Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To thinks SATs don’t really matter?

362 replies

whodawhodaeho · 09/05/2023 08:12

DD is year 6 and her class teacher( and year head) has told them that if they don’t do well in SATs then they’ll be put with the disruptive, badly behaved kids in ‘big’ school. Ie put in lower sets forever

I have told her this is nonsense - that the new school will assess her themselves up til Oct half term then stream sets for certain subjects (which they do - her DB is there ) and the SATs don’t matter.
And they continually assess and move kids around according to ability/ progress through school terms/ years

YABU - yes they matter, and yes secondary school will pay attention to the results

YANBU - they don’t really matter

OP posts:
Iamnotthe1 · 11/05/2023 23:19

XelaM · 11/05/2023 23:16

I guess all these nonsensical SAT/progress 8 and similar measures is why people go private 🤷‍♀️

If private schools don't care about them, they clearly make no difference to the actual student and are completely arbitrary measures.

In which case, you're dealing with the "grouped by destination" issue. If your child's a potential Oxbridge candidate, they'll get loads of support thrown at them so they can maximise the number of children with those destinations. If their academic ability suggests less, they'll get less.

There is always a "game" being played somewhere and you need to be aware of it to navigate it properly to your advantage.

Walkaround · 11/05/2023 23:18

XelaM · 11/05/2023 23:16

I guess all these nonsensical SAT/progress 8 and similar measures is why people go private 🤷‍♀️

If private schools don't care about them, they clearly make no difference to the actual student and are completely arbitrary measures.

🤣Oh yes, of course, private schools have no interest whatsoever in their statistics 🤣🤣🤣.

XelaM · 11/05/2023 23:16

I guess all these nonsensical SAT/progress 8 and similar measures is why people go private 🤷‍♀️

If private schools don't care about them, they clearly make no difference to the actual student and are completely arbitrary measures.

Walkaround · 11/05/2023 23:13

You could say that statistics like Progress 8 affect your specific child precisely because statistical measurements have no interest whatsoever in specific children as unique individuals - they force the focus onto groups of children who can be lumped together. Your child as an individual could therefore all too easily fall through the statistical cracks and not get the attention they need and deserve.

rewilded · 11/05/2023 22:57

As I said in my earlier post. This is exactly what happened to my DSs. The lower SATs/ Progress 8 result my elder DS achieved had no intervention, as the flight path was fine, the younger one had so much more thrown at him as he was on target for 7s and was slipping. Infact he came out with a couple of 9s seems unfair tbh.

Iamnotthe1 · 11/05/2023 22:46

XelaM · 11/05/2023 22:09

HOW does "progress 8" affect an individual pupil? Just how? I have absolutely zero clue what my daughter's progress 8 score is. How will this affect her GCSE/A-level results? The answer is it will have zero bearing on them. The only people who care about "progress 8" are those running the schools.

Because decisions are made with that in mind. Just as a simple example:

There are two classes who are achieving broadly in line with each other.
Class A are mostly attaining in line for 4s and 5s in their GCSE. Their targets, generated from their SAT results, are also 4s and 5s.
Class B are also mostly attaining in line for 4s and 5s in their GCSE. However, some of their targets are 6s and even a 7 or two.

When deciding on which staff are going to teach which classes next year, SLT will consider this. To the kids, parents and class teachers, these classes seem the same. To SLT, class A will generate a neutral or positive Progress 8 score and the class B be negative. SLT will decide to give the stronger teacher, with a better track record, to class B because they need to make more progress. If your child was in class B, they get the stronger teacher and are pushed to make more progress and achieve a higher result. If you child was in class A, quite basically, they don't get that same priority.

Walkaround · 11/05/2023 22:31

XelaM · 11/05/2023 22:09

HOW does "progress 8" affect an individual pupil? Just how? I have absolutely zero clue what my daughter's progress 8 score is. How will this affect her GCSE/A-level results? The answer is it will have zero bearing on them. The only people who care about "progress 8" are those running the schools.

The thing is, the DfE uses progress 8 specifically to affect schools’ behaviour - it doesn’t force these statistical measures on schools just as a matter of vague interest. And many parents hypocritically pay attention to them, too, whilst simultaneously claiming they don’t make a difference to their actual children. As with hospital waiting times and all other statistics, the effects statistics have on behaviour are not always the ones desired - ie they almost never result in a general improvement in everything you want an organisation to do well, they tend instead to make other things worse due to an unnatural focus on the things capable of being measured.

If your child’s particular needs do not fall within the needs of the groups of children identified statistically as needing particular attention by the school in order to improve its progress 8 score, then your child’s needs being met will have a lower priority than those of the group being focused on, because spending the money and time on your child won’t affect the statistics. Where funding is lacking and teaching vacancies abundant, you may perceive the effect on your child quite distinctly. If your child does not need specific support, but is fairly well-behaved and bright and served well by the general class teaching they are receiving already, without needing any more of a push than that, then it won’t matter too much.

Oblomov23 · 11/05/2023 22:22

Some posters sound naieve. Of course what Gymrabbit and CSTeacher say is true. Sets are important. If your school is good / normal, Set 1 and 2 for maths and English have very bright kids, not much / very little mucking about, because they want to be there.

Boomboom22 · 11/05/2023 22:22

XelaM · 11/05/2023 22:09

HOW does "progress 8" affect an individual pupil? Just how? I have absolutely zero clue what my daughter's progress 8 score is. How will this affect her GCSE/A-level results? The answer is it will have zero bearing on them. The only people who care about "progress 8" are those running the schools.

Just because you don't understand how it works doesn't mean it won't make any difference. If she is achieving a 5 and meant to great. If she's above target great for her and the school. If her target is 6 she may get more focus. Google educational triage, it still applies but now to individual targets but over a cohort so if you get a few 2 above you can afford some 2 below to come out at 0.
When you were at school teachers may have put attention to getting weaker students to a C and not stretched A to A* or whatever the measure was with cse or o levels, 5 good passes or whatever.

XelaM · 11/05/2023 22:09

Iamnotthe1 · 11/05/2023 19:32

Based on individual students. The measure is generated by looking at the progress made by individual students and then averaging it. So your comments in the post I replied to are wrong.

If you're suggesting that the existence of progress 8 and the expected attainment grades of individual students don't then affect those individual students then I'm afraid you are, once again, demonstratively wrong.

HOW does "progress 8" affect an individual pupil? Just how? I have absolutely zero clue what my daughter's progress 8 score is. How will this affect her GCSE/A-level results? The answer is it will have zero bearing on them. The only people who care about "progress 8" are those running the schools.

Caiti19 · 11/05/2023 22:01

Dulra · 09/05/2023 09:04

Reading back over all the comments I can see why your education system is in disarray it really really seems to focus on assessment and streaming kids at such a young age, doesn't happen at all in Ireland. Kids go into secondary schools at age 12/13 (they are in primary school for 8 years and secondary for 5 or 6). They are generally in mixed ability form classes and do get divided up into higher or ordinary level in second year but only in English, Maths and Irish, this is based on how they have done in the subject throughout the year and is often in consultation with a parent and the child particularly if they are borderline. After Junior cert (our GCSE equivalent) they choose 7 subjects for Leaving cert (A Levels) and some of them are mixed ability some again divided into higher or ordinary but it is done subject to subject. so you can be higher level in one and ordinary in another, there is also option for Leaving cert applied which is more vocation based.
Your children seem to be streamed so young and there seems to be so much exam and assessment pressure at such a young age. When have they time to develop their confidence, self esteem, self discovery?

You are so right. I grew up in the Irish system. My kids are in the U.K. system. I could type for an hour all the stuff that has utterly shocked me over the course of the primary years - particularly between ages 4 and 7. Identifying these kids for special treatment at that age based on their skill at taking tests does impact on their confidence, and constitutes a really crap launch into learning for many children. I have a Mum friend who described her 5 year old son as "not academic" based on feedback at his parent teacher meeting in his second year of formal education - dreadful stuff.

CSTeacher · 11/05/2023 21:55

OMG12 · 11/05/2023 21:45

That is terrible though sticking less academically able kids, who might well be timid/shy well behaved with disruptive kids. It stinks of just wrong them off. Common sense would say these two groups are probably the least suitable to be mixed, this is really letting kids down. This group of kids need extra support not competing for attention with kids with behavioural issues. I’m horrified at this!

Not all badly behaved kids are in the lower sets but I tend to see the badly behaved ones are in sets 3 and 4. Now that is a mixture of ability and attitude to learning.

For our SEND and very low-ability students they do have their class, but you have badly behaved kids in there because they need the small group setting as well or they are SEND. But we can't have set for every possible outcome. We don't have the staff or resources and that is the truth. So yeah badly behaved children do end up in lower ability groups because they don't want to learn and so are not as high ability as set 1 and 2 who are behaved. And we do teach differently depending on the set.

We do our best for everyone. If you are appalled then talk to your MP about the fact schools haven't got enough money to hire proper SEND teachers or enough teachers to have more sets.

But I have noticed that the worse the behavior, the lower the group and the lower the grade. That is a fact. And behavior and manners start at home.

Gymrabbit · 11/05/2023 21:53

OMG12

I think you are slightly misunderstanding the situation. The children are all of a similar ability however it often works out that the badly behaved children do not perform well in the same way as low ability children so they end up in bottom sets. its obviously not ideal and many schools try to put the brighter disruptive kids in classes above their ability to limit impact and hope the class will pull them up.
However, I’m sure you understand that children with very low reading and writing levels will often be taught together regardless of differing behaviours - which does make more sense than putting a Grade 9 English student with a child who is reading at the level of a 6 year old because they are both well behaved.

OMG12 · 11/05/2023 21:49

Writing them off rather

OMG12 · 11/05/2023 21:45

CSTeacher · 11/05/2023 21:04

If I may give a secondary school teacher's answer to this. We do use them as a basis and a starting point, along with their reading ability and how they do in a test called MidYis. This data all gets collated and sets are created in the Autumn term.
SATs are important as they give us insight into their ability but also it is only one part of the overall data picture we obtain.
Now in previous schools, I have worked at, there are Alternative Provision classes where the worst behaved 5% do go into. In my school, the bottom set is a mixture of badly behaved and low-ability students.
Tests do form the basis of the sets and the importance of SATs must be explained but the ability to move sets is possible. I would always say to my students and my own child, that you just do the best you can and that is all anyone can ask of you.

Basically SATs matter but not to the severity the teacher is coming off with. Whilst yes she can move sets, the initial sets are based on a mixture of things including SATs and MidYis.

I wish her luck.

That is terrible though sticking less academically able kids, who might well be timid/shy well behaved with disruptive kids. It stinks of just wrong them off. Common sense would say these two groups are probably the least suitable to be mixed, this is really letting kids down. This group of kids need extra support not competing for attention with kids with behavioural issues. I’m horrified at this!

Oblomov23 · 11/05/2023 21:43

@HT56 :
"As a parent I don’t worry about stuff like this. "

Me neither. I hate reading threads of kids stressed doing Yr 6 SATS. I don't like to read of parents considering pulling them out. Ds1 and ds2 when at primary never had all this stress. I expected them to behave, try their best throughout all schooling. They are both reasonably bright so I just expect them to do ok.
I never worried about SAT's, progress 8, the difference between predicted grades at GCSE and target. I don't even care what the 2 mean. At parents evening I just ask : is he behaving, is he doing ok. If yes, that's all I need to know.

CM1897 · 11/05/2023 21:24

whodawhodaeho · 09/05/2023 08:33

‘then they’ll be put with the disruptive, badly behaved kids in ‘big’ school
Did the head really say this? ‘

the head of hear year did - a good teacher usually but can be a bit unorthodox at times.
DD said they were doing revision and lots of kids were messing around- so I suppose it came out of frustration.

DH is flapping about the late night tonight - DD usually in bed around 9pm - but this is an unusual opp for her and even if she is a bit tired tomorrow I’m not sure it would really affect her ‘performance’ in SATs - she is where she is

Hate to think how dramatic that teacher would be about GCSEs 😂

SATs are to benefit the school, not the students. My daughter is in year 7, she ‘failed’ her SAT’s, but is in top sets for most subjects now

Walkaround · 11/05/2023 21:20

Hard pressed, underfunded schools will focus their limited extra support budget on the statistical anomalies, not those children who appear to be achieving and progressing OK, but have actually been wildly underachieving since primary school. To that extent, SATS results are relevant and important, because secondary schools are not generally so tiny that every child gets noticed and understood in the way their parents might have liked. In other words, whether you like it or not, statistics affect the treatment of the individual child to a certain extent.

CSTeacher · 11/05/2023 21:04

If I may give a secondary school teacher's answer to this. We do use them as a basis and a starting point, along with their reading ability and how they do in a test called MidYis. This data all gets collated and sets are created in the Autumn term.
SATs are important as they give us insight into their ability but also it is only one part of the overall data picture we obtain.
Now in previous schools, I have worked at, there are Alternative Provision classes where the worst behaved 5% do go into. In my school, the bottom set is a mixture of badly behaved and low-ability students.
Tests do form the basis of the sets and the importance of SATs must be explained but the ability to move sets is possible. I would always say to my students and my own child, that you just do the best you can and that is all anyone can ask of you.

Basically SATs matter but not to the severity the teacher is coming off with. Whilst yes she can move sets, the initial sets are based on a mixture of things including SATs and MidYis.

I wish her luck.

JenWillsiam · 11/05/2023 20:51

OMG12 · 11/05/2023 20:25

Any school that decides children’s attainment at GCSE level and beyond is going to be accurately reflected by SAT scores at 10/11 and does not constantly adjust to meet changing skills is quite frankly shit. It is doing late developers a massive disservice. Kids develop at different times. I’m not a big fan of sets for subjects (with the possible exception of maths and English).

Any teacher pigeon holing a child based on a few tests at 10/11 really should have a rethink about careers.

Absolutely agree with you.

Gymrabbit · 11/05/2023 20:42

Iamnotthe1

nearly 20 years in secondary schools teaching a core subject and 100% concur with all you’ve said.

I don’t believe that targets should be based on SATS results but they are and in many schools sets are too - it’s reality just because some people don’t like it,
doesn’t mean it’s not true….

Nononsensemumsy · 11/05/2023 20:36

My eldest didn’t do great in his sats, predicted grade Cs. He achieved As in maths and further maths, As and Bs in his other GCSEs. As maths and further maths at Alevel with an A and B in chemistry and physics. Awarded further maths student of the year. Went to a red brick uni got a BA in mathematics and now has a very good job. Please don’t sweat the sats there’s far too much pressure put on our children for the benefit of the school. They’re still kids and shouldn’t have this worry placed on them.

Lostinalibrary · 11/05/2023 20:36

Iamnotthe1 · 11/05/2023 20:34

And I explained that the measure by which the child will be compared is set externally to the secondary school and based entirely on their results in KS2. Secondary schools have no control over that.

Any targets set by the secondary school from internal tests are internal guidance only.

This.

Iamnotthe1 · 11/05/2023 20:34

Trixiefirecracker · 11/05/2023 20:19

Actually I said (if you have read my other threads) that most schools use Cats to stream and help set GCSE targets and if a school is basing a child’s GCSE targets solely on Sats then that is crazy.

And I explained that the measure by which the child will be compared is set externally to the secondary school and based entirely on their results in KS2. Secondary schools have no control over that.

Any targets set by the secondary school from internal tests are internal guidance only.