Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To thinks SATs don’t really matter?

362 replies

whodawhodaeho · 09/05/2023 08:12

DD is year 6 and her class teacher( and year head) has told them that if they don’t do well in SATs then they’ll be put with the disruptive, badly behaved kids in ‘big’ school. Ie put in lower sets forever

I have told her this is nonsense - that the new school will assess her themselves up til Oct half term then stream sets for certain subjects (which they do - her DB is there ) and the SATs don’t matter.
And they continually assess and move kids around according to ability/ progress through school terms/ years

YABU - yes they matter, and yes secondary school will pay attention to the results

YANBU - they don’t really matter

OP posts:
3WildOnes · 11/05/2023 20:32

Trixiefirecracker · 11/05/2023 20:19

Actually I said (if you have read my other threads) that most schools use Cats to stream and help set GCSE targets and if a school is basing a child’s GCSE targets solely on Sats then that is crazy.

It might be crazy but it is exactly what happens. Target grades are based solely on SATs (and postcodes), schools have no choice in this. Schools can set their own predicted grades which are different.

Iamnotthe1 · 11/05/2023 20:30

JenWillsiam · 11/05/2023 20:14

Well I hope your schools aren’t limiting kids based on their sats. Thankfully where I work they do not.

I'm not talking about a small number of schools I work in as a class teacher. The vast majority of class teachers are entirely unaware of the data-driven decisions being made by the data-focused members of the SLT.

OMG12 · 11/05/2023 20:25

JenWillsiam · 11/05/2023 20:14

Well I hope your schools aren’t limiting kids based on their sats. Thankfully where I work they do not.

Any school that decides children’s attainment at GCSE level and beyond is going to be accurately reflected by SAT scores at 10/11 and does not constantly adjust to meet changing skills is quite frankly shit. It is doing late developers a massive disservice. Kids develop at different times. I’m not a big fan of sets for subjects (with the possible exception of maths and English).

Any teacher pigeon holing a child based on a few tests at 10/11 really should have a rethink about careers.

Trixiefirecracker · 11/05/2023 20:19

Iamnotthe1 · 11/05/2023 20:04

You said GCSE targets are not based on SATs.
They are.

You said secondaries doing this is crazy practice.
It's not: it's what happens and secondaries have no control over this at all.

Actually I said (if you have read my other threads) that most schools use Cats to stream and help set GCSE targets and if a school is basing a child’s GCSE targets solely on Sats then that is crazy.

HT56 · 11/05/2023 20:17

As a parent I don’t worry about stuff like this. I wasn’t that clever at school and neither were my kids. However, we are all grafters and that’s all you need in my opinion. Neither of my kids have any university debt, both did apprenticeships. One is now an electrician earning shit loads and one is a builder earning more! You can push kids too hard in my opinion and the stress that comes from some of the jobs where you need to be clever seems to be not worth it in many cases. We all go to work, come home at 5 and switch off.

What does it really matter what set you are in?

JenWillsiam · 11/05/2023 20:14

Iamnotthe1 · 11/05/2023 20:05

No, it's not. It's the side effect of having an SLT who properly understand data and ensure that their strategic decisions are informed by them. It's something I have seen in every secondary I've worked with and that's a lot of secondary schools.

Well I hope your schools aren’t limiting kids based on their sats. Thankfully where I work they do not.

Sunnylassie · 11/05/2023 20:12

3WildOnes · 11/05/2023 19:41

If your target grade is an 8 based on on your sats but you are on track for a 6 then you are likely to find a lot of support and extra classes available to you in year 11.

This isn’t often the case though. My son did exceptionally well in his SAT’s because he had a reader, extra time and a private room. When he started in secondary he was put into all the top sets but because he was given zero support he floundered. When he wasn’t performing well, instead of extra support he was just moved further and further down the sets. Once there his predicted grades dropped substantially.

The school gave him no support. They wouldn’t let him have extra measures in the termly tests saying that they couldn’t because when it came round to GCSE’s they needed to prove he needed the extra help. That was pointless though as, due to being in the lower sets, he just wouldn’t have the knowledge to get higher grades. They systematically stated that they couldn’t apply for help until the last 2 years.

Yes, the sats can help to initially stream the children however, the biggest test is how they perform in class, how they grasp the knowledge and how they cope with a completely new way of learning. There are other ways to find which level a child is capable of and that should be down to more than a test in year 6. Sats are not a child centred approach in any way.

It’s an archaic system that needs to be overhauled. I’ve seen children buckle under the pressure, not because they’re not ‘bright’ enough but because of the stress involved. They start secondary on a sour note and some just don’t recover from that. We have a secondary school that chooses to put the children in lower sets for everything if they score poorly on one sat paper. For example, my niece scored poorly in literacy as she is severely dyslexic but scored exceptionally well in maths. When she started her in secondary they put her in the lowest set for each and every subject. She was far too capable for the lowest set in maths yet was left there for over a year. This meant she had the pressure of trying to catch up once she finally moved up, this had a really negative effect on her.

3WildOnes · 11/05/2023 20:09

Iamnotthe1 · 11/05/2023 19:59

What you've just said doesn't make sense. The schools aiming to have 1+ progress 8 scores are the schools making the most decisions based on the SATs generated targets because progress 8 is measured exclusively from the SATs results.

Exactly!

Amanduh · 11/05/2023 20:08

Honestly it depends. Do they matter? Well they can do, yes. I’ve worked in schools years ago where only children in top set could do a full range maths gcse, and anyone in bottom set could only do an intermediate paper where 100% would only earn them a C. They were assigned sets by SATS and never moved. (Yes I know this should’t happen but it did, and there are schools who do similar now) Should anyone be speaking to children about being in the ‘bottom set’ (hate that expression) like that? No. It’s shocking but they do often matter.

Iamnotthe1 · 11/05/2023 20:05

JenWillsiam · 11/05/2023 20:03

Nah, it’s a side effect of an excellent school who supports all kids the thrive. Nothing more.

No, it's not. It's the side effect of having an SLT who properly understand data and ensure that their strategic decisions are informed by them. It's something I have seen in every secondary I've worked with and that's a lot of secondary schools.

Iamnotthe1 · 11/05/2023 20:04

Trixiefirecracker · 11/05/2023 20:00

I have read the thread and I work in schools. I repeat what I said earlier and what the OPs school has informed her…and that is that many secondary schools have their own cat tests in year seven that they base their streaming off rather than sats. This is the case for all three of our local schools.

You said GCSE targets are not based on SATs.
They are.

You said secondaries doing this is crazy practice.
It's not: it's what happens and secondaries have no control over this at all.

JenWillsiam · 11/05/2023 20:03

Iamnotthe1 · 11/05/2023 19:59

What you've just said doesn't make sense. The schools aiming to have 1+ progress 8 scores are the schools making the most decisions based on the SATs generated targets because progress 8 is measured exclusively from the SATs results.

Nah, it’s a side effect of an excellent school who supports all kids the thrive. Nothing more.

Trixiefirecracker · 11/05/2023 20:00

Iamnotthe1 · 11/05/2023 18:38

It's not up to the school. The expected grades for GCSE are set as an external measure and the school cannot change them. They are held accountable to them.

I really wish people would read the full thread rather than posting pages of misinformation.

I have read the thread and I work in schools. I repeat what I said earlier and what the OPs school has informed her…and that is that many secondary schools have their own cat tests in year seven that they base their streaming off rather than sats. This is the case for all three of our local schools.

Iamnotthe1 · 11/05/2023 19:59

JenWillsiam · 11/05/2023 19:55

Again if poor school who isn’t monitoring children beyond sats. These are schools looking to smash it with a 1*. Not just make sure kids achieve in line with progress 8.

What you've just said doesn't make sense. The schools aiming to have 1+ progress 8 scores are the schools making the most decisions based on the SATs generated targets because progress 8 is measured exclusively from the SATs results.

JenWillsiam · 11/05/2023 19:58

Iamnotthe1 · 11/05/2023 19:57

There is an enormous gap between "These are important: take ownership and put in effort," and "You're doomed if you don't do well."

To be honest, Y6 children are not little kids. I've seen some that show a maturity, empathetic awareness and intellectual curiosity that dwarfs some of their parents. They are capable of so much more than many believe, including (at times) not putting in the effort and needing to develop their understanding and appreciation of metacognition.

They are not important to individual kids.

Iamnotthe1 · 11/05/2023 19:57

JenWillsiam · 11/05/2023 19:50

And I didn’t say all teenagers. I said they aren’t teenagers slacking off. Im well aware that the majority work really hard. But some
do not. And need a kick. Not during exam week mind you. But these aren’t those kids. They’re little kids.

moreover though no child or adult as ever motivated by the threat of “if you don’t you’re doomed”.

There is an enormous gap between "These are important: take ownership and put in effort," and "You're doomed if you don't do well."

To be honest, Y6 children are not little kids. I've seen some that show a maturity, empathetic awareness and intellectual curiosity that dwarfs some of their parents. They are capable of so much more than many believe, including (at times) not putting in the effort and needing to develop their understanding and appreciation of metacognition.

JenWillsiam · 11/05/2023 19:55

Iamnotthe1 · 11/05/2023 19:51

And the fact that they are aiming for high progress scores will mean that the children who are off track for their SATs generated expected attainment targets will be prioritised over children who are on track or have already attained it.

Again if poor school who isn’t monitoring children beyond sats. These are schools looking to smash it with a 1*. Not just make sure kids achieve in line with progress 8.

UndertheCedartree · 11/05/2023 19:53

whodawhodaeho · 09/05/2023 11:32

I do feel a bit sorry for the teachers who have to put up with the pressure of SATs, telling kids they matter when the teachers actually know they don’t for the kid - just for the school.
plus- the grammar papers! Have you seen them? They make no f-ing sense, and I say that as a writer! The ‘technical’ terms they’re expected to know have very little practical application when it comes to actually writing.

I've raged against some of the questions! In reading I find they ask a vague question that could have many answers but expect a really specific answer. As far as I'm concerned it is an absolute nonsense and the sooner they're over and they can go back to proper learning the better!

Iamnotthe1 · 11/05/2023 19:51

JenWillsiam · 11/05/2023 19:43

If your child is pigeon holed at secondary because of their sats results that is a school issue. And is pretty gross. Schools should be striving for progress 8 scores of 1+ which means nurturing ALL children regardless of their sats.

And the fact that they are aiming for high progress scores will mean that the children who are off track for their SATs generated expected attainment targets will be prioritised over children who are on track or have already attained it.

JenWillsiam · 11/05/2023 19:50

Iamnotthe1 · 11/05/2023 19:46

Except they do matter to the kids and for the kids.

The fact that you're assuming teenagers are slackers and that kids are just "only capable of what they're capable of" is shocking and I can only assume that you haven't seen just what Y6 children are capable of when they are motivated, determined and want to put in the effort. That statements also flies in the face of all the research on education, academic progress and how metacognition.

And I didn’t say all teenagers. I said they aren’t teenagers slacking off. Im well aware that the majority work really hard. But some
do not. And need a kick. Not during exam week mind you. But these aren’t those kids. They’re little kids.

moreover though no child or adult as ever motivated by the threat of “if you don’t you’re doomed”.

JenWillsiam · 11/05/2023 19:48

Iamnotthe1 · 11/05/2023 19:46

Except they do matter to the kids and for the kids.

The fact that you're assuming teenagers are slackers and that kids are just "only capable of what they're capable of" is shocking and I can only assume that you haven't seen just what Y6 children are capable of when they are motivated, determined and want to put in the effort. That statements also flies in the face of all the research on education, academic progress and how metacognition.

I’m not sure you have fully grasped the meaning of the word capable. If you don’t have the capacity to do something you don’t, if you have the capacity to do something when you work hard and are motivated you had that capacity all along.

Asosbabe · 11/05/2023 19:48

Unless they're torturing animals or something similarly disturbing

UndertheCedartree · 11/05/2023 19:47

What a terrible message!

The message given to my DD's year 6 group was we know you're all going to do your best and achieve, but remember this is only one way of doing that. You all have many talents whether in sport, music, art etc. You are all unique and have your individual strengths. We are so proud of you. Remember to support your classmates as some may be anxious, but you are all going through the same thing so can empathise with each other. Paraphrased but I was very happy with this message and my DD who has Long Covid and associated anxiety has been coping really well.

Asosbabe · 11/05/2023 19:46

Agree. Horrid reports shouldn't follow them

Iamnotthe1 · 11/05/2023 19:46

JenWillsiam · 11/05/2023 19:40

At this point if they don’t know it they don’t know. It’s that simple. For kids they don’t matter. They shouldn’t be cramming or stressing. It’s not going to help them at all and if anything will pull their marks down. These aren’t teenagers who are slacking off. They’re little kids. They are only capable of what they’re capable of.

Except they do matter to the kids and for the kids.

The fact that you're assuming teenagers are slackers and that kids are just "only capable of what they're capable of" is shocking and I can only assume that you haven't seen just what Y6 children are capable of when they are motivated, determined and want to put in the effort. That statements also flies in the face of all the research on education, academic progress and how metacognition.

Swipe left for the next trending thread