Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To thinks SATs don’t really matter?

362 replies

whodawhodaeho · 09/05/2023 08:12

DD is year 6 and her class teacher( and year head) has told them that if they don’t do well in SATs then they’ll be put with the disruptive, badly behaved kids in ‘big’ school. Ie put in lower sets forever

I have told her this is nonsense - that the new school will assess her themselves up til Oct half term then stream sets for certain subjects (which they do - her DB is there ) and the SATs don’t matter.
And they continually assess and move kids around according to ability/ progress through school terms/ years

YABU - yes they matter, and yes secondary school will pay attention to the results

YANBU - they don’t really matter

OP posts:
Spendonsend · 12/05/2023 15:52

Sunnylassie · 12/05/2023 15:42

If sats generate GCSE targets and enable to stream children into supposed suitable sets, what happened to all the children who didn’t do them due to covid lockdowns?

As far as I am aware, there will be no progress 8 published for the cohorts that missed Sats. So schools will do their own thing.
Its not that schools arent capable of internal trsting and data to predict grades and set targets.
Its that progress 8 is a published thing so schools take it into account.

Iamnotthe1 · 12/05/2023 15:47

Sunnylassie · 12/05/2023 15:42

If sats generate GCSE targets and enable to stream children into supposed suitable sets, what happened to all the children who didn’t do them due to covid lockdowns?

During lockdowns, SATs were scrapped for all. As a result, no child has that data. As of yet, the DfE have not stated how the progress of those children will be measured with regards to an adjusted "progress 8". They did, recently, state that they are exploring options and will share the progress accountability measure once they have decided what it is.

In the meantime, secondaries have been making it up based on whatever data the primary schools were able to provide for these children and hoping that they are guessing right as to how the accountability measures will be formed.

OMG12 · 12/05/2023 15:45

Gymrabbit · 12/05/2023 15:15

OMG12

You do understand that compares the 80s and the 90s there are very few special schools now meaning children with severe behaviour needs and academic needs are in mainstream classrooms? many schools also have lots of EAL students.

I’m still waiting for your pearls of wisdom, apparently we’re all shit teachers for not wanting to teach grade 1s and grade 9s in the same classroom so I assumed you had knowledge of how to manage that kind of class without inhibiting the learning of either end of the spectrum.

Well here’s the pearl of wisdom, treat all kids the same. Kids aren’t “grade 1s” or “grade 9s” they are kids with potential, some of whom get things more quickly than others , some need things explaining in different ways.

But my main advice is to stop classifying children by what grades you think they will get, because they’re likely to aim for those.

I would also advise you to be less aggressive in the face of challenge.

Sunnylassie · 12/05/2023 15:42

If sats generate GCSE targets and enable to stream children into supposed suitable sets, what happened to all the children who didn’t do them due to covid lockdowns?

Walkaround · 12/05/2023 15:36

DisquietintheRanks · 12/05/2023 06:26

@Walkaround yes heaven forfend there should be any accountability or measure of progress for a primary aged pupil. The old days when whole swathes of children could be gently failed and then quietly shovelled off to secondary was so much better. Hmm

I don't love SATS but they are an improvement on the nothing we had before.

@DisquietintheRanks - what’s with the🤔face directed at me? I haven’t expressed any opinion whatsoever on whether SATS or any other kind of measurement are a good or bad thing overall, I have simply pointed out to people who think it can have no bearing on, or relevance to, the way their individual children are treated by a school that this is slightly flawed thinking, and that statistical measurement to monitor and control human behaviour has its flaws and unexpected consequences; and have pointed out to someone who thinks private schools would avoid what they think are “nonsensical” measures is wrong, because measuring and grading children is very much in vogue in the private sector. I have never, at any point, said or even implied that statistical measurement of progress, and accountability measures, including SATS are pointless. Plenty of children are still being quietly failed, however, despite the statistics, as I have already pointed out. Trying to manipulate statistics does not have zero impact on the treatment of individual children.

DisquietintheRanks · 12/05/2023 15:17

whodawhodaeho · 12/05/2023 07:50

‘that in the vast majority of secondary schools they will be used to generate GCSE targets. ‘

well that’s just not true. Thank god. What does getting a question correct on fronted adverbials have to to do with Spanish, biology, music, chemistry, ethics, DT and on and on …

It is true. It might not be sensible but it is true.

Gymrabbit · 12/05/2023 15:15

OMG12

You do understand that compares the 80s and the 90s there are very few special schools now meaning children with severe behaviour needs and academic needs are in mainstream classrooms? many schools also have lots of EAL students.

I’m still waiting for your pearls of wisdom, apparently we’re all shit teachers for not wanting to teach grade 1s and grade 9s in the same classroom so I assumed you had knowledge of how to manage that kind of class without inhibiting the learning of either end of the spectrum.

Horsetoday · 12/05/2023 15:15

I threatened to pull my kids out of the end of Year 6 if the school didn’t lighten up on the pressure and break time detentions for those who weren’t improving and I wasn’t the only one to go it and have strong words. The school really lost all sense of perspective.

OMG12 · 12/05/2023 14:36

Gymrabbit · 12/05/2023 14:22

OMG12

Are you a teacher?

please feel free to explain to me how I can simultaneously teach a potential Oxbridge student, a student who knows three words of English and a student who reads and writes at the level of a 5 year old?

You could probably find a teacher from the 80s and 90s who seemed to manage it in my school. My classes had people who did attend Oxbridge and people who left school at 16 and went into work,

If you have a 15 year old with a reading age of 5 then clearly the system they have been in so far isn’t working for them. We are not talking teenagers who are effectively illiterate though in general are we? That clearly needs addressing separately. The educational system has quite clearly failed them or they aren’t suited to mainstream schools.

Gymrabbit · 12/05/2023 14:22

OMG12

Are you a teacher?

please feel free to explain to me how I can simultaneously teach a potential Oxbridge student, a student who knows three words of English and a student who reads and writes at the level of a 5 year old?

OMG12 · 12/05/2023 13:07

CSTeacher · 12/05/2023 12:27

Just as you said to me, you are entitled to your opinion, but you are viewing this from your experience which was probably (guessing) a minimum of 8 to 10 years ago. Times have changed and we do move children up and down sets all the time based on their ability. It is either we put them in lower sets to ensure we teach at their level and try to keep them in school or they are expelled, which we do not like to do.

When you have worked in a school and I work in a severely deprived area and am originally from London and have high SEND and disability needs, so I get that sets have their pros and cons, you see the need for them. We do our best. You do not know me and I do not know you. You do not know the kind of teacher I am. You do not know that I sit and wait every morning for a girl with severe anxiety that was a victim of abuse because I am the only person she trusts. You do not know that I get the badly behaved students in my tutor group because I am the only one they like because I listen and I tell them the truth. You do not know that I am there, talking badly behaved kids down from doing something that will make it worse for them. I do care for my kids. I like to say I am a mother to more than just my own biological son, but that does not mean that badly behaved kids are not badly behaved and that they need smaller, less fast paced sets because they will be out of lesson more often than the higher sets which means I need to go over material more and slower with the lower sets.

We do not WRITE OFF our kids. We adapt to them. But I am not going to put a badly behaved student that is achieving a grade 3 in a class with grade 8s. It is not fair to them and affects their mental health more. They need to be taught at their level. You do not get to judge my teaching when I am being adaptive to them and sometimes, I am the only one reminding them to eat. Sets work because I was a middle set child and it pushed me to stay out of bottom set and try for top, but also I was taught at my level and wasn't pushed too hard or not enough and it did not make me feel worthless for being around smarter children because I was with people working at the same speed as me.

Children do not all learn the same and adults do not all learn the same. We each have different needs. We cater to that and if you ever get the chance to see or work in a school you will see that. This will be my last comment. Have a good day.

Actually I was talking about the situation today. In my day1980s and 90s in my school there was minimal use of sets. They weren’t needed, all lessons suited all children, those who struggled most had additional help during lunch/breaks from teachers.

Whilst you might have been motivated to stay out of the bottom and move towards the top. A child put in the bottom group, effectively being told they’re not as good as others is having the same message pushed on them from many angles.

There is just no need for sets, teachers can be adaptable within classes. As I said, I have been top of the class and towards the bottom, at no point was I ever of the opinion someone who needed additional help holding me back, it taught me patience and compassion. When I was bottom, the more able kids were able to model better understanding and ways of thinking.

Schools are about more than academic achievement, esp where there are deprived pupils.

it’s great that you are looking out for that girl, but all children need looking after, whether they behave poorly or not, whether they are academic or not. There should be no need to move between groups. Children should not live in fear of falling down a group, they should feel safe to reach towards success and deal with inevitable failures that come with growth, they should not somehow feel they are punished for those failures. School should be a safe environment for exploration. I get that resources limit a schools ability, but none of what I suggest means more resources, it’s adapting what you already have.

if you thought you would feel “ worthless” being around kids smarter than you, surely that is an argument against sets. In life you will mix with people who are smarter and those who aren’t as smart. You will have to work amongst a mixture of abilities. Surely school should prepare you for that? Why would you feel worthless because someone is brighter. What on earth would make you feel that way. It’s another iteration of divide and conquer.

it’s interesting how inflexible your views are on this, how you take the criticism of a system and your defence of it as a personal attack.

CSTeacher · 12/05/2023 12:27

OMG12 · 12/05/2023 09:22

You’re perfectly entitled to your opinion of course, I’m sure sets benefit some pupils and teachers.

I can’t see why teachers can’t teach mixed ability groups, they managed it perfectly well through my school life. There was a certain amount of leading be example from the good and bright kids, class detentions meant peer pressure to behave well. All teaching and knowledge was available to all kids.

I left secondary school with the top A level marks in the year, yet I started it lagging behind in reading and maths. If I had been put in bottom classes with disruptive pupils, firstly it would have been too much, I would have hated school, disengaged had extremely poor mental health. It would never have allowed me to progress (I was a late developer, I didn’t read until 7). I had number blindness until around age 11.

I suspect sets are more for the benefit of the teachers than pupils (plus a sense of superiority for those in top sets).

it’s clear from your post you would probably label kids in bottom sets as likely the disruptive ones. Have you ever thought this grouping together of kids and lower expectations of them might be a self fulfilling prophecy?

All children should be elevated upwards, sets only serve to perpetuate inequality.

I came from a poor working class background, by mixing with kids with different home lives, and therefore often different attitudes to learning, behaviour, expectations and experiences it elevated me.

A child’s ability at 11 is only really a reflection of where they have come from, by perpetuating that in sets from an early age, schools are limiting where these children are going.

Sets might benefit the already advantaged, but they effectively keep the already advantaged in their position. Once a child has been in a lower set for a while it’s nearly impossible to extricate themselves from a cycle of reduced access to higher level knowledge and lower expectations. Even if, by some miracle, they do manage to climb out of the pit the educational system and life opportunities has dug for them they spend years playing catch up.

Parents are aware of this bias towards higher achieving pupils, being easier and more pleasant to teach. That’s why many spend a small fortune in tutors fees to make up for often limited education. But again this, when linked to a structure involving sets, gives certain pupils unfair advantages, less well off children with poorly educated parents don’t get this advantage.

For these, and many reasons, I think sets are an extremely bad idea. They are simply a reflection of societal structure with perhaps the odd few managing to escape.

IME children learn as much from other children as adults.

Just as you said to me, you are entitled to your opinion, but you are viewing this from your experience which was probably (guessing) a minimum of 8 to 10 years ago. Times have changed and we do move children up and down sets all the time based on their ability. It is either we put them in lower sets to ensure we teach at their level and try to keep them in school or they are expelled, which we do not like to do.

When you have worked in a school and I work in a severely deprived area and am originally from London and have high SEND and disability needs, so I get that sets have their pros and cons, you see the need for them. We do our best. You do not know me and I do not know you. You do not know the kind of teacher I am. You do not know that I sit and wait every morning for a girl with severe anxiety that was a victim of abuse because I am the only person she trusts. You do not know that I get the badly behaved students in my tutor group because I am the only one they like because I listen and I tell them the truth. You do not know that I am there, talking badly behaved kids down from doing something that will make it worse for them. I do care for my kids. I like to say I am a mother to more than just my own biological son, but that does not mean that badly behaved kids are not badly behaved and that they need smaller, less fast paced sets because they will be out of lesson more often than the higher sets which means I need to go over material more and slower with the lower sets.

We do not WRITE OFF our kids. We adapt to them. But I am not going to put a badly behaved student that is achieving a grade 3 in a class with grade 8s. It is not fair to them and affects their mental health more. They need to be taught at their level. You do not get to judge my teaching when I am being adaptive to them and sometimes, I am the only one reminding them to eat. Sets work because I was a middle set child and it pushed me to stay out of bottom set and try for top, but also I was taught at my level and wasn't pushed too hard or not enough and it did not make me feel worthless for being around smarter children because I was with people working at the same speed as me.

Children do not all learn the same and adults do not all learn the same. We each have different needs. We cater to that and if you ever get the chance to see or work in a school you will see that. This will be my last comment. Have a good day.

Sunnylassie · 12/05/2023 09:44

OMG12 · 12/05/2023 09:22

You’re perfectly entitled to your opinion of course, I’m sure sets benefit some pupils and teachers.

I can’t see why teachers can’t teach mixed ability groups, they managed it perfectly well through my school life. There was a certain amount of leading be example from the good and bright kids, class detentions meant peer pressure to behave well. All teaching and knowledge was available to all kids.

I left secondary school with the top A level marks in the year, yet I started it lagging behind in reading and maths. If I had been put in bottom classes with disruptive pupils, firstly it would have been too much, I would have hated school, disengaged had extremely poor mental health. It would never have allowed me to progress (I was a late developer, I didn’t read until 7). I had number blindness until around age 11.

I suspect sets are more for the benefit of the teachers than pupils (plus a sense of superiority for those in top sets).

it’s clear from your post you would probably label kids in bottom sets as likely the disruptive ones. Have you ever thought this grouping together of kids and lower expectations of them might be a self fulfilling prophecy?

All children should be elevated upwards, sets only serve to perpetuate inequality.

I came from a poor working class background, by mixing with kids with different home lives, and therefore often different attitudes to learning, behaviour, expectations and experiences it elevated me.

A child’s ability at 11 is only really a reflection of where they have come from, by perpetuating that in sets from an early age, schools are limiting where these children are going.

Sets might benefit the already advantaged, but they effectively keep the already advantaged in their position. Once a child has been in a lower set for a while it’s nearly impossible to extricate themselves from a cycle of reduced access to higher level knowledge and lower expectations. Even if, by some miracle, they do manage to climb out of the pit the educational system and life opportunities has dug for them they spend years playing catch up.

Parents are aware of this bias towards higher achieving pupils, being easier and more pleasant to teach. That’s why many spend a small fortune in tutors fees to make up for often limited education. But again this, when linked to a structure involving sets, gives certain pupils unfair advantages, less well off children with poorly educated parents don’t get this advantage.

For these, and many reasons, I think sets are an extremely bad idea. They are simply a reflection of societal structure with perhaps the odd few managing to escape.

IME children learn as much from other children as adults.

Whole heartedly agree!

OMG12 · 12/05/2023 09:43

CSTeacher · 11/05/2023 21:55

Not all badly behaved kids are in the lower sets but I tend to see the badly behaved ones are in sets 3 and 4. Now that is a mixture of ability and attitude to learning.

For our SEND and very low-ability students they do have their class, but you have badly behaved kids in there because they need the small group setting as well or they are SEND. But we can't have set for every possible outcome. We don't have the staff or resources and that is the truth. So yeah badly behaved children do end up in lower ability groups because they don't want to learn and so are not as high ability as set 1 and 2 who are behaved. And we do teach differently depending on the set.

We do our best for everyone. If you are appalled then talk to your MP about the fact schools haven't got enough money to hire proper SEND teachers or enough teachers to have more sets.

But I have noticed that the worse the behavior, the lower the group and the lower the grade. That is a fact. And behavior and manners start at home.

And your comment regarding badly behaved kids not wanting to learn is horrifying! No wonder they have disengaged from the school! These poor kids are being written off. Why don’t they want to learn? Why are they disruptive?

it’s clear that the system at your school is writing off large numbers of children, most likely the ones most in need of help. Many of those kids probably go home to families where the parents don’t care if they are in school or not, what grades they get, they probably tell their kids school is a waste of time, they’ll never amount to anything, they get to school surrounded by kids who have the same issues, teachers who clearly think the same, what bloody hope does that child have?

i heard a statistic the other day from the NSPCC. 7 kids out of every class will suffer abuse before the age of 18. I would bet the number in your bottom sets is much higher.

I could actually cry at the system you think is beneficial.

OMG12 · 12/05/2023 09:22

CSTeacher · 12/05/2023 08:17

Actually it is much less fair to not stream. We started the year without streaming and the children were mixed and in their tutor groups. You have very low-ability, middle ability, high ability, SEND and badly behaved all together. You end up with groups that have more higher ability or more SEND or, and we did have this, two full groups of badly behaved children who played off each other.

Teachers need to be able to teach to the ability of the child and we cannot do that if they are mixed. I definitely teach differently to my top set vs my lower sets because I am adapting to them and that is the truth of it. Top set will get through a task and on to the extension in the same time it will take lower set to get through half the task.

Sets work and I have seen it have an impact on a bright, but badly behaved young man where before he was in his mixed ability tutor group and was acting out, but once the sets were made and he was placed in a top set group his behavior and attitude changed, which I said as much to his parents at parents evening.

Sets have always been a thing, just now there are a few more of them rather than the standard three. We have 5. And as it has been stated in other posts, badly behaved children tend to be those who require the lower ability groups because the groups are smaller or the SEND groups because they have more TAs.

And many parents at my school are very happy with the sets as they know that the sets are there to ensure that we are teaching the children at their level and not going too high or too low for them.

Mixed ability groups are not beneficial. We cannot teach at a mixed ability level because some children will not be challenged enough and others too challenged, and mixed ability creates cracks that SEND children fall through because we are busy dealing with badly behaved children who have no respect for their peers who want to learn.

Also sets do work on some badly behaved children because whereas before they were with their friends, now they are in sets and for some it pushes them to work harder and behave more so that they can move up sets, which a lot of parents want too.

You’re perfectly entitled to your opinion of course, I’m sure sets benefit some pupils and teachers.

I can’t see why teachers can’t teach mixed ability groups, they managed it perfectly well through my school life. There was a certain amount of leading be example from the good and bright kids, class detentions meant peer pressure to behave well. All teaching and knowledge was available to all kids.

I left secondary school with the top A level marks in the year, yet I started it lagging behind in reading and maths. If I had been put in bottom classes with disruptive pupils, firstly it would have been too much, I would have hated school, disengaged had extremely poor mental health. It would never have allowed me to progress (I was a late developer, I didn’t read until 7). I had number blindness until around age 11.

I suspect sets are more for the benefit of the teachers than pupils (plus a sense of superiority for those in top sets).

it’s clear from your post you would probably label kids in bottom sets as likely the disruptive ones. Have you ever thought this grouping together of kids and lower expectations of them might be a self fulfilling prophecy?

All children should be elevated upwards, sets only serve to perpetuate inequality.

I came from a poor working class background, by mixing with kids with different home lives, and therefore often different attitudes to learning, behaviour, expectations and experiences it elevated me.

A child’s ability at 11 is only really a reflection of where they have come from, by perpetuating that in sets from an early age, schools are limiting where these children are going.

Sets might benefit the already advantaged, but they effectively keep the already advantaged in their position. Once a child has been in a lower set for a while it’s nearly impossible to extricate themselves from a cycle of reduced access to higher level knowledge and lower expectations. Even if, by some miracle, they do manage to climb out of the pit the educational system and life opportunities has dug for them they spend years playing catch up.

Parents are aware of this bias towards higher achieving pupils, being easier and more pleasant to teach. That’s why many spend a small fortune in tutors fees to make up for often limited education. But again this, when linked to a structure involving sets, gives certain pupils unfair advantages, less well off children with poorly educated parents don’t get this advantage.

For these, and many reasons, I think sets are an extremely bad idea. They are simply a reflection of societal structure with perhaps the odd few managing to escape.

IME children learn as much from other children as adults.

JenWillsiam · 12/05/2023 08:24

whodawhodaeho · 12/05/2023 07:50

‘that in the vast majority of secondary schools they will be used to generate GCSE targets. ‘

well that’s just not true. Thank god. What does getting a question correct on fronted adverbials have to to do with Spanish, biology, music, chemistry, ethics, DT and on and on …

And just like you’ve identified one of the know limits of the system. It tests a very small set of skills tested.

CSTeacher · 12/05/2023 08:17

OMG12 · 12/05/2023 07:16

In which case maybe streaming should not be done if it can’t be done effectively and fairly. When I went to school there were 3 sets for maths and English from GCSEs onwards. Everything else was just mixed. This seems a much better system.

I think mixed ability groups are extremely beneficial on many levels.

Actually it is much less fair to not stream. We started the year without streaming and the children were mixed and in their tutor groups. You have very low-ability, middle ability, high ability, SEND and badly behaved all together. You end up with groups that have more higher ability or more SEND or, and we did have this, two full groups of badly behaved children who played off each other.

Teachers need to be able to teach to the ability of the child and we cannot do that if they are mixed. I definitely teach differently to my top set vs my lower sets because I am adapting to them and that is the truth of it. Top set will get through a task and on to the extension in the same time it will take lower set to get through half the task.

Sets work and I have seen it have an impact on a bright, but badly behaved young man where before he was in his mixed ability tutor group and was acting out, but once the sets were made and he was placed in a top set group his behavior and attitude changed, which I said as much to his parents at parents evening.

Sets have always been a thing, just now there are a few more of them rather than the standard three. We have 5. And as it has been stated in other posts, badly behaved children tend to be those who require the lower ability groups because the groups are smaller or the SEND groups because they have more TAs.

And many parents at my school are very happy with the sets as they know that the sets are there to ensure that we are teaching the children at their level and not going too high or too low for them.

Mixed ability groups are not beneficial. We cannot teach at a mixed ability level because some children will not be challenged enough and others too challenged, and mixed ability creates cracks that SEND children fall through because we are busy dealing with badly behaved children who have no respect for their peers who want to learn.

Also sets do work on some badly behaved children because whereas before they were with their friends, now they are in sets and for some it pushes them to work harder and behave more so that they can move up sets, which a lot of parents want too.

3WildOnes · 12/05/2023 08:15

whodawhodaeho · 12/05/2023 07:50

‘that in the vast majority of secondary schools they will be used to generate GCSE targets. ‘

well that’s just not true. Thank god. What does getting a question correct on fronted adverbials have to to do with Spanish, biology, music, chemistry, ethics, DT and on and on …

But it is true! How can you have read your whole thread and still not understand this. KS2 sats are used to generate GCSE target grades in all mainstream state schools in England. Schools have no choice in this.

whodawhodaeho · 12/05/2023 07:50

‘that in the vast majority of secondary schools they will be used to generate GCSE targets. ‘

well that’s just not true. Thank god. What does getting a question correct on fronted adverbials have to to do with Spanish, biology, music, chemistry, ethics, DT and on and on …

OP posts:
OMG12 · 12/05/2023 07:16

CSTeacher · 11/05/2023 21:55

Not all badly behaved kids are in the lower sets but I tend to see the badly behaved ones are in sets 3 and 4. Now that is a mixture of ability and attitude to learning.

For our SEND and very low-ability students they do have their class, but you have badly behaved kids in there because they need the small group setting as well or they are SEND. But we can't have set for every possible outcome. We don't have the staff or resources and that is the truth. So yeah badly behaved children do end up in lower ability groups because they don't want to learn and so are not as high ability as set 1 and 2 who are behaved. And we do teach differently depending on the set.

We do our best for everyone. If you are appalled then talk to your MP about the fact schools haven't got enough money to hire proper SEND teachers or enough teachers to have more sets.

But I have noticed that the worse the behavior, the lower the group and the lower the grade. That is a fact. And behavior and manners start at home.

In which case maybe streaming should not be done if it can’t be done effectively and fairly. When I went to school there were 3 sets for maths and English from GCSEs onwards. Everything else was just mixed. This seems a much better system.

I think mixed ability groups are extremely beneficial on many levels.

Iamnotthe1 · 12/05/2023 06:33

DisquietintheRanks · 12/05/2023 06:26

@Walkaround yes heaven forfend there should be any accountability or measure of progress for a primary aged pupil. The old days when whole swathes of children could be gently failed and then quietly shovelled off to secondary was so much better. Hmm

I don't love SATS but they are an improvement on the nothing we had before.

It is worth noting that the removal of the Y9 SATs did contribute to a change to KS3 that later allowed academic research to find that Y7, Y8 and Y9 were "the Wasted Years" where very little progress was made. Whilst some schools have made moves to address that since the publication of that research, there are others in which the children typically slide backwards during the first few years due to lowered expectations, the splitting of subjects and being less of a priority for the school than they were before.

DisquietintheRanks · 12/05/2023 06:26

@Walkaround yes heaven forfend there should be any accountability or measure of progress for a primary aged pupil. The old days when whole swathes of children could be gently failed and then quietly shovelled off to secondary was so much better. Hmm

I don't love SATS but they are an improvement on the nothing we had before.

Iamnotthe1 · 12/05/2023 06:04

XelaM · 11/05/2023 23:31

It really depends on the individual private school. Private schools differ a lot

Absolutely but everyone is judged by something and they will prioritise that by which they are judged. It's necessary for the continued survival of the organisation.

For example, one of our local private primaries does enter SATs. However, they handpick the kids they enter for it based on whether they know for certain if that student will get a score in or above age-related. They take great pride in publishing an article every year about how 100% of their children "pass". They do this to try and boost the number of new applicants they have each year but what they fail to reveal is that only 6 out of the 15 in the cohort were ever entered for the test.

Walkaround · 11/05/2023 23:32

You can guarantee it was privately educated politicians who came up with the idea of testing primary school children and tracking their progress. Private schools love their entrance exams, end of year exams, 11 plus and 13 plus prep, and brochures and academic achievement boards advertising how many students they get into top public schools, or Oxbridge, or Ivy League universities every year. Few celebrate poor academic achievement.

XelaM · 11/05/2023 23:31

It really depends on the individual private school. Private schools differ a lot