Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

It's morally wrong to enter into a new relationship with serious health issues?

220 replies

Antisocialfluffmonster · 09/05/2023 09:36

Throwing this out there for debate.

I've been single for a decade after my partner died. This initially was due to work and childcare issues, the only childcare over night I had was for work, and I genuinely didn't have time to date, as a bereaved single parent, I don't get "weekends off".

Anyway, since then I've developed severe health issues, I will never get better, and no it's not because I'm a negative Nancy, it's because it's degenerative.

I'm in my early 40s, work full time mostly from home, spend a lot of non-work time in bed because work exhausts me. Have pets and hobbies, and friends, and my kids. Don't really do holidays as they exhaust me, nothing to do with the kids and all to do with travel and different food and things.

I've planned so that once the kids leave home, they will never be expected to come back and help me. They will be free to live their own lives. Due to health issues I will never own my own home, (can't get life insurance and probably won't live long enough to pay it off) but if I go before pension age the kids will have a sizeable deposit on a house for themselves.

I have a full life, lots of hobbies, pets, friends. I even have friends with benefits. But I don't date any more. I don't allow for any of those friends to go any further. In the past I've been ranted at, "surely it's my decision?"... Nope it's mine, yes it's lonely when you're stuck in bed and desperately wish there was someone else there to get you a cup of tea, but it's not a good enough excuse to have such a negative impact on someone else's life.

I do get a bit cross when friends and family suggest "you've just not met the right person" as if meeting someone else, however wonderful changes the fundamental feeling that it would be wrong to pull them into the reality of my life. I have met some absolutely incredible people, people who I'd have been very happy with, but it's because I cared about them and respected them that I didn't want it to go any further.

I have had counselling over this, and I've accepted the reality of the situation that this creates for me, and I'm genuinely happy with my life, just not my health. I wish my favourite hobbies didn't leave me crippled in bed for a week after it, but that's life.

At least with a FWB, if I'm too ill to get out of bed, or I don't feel sexual for 6 months, it's no big deal, or I'm in so much pain I'm vomiting uncontrollably it's no big deal. It doesn't impact their life in any way. Any dating profiles I have make it clear what's on offer and about my health, so I'm not leading anyone on.

What do you think? AIBU?

I know each person has to make their own decision, but I can be a bit of a judgemental a/hole when I see other very sick people entering the dating pool. So I probably do deserve a bit of flack for that.

OP posts:
RoseFl0wers · 09/05/2023 13:08

Antisocialfluffmonster · 09/05/2023 09:49

I have multiple autoimmune diseases, chronic fatigue, long covid, joint disorders the works and before all of that, I have been disabled since childhood. So my body is a ruin lol

If you're already in a relationship that to me is entirely different, you can't predict the future. But to know you are very sick with no hope of improvement, and still choose to enter into a relationship, in my opinion is horrifically selfish.

I have autoimmune diseases. I have a couple of friends in their 20s with chronic fatigue and ME (they still work but it’s a struggle). Should they be single for the rest of their lives even though they’re in their 20s?

MMMarmite · 09/05/2023 13:06

I do hold up my hands to having a very rigid way of thinking, and to me, loving someone is also not wanting to do them harm or let them come to harm.

You're only looking at harms and ignoring all potential good that could come of a relationship. That person might be far happier loving someone with a long term illness than being single and lonely.

I would say the majority of people have one issue or another that could foreseeably "hurt" their partner - debt, mental illnesses, drug or alcohol problems, difficult family, difficult ex... if all of those people gave up relationships forever, there's be a lot of single people!

If you don't have the energy to date, that is fine, but don't dress it up as a moral choice and judge others for choosing differently.

Braindrained · 09/05/2023 13:04

To be fair they might be a treatment one day for your condition.

If somebody wants to be with you and say they do and you want to be with them - I think why not. It's a cliche, but better to have loved and lost than never have loved at all.

Ktime · 09/05/2023 13:01

I do hold up my hands to having a very rigid way of thinking, and to me, loving someone is also not wanting to do them harm or let them come to harm.

Not wanting to harm a loved one is not due to a 'rigid way of thinking'.

captainmarvella · 09/05/2023 12:59

HeyDemonsItsYaGirl · 09/05/2023 09:58

I think you're self-sabotaging because you're afraid of being rejected, and you're trying to convince yourself it's because you're morally superior. Are you still in counselling?

This, with bells on.

OP, you are free to live your life the way you want to. But please don't term it as a morally right decision. It's not. You cannot label it as that for everyone on this world.

Antisocialfluffmonster · 09/05/2023 12:59

@Hillsmakeyoustrong Thank you for your lovely reply. I only did a condition dump at the start as someone asked, but I'm not in a relapse / remit type situation. I do hope that you continue to pace yourself and have a blast (in a sensible manner!).

I do hold up my hands to having a very rigid way of thinking, and to me, loving someone is also not wanting to do them harm or let them come to harm.

OP posts:
ElmTree22 · 09/05/2023 12:56

IMO this stems from the death of your partner. Ultimately you don't want to be the reason for someone else's grief. And although I respect that, I think you have closed yourself off from affection that could really enrich your life. But again it is your life and only you can make those decisions. At the end of the day, only you will have the regrets (or not).
But with this subject as a whole. Really if the person with the illness/disability has been open and honest and the other partner is aware of the situation then really the choice is given to the other person, it is there decision to make.
Disabled/ill people are not selfish for wanting love and affection, and others are not foolish for loving them!

AgnesX · 09/05/2023 12:54

Your life, your choice but don't think that you speak for the population as a whole.

As for your personal choice if that's the way you genuinely feel fair enough but I hope that you're not sat there behaving like a martyr (because you want to be persuaded otherwise).

Ktime · 09/05/2023 12:53

If I were to enter a relationship, no matter how honest and upfront I was, I would be knowingly subjecting that person to the realities of my condition.

But they would be knowingly going into the relationship with someone with a degenerative illness. They have agency too you know!

I can work and pay the bills, but spend weeks at a time not even able to hold a conversation with someone or even watch tv. I could choose different priorities, ok I probably should choose them, but I want my kids to have a good start in life.

So this is really about you having other priorities (work, kids etc) and that's absolutely fine.

Fladdermus · 09/05/2023 12:51

Couldn't disagree with you more. It's morally wrong to condemn people to a lifetime of being single against their wishes because that's what you've condemned yourself to.

I already had my lifelong illness when I met my husband. You may well think I'm extremely selfish entering into a relationship with him. He thinks he's the luckiest man alive to have met someone who enriches his life as much as I do. Because I may not be able to go out on long hikes or dancing at the weekends, but I make him laugh till his sides hurt and he loves the home and family we've built together.

Blossomtoes · 09/05/2023 12:50

People in relationships get sick, but that's very different from choosing to put someone else in the position once you're already sick.

The choice works both ways. You’re denying potential partners any choice. Of course that’s your prerogative but it seems a bit sad and defeatist.

Doris86 · 09/05/2023 12:46

Morally wrong? You’re seriously over thinking this.

Go out, have fun, meet people. Be open about your condition, and anyone you meet can make their own decisions. Just see what develops.

Rightnowstraightaway · 09/05/2023 12:46

I might think it's morally wrong if you hide the facts from your partner. Assuming not, of course it's not morally wrong to date with health issues.

theleafandnotthetree · 09/05/2023 12:41

Antisocialfluffmonster · 09/05/2023 12:40

@Highdaysandholidays1 thank you for the very thoughtful response.

I think it's balancing my own desires (I'm not an unfeeling potato) with my sense of responsibility to the other person. If I liked or loved someone, the last thing I'd want to do is hurt them, but a relationship with me these days wouldn't be positive for them however much I wish that wasn't the case.

I admire your attitude hugely, most people aren't that selfless! Or realistic.

Antisocialfluffmonster · 09/05/2023 12:40

@Highdaysandholidays1 thank you for the very thoughtful response.

I think it's balancing my own desires (I'm not an unfeeling potato) with my sense of responsibility to the other person. If I liked or loved someone, the last thing I'd want to do is hurt them, but a relationship with me these days wouldn't be positive for them however much I wish that wasn't the case.

OP posts:
Hillsmakeyoustrong · 09/05/2023 12:37

I get what you mean OP, and for the record, I'm truly sorry. I had a chronic fatigue diagnosis 10 years ago and whilst im better at pacing myself now, I still get relapses if I'm triggered. I know, for me, that there is a sense of real loss when I'm consigned to my bed and I feel it keenly for DH and kids when I can't join in. Ultimately, if someone loves you and wants to share life with you (including the tunnel parts) and you love them back, then don't disqualify yourself. Love is universal and does not discriminate. Sounds like you're deserving of that cup of tea in bed.

Pussycatbeen · 09/05/2023 12:34

I think there are different ideas of what makes "a relationship." In my experience, being deeply in love means imagining any life apart is impossible and being with the person I loved would matter most to me, if they were ill.

My partner is a widower, however, and it took him years of pain and the help of therapy to be able to love again, because he'd watched the woman he loved get ill and die. I imagine you're coming from that place, having experienced the terrible pain and loss, and don't want to put someone you love through that.

A therapist might suggest some anger at you lost loved one is being projected onto those you say you judge for getting into relationships despite their illness. Only you can tell, though.

I think it's very difficult, probably impossible, for people who haven't suffered like that to imagine what it's like and so they're going into relationships without full awareness of what might happen. However, it's their right and part of living life is to take such risks, to seize the joy and love while we can.

I admire you for not wanting to put others through pain, but also I do believe there are people who would choose to be with you and suffer the struggles and pain with you, because for some people meaning and fulfilment are found in loving despite the pain.

Whapples · 09/05/2023 12:32

I have a genetic condition that affects all my joints, along with various organs, causes pain and fatigue etc… I am getting married next year. He loves me and while sometimes seeing me so unwell makes him sad, he would never choose to leave me or not have loved me because of it. I don’t think that’s selfish of me, immoral of me or unethical of me. I am not going to spend my life alone because I’m disabled. I have lots of positives that I bring to his life, my whole personality is not “sick” so why should that be the major part of my relationship?

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 09/05/2023 12:27

No, I disagree with you. I don't think it's morally wrong, as long as you are completely transparent with the other person and they go in with their eyes wide open. That's their decision in my view.

Of course, you are entitled to make your own decision too, and if you feel that you don't want to be in a relationship because of your health issues or for any other reason, then it is entirely your right to choose.

Stating that it is morally wrong implies that you would judge others for making a different choice, though, and personally, I don't think that's any of your business.

tikkanaan · 09/05/2023 12:23

I do not think it is morally wrong. I think you however know your own circumstances and are the best judge of this and everyone else should butt out.

Newnamenewname109870 · 09/05/2023 12:21

Lots of people want a relationship of companionship and love. They don’t mind if you don’t feel sexual. Most people can deal without constant sex! not all men have high sex drives. You want someone who loves you and who will hold your hair back when you’re vomiting. They don’t have to live with you. They can be a long term partner you see as much as you like.

theleafandnotthetree · 09/05/2023 12:20

OP I think you are very clear eyed, realistic and a very moral person yourself. And kind of amazing. You clearly have a horror of depending on or burdening anyone else (you don't look for anything from your children either). I think I would be exactly of your way of thinking in your situation and would not want to.enter any relationship on what I would see as unequal terms. But honestly, most people don't think like that and while the responses to you are a bit more negative than I expected, they are probably reflective of wider thinking. You should continue exactly as you are but I think most people won't get it. Maybe because they like to think they wouldn't take these things into account if they were looking for someone (they'd be a fool if they didn't in my view) or they like to believe love conquers all (it doesn't). Do I think it is immoral or selfish to enter into a relationship where you know your issues will cause the other person to 'suffer'? A little bit, but I guess worse things are done every minute of every day.

OnedayIwillfeelfree · 09/05/2023 12:18

There is no wrong or right. You think it’s wrong, I don’t think it is. I couldn’t and wouldn’t try to change your point of view. Every situation is different. There is no rule book.

Antisocialfluffmonster · 09/05/2023 12:18

@beeskipa, oh I've had some amazing relationships, and you're very right, I've no right to dictate what other people do.

I do see a big difference in me 5 years ago, disabled and ill, sure but still able to contribute positively to a relationship. (I didn't at the time due to childcare, but I had an intimate friend). We could make plans, and sometimes those plans would have to change, or have to be cancelled, but for example, if they wanted to call me, there was a good chance I'd be able to talk. We could go out, have dinner, go on trips, talk about books, watch TV, just engage with each other and it was great.

I'm really thankful that we were just friends though, as if you're in a relationship, it's not like if you're partner can no longer do, all of the things you enjoyed doing, you can just walk off and do them with someone else. The loss for one is a loss for both.

I am aware I have very rigid thinking, something is either right, or it's wrong. There's no way I can talk myself around to doing something.

OP posts:
WhyOhWine · 09/05/2023 12:12

I dont see how it is morally wrong if the other person enters into the relationship with full disclosure. It is not even as if they have to stay in the relationship if they find down the line they cant actually cope with the reality.
The way that i would frame the debate if i were in your situation is not to focus on morality but to acknowledge to myself that there was a real possibility that they might bail out down the line and ask myself whether i would find that scenario harder to cope with than never having entered into the relationship in the first place.

If your DC are teenagers it presumably wont be that long until they head off to uni or whatever. I read today that by the time your children are 18 you will already have spent 93% of the total time you will spend with them. No idea how accurate that is (I read it on instragram!) but it did make me reflect on a few things.

Swipe left for the next trending thread