Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

It's morally wrong to enter into a new relationship with serious health issues?

220 replies

Antisocialfluffmonster · 09/05/2023 09:36

Throwing this out there for debate.

I've been single for a decade after my partner died. This initially was due to work and childcare issues, the only childcare over night I had was for work, and I genuinely didn't have time to date, as a bereaved single parent, I don't get "weekends off".

Anyway, since then I've developed severe health issues, I will never get better, and no it's not because I'm a negative Nancy, it's because it's degenerative.

I'm in my early 40s, work full time mostly from home, spend a lot of non-work time in bed because work exhausts me. Have pets and hobbies, and friends, and my kids. Don't really do holidays as they exhaust me, nothing to do with the kids and all to do with travel and different food and things.

I've planned so that once the kids leave home, they will never be expected to come back and help me. They will be free to live their own lives. Due to health issues I will never own my own home, (can't get life insurance and probably won't live long enough to pay it off) but if I go before pension age the kids will have a sizeable deposit on a house for themselves.

I have a full life, lots of hobbies, pets, friends. I even have friends with benefits. But I don't date any more. I don't allow for any of those friends to go any further. In the past I've been ranted at, "surely it's my decision?"... Nope it's mine, yes it's lonely when you're stuck in bed and desperately wish there was someone else there to get you a cup of tea, but it's not a good enough excuse to have such a negative impact on someone else's life.

I do get a bit cross when friends and family suggest "you've just not met the right person" as if meeting someone else, however wonderful changes the fundamental feeling that it would be wrong to pull them into the reality of my life. I have met some absolutely incredible people, people who I'd have been very happy with, but it's because I cared about them and respected them that I didn't want it to go any further.

I have had counselling over this, and I've accepted the reality of the situation that this creates for me, and I'm genuinely happy with my life, just not my health. I wish my favourite hobbies didn't leave me crippled in bed for a week after it, but that's life.

At least with a FWB, if I'm too ill to get out of bed, or I don't feel sexual for 6 months, it's no big deal, or I'm in so much pain I'm vomiting uncontrollably it's no big deal. It doesn't impact their life in any way. Any dating profiles I have make it clear what's on offer and about my health, so I'm not leading anyone on.

What do you think? AIBU?

I know each person has to make their own decision, but I can be a bit of a judgemental a/hole when I see other very sick people entering the dating pool. So I probably do deserve a bit of flack for that.

OP posts:
mandlerparr · 10/05/2023 18:05

As long as they are being told up front, then it is not morally wrong.

Nomad12 · 10/05/2023 13:18

It's not clear whether you are turning men down who are pursuing you for a committed relationship? If that's the case, most of us are saying that we wouldn't see it as immoral in your circumstances.

Highdaysandholidays1 · 10/05/2023 11:48

But surely it isn't fixed, though, and if opportunities arose, then they could happen, and if not not.

Deep down it's hard to feel lovable in some situations in life when we don't feel ourselves for whatever reason, perhaps having MH issues or just low esteem or being physically different than we desire to be.

I understand that, but you also have to understand those around us perceive us differently and if they are still up for a bit of a tumble, that's not morally wrong!

Highdaysandholidays1 · 10/05/2023 11:45

I think that's what's driving you to figure this out- the change in your disability/sickness that requires a whole new level of care or loss of energy which seems so much more significant than before.

People have reacted as you made it seem like a general moral rule- one shouldn't do this that and the other, whereas it seems like it is you struggling with what you a) can do and b) should do given your changed circumstance.

If you aren't able to have visitors very much as so debilitating, I would think that dating/FWB is off the table on a pragmatic level.

DanceMonster · 10/05/2023 11:43

Antisocialfluffmonster · 10/05/2023 11:39

I’ve only been this Ill for about a year or 18 months, and as I’ve stated, I’ve had a number of intimate friends since I was widowed over the space of 10 years who keep in touch with me.

I had to discontinue what I had been doing for years. That is an actively making a choice.

it isn’t hypothetical when you’re having conversations about it.

But your previous posts suggest you’ve discontinued because you’re no longer physically able to seek out and maintain a relationship?
Or do you think your ‘intimate friends’ from the past 10 years would still like to have a more serious relationship with you now?

Antisocialfluffmonster · 10/05/2023 11:39

DanceMonster · 10/05/2023 07:58

That was my point really. You’re saying ‘I’m choosing to never have a relationship’, but the opportunity isn’t there, is it? So it’s not really a choice you’re making, it’s circumstance. You’re not valiantly batting away suitors from your door.

I’ve only been this Ill for about a year or 18 months, and as I’ve stated, I’ve had a number of intimate friends since I was widowed over the space of 10 years who keep in touch with me.

I had to discontinue what I had been doing for years. That is an actively making a choice.

it isn’t hypothetical when you’re having conversations about it.

OP posts:
DanceMonster · 10/05/2023 07:58

Antisocialfluffmonster · 10/05/2023 06:33

I have a track record of managing to avoid dating entirely. Now I’m physically too Ill to socialise, leave the house, or really have visitors, go on holiday etc. I can’t even go food shopping.

unless a really hot burglar tried to break in

I have cared for a lot of people over the years, I’ve seen the impact on everyone around the sick person. I’m not going to be that person.

That was my point really. You’re saying ‘I’m choosing to never have a relationship’, but the opportunity isn’t there, is it? So it’s not really a choice you’re making, it’s circumstance. You’re not valiantly batting away suitors from your door.

swayingpalmtree · 10/05/2023 07:24

Everyone has agency and responsibility for their own decisions and choices. We DO owe people honesty about our circumstances and what we are looking for in a relationship. As long as you are honest with people about your health and what that would mean practically for any potential partner it is not "selfish". at all.

They are grown adults who have the right to choose to date anyone they choose. I think you are infantilising people a bit here by almost implying that you know whats best for them- you dont. If someone wants to date someone with a severe health condition that is entirely up to them. Equally, if they chose not to, that is also entirely up to them.

There may well be many people who want to have an open relationship for example- I would expect them to be honest about that from the start and thats not something I would ever be interested in, but there may be many people who wouldnt mind that at all and thats up to them to decide for themselves.

As I said, we owe people honesty, the rest is up to them to decide.

Antisocialfluffmonster · 10/05/2023 06:33

DanceMonster · 09/05/2023 21:23

It’s an entirely hypothetical situation though isn’t it, as currently (unless there’s someone you haven’t mentioned), there isn’t anyone to have a relationship with. I think it’s very different making a decision based on an entirely hypothetical situation, to making a decision when in a real life situation. If you were in love with someone, and he with you, it may not be so easy to walk away.
Regardless, you are entitled to make any decision you want with regards to your personal relationships. You’re not entitled to make that decision for someone else though. I think it’s unreasonable to essentially tell people who have chosen to be in a relationship with someone who is chronically ill that they don’t know their own minds.

I have a track record of managing to avoid dating entirely. Now I’m physically too Ill to socialise, leave the house, or really have visitors, go on holiday etc. I can’t even go food shopping.

unless a really hot burglar tried to break in

I have cared for a lot of people over the years, I’ve seen the impact on everyone around the sick person. I’m not going to be that person.

OP posts:
Luredbyapomegranate · 10/05/2023 00:15

It’s very odd that you are judgemental about sick people entering the dating pool. Why on earth would you care? And what could be wrong with it as long as potential partners are aware of it?

Life is short and you may as well live while you can. If you don’t want a relationship that is fair enough, but I have no idea why you think that is the ethical thing to do. It doesn’t matter either way.

Ananda1 · 10/05/2023 00:11

absolutelty not morally wrong if your honest - it doesn’t sound like you want it all that much to me? I have chronic illness and I think my partner would say that 50% of my time now is better than 100% of my time when I was technically off but v distracted with work. Life should be enjoyed and if you meet someone that’s awesome - s o many physical and mental benefits

Antisocialfluffmonster · 09/05/2023 23:56

Nomad12 · 09/05/2023 22:01

Surely it's much better getting into a relationship when the other party knows exactly what they're getting into, rather than starting a relationship healthy, one getting sick, and not knowing if the other is staying out of obligation? It's the latter case where you could give someone the option to leave.
It sounds like you need to work on why you feel you're not good enough. Being honest about chronic illness at the start of a relationship is not being horrifically selfish, but I think it may be what you tell yourself because you don't want to put yourself out there.

It’s not the being honest part I think is selfish, it’s putting my own desire to not be alone ahead of someone else’s well-being.

I have taken on board other peoples comments that it’s not my decision as to whether someone’s prepared to accept my situation or not. I have no right to dictate their decisions.

The putting myself out there is a moot point though.

OP posts:
Mycathatesmecuddling · 09/05/2023 23:43

Antisocialfluffmonster · 09/05/2023 23:38

its not like we can both whip out our illnesses and measure them. You clearly didn’t think you were too sick to date

I feel very differently

You dont get it

Its not that you think you are too sick to date. Thats your decision and utterly up to you.

But you didnt make this thread about you. You made it about lots of people and then called us morally wrong and horrifically selfish.

You said you judge people who are sick who date. They clearly dont think they are too sick to date. But you still judge them

Antisocialfluffmonster · 09/05/2023 23:38

Mycathatesmecuddling · 09/05/2023 22:49

My new relationship came after my disability/sickness

You might be the only person that gets hurt by not dating, but you are hurting other people by implying we are morally wrong and horrifically selfish for daring to start a relationship whilst having life limiting conditions.

If you wanted this thread to be about you then fine. But you made it about a lot of people including me and the language you have used is hurtful.

its not like we can both whip out our illnesses and measure them. You clearly didn’t think you were too sick to date

I feel very differently

OP posts:
Mycathatesmecuddling · 09/05/2023 22:49

Antisocialfluffmonster · 09/05/2023 19:44

I haven't said what the illness is as it's a very common one with relatively simple life-saving treatment options. I just so happen to be allergic to all of them and I honestly can't be bothered listening to dozens of people telling me how they were cured with anal prayer beads or whatever MLM guff they insist on trying to push.

I didn't saying it was selfish to be in a relationship, it was starting a new relationship when you are already very sick with no hope of improvement.

But lots of other people have disagreed with that, and given great examples.

I may be totally wrong, but the only person that gets hurt by me not dating is me.

My new relationship came after my disability/sickness

You might be the only person that gets hurt by not dating, but you are hurting other people by implying we are morally wrong and horrifically selfish for daring to start a relationship whilst having life limiting conditions.

If you wanted this thread to be about you then fine. But you made it about a lot of people including me and the language you have used is hurtful.

Nomad12 · 09/05/2023 22:01

Surely it's much better getting into a relationship when the other party knows exactly what they're getting into, rather than starting a relationship healthy, one getting sick, and not knowing if the other is staying out of obligation? It's the latter case where you could give someone the option to leave.
It sounds like you need to work on why you feel you're not good enough. Being honest about chronic illness at the start of a relationship is not being horrifically selfish, but I think it may be what you tell yourself because you don't want to put yourself out there.

DanceMonster · 09/05/2023 21:23

It’s an entirely hypothetical situation though isn’t it, as currently (unless there’s someone you haven’t mentioned), there isn’t anyone to have a relationship with. I think it’s very different making a decision based on an entirely hypothetical situation, to making a decision when in a real life situation. If you were in love with someone, and he with you, it may not be so easy to walk away.
Regardless, you are entitled to make any decision you want with regards to your personal relationships. You’re not entitled to make that decision for someone else though. I think it’s unreasonable to essentially tell people who have chosen to be in a relationship with someone who is chronically ill that they don’t know their own minds.

knobheeeed · 09/05/2023 21:12

I may be totally wrong, but the only person that gets hurt by me not dating is me
Well yes, correct, so don't date then.

I just don't understand what you want out of this thread OP.
Who are you trying to justify yourself to? You don't want to date/have a relationship for the reasons you have listed - so don't
Who are you trying to convince not to start a relationship? Yourself? Or other people?
It's up to each individual to decide whether they are in a position to be in a relationship or not. That's it. The only people it should concern are the person themselves, the partner and any children of either of the partners if there are any.

Antisocialfluffmonster · 09/05/2023 21:01

HeyDemonsItsYaGirl · 09/05/2023 09:58

I think you're self-sabotaging because you're afraid of being rejected, and you're trying to convince yourself it's because you're morally superior. Are you still in counselling?

Counselling yes, it's been using in coming to terms with what happened and accepting that there's no treatment etc. . Counsellor didn't think my feelings on staying alone or the reasons were unusual to be fair, she was much more interested in my hatred of visitors.

Being rejected would be a lot less terrifying than someone trying to say yes that I actually cared about

OP posts:
SchoolShenanigans · 09/05/2023 20:53

Personally I think your comments could be pretty insulting to all the other people out there with "faults" or challenges. Many women here will have mental or health disabilities. That doesn't mean they can't make good partners.

BUT YANBU for deciding how you want to live your life and if you don't feel comfortable being in a relationship, then YANBU to pursue more casual relationships.

All the best OP x

Antisocialfluffmonster · 09/05/2023 20:38

OooWhatAWhopper · 09/05/2023 20:33

I have a friend who entered a relationship with someone who didn't tell them they had terminal cancer. When my friend found out, they made the decision to leave the relationship. It's had a profound, negative effect. They carry guilt for leaving the relationship, feelings that they were unfairly used as a prop in a play & they haven't been able to move forward. The ex partner wanted one last rush of love - I get that - but it's cost my friend dear.

oh that is a horrific situation. Your poor friend!

OP posts:
OooWhatAWhopper · 09/05/2023 20:33

I have a friend who entered a relationship with someone who didn't tell them they had terminal cancer. When my friend found out, they made the decision to leave the relationship. It's had a profound, negative effect. They carry guilt for leaving the relationship, feelings that they were unfairly used as a prop in a play & they haven't been able to move forward. The ex partner wanted one last rush of love - I get that - but it's cost my friend dear.

Poppopi · 09/05/2023 20:22

*Now not know🙈

Rosscameasdoody · 09/05/2023 20:22

Antisocialfluffmonster · 09/05/2023 17:32

@CoronationKicking

calling people names and swearing to make your point: pistols at dawn.

I'm not horrified at all at other people's stories, people have opened up with amazing examples of having made things work and why they disagree with me. That's the reason it's a debate, because you can actually discuss it rather than just shouting someone down.

My personal story of where the line was for me between just being my normal disabled / chronically ill self , and the point I became too sick to even be myself any more, is just that. I absolutely get to define it, to believe that there's a point where it's not ok to get involved with someone else.

Just like a whole lot of people on this thread can choose to totally disagree with me, explain why I'm wrong and give a different view point.

It's not something I would discuss with my family and friends, my friends would see it as some kind of invitation to try and set me up, and that would be incredibly distressing.

I have a lifelong disability and I was married at 21. My partner of 40 years died a few years ago and I have since started another relationship. My condition has deteriorated over the years and I am definitely not what I was at 21 (are any of us !!) but it didn’t stop me from getting involved again. I was open and honest from the start about my disability and the fact that an aspect of it is degenerative. My partner fully accepted this and supports my condition as and when is needed. It doesn’t stop us from being happy together - we came to the conclusion that dwelling on what may or may not happen in the future is of no consequence if you live in the here and now.

If I’m honest I would say this isn’t a decision you should make unilaterally and set in stone. You never know what’s round the next bend in life and it seems harsh to rule out the most basic of human emotions - love and comfort - because of a health condition. Better to keep yourself open to the possibility and then if something does present itself, as long as you are honest from the start and they know what to expect, then it’s a decision you can make together as the circumstances dictate.

You say you don’t think you have anything positive to bring to a relationship and I find that difficult to accept - your health condition doesn’t make you inherently unlovable. And love is very definitely a positive. If you’re truly loved, you can overcome anything and find happiness in the most extraordinary of situations. I know this from personal experience. Not once, but twice. Keep an open mind.