Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this is outrageous from the school?

288 replies

HarryViles · 09/05/2023 21:42

DS is just 4. He is at pre-school attached to a private school. He had an awful first few months there - very unsettled and unable to concentate - to the point where he is now on waiting list for ASD diagonsis as the pre-school's recommendation.

However, the last few months he has been doing so well. They have always been a little cold but they are professional and followed the local authority's advice and he has responded very well. They tell me all the time how much progress he is making and friends/familiy comment on the incrase in confidence/verbal etc.

Long story short - I went to a meeting today to see about him going to reception to the school in Sep this year - I know they have places.

(He does have a space at a local state school which seems great - just big class sizes but lovely kids and teachers)

The private school told me they couldn't cater for him as well as the state system, and that 'kids like him are better suited in the state system because they have the resources'. They said 'those schools can do things like sensory rooms, breakout areas, and with additional funding can provide 121 support - we can't and won't do any of that as we simply don't have the resources' (the fees are £20k plus a year). The Senco then said "it's not our fault the government don't give us additional money for kids with challenges".

They also said "our governors want us to be more competitive academically, so they are going to invest in that, not support for kids who are strugglign. sorry to be blunt but that's the way it is"

Obviously I don't want him to go there now. We can't barely afford the fees by the way but he's really doing well there - he has friends, he runs in every day, he comes home and tells me what he's learnt - the change in his is enormous so would sell a leg to continue that if I could.

They keep telling me how bright and funny he is, and then when I say about him staying they say "no no, kids like yours aren't catered for here"

He's barely 4 years old.

Isnt' that discrimantory? I feel angry. I know he won't go there. But can private schools basically do what the F they like?

OP posts:
Zuyi · 09/05/2023 23:05

It's disgusting. They are the worst. At least you know now, though.

PurposefulBear · 09/05/2023 23:04

Palomabalom · 09/05/2023 23:01

Private schools can discriminate as long as they can argue that having the child at the school could cause issues for other children and impact the welfare, wellbeing and education of other students. There is often pressure from other parents who don’t want any children there who are disruptive or time and resource hungry taking away from their own child’s education

I’m not quite sure what you’re saying, do you mean they should be obliged to take a child under these circumstances?

JaniceBattersby · 09/05/2023 23:03

And we wonder why this government with a cabinet made up of people straight out of fancy, expensive, selective public schools with zero pupils with SEN, or disabilities, or any type of issues that are unpalatable for the school, have such low regard for anyone who is not an A-grade go-getter from Surrey.

SisterSister23 · 09/05/2023 23:03

That doesn't sound like a good private school to be honest. At my private school (almost half the fees of yours) they have a range of SEND, including ASD. Yes, they don't have the TAs or sensory rooms etc that some specialist schools or large state schools have. But the students benefit from smaller class sizes, quieter environments. So I'm quite shocked they would say that straight to your face. Especially at 4 years old - how could they possibly know he would struggle at that age? Plus, they could cater for SEND kids if they wanted but would rather spend money elsewhere that's less effort and all they care about is results - which says a lot about their ethics and motives. Best avoid.

Palomabalom · 09/05/2023 23:01

Private schools can discriminate as long as they can argue that having the child at the school could cause issues for other children and impact the welfare, wellbeing and education of other students. There is often pressure from other parents who don’t want any children there who are disruptive or time and resource hungry taking away from their own child’s education

Remaker · 09/05/2023 22:59

Literally the whole point of private schools is they pick and choose who goes there. It feels lovely and special when your child is one of the chosen ones. Parents talk up how difficult it is to get in because that makes them feel even more special. But in order to create that exclusive environment there must be the kids who are kept out. And sadly that includes some who are told to their faces that they don’t belong.

My friend’s DS was bullied at school for being gay. After 5 years of paying extortionate fees when his parents went to the school for help they were told it’s probably not the right school for him. Other parents at that school assure me the pastoral care is first rate - their kids are the chosen ones of course.

You’ve had a lucky escape but I’m sorry, it must be hurtful to be rejected like that.

Hiddenvoice · 09/05/2023 22:57

Private schools can afford it more than state schools, sadly some just don’t want to. They were brutally honest and have pretty much said they are focussed on being “competitive academically” meaning they are test driven.
Everything they have said would massively put me off that school and I’d be thankful my child wouldn’t be attending. I would have remained polite during the meeting, I’d have politely reminded them that it’s a shame they wouldn’t provide any additional resources for all children seeing as they are in a good position to provide it then I’d leave.
Not all private schools are like that, some provide sensory/nurture rooms and one to one support because it can benefit all children.
I know you’re worried about your child going into a new environment but no matter what school he attends, it will all be new to him and will be a big change.
When you find the school that’s best for him then you can help get him ready by walking past it, visiting it, talking about break and lunch times etc. it will be a big change but he will adapt over time and make new friends.

JMSA · 09/05/2023 22:57

It's a well known fact that children with additional needs are best catered for in the state system. They were completely right in what they told you.

BringItBackBruno · 09/05/2023 22:57

My child was "encouraged out" of the local state primary as they couldn't cater to her social and higher academic needs. We were forced into private, it works both ways.

MrsSkylerWhite · 09/05/2023 22:56

Most independents take this stance.

Scattery · 09/05/2023 22:55

YANBU, that's a horrid way to treat any child. Substitute just about anything else for "autistic" and it sure feels discriminatory to me.

I've encountered some awful people along the way (people who read "autism" and don't want my son around) but do remember you will meet a few truly lovely ones as well, people who are inclusive and understanding.

I'm personally very against private education and my 14yo autistic DS is currently thriving in state education and predicted 7+ in all his GCSEs. You're gonna find your road even if it isn't the one you expected.

JTro · 09/05/2023 22:54

Let me share my story. When my DC1 was assessed at private primary (preparatory) for a place at the reception class, I had the same outcome as you did. They did not like my DC1 as my DC1 was not as verbal as others (yes, DC1 had speech delay due to being bi-lingual, but they did not care). I was upset and could not uderstand why. My DC1 went to a state primary, when there was a time to apply for secondary, DC1 got 2 academic scolarships (35% and 40%) at well-regarded private secondaries and a place at the local grammar school. We chose the grammar school, where DC1 is thriving. So, please, forget what they are saying to you as you know you DC much better than them and there is nothing wrong with a good state primary, where you've got a place.

ThisDayThatDay · 09/05/2023 22:53

HarryViles · 09/05/2023 21:54

I knew they were selective in later years - and that there are entrance exams etc of course i kow that.

But at 4. to turn him down due to suspected neurodiversity. that i didn't expect. especially when they also tell me he's made amazing progress in all areas.

It's a weird one as I don't want him to go there anymore - their loss - but I feel angry and defensive over him.

I don't blame you one bit for feeling like that.

Frankly, he's probably far better out of a school like that. Your son has you in his corner - he'll be fine.

Allfizzandfun · 09/05/2023 22:52

It’s heartbreaking to hear someone reject your child. We’ve been there, both state and private- too many SEN requirements for some, not SEN enough for others. We’re now on our fourth school, and he’s about to move again in September for Yr 7. It’s hard but do try other private schools if you can. Ideally not boarding as they are all now seemingly becoming more selective. They don’t have to be. They can make allowances and some have fanatics resources but they don’t need to if they don’t want to. We’ve managed to find a lovely school (private) that hopefully will support him through to GCSEs. Good luck!

PurposefulBear · 09/05/2023 22:51

I’m sorry you’ve had this experience, but I think the school is right to set guidelines around what it can and cannot support.

To you, this is your son and nothing matters more. You expect from your fees that his needs should be fully catered for because it is a private school.

To the school, there may be any number of children in a similar position, many of whom go to private schools because of it, and the school is aware that there is a limitation to how much support they can commit.

To the other parents, there is an imbalance in the time and attention that some children receive compared to others when everyone wants their child to do well in their own way. As a parent of a middle of the road child at a private preprep, I have seen my child’s teachers’ time absolutely monopolised having to support children with SN, to the extent that it leaves the teacher much less time for the rest of the school / class.

I’m not saying whether it’s right or wrong, just that resources are not infinite just because you’re paying for it.

You will know when you find the right environment and most importantly it will be somewhere where you feel your dc fit in and are at home.

AuntieObnoxious · 09/05/2023 22:51

I’m sorry this happened to you, the same thing happened with my DS years ago. Luckily we also had a place at a state school (small village one) - he’s now 15 and at a special school- oversubscribed, & wonderful. The primary school helped us get the place & were so supportive. Sometimes things happen for a reason. Good luck & don’t let it get you down

Climbles · 09/05/2023 22:49

YANBU for feeling hurt and a sense of rejection on his behalf. However, they are probably right that he will be better off in a non-private school unless you can pay for extra support on top of school fees.
When he is a world famous millionaire he will have a good narrative arc for his biography and they will be kicking themselves.

Starplekk · 09/05/2023 22:48

At least they're being honest although appreciate its not nice to hear. Private schools can't access funding in the same way state schools can for children who require 1:1s etc. Here they charge additional on top of the fees for TAs, so children who need a 1:1 have to pay the standard fee everyone does and then for every hour their child needs that support- it can get very pricey.

Labtastic · 09/05/2023 22:46

Yes they are. Of course they can afford it if the want to. state schools don't get anywhere near 20k per child

Of course private schools get far more money in each year than state schools, but they just don't routinely budget for additional needs. While £20k a year per pupil sounds (and is!) a lot of money, it's all budgeted for already in more favourable teacher:pupil ratios, specialist subject teachers, clubs, facilities, sports etc etc. Staff costs are something like 80%+ of a school's budget, so if you've got a teacher and a TA in a class of 12 already, as crazy as it sounds the money won't be there for an additional 1:1 for an individual pupil without the parents forking out extra. While they take in a huge amount in fee receipts each year, most private schools aren't sitting on a ton of cash reserves. It's all in and all out on a planned budget. (Not saying it's right or wrong, just a fact).

Yazo · 09/05/2023 22:45

It's disgusting, private schools can be awful and this is 100% why I'd never send my boys to one. They claim they have the brightest kids but they really don't, they have the ones that are most likely to be good (and easy) customers, whatever that looks like. It's a shame now he's settling but private schools have so much disruption with kids in and out so friendships are less likely to be long term anyway. I think how they've treated the referral process as a bit of an excuse to refuse a place is disgusting, it must happen to so many families throughout school even if they get all the way to exams of they don't make the grade. Better to keep your head up, cut your losses and good luck to you and your family, he can do amazingly well in the state system whether he has different abilities or not.

Nevermind31 · 09/05/2023 22:44

State schools do get some funding if your child has a plan. They may get a 1:1. They also can refer for assessments.
my child’s state school has interventions, a sensory room, a special class for those who cannot be in mainstream all day. They buy in support (e.g. language therapist).
a private school cannot refer for assessment- parents will need to pay. No interventions - parents usually pay extra. No 1:1, unless parents pay extra.
Private schools don’t necessarily want to invest in these areas - a lot of parents will complain that their fees are spent on extra support that their children are not benefiting from.
so it might not be that they don’t want your son - they are saying that they don’t have the right resources and would need to buy them in. For which you would need to pay.
it could get very expensive very fast.
I hope your son will thrive at his new school, and once you have a better understanding of what his needs are, you will be able to find the right support for him.
with £20k a year you can do an awful lot

Sugargliderwombat · 09/05/2023 22:38

I think you have had a lucky escape OP.

StillWantingADog · 09/05/2023 22:37

Absolutely rubbish for you but good to know now rather than further down the line

there are some private schools well equipped for kids like your ds however the best option for you will likely be to send him to a good state option and be willing to pay for extra help if required

Clymene · 09/05/2023 22:36

HollyGolightly4 · 09/05/2023 22:29

Erm. I'm genuinely shocked at the responses on this thread. You are not being unreasonable and I think the school is playing a very dangerous game, as to discrimination, under the equality act.

They sound vile, so be glad you don't have to see them again.

Private schools have no obligation to accept any pupil.

GOW56 · 09/05/2023 22:36

Deathbyfluffy · 09/05/2023 21:51

They’re not being discriminatory - they’ve not outright said he has to leave, just that they don’t have the resources to give him the extra stuff he needs.

That’s their choice I’m afraid

Yes they are. Of course they can afford it if the want to. state schools don't get anywhere near 20k per child. They said they want to concentrate on academic results not support.
This is why private schools get good results. It's not because they are better it's because they are selective. You will find better teachers in state schools.