Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this is outrageous from the school?

288 replies

HarryViles · 09/05/2023 21:42

DS is just 4. He is at pre-school attached to a private school. He had an awful first few months there - very unsettled and unable to concentate - to the point where he is now on waiting list for ASD diagonsis as the pre-school's recommendation.

However, the last few months he has been doing so well. They have always been a little cold but they are professional and followed the local authority's advice and he has responded very well. They tell me all the time how much progress he is making and friends/familiy comment on the incrase in confidence/verbal etc.

Long story short - I went to a meeting today to see about him going to reception to the school in Sep this year - I know they have places.

(He does have a space at a local state school which seems great - just big class sizes but lovely kids and teachers)

The private school told me they couldn't cater for him as well as the state system, and that 'kids like him are better suited in the state system because they have the resources'. They said 'those schools can do things like sensory rooms, breakout areas, and with additional funding can provide 121 support - we can't and won't do any of that as we simply don't have the resources' (the fees are £20k plus a year). The Senco then said "it's not our fault the government don't give us additional money for kids with challenges".

They also said "our governors want us to be more competitive academically, so they are going to invest in that, not support for kids who are strugglign. sorry to be blunt but that's the way it is"

Obviously I don't want him to go there now. We can't barely afford the fees by the way but he's really doing well there - he has friends, he runs in every day, he comes home and tells me what he's learnt - the change in his is enormous so would sell a leg to continue that if I could.

They keep telling me how bright and funny he is, and then when I say about him staying they say "no no, kids like yours aren't catered for here"

He's barely 4 years old.

Isnt' that discrimantory? I feel angry. I know he won't go there. But can private schools basically do what the F they like?

OP posts:
Isitthathardtobekind · 09/05/2023 22:34

Not all private prep schools are just about results, but actually really may not be able to afford the support needed.

Stopsnowing · 09/05/2023 22:30

For all those saying that state schools provide 121 TAs that is usually for kids with Echp and those are not easy to get!

HollyGolightly4 · 09/05/2023 22:29

Erm. I'm genuinely shocked at the responses on this thread. You are not being unreasonable and I think the school is playing a very dangerous game, as to discrimination, under the equality act.

They sound vile, so be glad you don't have to see them again.

Moveoverdarlin · 09/05/2023 22:29

At least they’re being honest and not just taking the 20k fees and hoping for the best when starts in September. Surely it’s good news that the best place for your son is the place he can attend for FREE. Imagine the worse scenario where the best place for your child would cost you 150k for their primary education. Surely this is good news??

Dixiechickonhols · 09/05/2023 22:28

Not all private schools are selective. One near us is aimed at children who would struggle in a big class but not enough to qualify for help - the benefit from a small class/need bit more attention group. It’s not academic.

undergroundstation · 09/05/2023 22:24

It stinks, doesn’t it. It’s a choice they make,
not to meet needs - they COULD do it, either by changing what they offer other kids, or by putting fees up. It’s their choice not to, and they do it to protect their brand. People who pay loads for school don’t want potentially complicated kids about - they are paying for their kids to have an easy life.

get out and don’t look back! Your child will be better served and have a richer schooling experience in the state system.

dont see this as a judgement on your child, in any way. See this as learning more about how our society segregates. From FOUR.

arethereanyleftatall · 09/05/2023 22:24

There's two different types of private school though @IAmADancer
Those that market themselves on being inclusive and supportive; and those that market themselves on results.

anon12093 · 09/05/2023 22:22

What did you say to them to call them out on their shitty behaviour op?

IAmADancer · 09/05/2023 22:21

My son is ND and is at private school. They school have been exceptional in supporting him and I have regular meetings with his teacher and the senco to make sure he is doing well and getting the correct support.

he goes into year 4 in September and will get 1-1 teaching twice a week for 30 mins to make sure he stays on top of his maths and English. They are doing everything they can to help him succeed and he is very happy there.

I’m sorry you have had such a dreadful response from the school your son is at but not all private schools are the same and it might be better looking at others with a strong wellbeing and senco support network.

oneleggedspider · 09/05/2023 22:20

I work in a private school and have also worked in state schools. I would agree that state schools are far better equipped to deal with children with special needs.

It's true that if he needs 1-1 support for example, you will have to pay the salary of the TA, in addition to the school fees.
Many parents do this at the school I work at, but I honestly feel they would be getting a much better deal at a good state school.

State schools that I've worked at have had full time well being staff, family liason officers, 1-1 TA's, small support groups for special needs, dyslexia teachers etc etc, all provided for you. The private school has none of this. Even dyslexia tutoring has to be paid for.

I would take it that they were trying to be honest about what they can provide for your son, and try not to take it personally. Start planning what you can do with the money you'll be saving!

arethereanyleftatall · 09/05/2023 22:17

thaegumathteth · 09/05/2023 22:03

Well I'd just focus on the fact I wouldn't want my 4 year old in that environment. I know it's not great to have to move him but he's 4 and he'll be ok. Honestly I think you've dodged a bullet.

This is a lovely way of looking at it.
I know at our local private school they flaunt all the kids who are thriving there, but there are a great many hidden away who really really aren't. You don't want that for your ds.

I expect a lot of this will be noise from other parents. They're paying a lot, and that's for their child to get more focus and attention than they would in state. They won't get that if the teachers time is taken up by ND.

CaroleSinger · 09/05/2023 22:15

Unfortunately it nay be a case of telling you what you didn't want to hear. I think the implications could be far worse on his development if they didn't tell you so honestly what they are not able to offer going forward. They could be doing you a huge favour here in signposting you to a school which can give him the resources and time that he needs. Private schools are often about bringing out the best in children who are not already with challenges. At least they aren't going to just take your money without being honest about what they can or cannot offer. I live beside a private school and you only need to look at the vehicles dropping the little princess and princesses off to see that it only caters for a certain kind of clientele. They aren't interested in children who aren't already academically advanced for their age at entry level.

Purplestorm83 · 09/05/2023 22:13

It’s horrible, my friend’s son was turned down by a private primary school (and one that claimed to have a progressive ethos at that!) they said he wasn’t suitable for the school. She was heartbroken, I said to her it’s not her son who is unsuitable, the school is unsuitable for him in that case! You could try a Montessori school or there are also schools especially for ASD/ADHD in some areas that might be worth looking into.

UnbeIievabIe · 09/05/2023 22:12

If they are not equipped they are not equipped.

SheilaWilcox · 09/05/2023 22:11

I wonder if they were just trying to be honest and got the tone very badly wrong.
My daughter is at a private school that is not terribly selective. There is a girl in her year that requires extra help and her parents have to pay for everything 'extra' that she needs. She ends up giving up part of some lunchtimes and after school for extra tuition.
Either state or specialist private school may well be a better fit.

It must be hard not to feel hurt, but getting any additional needs identified early can only be a good thing, rather than struggling.
He's not being written off, just being given the opportunity to get the support he deserves.

BecauseLifecanBeHard · 09/05/2023 22:07

‘Fraid they can. I Remember one particularly delightful conversation with the head of dc’s primary school: In which they said: if there was anything provably “wrong” with my dc then they would be asked to leave. Super.

we kept them in the school because it was the best fit locally for them. Though paying the fees grated somewhat.

Both got diagnosis in their fantastic secondary school which literally could not be more supportive.

Radiodread · 09/05/2023 22:04

I am laughing out loud at the notion state schools have all the SEND funding and the poor private ones, none. Also at the idea that it is hard for them to make ends meet right now. There is huge price elasticity in independent schools. Costs go up, prices go up, people pay up -ie the evidence tends to show that there is no correlation between price increases and the share of pupils educated in the independent sector.

They can set academic standards for entry but they are not permitted to refuse admission solely because your child has a disability. Yes, they set their own entry criteria but they are not above the equality act.

OllytheCollie · 09/05/2023 22:04

Reading your post I think they have been careful to word it as 'advising you on the best setting for your child' not directly saying he cannot have a place as that would obviously be discrimination on the grounds of disability. It could still be indirect discrimination if, as a matter of policy, they refuse to adopt inclusive practices for the EYFS and KS1 age groups who let's face it, whether you are super academic or not all benefit from small classes, lots of creative play, sensory stimulation, outdoor play etc and that discourages disabled children from attending who might otherwise enjoy the setting. In theory you could apply for a place anyway and challenge any decision at an equality tribunal but proving indirect discrimination is very hard. Was an SEN governor for years, fortunately at a very inclusive primary. We would not and could not refuse admission on the basis of disability but there were occasions where the HT thought the child might do better in a different school generally because it had better facilities but those are very sensitive conversations to have.

But as you and others have already said you probably want a more welcoming setting for him anyway and I hope you find it, whether state or private. I am sure he is amazing and a better school will appreciate and nurture that.

thaegumathteth · 09/05/2023 22:03

Well I'd just focus on the fact I wouldn't want my 4 year old in that environment. I know it's not great to have to move him but he's 4 and he'll be ok. Honestly I think you've dodged a bullet.

TomatoSandwiches · 09/05/2023 22:02

If your son does indeed have SEN then this discussion you had was probably the first and last time you will have such honesty from people involved with his education.
Thankfully if you get the right help within the state system including an EHCP ( which you can apply for now btw and you should ) you have far more recourse than with Private schooling.

Addymontgomeryfan · 09/05/2023 21:59

The issue they will have is that if he needs 1:1 support the fees you pay per year won't even cover the wages of that person, and being private they can't get that member of staff funded like state school can.

Alittlesummeroasis · 09/05/2023 21:58

It’s horrible, but at least they’ve shown you their priorities early on. They don’t care and won’t offer support, if that is their attitude he is better off elsewhere. Absolutely understand you feeling upset though, I would be too.

Find a school (private or state) that can demonstrate to you how they want the best for your little boy, to support him to reach his potential (whatever it may be), and to feel happy, secure and safe there. Best of luck.

WGACA · 09/05/2023 21:57

They’re a business and everything you’ve been told is true. If you opt out of the state sector you’ll have to pay for every bit of additional support needed.

Clymene · 09/05/2023 21:56

I'm sorry, it really stings. You will come up against his over and over again though so I'm afraid it just become boring in the end.

parietal · 09/05/2023 21:54

i'm afraid that is how private schools work - they don't have extra 121 support for kids who need it, and they are not set up to help autistic kids.

the state school will probably be a much better option, and save the money that you would spend on fees for other support or secondary school.

Swipe left for the next trending thread