Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To thinks SATs don’t really matter?

362 replies

whodawhodaeho · 09/05/2023 08:12

DD is year 6 and her class teacher( and year head) has told them that if they don’t do well in SATs then they’ll be put with the disruptive, badly behaved kids in ‘big’ school. Ie put in lower sets forever

I have told her this is nonsense - that the new school will assess her themselves up til Oct half term then stream sets for certain subjects (which they do - her DB is there ) and the SATs don’t matter.
And they continually assess and move kids around according to ability/ progress through school terms/ years

YABU - yes they matter, and yes secondary school will pay attention to the results

YANBU - they don’t really matter

OP posts:
TeenLifeMum · 11/05/2023 08:36

I do think SATs are useful for benchmarking and as a parent they gave me an idea as to how my dc were doing. Dd1 matched what school told me so no big surprises but dtds did very differently to expected (much better) which backed my thoughts that they were both more able than school felt. It is just a snapshot though and not the only information parents should use.

i also think it’s good to introduce exams early to give more experience.

they should be done with no pressure though!

Pipsquiggle · 11/05/2023 08:30

It's bloody crazy how some schools treat SATs. Way too much pressure.

SATs are for the assessment of the school NOT the child. To check they are continuing on the same 'curve'

SATs results are sent to the secondary school but all the ones in my borough said they carry out their own assessments for streaming some classes.

SATs can indicate how a child will perform in GCSEs. But this is usually about the 'curve' they are on

This week I have got nothing from my DS apart from what he has eaten at breakfast, which TBH I am relieved about

ExtraOnions · 11/05/2023 08:27

Teateaandmoretea · 11/05/2023 08:22

To some extent.

If you get low scores in SATs because you are struggling at school and don’t have the right level of reading, writing and maths to start secondary and access the curriculum properly that will impact on your GCSE results.

If you get 99 instead of 100 however on one paper then this is a rather different situation.

If someone isn’t able to read and write well enough to cope with a high school curriculum, I would hope that the primary school they were in would be fully aware, and sharing their knowledge with high school, without the need for a “test” in Y6.

Regholdsworthswaterbed · 11/05/2023 08:26

KittyAlfred · 11/05/2023 08:12

It’s wrong to state this categorically. Secondary schools vary, and our local schools don’t set the kids at all at the start. It’s totally random. Then after the first term they set them for maths. Then in year 8 they set them for science. They are never setted for English, history, geography, RE, D&T, computing, drama, music etc.

I can only go on my own experience as my DD started the same secondary last year. Sorry I assumed they were all the same. I guess SATs matter depending on the school in that case.

Sunnylassie · 11/05/2023 08:25

Personally, I think SAT’s are completely useless. One of my children didn’t sit them at all as school felt she wasn’t ready for them. When she started secondary they assessed her there and allocated sets accordingly. When my son completed SAT’s he had support to do so due to special needs. He did exceptionally well in them but that led to huge problems when he moved to secondary. They put him in top sets where he struggled as he had no support in class like he did for SAT’s.

honestly, I think they should do away with them. Secondary schools should do their own assessments to allocate students accordingly and reassess regularly. SAT’s are also a poor indicator on how ‘well’ a school is performing as they don’t recognise children with special needs. My daughters school struggled as they had a higher percentage of Sen children compared to other local schools.

Teateaandmoretea · 11/05/2023 08:25

@EveryoneIsAnAlienSomewhere the PE sets seem to be based at dd’s school on ability in ball sports. Dd isn’t well known for her eye to ball co ordination but is good at athletics also, she is also a county level swimmer. So is in middle.

Teateaandmoretea · 11/05/2023 08:24

@EveryoneIsAnAlienSomewhere the PE sets seem to be based at dd’s school on ability in ball sports. Dd isn’t well known for her eye to ball co ordination but is good at athletics also, she is also a county level swimmer. So is in middle.

EveryoneIsAnAlienSomewhere · 11/05/2023 08:22

My daughter was put in a lowish set for science and maths, and the lowest set for PE. She’s now at a very good uni doing a science degree and successfully competing for the uni at athletics. I personally think some schools are not very good at measuring or encouraging ability, and in hindsight SATS meant little in my daughter’s case as they certainly didn’t predict her likely future.

Teateaandmoretea · 11/05/2023 08:22

ExtraOnions · 11/05/2023 08:16

Things that will influenced GCSE results:

Quality of Teaching
Friends / Peers
Home Life
Mental Health
Morivation
Interest in the Topic

Not Y6 SATS

To some extent.

If you get low scores in SATs because you are struggling at school and don’t have the right level of reading, writing and maths to start secondary and access the curriculum properly that will impact on your GCSE results.

If you get 99 instead of 100 however on one paper then this is a rather different situation.

whodawhodaeho · 11/05/2023 08:18

@ExtraOnions totally agree

OP posts:
KittyAlfred · 11/05/2023 08:17

My take on SATs is to go with what your child wants. If your child is very anxious, getting stressed and worried, then I would tell them the SATs don’t matter at all. If they’re calm and not fussed, then just let them get on with it.

DS1 was massively stressed about SATs. He was very well behaved and he wanted to please the teacher, and he could see the SATs were important to her, so he was worried about them. Sadly his teacher quit teaching after that, because she didn’t want to be part of something that stressed kids out so much.

DS2 was due to do SATs in 2020 so obviously they didn’t happen. He wouldn’t have been bothered at all. I think he’d barely have known they were going on.

ExtraOnions · 11/05/2023 08:16

Things that will influenced GCSE results:

Quality of Teaching
Friends / Peers
Home Life
Mental Health
Morivation
Interest in the Topic

Not Y6 SATS

KittyAlfred · 11/05/2023 08:12

Regholdsworthswaterbed · 11/05/2023 08:09

In the grand scheme of things, no they don't matter but they definitely help to determine initial sets for maths and English in secondary school. I have a very clever, but lazy boy and I want him to get into the higher sets from the beginning as I think he's more likely to work hard and remain there IYSWIM.

It’s wrong to state this categorically. Secondary schools vary, and our local schools don’t set the kids at all at the start. It’s totally random. Then after the first term they set them for maths. Then in year 8 they set them for science. They are never setted for English, history, geography, RE, D&T, computing, drama, music etc.

Regholdsworthswaterbed · 11/05/2023 08:09

In the grand scheme of things, no they don't matter but they definitely help to determine initial sets for maths and English in secondary school. I have a very clever, but lazy boy and I want him to get into the higher sets from the beginning as I think he's more likely to work hard and remain there IYSWIM.

PiriPiriChicken · 11/05/2023 08:08

Yes and no. My daughter is doing hers too and she will be streamed using the results. The secondary will then move children around in the first term, as they get to know the children’s abilities themselves.

Every day when I ask my daughter how it went, she says it’s a mixed bag. My daughter is a mixed bag academically and I think her results will mostly match her abilities, if I’m honest.

I have encouraged my daughter to revise a little but to be calm about the exams and she very much is. I have also told her there will be no revision the night before the exam itself. Just a healthy dinner and an early night. I do not think SATs are very important but, I do think it’s a good opportunity to set her up with healthy exam habits before secondary school.

Teateaandmoretea · 11/05/2023 08:02

It’s amazing how many mumsnetter’s kids go to really bad schools with very serious behaviour problems that don’t affect top sets at all.

In most schools the lower sets will have more challenging kids, but this is managed effectively most of the time. Sometimes bottom sets can actually be the easiest depending on who is in them especially if they are smaller. Middle can be more challenging ime.

But kids need to be in the right sets for them.

Sometimes top sets can be tricky as there is sometimes arrogance from the kids. Particularly in challenging schools where most of the kids wouldn’t even be in top set elsewhere.

LostFrog · 11/05/2023 07:59

As others have said, it is a benchmark to judge what to expect at KS4 results, so matters to secondary schools in that sense. I would be very unhappy if that was actually what the teacher said.

KittyAlfred · 11/05/2023 07:58

Where I am the SATs have 2 uses.

  1. for the school - some parents look at SATs results when choosing schools.
  2. they are used as a benchmark for the child. In our secondary , kids aren’t setted when they start, and are only put into sets from the second term onwards , so the SATs have no bearing on what set they’re in. But, the SATs result is used to plot the expected achievement of the child, and the secondary school is expected to keep them on that trajectory.
OMG12 · 11/05/2023 07:56

That teacher is bonkers. What she means is if the young children don’t get sufficiently scared to make the school look good the head teacher will get stressed. She’s selling kids mental health up the river!

our HT said to the kids not to worry about it, it’s testing the school not the kids snd she’s very proud of them because she knows they will all try their best. Testing at this age really annoys me. I left a great primary low average left a shit secondary with the top A levels in the year.

Luckily our secondary doesn’t stream in first year

TheNefariousOrange · 11/05/2023 07:54

Needmorelego · 11/05/2023 07:40

@TheNefariousOrange how does your school decide on sets for children who didn't take SATS (ie coming from a private primary)?
How do you know if a child is "gifted and talented" at music/art/sport etc when these aren't tested at SATS ?

They go where there's space or a middle set.
Our G&T programme is academic subjects only and it is 100% done on SATs scores. Is it perfect, no, but the OP asked what the impact could be and this is one thing schools do.

KTSl1964 · 11/05/2023 07:51

The results are for the school only - secondary schools haven’t the time or inclination to check out all the SATs results - your allocation of schools in the uk is based on distance. A local school to me was pressuring parents to send kids in every morning over a week at Easter.
It’s obviously the schools are under pressure from whoever to show “performance results” probably similar to OFSTED. Who’d be a teacher!!!

Fadedstripes · 11/05/2023 07:47

DS went to the local comp that has bad results overall. He was in top set for everything and his friends and him all got good A level results. They were initially put in sets using SATS and then took a further test after a couple of months and there was a little bit of shuffling. The lower sets were disruptive.

ilovesushi · 11/05/2023 07:47

My DC are at different secondaries. One school prints the SATs results at the top of every termly report - even now in Y10 - and they have this ridiculous thing called professionally predicated GCSE results which seems to be some algorithm that the SATs feed into which you get right from Y7. It's like your destiny is set already.

My other DC didn't do SATs because of covid and they take her as she comes. Reports are based on how she is actually doing in class. She was considered mid range to weak at maths in primary and was taken out of class for extra small class teaching. She is now in the top set for maths at secondary and doing well. I do wonder how a mid/poor SATs result might have prevented that outcome.

In summary SATs are stressful nonsense and no good comes of them IMO!

BiggerBoat1 · 11/05/2023 07:45

Unfortunately SATS do matter. I wish they didn't, but they are what secondary schools use as their baseline. Having said this, of course children can change sets based on how they perform in termly and end of year assessments.

Needmorelego · 11/05/2023 07:40

@TheNefariousOrange how does your school decide on sets for children who didn't take SATS (ie coming from a private primary)?
How do you know if a child is "gifted and talented" at music/art/sport etc when these aren't tested at SATS ?

Swipe left for the next trending thread