Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder who decided that customers want small talk at the till in a shop?

319 replies

YouWonJayne · 09/05/2023 12:31

Seriously I want to know their names. Which suits sat in a boardroom and said “Do you know what customers really want? When they’re stressed and frazzled trying the find a plain black shirt and black skirt for a 9 year old’s school play, which BTW are nigh-on impossible to find, when they get to the till they want the assistant to ask what they’re up to this morning and if they’re busy? That will keep customers happy!”

The poor girl on the checkout was trying her best not to look bored as she asked the woman in front of me “Have you got much planned this morning? Do you have a busy day” especially when the woman have details of all the wedding outfits she needed to buy for her grandchildren.

I hope the assistant was relieved when I just gave a “No” when she asked me the same. I really couldn’t be arsed.

I noticed this everywhere now. Is it just me who doesn’t actually want small talk, who just wants to buy my stuff and get on with me day without being a conversationalist extraordinaire? Don’t get me started on upselling! Or the people in Lush who pounce when you’re through the door. It’s completely insufferable.

The worst part is these poor people (probably on minimum wage) get bollocked if they don’t behave this way. I can’t imagine any of them want to behave this way.

I feel like it needs a serious platform, a campaign called Leave Shoppers Alone (half joking) 😂

OP posts:
Blossomtoes · 11/05/2023 12:31

The ability to actually speak comfortably and easily to other humans seems to be slipping away from some people.

It will continue to do so if people take exception to normal human interaction. I bet they’re the same people who won’t answer their door.

winelove · 11/05/2023 12:21

Surely it is part of being human, as someone else said it might be the only time a customer has talked to someone all day.

Gtsr443 · 11/05/2023 12:17

And the flip side - I walked out of two shops yesterday without spending anything because the owners were rude twats without a shred of social skills and I'll never go back.
If you can't be arsed to be friendly and polite then you don't get my money.
The ability to actually speak comfortably and easily to other humans seems to be slipping away from some people.

LyingWitchInTheWardrobe · 11/05/2023 12:17

I find Waitrose very bad for this. Checkout staff don't seem to care if there's a queue forming because they appear to have a mandate for chatting with customers. Supermarkets are not a destination for me, I go in to buy what I need with a quick hello and thank you, and I'm off out of there...

I can just about cope with that but I do not like it when they paw your purchases. I spent time picking a nice-looking, ready-to-eat salad, multiple ingredients and a sauce of some kind. I saved it to last item so that I could put it on top and the contents remain undisturbed only for the checkout person to proclaim that it 'looked nice', turning it upside down to see what the ingredients were. I was really annoyed. Angry

Just stop. If you cannot read people and respond accordingly then just do the minimum with politeness, you can't go wrong there.

My2pence2day · 11/05/2023 12:10

EarthwormJane · 09/05/2023 12:38

You might not like it, but for some people, that person on the till is the only person that they've spoken to all weekend.

This

YouWonJayne · 11/05/2023 12:00

dottypotter · 10/05/2023 10:57

Dreadful Post.

Miserable c*
Springs to mind.

Good grief what a melodramatic overreaction!

OP posts:
Justleaveitblankthen · 11/05/2023 09:16

EarthwormJane · 09/05/2023 12:38

You might not like it, but for some people, that person on the till is the only person that they've spoken to all weekend.

I always remind myself of this, usually in Tesco, where the Staff never hurry anyone along and are always friendly (Aldi not so much 😂)
It brightens me up- even if I am rushed and stressed- just to have friendly smalltalk for a moment while I'm packing/paying.
It doesn't hold anyone up.

Roselilly36 · 11/05/2023 08:50

Light chitchat fine, but some staff really don’t have any idea what this is.

I was in a store the other day a customer was buying a regular household item and said to the assistant something along the lines of I am buying these instead of using the expensive ones bought as wedding gifts, for the assistant to ask “are you still married?” The customer replied, no, I honestly couldn’t believe what I was hearing. Why on earth would you ask such a question?

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 10/05/2023 23:26

Different coloured baskets/trolleys for those of us who want to left alone please

But what if they've run out of 'leave me alone' blue baskets and they only have 'please accost me relentlessly' red ones left? Do you have to awkwardly carry all your shopping in your arms or take the wrong basket and glower at people as you go?!

Reminds me of an event I once helped at. Everybody was supposed to have a badge, but one last-minute helper hadn't had one made up for him, so in order to comply with the request, he borrowed one off a chap who was away for the session - and he seemed genuinely surprised when everybody kept calling him Pete when his name was actually John Grin

YouWonJayne · 10/05/2023 20:52

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 10/05/2023 09:45

To add, I think some people on this thread are suggesting that NO small-talk is necessary/wanted/welcomed. I personally have no issue at all if people read the tone of the circumstances and have a natural little chat; it's just when they've clearly been ordered to chat to everybody and make no distinction between somebody ambling along with a smile and giving off friendly and unrushed vibes at a quiet time and a stressed mum with three screaming pre-schoolers at the front of a big long queue.

Yes this is exactly what I mean.

I don’t mind anyone saying hello or asking if it’s still raining/sunny outside but it’s the false narrative they’re forced to bestow on us. It’s SO patronising for these companies to treat their customers like they’re stupid, like they really believe Chloe from Next wants to know what they’re up to this afternoon.

On another point I think mystery shopping is a dreadful, ridiculous concept. How about just employ decent managers! Because they never consider if the mystery shopper actually WANTS what they’re told to expect from a member of staff.

OP posts:
dayswithaY · 10/05/2023 20:13

Different coloured baskets/trolleys for those of us who want to left alone please

And what happens when these people want to ask the staff where the butter has been moved to or when you’re getting pink toilet paper in back in? Are we allowed to talk to them or not?

Maybe you could try and make our jobs even more complicated?

AlmostWhitby · 10/05/2023 19:51

BarbaraofSeville · 10/05/2023 18:59

I can't believe that shops operate like this and that they've been allowed to get away with it.

It's got 'unfair dismissal claim' written all over it.

Why would it be an unfair dismissal claim? The company are the employer and they set the terms of the employment, and as long as it's not illegal, discriminatory or immoral then the employee is expected to follow those terms and if they don't they can be disciplined and fired. In fact even immoral I'd say is a rocky area because the way a certain high street newsagents pushes upselling at pain of disciplinary action if you don't happen to nag enough people into buying an obscure flavour of dairy milk, is immoral to me - still perfectly legal to discipline or sack you for not meeting your targets though.

Those terms being misguided, a pain in the arse or putting off customers doesn't matter - they're still the terms imposed by the employer that the employee is expected to adhere to.

And as I've said, there must be a basis somewhere to the investment of these policies because otherwise they wouldn't keep investing in them.

coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 10/05/2023 19:09

BarbaraofSeville · 10/05/2023 18:59

I can't believe that shops operate like this and that they've been allowed to get away with it.

It's got 'unfair dismissal claim' written all over it.

Businesses can dismiss you if you're not doing your job properly though. It's perfectly legal - and it's even easier if you've been there less than two years.

If your job is to do X and they can prove that you've repeatedly failed to do X despite training and warnings, there's not much you can do about it.

BarbaraofSeville · 10/05/2023 18:59

I can't believe that shops operate like this and that they've been allowed to get away with it.

It's got 'unfair dismissal claim' written all over it.

coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 10/05/2023 18:53

Likewise, shop workers need to learn to read the signals, whether busy or quiet. It's pretty obvious when someone wants to chat as opposed to being stressed and in a hurry.

Believe me, we can read the signals - we just don't have a choice.

I did a decade in retail and we had to talk to people no matter how much they (and we) hated it. In the last shop I worked in, we had to greet people within 30 seconds of them coming into the store - if we didn't, we got a bollocking. If that person happened to be a mystery shopper, we failed the entire mystery shop, no matter how well we did on the rest of it.

If we failed a mystery shop, we got a written warning. Multiple failures would eventually lead to people being dismissed for poor performance.

JMSA · 10/05/2023 18:37

You want to know the cringiest thing? My daughter works at a Scottish airport for an American airline. If American US military personnel come through, she is supposed to thank them for their service.
She doesn't Grin

theemmadilemma · 10/05/2023 18:32

You all need these!

To wonder who decided that customers want small talk at the till in a shop?
1offnamechange · 10/05/2023 18:20

YouWonJayne · 09/05/2023 19:15

This is why I no longer ship in the body shop.

Teh last time I was in, I was accosted a total of six times between 3 different people
”How are you today?”
”Do you need any help?”
”I want to draw you to our nectarine mousse scrub which actually has 5p off today only”
”How are you getting on?”
”Is there anything particular you are looking for?”
Then an upsell at the till.

I did actually say something that day to the girl on the till, I said I know it’s not your fault it’s your job but I won’t be coming in here again because it’s too intense. I was trying to listen to a podcast as well so kept having to rewind it!

telling the girl at the till won't achieve anything though, she probably hates it as much as you. If you wanted to make a difference you should have asked to speak to the manager or contact head office. They obviously make these stupid policies based on some sort of market research, so the only way they might change them is if they get significant feedback saying the opposite!

GimmeSleep · 10/05/2023 15:15

Actually the Lush I was in at the weekend had yellow baskets for "happy to be left alone". Reading some of the comments here I'm wondering if that was store specific and not standard for Lush.

Or you could wear a lanyard, thus taking the responsibility and workload away from the staff.

What would the design be 😆

TheOrigRights · 10/05/2023 14:57

GimmeSleep · 10/05/2023 14:41

Different coloured baskets/trolleys for those of us who want to left alone please 🙅

Or you could wear a lanyard, thus taking the responsibility and workload away from the staff.

GimmeSleep · 10/05/2023 14:41

Different coloured baskets/trolleys for those of us who want to left alone please 🙅

AlmostWhitby · 10/05/2023 14:37

user1497207191 · 10/05/2023 12:44

@AlmostWhitby

Well there's complaining a-plenty about 'shit customer service' and probably one thread a month at least here about an apathetic, disinterested, didn't make eye contact (basically didn't care enough)shop assistant. And what are they told to do? Complain.

Well there's the middle ground rather than the extremes. Not making eye contact and just "grunting" rather than a polite please and thank you does in fact deserve complaint. But that doesn't mean that customers want the full "small talk" experience does it? I'm happy with polite shop assistants etc who do the job. I don't want endless small talk just as much as I don't want someone who barely acknowledges me and just grunts. The middle ground is what's needed.

Yes, totally, but that's not what's happening unfortunately, and if people aren't complaining about it, then the people making the policies in some of the worst offending places are patting themselves on the back for a job well done - while the shop assistants get moaned at for doing it and disciplined for not.

My point was these policies have to have started life somewhere and I doubt it was just a way to piss people off, it's likely from a very noisy few people who feel they need the red carpet rolled out to them when buying a pint of milk, or there's actually far more people than we know indicating that that is what they want, most things in these types of industry are profit driven - upselling clearly makes more money than not upselling so it stays, this staff in your face doesn't do that, so there must be another motivation (other than the belief that someone in an office somewhere wants to make life hell for their staff and customers).
I would think if enough people complained about their staff having to accost every customer and ask them at the till what they're doing this afternoon, then they'd look at the policies but clearly despite maybe what, 100 people on this thread saying they don't like it, it must be overall, a successful policy because they continue to invest in it.

I'm not defending it happening, I hated doing it as a member of staff and dislike it done to me when my mind is elsewhere, or I've spent all day being pleasant and polite to arseholes other people because that's my job and really don't want another mindless conversation with someone I don't know and the effort of having to think about more than what I know I'm going to forget to buy 😂. I'm not that bothered about being grunted at or not having eye contact as long as I can buy what I need though, they're there to facilitate the sale, not validate my presence.

user1497207191 · 10/05/2023 12:44

@AlmostWhitby

Well there's complaining a-plenty about 'shit customer service' and probably one thread a month at least here about an apathetic, disinterested, didn't make eye contact (basically didn't care enough)shop assistant. And what are they told to do? Complain.

Well there's the middle ground rather than the extremes. Not making eye contact and just "grunting" rather than a polite please and thank you does in fact deserve complaint. But that doesn't mean that customers want the full "small talk" experience does it? I'm happy with polite shop assistants etc who do the job. I don't want endless small talk just as much as I don't want someone who barely acknowledges me and just grunts. The middle ground is what's needed.

AlmostWhitby · 10/05/2023 12:31

BarbaraofSeville · 10/05/2023 05:04

It's a great solution, right up until a customer complains that the assistant didn't 'engage' enough, didn't appear to care about the customer because short of the essentials they just stayed quiet, didn't make it enough of an experience, didn't make them feel special and valued as a customer

The number of people who would actually prefer, notice and care enough to change their shopping behaviour or indeed complain about the lack of unnatural scripted forced engagement and pushy upselling exhibited by shops is likely to be virtually zero.

No-one cares about 'the experience' of buying groceries, school shoes or household electronics and they know the people who serve them are acting under the misguided instruction of their employer.

So why annoy the vast majority, who just want to get on with their day and fit a task into the many other things they have to do, so are happy with basic pleasantries and don't want to discuss potentially sensitive private issues with everyone they meet?

Retail staff serve hundreds of people a day. The pretence that they care about them all is utterly ludicrous.

Well there's complaining a-plenty about 'shit customer service' and probably one thread a month at least here about an apathetic, disinterested, didn't make eye contact (basically didn't care enough) shop assistant. And what are they told to do? Complain.

If people were complaining in droves about this issue of shop staff being too in your face, it'd be changed (not upselling, that's different, it makes money) because it doesn't really improve the bottom line does it? Asking you what your plans are for the rest of the day doesn't put more money in the till.

As much as I don't really care for the jobs in suits in offices, who come up with these policies, I doubt their sole aim is to piss off staff and customers alike for the hell of it - either it makes/saves money or it's in response to customers indicating that's what they want either by canvassing opinion or complaints that come in.

You and I don't like it, but either those who do are (and like I said ime they are) are very vocal about how they feel they should be treated as a customer to get noticed, or they're the vast majority and we're not - because it's still happening and apparently according to this thread getting worse, but also according to other threads (with some of the same names) customer service is shit and companies/staff don't care. 🤷🏼‍♀️

dottypotter · 10/05/2023 10:57

Dreadful Post.

Miserable c*
Springs to mind.

Swipe left for the next trending thread