Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Arrested for holding a banner - can't ruin a big day, can we... PART 2

209 replies

vera99 · 09/05/2023 13:32

A continuation of the debate started at https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/4800317-arrested-for-holding-a-banner-cant-ruin-a-big-day-can-we?page=39&reply=126045871

OP posts:
Thread gallery
24
Novella4 · 09/05/2023 16:09

@vera99
I couldn't agree more with your post below

"Once you get to 50% then that is a watershed moment. If they have any sense they will use their time now to pause and reflect as to what works and what doesn't and how they can be more accountable and relevant particularly to the younger generation. From where I'm standing that just doesn't seem to be happening and since they cannot be political (the Rwanda comments and Johnson was interesting and in a very limited and specific way I'm with the ex-PM this - the King cannot countermand or seek to influence elected representatives) then endless guff about clothes, opening leisure centres or an occasional visit to a food bank or hospital and the like just seems pointless and totally out of touch with 21st Century Britain.

Britain was and is a great country - but we desperately need an election, electoral reform and a progressive consensus around issues such as housebuilding at pace, the climate crisis, employment, pensions, the NHS, affordable childcare and a country that works for the many not the few in all aspects of our lives. Not one hollowed and pillaged for short term profits by a rapacious financial class.

Otherwise, there is no real future for those coming through at the base. From the young people I know the monarchy is a symptom of an unequal society getting more unequal by the day and has no relevance at all to their lived lives."

I feel this coronation has been a watershed moment . Yes I know some posters love 'pomp' but that isn't always how it's viewed here or internationally.
It's looking a bit ridiculous and ossified. A bit of the Miss Havershim's about it

So much of the 'pomp' is military and connected to a long gone empire . There was an article in the New York Times saying just that . I'll link it if I find it again

vera99 · 09/05/2023 15:52

NeverMyKing · 09/05/2023 15:21

This link is frightening - “the crowds cheered the arrests”. Well yes they would wouldn’t they? 🤦‍♀️ So it’s now mob rule? Whoever cheers the loudest gets the police to arrest the others.

This is the moron who is sorting out the Met? God help us all.

He might like to say they were cheering was in a first draft that I unfortunately sent out in error ! What an absolutely terrible thing to say about cheering, like you say, it's tacitly supporting mob rule. Maybe officers would like to search through all the rubbish left behind on the Mall and send fixed penalty notices to the offenders since they have a very low tolerance for disruption.

OP posts:
Roussette · 09/05/2023 15:50

Zuve · 09/05/2023 15:39

They knew they would be in trouble. The police can not win. Yes I think they had to be arrested.

They had months of talks with the Police before the event. Even on Friday the CEO of Republic had agreement from the police force to stand where they did. The Police knew how many placards they were taking, everything.

So your post saying they had to be arrested is about as valid as me having to be arrested for going to Sainsburys instead of Tesco!

countrygirl99 · 09/05/2023 15:44

Zuve · 09/05/2023 15:39

They knew they would be in trouble. The police can not win. Yes I think they had to be arrested.

I'm confused. Why would Republic expect trouble when they had agreement from the very police force that arrested them? Why would the team that help women out on the streets at 2am expect trouble from the police force whose logo they have on their hi-viz?

DuncinToffee · 09/05/2023 15:41

Zuve · 09/05/2023 15:39

They knew they would be in trouble. The police can not win. Yes I think they had to be arrested.

Who is 'they'?

The people from Republic who had held detailed discussions and agreements with the police beforehand?

Zuve · 09/05/2023 15:39

They knew they would be in trouble. The police can not win. Yes I think they had to be arrested.

vera99 · 09/05/2023 15:35

Novella4 · 09/05/2023 15:05

One royalist argument you hear all the time is that the Windsors are apolitical ( not!) and that they unite the country

They really don't .
They are pushing it to say they unite England but once it's 50/50 - what then ?

Once you get to 50% then that is a watershed moment. If they have any sense they will use their time now to pause and reflect as to what works and what doesn't and how they can be more accountable and relevant particularly to the younger generation. From where I'm standing that just doesn't seem to be happening and since they cannot be political (the Rwanda comments and Johnson was interesting and in a very limited and specific way I'm with the ex-PM this - the King cannot countermand or seek to influence elected representatives) then endless guff about clothes, opening leisure centres or an occasional visit to a food bank or hospital and the like just seems pointless and totally out of touch with 21st Century Britain.

Britain was and is a great country - but we desperately need an election, electoral reform and a progressive consensus around issues such as housebuilding at pace, the climate crisis, employment, pensions, the NHS, affordable childcare and a country that works for the many not the few in all aspects of our lives. Not one hollowed and pillaged for short term profits by a rapacious financial class.

Otherwise, there is no real future for those coming through at the base. From the young people I know the monarchy is a symptom of an unequal society getting more unequal by the day and has no relevance at all to their lived lives.

OP posts:
countrygirl99 · 09/05/2023 15:31

milveycrohn · 09/05/2023 15:29

I think the police are caught between a rock and a hard place, tbh.
We saw something, I believe at the late Queen's funeral, when a protestor was attacked by others nearby trying to show their respect. So it may be that the police thought that protestors would cause a similar type of incident, where one or more could be attacked by others trying to celebrate.
On the whole, I think protestors should be allowed, but I think the police can't win. If protestors had caused an incident, they presumably thought it best they were not there.
I think it largely depends on the kind of protest. There were rumours that some 'Stop oil' protesters were going to blow some kind of whistle to disturb the horses, which can be very dangerous. The horse can bolt, or charge into the crowd. So, the police were possibly heavy handed, but maybe they saw it as being cautious.

Surely it's the people attacking others who should be arrested. Or is violence by Royalists acceptable these days?

countrygirl99 · 09/05/2023 15:30

It's the old saying about a lie being half way round the world while the truth is still putting it's shoes on.

milveycrohn · 09/05/2023 15:29

I think the police are caught between a rock and a hard place, tbh.
We saw something, I believe at the late Queen's funeral, when a protestor was attacked by others nearby trying to show their respect. So it may be that the police thought that protestors would cause a similar type of incident, where one or more could be attacked by others trying to celebrate.
On the whole, I think protestors should be allowed, but I think the police can't win. If protestors had caused an incident, they presumably thought it best they were not there.
I think it largely depends on the kind of protest. There were rumours that some 'Stop oil' protesters were going to blow some kind of whistle to disturb the horses, which can be very dangerous. The horse can bolt, or charge into the crowd. So, the police were possibly heavy handed, but maybe they saw it as being cautious.

PollyThePixie · 09/05/2023 15:29

I hadn’t heard that the Police had corrected what was on the news.

Roussette · 09/05/2023 15:27

PollyThePixie · 09/05/2023 15:25

The arrests I’m aware of were of people in a van that contained placards as well as chains and padlocks. By all means protest with your banners but planning on chaining yourself to walls etc is too much.

No chains
No padlocks

String or straps to hold the placards together in the back of the van so they weren't sliding around. Even the Police have confirmed this

Please be aware that what you are saying is not true.

Frabbits · 09/05/2023 15:26

PollyThePixie · 09/05/2023 15:25

The arrests I’m aware of were of people in a van that contained placards as well as chains and padlocks. By all means protest with your banners but planning on chaining yourself to walls etc is too much.

Not true.

They had ordinary fabric luggage straps with them, as often used with placards to stop them being dropped/blown around in the wind and stuff. Nothing that could be used to actually attach yourself to anything.

Roussette · 09/05/2023 15:26

NeverMyKing · 09/05/2023 15:21

This link is frightening - “the crowds cheered the arrests”. Well yes they would wouldn’t they? 🤦‍♀️ So it’s now mob rule? Whoever cheers the loudest gets the police to arrest the others.

This is the moron who is sorting out the Met? God help us all.

Someone posted about how they wouldn't want a rabble spoiling everything, holding placards, shouting. How they would feel intimidated.

My god, the rabble are royalists ... I saw some footage and their language telling the group of protestors to fuck off and worse, was awful. That's what you call a rabble. They are the intimidating ones, as the Republic people are in a tiny minority.

Those from Republic are told how to behave, what to bring with them, what not to bring with them etc.

Yet the Royalists can do exactly what they want, leave the place looking like a warzone when they've finished cheering their man in a crown...

PollyThePixie · 09/05/2023 15:25

The arrests I’m aware of were of people in a van that contained placards as well as chains and padlocks. By all means protest with your banners but planning on chaining yourself to walls etc is too much.

NeverMyKing · 09/05/2023 15:22

@Frabbits absolutely. By his logic whoever cheers the loudest wins the fight.

NeverMyKing · 09/05/2023 15:21

This link is frightening - “the crowds cheered the arrests”. Well yes they would wouldn’t they? 🤦‍♀️ So it’s now mob rule? Whoever cheers the loudest gets the police to arrest the others.

This is the moron who is sorting out the Met? God help us all.

Frabbits · 09/05/2023 15:21

What a load of shite that article is.

NeverMyKing · 09/05/2023 15:06

Yes their argument on Saturday was that our right to protest is contextual - a truly horrifying thought. Republic have been protesting at quite a number of royal events since September - it’ll be interesting to see the “context” of the next one.

There were about 2000 protesters there - far more than were shown on the BBC. Why is the BBC censoring what the viewers see?!?

Novella4 · 09/05/2023 15:05

One royalist argument you hear all the time is that the Windsors are apolitical ( not!) and that they unite the country

They really don't .
They are pushing it to say they unite England but once it's 50/50 - what then ?

Roussette · 09/05/2023 14:43

Whaeanui · 09/05/2023 14:41

He did really well with that interview considering how combative Kay was, she’s so rude!

Yes, the only consolation is... she is exactly the same with whoever she interviews so it definitely wasn't personal or biaised.

Roussette · 09/05/2023 14:42

Whaeanui · 09/05/2023 14:34

Their policing on Saturday was about the king first. They as much admitted it when they suggested rights depended on what occasion it was."

Thats really bad isn’t it?

Yes. It had to sink in with me too.

So ... if you are protesting about climate change or the CoL, or NHS workers protesting, that appears to be OK. (But no Stop Oil) But if you are protesting about the Monarchy, it isn't.

Whaeanui · 09/05/2023 14:41

He did really well with that interview considering how combative Kay was, she’s so rude!

Novella4 · 09/05/2023 14:40

I haven't read the thread but I just want to say thanks for the new thread

This is so important

I hope I'm wrong but I suspect 'they'
didn't want any protestors seen - I don't know if that was from baby charles or the government but it has backfired

I have seen tweets from people who were there saying the crowds were much bigger than the media showed - if they showed them at all

Graham Smith is doing a great job so far

Swipe left for the next trending thread