Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To thinks SATs don’t really matter?

362 replies

whodawhodaeho · 09/05/2023 08:12

DD is year 6 and her class teacher( and year head) has told them that if they don’t do well in SATs then they’ll be put with the disruptive, badly behaved kids in ‘big’ school. Ie put in lower sets forever

I have told her this is nonsense - that the new school will assess her themselves up til Oct half term then stream sets for certain subjects (which they do - her DB is there ) and the SATs don’t matter.
And they continually assess and move kids around according to ability/ progress through school terms/ years

YABU - yes they matter, and yes secondary school will pay attention to the results

YANBU - they don’t really matter

OP posts:
Iamnotthe1 · 11/05/2023 18:38

Trixiefirecracker · 11/05/2023 16:37

I think you’ve got a crappy school if they base their GCSE targets on SATs, that’s crazy practice. A school with any merit will do their own testing in year 7 to start streaming kids.

It's not up to the school. The expected grades for GCSE are set as an external measure and the school cannot change them. They are held accountable to them.

I really wish people would read the full thread rather than posting pages of misinformation.

lovingretirement · 11/05/2023 18:31

My number 3 son did better in his SATS than his older brother, his teacher at Junior school said he was a little grafter, he is also dyslexic
at secondary school he was put in the class with kids with behaviour problems, gradually lost contact with his mates and within two years had behaviour problems to fit in, not exactly Rocket science
it took ten years for him to regain his self esteem
he is 29 now, has a good job that he enjoys, a girlfriend and a stepdaughter
if we drove past the school even now he says that his life went wrong when he went there

Trixiefirecracker · 11/05/2023 16:37

I think you’ve got a crappy school if they base their GCSE targets on SATs, that’s crazy practice. A school with any merit will do their own testing in year 7 to start streaming kids.

1stTimeBoyMumx · 11/05/2023 15:54

It’s 15 years ago now but we did SATS in primary school and it had absolutely no bearing on the set you were in in high school, sets didn’t come into play until year 9 or maybe even 10 when you had done your options for GCSEs. I don’t think they’re particularly important if she was graded low but outperforming in her set they would move her to the appropriate set. They did all of our classes in tutor groups the first at least 2 years of high school except food / design / the one where you sow haha

Walkaround · 11/05/2023 15:50

Obviously SATS matter, to the extent that if you do astonishingly badly in them, it is unlikely you are actually ready for secondary school, as it is an indication you have extremely inadequate English and maths skills and will likely miss a lot of the year 7 curriculum due to having to attend remedial classes in primary-level English and/or maths. For parents of children of around average ability or above who have been well enough taught to do OK in their SATS, exactly how well they do is considerably less important. However, if all, or a substantial proportion of children nationally are doing less well in SATS now than pre-covid, this will likely have an impact on the entire cohort’s education at the start of secondary, as more time than usual will have to be spent identifying and plugging the gaps in their primary education - by teachers not trained to teach the primary curriculum.

Spellcheck · 11/05/2023 15:25

I coached my older kids for their SATs (I know, I know) and they all got the highest marks achievable. Yay, go us.
How it ended up further down the line was that their SATs were used to form their target GCSE grades in secondary school. So my children were constantly ‘under-achieving’ because they weren’t going to get 9s. Not good. I won’t be making that mistake with my younger ones!

celticprincess · 11/05/2023 13:44

My DD’s school do use data for initial streaming. But they don’t stream everything and much is mixed ability - so they say. But when my DD1 started high school it was 2020 and Covid had cancelled sats. The school made them all sit the CAT tests to be able to assess for proper streaming. They did say these tests were due to not having sat their SATs so it will be interesting this year as my DD2 is currently sitting here and going to the same school in September. She is bright and predicted greater depth for most things but that’s not a given. After yesterday’s reading paper - which she did finish and said was fine - it could go either way this time round.

Esmereldapawpatrol · 11/05/2023 13:11

I think it depends on your secondary school's procedure for streaming more than anything to how much the SATs matter.

The school my DS will be attending absolutely uses SATs results to decide which sets they will be in for Maths and English from day 1. My DH had said to my son to try hard so he didn't end up in a lower set as he did and it meant it was very disruptive and as a result he really struggled with maths.

Therefore the SATs do matter to a certain degree. Having said that they are a very small snapshot of what the children learn and are capable of. Trying to convey that to my DS has been hard though, he has been stressed this week and it has been very hard to see.

OMG12 · 11/05/2023 12:57

Pipsquiggle · 11/05/2023 08:30

It's bloody crazy how some schools treat SATs. Way too much pressure.

SATs are for the assessment of the school NOT the child. To check they are continuing on the same 'curve'

SATs results are sent to the secondary school but all the ones in my borough said they carry out their own assessments for streaming some classes.

SATs can indicate how a child will perform in GCSEs. But this is usually about the 'curve' they are on

This week I have got nothing from my DS apart from what he has eaten at breakfast, which TBH I am relieved about

Yep all we got when we asked how they had gone was - “alright” I think this response indicates a great success both for home and school life. My DS actually started the week saying he was excited for this week - he suffers from anxiety. I love the way his school has handled this.

IDontWantToBeAPie · 11/05/2023 12:31

Lol I did SATs in year 2, 6 and early in yr 8. I then did some early GCSEs in year 9 and then regular GCSEs in years 10 and 11. Then AS exams then A Level.

It was shit to constantly have exams. In fact in 13 years of school (including A levels) I had 8 years of exams. Followed by five years of exams at uni and professionally.

I have to say while it was stressful at first it made me absolutely belting at exams. So maybe just see it as good practice?

toobusymummy · 11/05/2023 11:53

I've got a DD is year 7 and one doing SATs this week in Year 6 - and NEITHER time has the school put this kind of pressure on the kids, they've been prep'ing at school for weeks and sent bits of info for parents out but the general theme is that they should just do their best! As for moving to secondary - the SATs made no difference whatsoever in 'grading' for Year 7 - this happens at the end of year 7 with their end of year exams (which DDy7 is currently doing) and the results will determine 'sets' for next year (year 8). My guess would be that, as the school are ranked and graded based on what levels the kiddos attain, they are more concerned about their own rankings than they are the kiddos welfare! Have you seen the fuss today about the literacy test yesterday, apparently it was the worst/hardest one most teachers have seen and even excellent readers were struggling with it! These tests are definitely NOT the be all and end all - they are simply a means of the establishment patting themselves on the back for a job well done (you know, like cramming exam prep and revision down 10 and 11 year olds throats and introducing them to unreasonable stress) when what they should be doing is enjoying school, learning new stuff every day and finding out who they are and what they're individually good at!

northernbeee · 11/05/2023 11:01

SATS are for schools - I made sure my kids (now in their 20's) were not pressurised one bit for them. There's enough pressure on kids anyway without adding these to it.

Gymrabbit · 11/05/2023 10:16

XelaM

But as numerous people have explained they do affect pupils as decisions in state schools are often made based on them.

rewilded · 11/05/2023 09:53

They do have an impact. My eldest DS did average in his Sats and had no intervention for his GCSEs his flight path was for average grades and it did affect his self esteem. DS2 did well and got into top sets. He was given lots of intervention measures when GCSEs came around as he was dropping from a 7 in triple science and had 8 weeks of tuition after school by a third year degree science student! Not to mention lots of other additional help.

XelaM · 11/05/2023 09:50

Gymrabbit · 11/05/2023 09:23

XelaM

Yes I’m sure that’s true but the vast majority of the country don’t go to prep or private schools.

What I am saying is that they clearly only matter to state primary schools and not the actual pupils if prep schools don't care about them.

FuglyHouse · 11/05/2023 09:44

This thread has made me realise that my DCs are really fortunate in their state secondary. They didn't do SATs (educated abroad then home ed) but the lack of SATs has never been an issue. They were taught in tutor groups for the first part of Year 7 then streamed into sets, and they've been moved between sets when appropriate. I'm staggered at the suggestion that some schools rely so heavily on SATs throughout the kids time at school.

Gymrabbit · 11/05/2023 09:23

XelaM

Yes I’m sure that’s true but the vast majority of the country don’t go to prep or private schools.

Gymrabbit · 11/05/2023 09:22

Trixiefirecracker

well in the 20 years I have been teaching across a variety of secondary schools (all state) they have been used. But feel free to tell parents they don’t matter at all so they can wonder why their child gets stuck in bottom sets….

ExtraOnions · 11/05/2023 09:19

Generating a GCSE target for a 16 year old, based on an exam there took at 11 … you may as well chuck darts at a board.

They are not there to help children, they are there to measure the “success” of a school … and take no account of other factors that affect a young persons GCSE results. They do more harm that good when schools “off role” troubled students, as the school is more worried about the impact on thier “score” (and OFSTED), than what’s best for that child.

XelaM · 11/05/2023 09:18

My daughter went to a private prep and the school couldn't care less about SATs. They weren't even preparing for them - only the 11+. So SATs are only important for state schools themselves, not the kids. Private schools don't stress about SATs at all.

Trixiefirecracker · 11/05/2023 09:17

Gymrabbit · 11/05/2023 09:06

Can people please read the thread.
Loads of actual teachers have explained that Yes Sats results are used to set in some secondary schools and that in the vast majority of secondary schools they will be used to generate GCSE targets.
This does not mean that Year 6 students should panic about them but that they should take them seriously and try their best.
The message from HTs should be do your best so you are put in an appropriate set - not the negative message that the teacher in the OP sent out.

Like I said most secondary schools will use their own CAts system to put their pupils in sets and get an idea of their attainment levels. This is done in year 7 and has been in all the schools I’ve worked in. Sats rarely have any bearing on any GCSE targets. Here’s a link:
https://www.theschoolrun.com/year-7-cats-what-every-parent-needs-know

Year 7 CATs: what every parent needs to know

CATs (Cognitive Abilities Tests) are used in year 7 to help settle children into secondary school. We explain what parents need to know.

https://www.theschoolrun.com/year-7-cats-what-every-parent-needs-know

Gymrabbit · 11/05/2023 09:06

Can people please read the thread.
Loads of actual teachers have explained that Yes Sats results are used to set in some secondary schools and that in the vast majority of secondary schools they will be used to generate GCSE targets.
This does not mean that Year 6 students should panic about them but that they should take them seriously and try their best.
The message from HTs should be do your best so you are put in an appropriate set - not the negative message that the teacher in the OP sent out.

whodawhodaeho · 11/05/2023 08:54

‘If the teacher really said that then I would put in a formal complaint.’

apparently other parents already did, and as i mentioned before DD didn’t take it seriously- she’s got enough confidence to know she won’t be in bottom set of anything.
I think he’s a good teacher and the kids love him, but he deffo has a bit of an edge to him.
we all make mistakes though… so I’ll give him some slack…

OP posts:
MzHz · 11/05/2023 08:39

Needmorelego · 09/05/2023 08:27

If the teacher really said that then I would put in a formal complaint.
Children in the bottom sets aren't there because they are "badly behaved".
Revolting thing to say about children.
Teachers who say things like that shouldn't be anywhere near children.

100% this!

put in a complaint

Trixiefirecracker · 11/05/2023 08:38

Secondary schools do their own testing in the first year so don’t rely heavily on SATs results.

Swipe left for the next trending thread