Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Arrested for holding a banner - can't ruin a big day, can we... PART 2

209 replies

vera99 · 09/05/2023 13:32

A continuation of the debate started at https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/4800317-arrested-for-holding-a-banner-cant-ruin-a-big-day-can-we?page=39&reply=126045871

OP posts:
Thread gallery
24
NeverMyKing · 09/05/2023 21:36

These are the “lock on” devices 🙄. Which bit are we making up @Boudicasbeard? I’m intrigued.

Arrested for holding a banner - can't ruin a big day, can we... PART 2
Roussette · 09/05/2023 21:33

Boudicasbeard · 09/05/2023 21:31

I mean that 75% of things you read online are either straight up bullshit or heavily reinterpreted.

A lot of the things I read on Mumsnet set off my bullshit alarm, none more so when people rely on the opinions created by group think.

It would be nice if people spent more time in the real world and less time recycling crap online. The Chinese whispers are insane.

Any particular bit of what we are discussing at this moment in time?

I am listening to different news channels, and reading many varied news outlets. Nothing has led me to believe anything is incorrect on the false arrests and subsequent apologies by high up in the Met.

pointythings · 09/05/2023 21:33

Boudicasbeard · 09/05/2023 21:31

I mean that 75% of things you read online are either straight up bullshit or heavily reinterpreted.

A lot of the things I read on Mumsnet set off my bullshit alarm, none more so when people rely on the opinions created by group think.

It would be nice if people spent more time in the real world and less time recycling crap online. The Chinese whispers are insane.

So is this you agreeing that with regard to Republic, the police got it badly wrong, caused reputational damage to itself and made the UK look bad around the world? Given that there will be no charges and that the police actually apologised and admitted they mishandled it...

Roussette · 09/05/2023 21:31

It is headlines on ITV news, just seen a clip of the upcoming News at Ten.

This... from the article...

Smith can see the value of all that now, he says. A friend of a friend spotted him on the TV news in Mexico. “If they were trying to diminish our publicity in order to enhance theirs, it massively backfired, in a spectacular way,” he says. And yet, he appears genuinely troubled as he details for the first time the full extent of the conversations and agreements he had with a senior officer in charge of policing the coronation, Supt Martin Kirby.

Mexico????!

A very bad look the whole thing is

Boudicasbeard · 09/05/2023 21:31

I mean that 75% of things you read online are either straight up bullshit or heavily reinterpreted.

A lot of the things I read on Mumsnet set off my bullshit alarm, none more so when people rely on the opinions created by group think.

It would be nice if people spent more time in the real world and less time recycling crap online. The Chinese whispers are insane.

cakeorwine · 09/05/2023 21:30

It’s good to remember that things you read online are often not true and don’t reflect real life

It's been interesting to read the papers like the Express and the Mail and how they have covered this. Even the choice of images seek to carry an impression. As well as missing out key bits of information - all to create an impression.

Overall, the police did a good job on the Coronation. There were no terrorist incidents or disruption. I do think that's a good thing - I think there is a time and a place for disruptive protest. However, this action has damaged the reputation.

We police by consent in this country. I don't know what happens if the police lose that consent.

pointythings · 09/05/2023 21:29

It’s good to remember that things you read online are often not true and don’t reflect real life.

You mean like lock on devices being found (only it turned out there were none?)

DuncinToffee · 09/05/2023 21:27

It’s good to remember that things you read online are often not true and don’t reflect real life.

You mean like rape alarms being used to scare horses?

Boudicasbeard · 09/05/2023 21:25

Difference of opinion should be encouraged.

Civil discussion would be ideal. But unfortunately the internet is not often the place to find that civil discussion. People are often far more rude and aggressive when they can’t see the person they are talking to.

It’s good to remember that things you read online are often not true and don’t reflect real life.

Remember: the world is actually round, not flat.

NeverMyKing · 09/05/2023 21:24

@Boudicasbeard you don’t really believe they did this for safety though do you? Why would they not say that at the time? They arrested them first THEN searched the van and THEN invented some BS about lock on straps 🙄. It was a political arrest.

@vera99 you’ll be waiting until hell freezes over until Charles speaks out in favour of protest. He’ll want to see the Republic crushed. He has no interest in debate.

Crustsamongus · 09/05/2023 21:24

Roussette · 09/05/2023 21:19

It seems to me as if a difference of opinion isn't accepted by some on here.

Ain't that the truth! I don't go on the RF board often, but from what I've seen there are a few royalist posters who get rather angry and combative/ rude about all the republican posters being rude. Haven't come across much if any actual examples of rudeness from republican posters...

Roussette · 09/05/2023 21:19

It seems to me as if a difference of opinion isn't accepted by some on here.

Crustsamongus · 09/05/2023 21:18

Boudicasbeard · 09/05/2023 21:05

I think at an event involving this many people in such a confined area of London, involving so many variables (horses especially) that the police are right to be cautious for everyone’s safety.

in the same way that anti-abortion protesters are no longer allowed to stand right in front of clinics and harass women as they enter.

Or we would want pro- Brexit protesters to be held back from the anti-Brexit marchers to prevent violence.

The right to protest isn’t the right to disrupt or cause violence- some people fail the understand this.

And I’m not going to further engage in accusations of bad behaviour on the royal family boards. People can read for themselves and come to their own conclusions.

Anti-abortion protestors can stand in other agreed areas, and would not be arrested for doing so. As much as I oppose their views, they have a right to express them in a way that doesn't affect the right of others to access healthcare.

The right to protest isn’t the right to disrupt or cause violence- some people fail the understand this.

And some people are wilfully misrepresenting what happened with the Republic members who were arrested on Saturday morning. There was no intention to disrupt the coronation and no intention to cause violence. This is a complete strawman argument.

Boudicasbeard · 09/05/2023 21:18

I think you’ve just proven my point for me @vera99

I do hope @mnhq will consider a Republican board.

Roussette · 09/05/2023 21:18

And I’m not going to further engage in accusations of bad behaviour on the royal family boards. People can read for themselves and come to their own conclusions

Totally agree.

If you read the Guardian article you will see the lengths Republic went to, to keep the Police informed and were assigned a Police Liaison Officer who agreed everything with them right up until Coronation Day

Anyway, it's all confirmed now with apologies from the Met. And apologies at the Graham Smith's house person to person from the Chief Inspector.

vera99 · 09/05/2023 21:17

Roussette · 09/05/2023 21:03

Does the beliefs of the protestors affect people's reactions to the story?

Interesting.

The Tories have agreed to animal testing after 25 years. What if the protest was on Coronation Day to bring this awful backtrack to the attention of the Monarchy?

Or not even on Coronation day but any time, and protestors arrested under this law?

The Telegraph ran a puff piece that the ban on fox hunting had contributed to the collapse of the fox population in the countryside. Seems to be something in the air of a rollback to the rulers and the ruled, the rich man in his castle the poor man at the gate stuff. Charles did that back in the day lest we forget. A HUGE red line for me.

I would be very happy with a Republican board as well and as Roussette points out at a lot of the abuse has come from sneery, goady monarchists SHOUTING IN CAPS at the losers that literally NO ONE CARES ABOUT and don't engage in any meaningful way. That said there's no need for abuse from either side and civilised discussion, even if we have opposing viewpoints should be the order of the day.

OP posts:
cakeorwine · 09/05/2023 21:16

I think at an event involving this many people in such a confined area of London, involving so many variables (horses especially) that the police are right to be cautious for everyone’s safety

But. As has been pointed out - and even by the police, there was a protest that was allowed to take place.

Republic organised the protest. It was agreed.

6 people from Republic were arrested - and after some misinformation, it seems they were arrested under the charge of going prepared to lock on (a charge under the new law)

As on the previous thread - there are several outcomes from the moment of arrest.

They should have realised / listened to Graham and listened to the fact that he was the Chair of Republic who are not known for such direct action.

They could have removed the luggage straps and let them carry on their way.

They could have arrested them and released them earlier when they realised the circumstances.

Instead, they held them for 16 hours
The news has dominated the headlines for a few days.
There's been an urgent question in the House.
Republic have had massive publicity
A Chief Inspector has apologised.
The Head of the Met has written a worrying article mentioning the police being applauded for arresting protestors.

I am not sure this was the outcome the police and the Government were looking for.

Boudicasbeard · 09/05/2023 21:05

I think at an event involving this many people in such a confined area of London, involving so many variables (horses especially) that the police are right to be cautious for everyone’s safety.

in the same way that anti-abortion protesters are no longer allowed to stand right in front of clinics and harass women as they enter.

Or we would want pro- Brexit protesters to be held back from the anti-Brexit marchers to prevent violence.

The right to protest isn’t the right to disrupt or cause violence- some people fail the understand this.

And I’m not going to further engage in accusations of bad behaviour on the royal family boards. People can read for themselves and come to their own conclusions.

cakeorwine · 09/05/2023 21:04

Interesting article

‘It massively backfired’: Republicanism in spotlight after arrests | Protest | The Guardian

An extra £50,000 in income.

This bit is interesting

Around midday, the detective looked in. “He said: ‘You’re making the news around the world.’ You know, I immediately felt more bullish although it was sort of 11 hours before I got out.”

11 hours after the detective said this - and they got released, having made the news around the world.

‘It massively backfired’: Republicanism in spotlight after arrests

Head of Republic campaign group believes detention at coronation was premeditated attempt to kill protests

https://www.theguardian.com/world/2023/may/09/it-massively-backfired-republicanism-in-spotlight-after-arrests

Roussette · 09/05/2023 21:03

Does the beliefs of the protestors affect people's reactions to the story?

Interesting.

The Tories have agreed to animal testing after 25 years. What if the protest was on Coronation Day to bring this awful backtrack to the attention of the Monarchy?

Or not even on Coronation day but any time, and protestors arrested under this law?

cakeorwine · 09/05/2023 21:00

I wonder if the reactions would have been different if a different group of protestors had been arrested under this law under similar circumstances.

Does the beliefs of the protestors affect people's reactions to the story?

It would be an interesting psychology experiment - to give different groups of people different versions of an event with different protagonists, and to see their reactions and who they side with.

cakeorwine · 09/05/2023 20:56

Boudicasbeard · 09/05/2023 20:39

It’s actually quite nice that this is out in the open on the AIBU forum so general Mumsnet users can see some of the behaviour of posters who frequent the royal family board to goad, sneer and generally berate people who wanting to talk about the royals in a more positive way.

@mnhq is there any chance of a Republican board where people can go to discuss anti monarchy stuff. The royal family board has become unusable recently. I’m all for debate but the tone is so aggressive and unhelpful that you spend more time asking people to be civil than actually discussing anything at all. Surely the republicans would enjoy a space to themselves, in the spirit of everyone getting to have a space to be themselves.

This though isn't about the Monarchy. I have my opinions - but this - as the original thread - is about the right to protest.

It will be interesting to see the case law when someone eventually gets charged under this and appeals. Hopefully we will still be in the EHCR?

Roussette · 09/05/2023 20:54

Mumsnet users can see some of the behaviour of posters who frequent the royal family board to goad, sneer and generally berate people

You cannot lay this on those who aren't Royalists. The most deleted posts for sneering, insulting and general PAs are from those that support the RF wholeheartedly and get incensed at a different opinion. I've seen it, felt it, had numerous attacking posts deleted.

Happy with a republican area, or on Royal threads or AIBU. Either way it would be hijacked betcha. Take for instance, the thread on Coronation Day talking about the arrests, certain posters came in to sneer and insult when all we were doing was having an in depth conversation about the arrests of Republic staff.

DuncinToffee · 09/05/2023 20:49

This is not an anti monarchy thread, it's about the right to protest.

Cheguevarahamster · 09/05/2023 20:49

Boudicasbeard · 09/05/2023 20:39

It’s actually quite nice that this is out in the open on the AIBU forum so general Mumsnet users can see some of the behaviour of posters who frequent the royal family board to goad, sneer and generally berate people who wanting to talk about the royals in a more positive way.

@mnhq is there any chance of a Republican board where people can go to discuss anti monarchy stuff. The royal family board has become unusable recently. I’m all for debate but the tone is so aggressive and unhelpful that you spend more time asking people to be civil than actually discussing anything at all. Surely the republicans would enjoy a space to themselves, in the spirit of everyone getting to have a space to be themselves.

I'd love a republican board.