Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To thinks SATs don’t really matter?

362 replies

whodawhodaeho · 09/05/2023 08:12

DD is year 6 and her class teacher( and year head) has told them that if they don’t do well in SATs then they’ll be put with the disruptive, badly behaved kids in ‘big’ school. Ie put in lower sets forever

I have told her this is nonsense - that the new school will assess her themselves up til Oct half term then stream sets for certain subjects (which they do - her DB is there ) and the SATs don’t matter.
And they continually assess and move kids around according to ability/ progress through school terms/ years

YABU - yes they matter, and yes secondary school will pay attention to the results

YANBU - they don’t really matter

OP posts:
Summerwhereareyou · 12/05/2023 22:34

Tell dd that child in bottom set is there usually because they have home issues meaning they struggle to concentrate on schoolwork... Parent has serious illness/addiction or mental health issues.
They may be extremely bright but can't concentrate after looking after siblings or parent.

They may be extremely bright but unfortunately the one trick pony school system we have means they weren't given the opportunity to read another way and they are illiterate like a massive % of our prisoners... Or they learned too late by which time they had lost lots of learning.

They didn't have a parent to help them learn to read another way.
. Or they have other mild sen our stupid clunky system can't cope with or they have more deeper sen our system can't cope with.
. Such dc have already been labeled by secondary and ate quite frankly feeling pretty awful about themselves and school and are bored out of their minds.

jenkel · 12/05/2023 22:25

When my dd done says many years ago, we went into it not thinking too much about it. Just told her to try her best but it has no bearing on anything, how wrong were we.

At secondary school when we were asking for additional help, we were told she wasn’t priority as she was reaching her predicted grades, predicted from Sats.

Be vary wary

NEmama · 12/05/2023 21:56

Oh and anyone not seeing the need for sets.
You try teaching quadratic equations to some kids and others in the same year can't do 3x4
Yes this is the reality of secondary teaching

NEmama · 12/05/2023 21:54

Sunnylassie · 12/05/2023 15:42

If sats generate GCSE targets and enable to stream children into supposed suitable sets, what happened to all the children who didn’t do them due to covid lockdowns?

The primaries estimated their scores so my now y8 Ds who is in top set has a grade 5 flight path 😔

eastegg · 12/05/2023 21:47

Suzannargh · 09/05/2023 08:35

You could say the same about GCSEs and A Levels - they don’t define you and life will work out right regardless of grades.

However it is an important assessment measure both for the children and the school and in some cases will define which set they’re put in. YABU for downplaying the importance and letting her have an 11pm bedtime unless the audition is the final stage for something life changing.

No you really couldn’t say the same about A levels. That’s ridiculous. Of course GCSEs and A levels don’t necessarily have to define you, but SATS are of minuscule importance to the child compared to them.

OP I think you’re right to have sent DD to the audition. Part of practising for tests is learning that life continues around them and you might not get ideal conditions every time you have to take one. My yr6 has carried on with evening activities this week (although admittedly he’s gone to bed before 11!).

Toomuchtrouble4me · 12/05/2023 21:30

SATs only matter up the school and don’t benefit the children sitting them at all.

Doobydoo · 12/05/2023 21:07

goodness!

Doobydoo · 12/05/2023 21:06

Agree with @Needmorelego I was in 'normal' mixed group for 1st year at secondary then in the 'remedial' class(as it was called then) for the 2nd year and then in the 3rd year the 'top' set. This was a few decades ago though. Thank goidness ds2 is home edded. What an awful thing for the teacher to say.

Boomboom22 · 12/05/2023 20:38

Countries that set least and latest eg Finland and Japan do well on pisa. Then again so do Singapore and they set very early. As a teacher I think a bit of setting or at least tabling within mixed ability is def better for higher ability. However it is best for lower ability to be stretched so setting is bad for them.

Lcb123 · 12/05/2023 20:36

They don’t matter. No exams really matter as long as you do well enough to get to the next stage.

ScruffyGrape · 12/05/2023 20:30

You are not being unreasonable. We put no pressure on our child, just said do your best, this is not gcse's you will be going to your chosen HS either way. She broke down crying twice during SATs because of the pressure the school put on them about them.

DietrichandDiMaggio · 12/05/2023 20:29

Can I add, whole class teaching is, and should be, manageable in primary schools, but by secondary the gap between higher and lower attainers just gets too wide.

Mandyjack · 12/05/2023 20:29

That's really unfair to put that much pressure on such a young child. The SATs are a measure of how well the school are performing. They are taught to pass an exam and I don't agree with them at all.
Parents that have kids that do well brag about it so parents whose kids don't get such high marks then feel like they've failed

DietrichandDiMaggio · 12/05/2023 20:26

Well here’s the pearl of wisdom, treat all kids the same. Kids aren’t “grade 1s” or “grade 9s” they are kids with potential, some of whom get things more quickly than others , some need things explaining in different ways.

Children who get things quickly shouldn't have to sit around being bored, whilst the teacher goes over things again and again, instead of moving on and being challenged. Imagine being an able mathematician in year 11 sitting in a class where the teacher is still trying to teach other children stuff that an average year 6 child can do - when exactly do you think they'd learn anything?

DietrichandDiMaggio · 12/05/2023 20:14

I can’t see why teachers can’t teach mixed ability groups, they managed it perfectly well through my school life. There was a certain amount of leading be example from the good and bright kids, class detentions meant peer pressure to behave well.

It's not the responsibility of well-behaved/bright children to educate other children and class detentions are one of the worst methods of behaviour management.

Horsetoday · 12/05/2023 20:02

My kids didn’t find the SATs exams stressful they found the pressure from the teacher stressful - it’s such a shit approach to education.

Ohgollymolly · 12/05/2023 19:58

My eldest is in year 7 at a selective Grammar School. SATS mean absolutely diddly squat there!

In fact, he was told he was behind with his maths for two years at primary school. He got 98% on his end of year 7 exam in Maths and he’ll be in top set. The 11+ is designed to determine the top 20% of the cohort anyway, so to be top set out of those children is certainly not a child who is badly behind.

Gymrabbit · 12/05/2023 19:27

CantFindMyMarbles

Please read the thread.
many secondary teachers have said that in their schools SATs do decide sets and that they don’t do CATs or if they do they aren’t used to decide sets.
Also FFT targets which most schools use have SATS as a basis so they decide GCSE targets which influence sets at GCSE as well as interventions.

It’s definitely true that SATs aren’t the be all and end all and that success or failure in them doesn’t lead to those outcomes in future exams but what you are saying is just blatant misinformation and it’s unfair to parents who may base decisions on what you are saying.

CantFindMyMarbles · 12/05/2023 19:15

101jobs · 12/05/2023 17:29

I am not a professional or an expert in such matters. I’m just a mum with an opinion!

However, my opinion is that SATS really DO matter.

Plus, I fully support sets in secondary school. Every teacher adapting the lesson for the students they have infront of them. It seems common sense to me. But I can see from many comments that I’m outnumbered.

I am a professional. Sets aren’t decided based on SATS. They are based on general teacher feedback. Children are baseline assessed within 6 weeks of starting secondary school.

they do NOT matter.

CantFindMyMarbles · 12/05/2023 19:13

Teacher here. They absolutely do not matter at all. They are entirely about the school. They do not measure a child’s academic ability in the least. They measure a child’s ability to sit an exam. There is a reason that secondary schools baseline children in the first 6 weeks - because the SATS are ineffective at measuring a child’s academic ability and learning styles.

Littleladygeorge · 12/05/2023 19:07

My DD has been doing SATs this week too. She’s been so stressed it’s unbelievable. I’ve been saying to her that they’re not the be all and end all. What will be will be. I certainly don’t agree that 10 year olds should be doing them.

lookingforchangenowww · 12/05/2023 19:00

I am with you !
SATs in my point of view is nerve wracking and soul destroying for both parents and especially the children who goes through this.
I u desertando that is a challenge and in one way prepares children for other types of challenges along their life’s, teaches discipline and dedication towards a goal but let’s be honest, who does that all benefits more rather than the schools that will be rated by their SATS levels results ? Certainly not the child.
why ? Because they will pass and move on to secondary school ANYWAY !!!!

so my answer is NO, it doesn’t matter ! And I also say that because I have a child that missed a lot from year 1 to 5 with covid in the middle and is very late and I already put in my mind that it doesn’t matter if he doesn’t do well nexts year. I won’t worry or make him feel bad for it, I won’t diminish his capability of doing better the years after because I won’t crush his dreams and self steam.
I came from a country where studies are highly paid and had exams every 3 months and if I didn’t study and pass, guess what ? I was held back to re-do the year all over again. That is what I call hard and a real worry, not the system in the UK.

I hope it helps :)
don’t worry !

Walkaround · 12/05/2023 18:15

101jobs · 12/05/2023 17:29

I am not a professional or an expert in such matters. I’m just a mum with an opinion!

However, my opinion is that SATS really DO matter.

Plus, I fully support sets in secondary school. Every teacher adapting the lesson for the students they have infront of them. It seems common sense to me. But I can see from many comments that I’m outnumbered.

I don’t think you are outnumbered. I think there are a variety of opinions on here on a variety of different issues. You have failed to say why you think SATS matter, however. What, in your opinion, is the purpose of SATS, and do you think they are solely used for that purpose?

101jobs · 12/05/2023 17:29

I am not a professional or an expert in such matters. I’m just a mum with an opinion!

However, my opinion is that SATS really DO matter.

Plus, I fully support sets in secondary school. Every teacher adapting the lesson for the students they have infront of them. It seems common sense to me. But I can see from many comments that I’m outnumbered.

Gymrabbit · 12/05/2023 17:05

OMG12

you have proved time and again on this thread that you know less than fuck all about modern education and the types of children who are taught together yet you keep bleating on telling experienced teachers how to do their jobs.
And strangely not one practical suggestion, just platitudes.
if it’s so easy and you know so much, how come you’re not a teacher? I mean with your vast experience of once attending school it’s amazing that schools aren’t all ringing you up to ask for your expertise.

Swipe left for the next trending thread