstream state schools are being put under.

Elfer13 · 10/05/2023 21:53

It's a cop out from private schools and used often to select only those who will produce the best results at exam time. I had a similar experience but for different reasons with my dd and was advised/ told to withdraw her from a very selective private school in the North of England. The state school she subsequently attended recognised her ability in stem subjects which wouldn't have happened at the private school who view an A+ grade in sociology better than an A in Physics, it looks better on thier advertising for the next year's intake. So even at such an early stage I would say don't worry too much. Help and support will be available at a state school as it was for my dd who is now doing a master's in chemical engineering at a Russel Group University whist many of her ex private school graduates are wondering what to do with a 2-2 in an "ology"
Good luck.

itsrainin · 10/05/2023 21:03

@turnthetoiletpaperroundproperly your post is really interesting and honestly made me wish I went to private school. I’m 24. In my primary school there were violent kids, one even attacked me! School was definitely all about pandering to those kids and a lot of lesson time was soaked up trying to calm them down. In secondary school, there were people who were disruptive in other ways eg arguing and being disrespectful to teachers in class. The culture was generally that being smart is embarrassing/loser and getting low grades was cool. I felt I had to hide my intelligence almost, some people felt it was ridiculous that I retook my January A grade in maths for a June A* grade for example. The culture of my state school was definitely not about bringing out the best in anyone.

AtlasSix · 10/05/2023 17:17

I’m sorry OP, this must have really hurt.

We had a similar private school experience with my autistic DS, except in our case they kept him in the school for a few years before telling us that he wouldn’t be welcome for the next school year.
It was very upsetting at the time, especially as DS liked the school and was settled there, but ultimately, they didn’t want him and they weren’t prepared to try supporting him. I still think that the private school could have done more to support his needs if they’d wanted to, but it was easier for them to manage him out.

Luckily a few of our local state primary schools had spaces in the right year group, so we were able to look at several schools to find the best one for him. We were very open about DS’s diagnosis and his needs when we were talking to the headteachers - the last thing we wanted was to send him to another school that didn’t want to deal with SEN children. And one or two headteachers of the state schools we looked at also gave off unwelcoming vibes once we mentioned the ASD diagnosis.

The state school we picked in the end worked out well for DS - they do not have the available resources that private schools do; but the headteacher was genuinely committed to making the school as inclusive as possible for children with SEN, which makes a big positive difference.

Newuser82 · 10/05/2023 15:18

turnthetoiletpaperroundproperly · 10/05/2023 15:08

This is awful Op . I feel I am one of those parents to blame though. I am very selfish and I have a kid well man now who went to a highly selective private school. I took my child out of state at 9 yrs because there were SEN kids in his class of 31. He,my son was falling behind and the overstretched teachers with minimal assistance had to focus on the needs of the children who needed extra support,who were disruptive ,who were violent etc. I understand the needs of all concerned but I felt my son was being failed too. I remember and we are going back now over 17 yrs I took my son for his entrance exam and I had a meeting with the Head.He asked me what I expected from school and I told him what I wanted for my son. I paid 24.000 per year back then to have my son out of the way. Its shameful to admit it but thats what I did. To be fair I appreciate I bought him his education and gave him a leg up the ladder,it worked and I am not sorry I did it I am sorry I felt I had to though. I didnt understand back then as I dont understand now (my so is grown with a family of his own) why the help and support that is so badly needed just isnt there.The only way I felt to help my son was for me to buy our way out and its tough,not everyone can do it. I wanted my kid back then to be happy and given a fair crack at school but school couldnt cater to him as so many resources were and had to be aimed at the kids who needed more so my only option I felt was to remove him and buy our way out, I paid my money and they handed my son back at 18 exactly how I wanted him to be, It was a business transaction nothing more nothing less,They did a good job for us,thats why private schools work to appease parents like me thats all. I didnt do it for status or glory I did it as a parent of a non SEN kid I felt I had to. There is no sentiment in how private schools work,they know what we want and we pay to supply it and they do. My kid is as important to me as yours is to you we,both of us were let down but in different ways educationally. I had to buy my way out to look after mine thats all.

This is a really interesting post. I have two children at private school. One of who has SEN. We aren't sure if he is going to make it into the senior school, not through intelligence or behaviour or work ethic but simply due to his difficulty (he has dyspraxia). However I don't think you need to be in any way apologetic as ultimately don't we all, as parents, want the best for our children and put it into place any way we can wether that be time or money or whatever.

I also don't think this is simply a private school issue as I have known state schools off load pupils who didn't fit in for whatever reason but I think it's very difficult to hear that they don't want your child and if it does come to that with my son I will be both furious and heartbroken. I wish you all the best.

Spiderboy · 10/05/2023 15:13

They are a selective school. It is a shame for you and your child but they are essentially a business and of course they can make this choice.

turnthetoiletpaperroundproperly · 10/05/2023 15:08

This is awful Op . I feel I am one of those parents to blame though. I am very selfish and I have a kid well man now who went to a highly selective private school. I took my child out of state at 9 yrs because there were SEN kids in his class of 31. He,my son was falling behind and the overstretched teachers with minimal assistance had to focus on the needs of the children who needed extra support,who were disruptive ,who were violent etc. I understand the needs of all concerned but I felt my son was being failed too. I remember and we are going back now over 17 yrs I took my son for his entrance exam and I had a meeting with the Head.He asked me what I expected from school and I told him what I wanted for my son. I paid 24.000 per year back then to have my son out of the way. Its shameful to admit it but thats what I did. To be fair I appreciate I bought him his education and gave him a leg up the ladder,it worked and I am not sorry I did it I am sorry I felt I had to though. I didnt understand back then as I dont understand now (my so is grown with a family of his own) why the help and support that is so badly needed just isnt there.The only way I felt to help my son was for me to buy our way out and its tough,not everyone can do it. I wanted my kid back then to be happy and given a fair crack at school but school couldnt cater to him as so many resources were and had to be aimed at the kids who needed more so my only option I felt was to remove him and buy our way out, I paid my money and they handed my son back at 18 exactly how I wanted him to be, It was a business transaction nothing more nothing less,They did a good job for us,thats why private schools work to appease parents like me thats all. I didnt do it for status or glory I did it as a parent of a non SEN kid I felt I had to. There is no sentiment in how private schools work,they know what we want and we pay to supply it and they do. My kid is as important to me as yours is to you we,both of us were let down but in different ways educationally. I had to buy my way out to look after mine thats all.

ThomasWasTortured · 10/05/2023 14:31

Request an EHCNA now and appeal if refused. The process takes 20 weeks if you don’t have to appeal, but many do have to appeal, some more than once, and the wait for appeals is long. The initial threshold for an EHCNA is relatively low - a) has or may have SEN, and b) may need SEN provision to be made via an EHCP.

Despite what many say LAs and schools can’t have a blanket policy of refusing to accept independent assessments and diagnoses just because they are independent. And SENDIST do take them into consideration.

If you haven’t already it is worth speaking to the SENCO at the state school DS has a place at. Support is based on needs, so DS won’t need to already have a diagnosis before they provide SEN support.

Independent mainstream schools can be funded via EHCPs but you need an offer of a place for them to be named and some aren’t supportive.

Tanith · 10/05/2023 14:01

EastEndQueen · 10/05/2023 11:06

Hi OP, no idea if you’ll get to my message as it’s so far along the thread! Anyway I’m so sorry this happened to you and your DC and I am sending you a big hug.

There is a lot of knee-jerk private school hostility on this thread which I’m not sure is constructive or kind. I too send my my DS (6) and DS (4) to a small private school for reasons of small class sizes and individual attention (zero personal interest in flashy campus, chapel, Ancient Greek, ‘posh friends’ etc)

A very wise freind of mine who is a (state) primary School headmistress said ‘choose a school not a sector’ and I am very convinced of the sense of this. Some schools are much better than others at managing and encouraging SEN children.

There are absolutely private schools who want the easy road and throw out children enthusiastically when they look like being extra work. There are others which see themselves as genuine communities and would be horrified at this approach. I’ve experienced the former (a Montessori preschool which asked my DS to leave aged 3 with no consultation or attempts to work with us on strategies to help. I’m unclear at his age if my lovely gentle and friendly DS has SEN but he certainly has fine motor control issues and struggles with sustained concentration). His current private school is supportive and kind and has introduced a brilliant occupational therapist to our lives.

I am certain your son can thrive in a good state primary particularly if you can afford to supplement with 1:1 help as required. Equally there will be more holistic and supportive private schools around. Wishing you all very well.

Very few of those knee-jerk posters seem to have a clue what they're talking about.
I've seen blatant discrimination and rejection at state schools, too. It's a fallacy that they are all inclusive and welcoming, coping with every SEN child. A quick look on the SEN children board will disabuse anyone of that rose-tinted fantasy!

Some of those SEN children rejected by state schools end up being funded by the LA at private specialist schools. Too many are left to fester in an education that can't cope with them.

The expectation that every single state school must cope with any and all types of child has contributed to the current intolerable pressure on teachers.

Twilightstarbright · 10/05/2023 13:04

OP I’m really sorry this happened, but they really did you a favour being honest.

DS has SEN and is in a private school that is known for working with ‘mild’ SEN. He gets support and he has therapies in school that I pay for. But the school were clear that they were at the limit of the support they could provide, but I can appreciate they were doing all they could. He no longer needs SALT and is thriving. Unlike the poster who claims that private schools are uncaring 🙄 there are some great ones that nurture.

I’m a governor at a local state school that is brilliant with SEN. I always suggest it to local parents who have children with SEN because they are better at dealing with it- brilliant SENCO and the teachers have plenty of experience with autistic children unlike the local private schools.

It’s about the right school for the right child. I volunteer as a school governor to try to help improve things and demand better for children, and I vote accordingly.

JobChangeSoonPlease · 10/05/2023 11:50

My DD has some special needs/adjustments and she was far better served by her secondary state school than her primary prep school (who denied her needs so they didn't have to address them). What your school have said is factually correct. Your boy will be better off in state than private - not because he is/isn't clever enough - but because he WILL get the right support/1:1/provisions/assessments from state that no private can/will provide.

EastEndQueen · 10/05/2023 11:06

Hi OP, no idea if you’ll get to my message as it’s so far along the thread! Anyway I’m so sorry this happened to you and your DC and I am sending you a big hug.

There is a lot of knee-jerk private school hostility on this thread which I’m not sure is constructive or kind. I too send my my DS (6) and DS (4) to a small private school for reasons of small class sizes and individual attention (zero personal interest in flashy campus, chapel, Ancient Greek, ‘posh friends’ etc)

A very wise freind of mine who is a (state) primary School headmistress said ‘choose a school not a sector’ and I am very convinced of the sense of this. Some schools are much better than others at managing and encouraging SEN children.

There are absolutely private schools who want the easy road and throw out children enthusiastically when they look like being extra work. There are others which see themselves as genuine communities and would be horrified at this approach. I’ve experienced the former (a Montessori preschool which asked my DS to leave aged 3 with no consultation or attempts to work with us on strategies to help. I’m unclear at his age if my lovely gentle and friendly DS has SEN but he certainly has fine motor control issues and struggles with sustained concentration). His current private school is supportive and kind and has introduced a brilliant occupational therapist to our lives.

I am certain your son can thrive in a good state primary particularly if you can afford to supplement with 1:1 help as required. Equally there will be more holistic and supportive private schools around. Wishing you all very well.

rumbusiness · 10/05/2023 10:55

Quinoawoman · 10/05/2023 07:01

This really boils my piss. They just don't want him there, full stop.

Send him to the lovely local state school and stop paying 20 grand a year to be mugged off.

Why does it boil your piss that an institution created entirely in order to exclude, to privilege, to select, and to segregate 'the right sort' from 'the wrong sort' is doing exactly that?

rumbusiness · 10/05/2023 10:53

Poopoolittlekitten · 10/05/2023 09:54

It's private school's losses that they want everyone yo look the same, act the same, be from the same background - so they can churn out little robots.

I can't fathom why anyone would want their children to go to schools that are so limited in experience - even if they do come with paddocks and golf courses

Social climbing, snobbery, buying privilege, and buying better exam results than they would get with an even playing field.

Poopoolittlekitten · 10/05/2023 10:41

I also think its disgraceful that they're writing off your 4 year old! One of DS best friends has a form of autism, affects behaviour and social stuff BUT the kid is an absolute bloody genius - doing early triple science, advanced maths, stats, astonomy etc at 14.

Thank god no-one looked at him at 4 and thought - nah, he's going to be hard work... but that's states schools for you - busy trying to see the potential in everyone rather than sticking everyone into the same boring identikit life

nidgey · 10/05/2023 10:38

HarryViles · 10/05/2023 08:45

I do agree with people that an education that only allows for one type of child is hugely problematic. To be honest, I felt like an outsider with the other mums (only person with a normal car!) and going to playdates has been eye opening!

I'm not desperate for private school. I'm desperate for my kid to be happy and confident and he is there, despite the management. The staff who support him are so brilliant. And the classes are half the size of the state he will not go to.

I felt sad that in theory my kid is going to struggle academically and that the answer is to send him to a more stretched bigger school and he probably won't qualify for extra support there anyway. And also how are they judging these 4 year old? When I pick my boy up half of them are crying, screaming, being hilarious and silly - I mean they are pre schoolers. How sad the judgment starts so young.

I think some posters on here are a bit dismissive of your concerns. If you've a child who you've been worried about but who is now thriving in a particular setting, it much be sickening to be told he's not welcome to stay. ND children often take a longer time than usual to adjust to change, and I empathise with how awful this must be for you. Private schools getting charitable status given their attitude is just mind-boggling.

If he goes to a state school will he definitely be in a class of 30 with just one teacher?
Have you found any less ableist private schools with small class sizes?

Best of luck OP, and hope you and your son are getting to have fun together meanwhile.

HurryShadow · 10/05/2023 10:26

Just think it's laughable tha the state school who are currently raising money to do up the school hall have some money pot waiting to use for kids like my son.

This is where state and private schools are totally opposite.

State schools have a protected pot of money that needs to be spent on the pupils that need it the most, but at the same time there is little money to be spent on the facilities.

On the flip side, a private school is a business and the best way to keep attracting new pupils is to have all singing and dancing facilities, not spend money on the minority of students.

For a student that needs some additional support, I agree that the state school will likely be better. If he needs one-to-one support, that will be made available to him, whereas in a results orientated private school, he would end up (in later years) being pressurised in to doing well which, if he's not academically minded, is not great. You only have to look in the news last week about the girl from Wycombe Abbey that had ASD and committed suicide after being given a detention.

Send him to the local state school, use the money you're saving to provide any additional support he needs and if it transpires he would be able to cope in private school you can always send him when he's a bit older.