Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

It's morally wrong to enter into a new relationship with serious health issues?

220 replies

Antisocialfluffmonster · 09/05/2023 09:36

Throwing this out there for debate.

I've been single for a decade after my partner died. This initially was due to work and childcare issues, the only childcare over night I had was for work, and I genuinely didn't have time to date, as a bereaved single parent, I don't get "weekends off".

Anyway, since then I've developed severe health issues, I will never get better, and no it's not because I'm a negative Nancy, it's because it's degenerative.

I'm in my early 40s, work full time mostly from home, spend a lot of non-work time in bed because work exhausts me. Have pets and hobbies, and friends, and my kids. Don't really do holidays as they exhaust me, nothing to do with the kids and all to do with travel and different food and things.

I've planned so that once the kids leave home, they will never be expected to come back and help me. They will be free to live their own lives. Due to health issues I will never own my own home, (can't get life insurance and probably won't live long enough to pay it off) but if I go before pension age the kids will have a sizeable deposit on a house for themselves.

I have a full life, lots of hobbies, pets, friends. I even have friends with benefits. But I don't date any more. I don't allow for any of those friends to go any further. In the past I've been ranted at, "surely it's my decision?"... Nope it's mine, yes it's lonely when you're stuck in bed and desperately wish there was someone else there to get you a cup of tea, but it's not a good enough excuse to have such a negative impact on someone else's life.

I do get a bit cross when friends and family suggest "you've just not met the right person" as if meeting someone else, however wonderful changes the fundamental feeling that it would be wrong to pull them into the reality of my life. I have met some absolutely incredible people, people who I'd have been very happy with, but it's because I cared about them and respected them that I didn't want it to go any further.

I have had counselling over this, and I've accepted the reality of the situation that this creates for me, and I'm genuinely happy with my life, just not my health. I wish my favourite hobbies didn't leave me crippled in bed for a week after it, but that's life.

At least with a FWB, if I'm too ill to get out of bed, or I don't feel sexual for 6 months, it's no big deal, or I'm in so much pain I'm vomiting uncontrollably it's no big deal. It doesn't impact their life in any way. Any dating profiles I have make it clear what's on offer and about my health, so I'm not leading anyone on.

What do you think? AIBU?

I know each person has to make their own decision, but I can be a bit of a judgemental a/hole when I see other very sick people entering the dating pool. So I probably do deserve a bit of flack for that.

OP posts:
Antisocialfluffmonster · 09/05/2023 16:23

@glitterisntgendered I do see your point, what you had was valuable and it would have been a tragedy if you'd never met him, however painful it was to lose him.

I think losing aspects of yourself to illness does make you re-evaluate what you have to offer, to friends, to family and anyone else.

OP posts:
Antisocialfluffmonster · 09/05/2023 16:07

@CoronationKicking @readbooksdrinktea I've had chronic health issues and disabilities since I was a baby. I've lived a wild and exciting life including relationships. I'm not saying people shouldn't

I'm asking whether there's a point where health becomes so poor that it is wrong to look for a new relationship?

It's not something I could discuss with family and friends,

But you can disagree with someone without being pistols at dawn about it. But I suppose it is MN

.

OP posts:
Ladybug14 · 09/05/2023 15:12

Antisocialfluffmonster · 09/05/2023 09:54

Not at all, choosing to accept a situation, is not the same thing as choosing it.

I would much prefer to be in a relationship, as my obscene kindle library can confirm. If I were to enter a relationship, no matter how honest and upfront I was, I would be knowingly subjecting that person to the realities of my condition. It's not like we met when I was ok, and now they are sticking by my side.

and as I said, it's a debate, so I accept that other people may have different opinions.

You would be allowing that person to knowingly make their own decision , given the facts in front of them

Adults do that all the time

What WOULD be immoral is if you did not tell them of your health issues

Antisocialfluffmonster · 09/05/2023 15:05

Rightnowstraightaway · 09/05/2023 12:46

I might think it's morally wrong if you hide the facts from your partner. Assuming not, of course it's not morally wrong to date with health issues.

@Rightnowstraightaway you're absolutely right. I remember a few years ago I did have attempt a dating profile, and I was brutally honest on there. I use crutches, and that was when I was disabled but not really sick and the most frustrating thing is that hardly anyone bothered to read it. You'd be surprised how many times I turned up on a date on crutches and they would be totally shocked.

OP posts:
readbooksdrinktea · 09/05/2023 15:01

CoronationKicking · 09/05/2023 09:54

"Horrifically selfish"

Have a fucking word OP. Self flagellate and martyr yourself forever just so you can say you were doing everyone a favour if you must, but don't slate others who prefer to get on with living their lives their way.

And yes, your post about "health issues" does include lots of people with disabilities whether you are comfortable with that or not.

Absolutely this! Unreal.

Antisocialfluffmonster · 09/05/2023 14:54

WisherWood · 09/05/2023 14:17

I do hold up my hands to having a very rigid way of thinking, and to me, loving someone is also not wanting to do them harm or let them come to harm.

Well you can try not to harm them by your own direct actions. But you cannot stop someone from being hurt. The only way to stop feeling pain is to stop feeling altogether, and who wants that? People will come to harm, it's just part of life. The flip side is that if you can feel hurt, you can feel joy. Now, you may be choosing to dull any sensation and to try to stop any potential partner from feeling anything. But other people in similar positions will make different positions and they are not, IMO, morally wrong. To state that is just some weird public martyrdom on your part.

@WisherWood

I think there's a huge difference between a pathological attempt to do no harm ever like an emotionless robot, and having the self awareness to know that you're too ill to be in a relationship.

It was nice to hear other people's views on it, and I did say it was a debate. I do see what other people are saying about making other people's decisions for them.

MN can be pretty savage at times and it's nice that people actually talked about it rather than just resorted to insults.

OP posts:
Antisocialfluffmonster · 09/05/2023 14:31

@thesebloodycats I'm sorry to hear that you've got so much on your plate, but I'm glad that you've found a relationship that works for you and that you're both very happy. It's nice to hear that people do manage to find a way to make it work no matter how challenging it is.

I do realise that I am very rigid in my thinking, and because of that I don't feel like it was ever a choice to be single. 10 years ago supporting my kids after they lost their dad was more important than trying to establish a new relationship for myself, as I'm sure you can understand.

These days yes it is a choice, but even if I'm entirely wrong, the only person being hurt by my own action is myself.

And being judgemental is human, you're judging me right back. But I did ask for your opinion, and it was good to hear your point of view.

OP posts:
WisherWood · 09/05/2023 14:17

I do hold up my hands to having a very rigid way of thinking, and to me, loving someone is also not wanting to do them harm or let them come to harm.

Well you can try not to harm them by your own direct actions. But you cannot stop someone from being hurt. The only way to stop feeling pain is to stop feeling altogether, and who wants that? People will come to harm, it's just part of life. The flip side is that if you can feel hurt, you can feel joy. Now, you may be choosing to dull any sensation and to try to stop any potential partner from feeling anything. But other people in similar positions will make different positions and they are not, IMO, morally wrong. To state that is just some weird public martyrdom on your part.

thesebloodycats · 09/05/2023 13:57

I have autoimmune and neurological conditions, with chronic fatigue, plus I've got ADHD and I'm autistic as well, for good measure. My partner of many years knew all of this before we got together, he knew I am regularly limited in what I can manage, and he knew that some of these things were only ever going to stay the same or get worse. He still very much wanted to be with me, and we work around it. We're very happy.

By your reasoning it was "horrifically selfish" of me to enter into this relationship, because I should have treated him like a child; told him I knew what was best for him regardless of his thoughts or wishes, implied he wouldn't be capable of handling these things (pretty insulting) and then remained single forever...because anything else is morally wrong?

You do you. Stay single forever if that's what your morals dictate. Don't judge other people for their choices.

Antisocialfluffmonster · 09/05/2023 13:57

@Whapples do you have EDS by any chance? Sorry hope that's not too personal?

I have EDS, and have struggle with it since I was young, and absolutely I just was determined to go live my life in spite of it.

There was one particular incident where the kids dad mentioned that I could get my legs behind my head at the Christmas dinner table, and his granny asked why the heck anyone would want to do that.. awkward!

Anyway, it's a tough condition, if that's what you've got so I do wish you all the good things.

OP posts:
Porkandbeans1 · 09/05/2023 13:56

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

No you can't. She's entitled to her opinion. You can disagree and debate. But telling her to fuck off for having a different view of the world isn't adding anything to the conversation.

SnipSnipMrBurgess · 09/05/2023 13:50

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

glitterisntgendered · 09/05/2023 13:45

I appreciate your best wishes OP. But I fear you missed my message - yes I experienced pain when he died but was the time I had with him worth that pain? Absolutely. I'd have been much more upset if I had never had the chance to be with him.

Don't date if YOU don't want to, but it's not your job to control and manage other peoples emotions. If they love you and you die, maybe they're absolutely ok with having just had the chance to love you (or even just bonk you if that's what you both want)

knobheeeed · 09/05/2023 13:44

When I care about someone, I really do want the best for them. I just know that my situation isn't that

Yes and that's fine. I'm sorry you've had to suffer so much. You've made the decision which you feel is right for you, given your circumstances. You said you want a debate, but you don't seem to want to engage with people really.
As many others are saying, it's fine for you to decide that in your circumstances it would be wrong for you to begin a relationship but it's not fine for you to say that it's morally wrong for others to do that. It's up to them to decide what they are able to give to a relationship and to discuss that with potential partners.

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 09/05/2023 13:42

You're not going to be dating a child, you're going to be dating an adult, and with this mindset you're removing all agency from that hypothetical person.

You're entitled to do what you want, but by having FWB I'd argue you're leaving the door open for the other person to develop feelings for you whether you like it or not.

I don't see anything wrong so long as you're up front about it. Would I date a person with issues like this? No. But don't tell me what I can and can't do because I'll date you out of pure spite.

Antisocialfluffmonster · 09/05/2023 13:40

RoseFl0wers · 09/05/2023 13:08

I have autoimmune diseases. I have a couple of friends in their 20s with chronic fatigue and ME (they still work but it’s a struggle). Should they be single for the rest of their lives even though they’re in their 20s?

@RoseFl0wers I'm not saying that at all!

I only mentioned some conditions as I was asked, but I'm not in the same position as your friends. In my 20s I was disabled, working through it, having a wild time and absolutely dating and loving it. It was a struggle even back then, but I still had a lot to offer in a relationship.

It's actually really difficult to talk about health stuff without making it a competition and I really do hope I don't come over that way as anyone with a long term illness battles in their own way.

I'm at the stage where I'm not recovering from relapses any more, and it is life threatening. It wouldn't be life threatening normally, as there is a standard life saving treatment, but guess which really awkward and difficult person is allergic to the essential medication?

When I care about someone, I really do want the best for them. I just know that my situation isn't that.

OP posts:
Highdaysandholidays1 · 09/05/2023 13:38

@whatcanidotobelieve that must be really hard.

Op, I think this relates to seeing yourself as a burden. you've already said that you don't want your kids caring for you in any capacity. I don't either (they do have to make cups of tea) and I hate being a burden, so I sympathise.

I think you have to accept, though, that others may see both being a burden and taking on that burden differently.

I also think posters are naive about how many nice intelligent quality men are queueing up to date middle-aged women with kids and a significant health burden if you look at the stats and the threads on mumsnet. Many cannot be bothered to parent their own children a reasonable amount of the time or do basic housework, so imagine asking them to do all of that and to care for you physically and emotionally and accept limits on their lives. I'm sure there are a few mature souls out there, but most people want partners who can match their energy, activities and lifestyle and it's hard when you can't offer as much as you would like on that front.

That said, finding a great companion or good friend or FWB or the love of your life, I don't think you need to close those avenues off, just be realistic and content if you can with what you do have, no need to worry what anyone else is up to.

whatcanidotobelieve · 09/05/2023 13:31

I understand what you are saying OP.

My situation is different but similar. I have recently been diagnosed with something progressive and eventually terminal. There is medication to keep the symptoms at bay, and although I seem pretty healthy now, I'm not and my future doesn't look great. I'm going to be able to do less and less until I am housebound and on oxygen. If I live another 20 years it will be a miracle. I'm 38.

I guess the difference is that I am married and have two very young children. Since this though when I have fought with my husband I realise I am in this marriage whether I like it or not. I love him and have no plans to leave him, but when we fight and I am so angry in that moment, I also realise I am trapped. Very soon I physically won't be able to look after my kids myself, so if I was a single mum I wouldn't be able to cope. Also finances etc etc. I've always been independent so in these moments it certainly doesn't feel great.

I've also considered the fact that if I was single I would also feel I would have to stay that way. How could someone enter into a relationship with me when I'm offering them a life that is essentially a ticking time bomb of ill health. Who would want that? But also, how could I give that to someone?

I feel like I owe my husband an apology everyday, because he didn't sign up for this when we married. When I married him I was the picture of health - fit, active, sporty, outgoing. And now, who knows?

Life is hard OP, but I get you...

But well done for all you have done for your kids...financially etc...that is love and you must be a wonderful mum 💜

Sailingaround · 09/05/2023 13:30

Ktime · 09/05/2023 12:53

If I were to enter a relationship, no matter how honest and upfront I was, I would be knowingly subjecting that person to the realities of my condition.

But they would be knowingly going into the relationship with someone with a degenerative illness. They have agency too you know!

I can work and pay the bills, but spend weeks at a time not even able to hold a conversation with someone or even watch tv. I could choose different priorities, ok I probably should choose them, but I want my kids to have a good start in life.

So this is really about you having other priorities (work, kids etc) and that's absolutely fine.

So this is really about you having other priorities (work, kids etc) and that's absolutely fine.

I suspect this is probably the case. OP, maybe you don’t have capacity for a partner because you only have so much energy and you’ve chosen to spend it on other things which is fair enough but please remember another disabled person or someone with poor health may chose not to have kids and actually focus on a partner and they may judge you as the selfish one. An adult partner can easily walk away but a child can’t. so bear that in mind while you make your judgement about others.

StarlightLady · 09/05/2023 13:26

You are ill and that is sad, but you have the right to live your life to the full whenever and wherever possible. So go ahead and enjoy what you can. It would be morally wrong not to.

Porkandbeans1 · 09/05/2023 13:26

I understand where you are coming from OP and I think some of the PPs have been quite harsh.

I personally wouldn't judge anyone who has a disability for getting into a relationship. I can only imagine finding someone is difficult. Maybe I'm selfish but many disabilities would put me off a potential partner, I live a certain lifestyle and I wouldn't want to give that up. So if I had a disability myself I suppose I would feel disingenuous to get into a relationship knowing I wouldn't if the tables were turned.

speakout · 09/05/2023 13:25

Relationships exist in many forms.
And we each have the freedom to dictate how that relationship looks. Or not to have those relationships.

It may be casual, serious, long or short term term, with or without expectations of marriage or living together.
It may involve sex, it may not. It may be mostly chatting online, or phone. You may only meet in cafes or venues, you may only visit each other at home. You can see each other once a day or once a month. You have have a torrid love affair or be friends. You can have romance or none.
You can see someone when you feel up to it, or when they are good, share as much or as little as you like.
Depend a lot on each other or hardly at all.
And everything in between.

You are allowed to create a relationship that works for you.
As long as you are both open and consenting morals don't come into it.

Sailingaround · 09/05/2023 13:22

Hankunamatata · 09/05/2023 10:01

You said about being disabled since you were a child. Not trying to be goady but to understand- why did you make the initial decision to enter into a relationship and have children with known issues. Were they not as bad or life limiting when you were younger?

I do think there's a middle ground. You can date and have a boyfriend as long as they know you might be unavailable for periods of illness.

Is accepting situation more about protecting yourself and your emotions?

@Antisocialfluffmonster did you answer this or the other similar questions? Looked through your replies and couldn’t see it if you did.

If you haven’t already - could you explain? I think it’s a very valid question.

As a pp said it sounds a bit like travelling the world on a plane then admonishing those who go on holidays abroad for ruining the environment. You’ve had your kids and now you’re implying others are selfish for getting into relationships??

Antisocialfluffmonster · 09/05/2023 13:10

AgnesX · 09/05/2023 12:54

Your life, your choice but don't think that you speak for the population as a whole.

As for your personal choice if that's the way you genuinely feel fair enough but I hope that you're not sat there behaving like a martyr (because you want to be persuaded otherwise).

@AgnesX As I said at the start of the post, it was a debate

For me to be looking to be persuaded otherwise, or to be a martyr I'd need someone with a Time Machine as I've been single for a decade. Thankfully a lot of people on the thread have really been polite, engaging and thought provoking, which was the point.

OP posts:
bd67thSaysReinstateLangCleg · 09/05/2023 13:08

Stephen Hawking married his nurse long after he was in a wheelchair and talking with the robot voice.

You do you, but don't judge others.