Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To thinks SATs don’t really matter?

362 replies

whodawhodaeho · 09/05/2023 08:12

DD is year 6 and her class teacher( and year head) has told them that if they don’t do well in SATs then they’ll be put with the disruptive, badly behaved kids in ‘big’ school. Ie put in lower sets forever

I have told her this is nonsense - that the new school will assess her themselves up til Oct half term then stream sets for certain subjects (which they do - her DB is there ) and the SATs don’t matter.
And they continually assess and move kids around according to ability/ progress through school terms/ years

YABU - yes they matter, and yes secondary school will pay attention to the results

YANBU - they don’t really matter

OP posts:
Windowcleaning · 13/05/2023 11:30

Yes, all children and young people experienced considerable disruption to their education and social development during the pandemic, not helped by broader social issues like underfunding of education, health, CAMHs, SALT services etc. Very varied experiences which are still being expressed through behaviour, attendance, mental health and attitude.

Generalising about 'this cohort' and making hyperbolic claims is supremely unhelpful imvho.

Iamnotthe1 · 13/05/2023 11:08

OMG12 · 13/05/2023 10:29

Exactly- we’re looking at a cohort who have had nearly half of their junior school education delivered by parents. It’s made the division so much worse. Shane on anyone who wants to perpetuate this

That's a little hyperbolic, don't you think? For this cohort, it has been:

Year 3 as normal: 7 months
Year 3 in lockdown: 2 months
Year 3 in phased return: 1.5 months (either in person or remote, depending on the school).
During the Y3 lockdown, educational delivery was suspended by the Government. Some things might have been delivered but this depended on the school.

Year 4 as normal: 8.5 months
Year 4 in lockdown: 2 months
This lockdown had lessons prepared by teachers that were either delivered remotely by teaching staff or printed and instructions followed by parents (again, depends on the school).

Year 5 as normal

Year 6 as normal

Even if the schools provided absolutely nothing and none of these children returned to school in Y3 during the phased return, the maximum time spent in lockdown learning was around 15% of their junior school education. For some, there may have been further periods off due to having Covid but those bouts would have to total an additional 13 - 15 months in order to bring it to half of their junior school education.

Yes, this cohort has felt the impact of Covid, as other cohorts have, but exaggerating the time with inaccurate statements doesn't help anyone.

IglesiasPiggl · 13/05/2023 10:56

My DS is going into Y7 in Sept and will be sitting a series of CATs next month at his new school. They use these to create balanced tutor groups, and to help with setting in January. They don't use the SATs for anything of consequence.

Monimom · 13/05/2023 10:51

On a tour of a reputable and lovely secondary school the headteacher stage whispered to the kids that they do their own tests in year seven "do your best for you and your teachers", but don’t worry about us, type thing. It was really refreshing to hear - and true. The school the kids ended up attending did exactly that, including cognitive ability tests.

OMG12 · 13/05/2023 10:29

Caramac555 · 13/05/2023 10:04

This years year 6 have significant disruption due to Covid in their school careers, they have returned to schools which have been underfunded throughout their entire time at school and where their classroom teacher has been out on strike and some TAs have left to work in supermarkets. Some kids need to be given breakfast at school.

And we give them papers harder than any before.

Shame we can't score them for resilience. I think my child won't pass, but all credit to him for staying calm and doing his best and not crying.

Exactly- we’re looking at a cohort who have had nearly half of their junior school education delivered by parents. It’s made the division so much worse. Shane on anyone who wants to perpetuate this

Caramac555 · 13/05/2023 10:04

This years year 6 have significant disruption due to Covid in their school careers, they have returned to schools which have been underfunded throughout their entire time at school and where their classroom teacher has been out on strike and some TAs have left to work in supermarkets. Some kids need to be given breakfast at school.

And we give them papers harder than any before.

Shame we can't score them for resilience. I think my child won't pass, but all credit to him for staying calm and doing his best and not crying.

Walkaround · 13/05/2023 09:31

OMG12 · 13/05/2023 06:55

Actually they were extremely effective

And, in my personal experience, caused bullying and resentment.

DietrichandDiMaggio · 13/05/2023 09:30

They created peer pressure on the naughty kids to behave. It’s really not that hard to work out.

Well obviously in your school all the 'naughty' kids were misbehaving purely through choice and stopped doing so because they wanted to keep the rest of the class happy.Hmm
As others have pointed out, when you were at school many more children would have been in special schools, so the more challenging behaviour was not in mainstream.
You know nothing about the reasons for inappropriate behaviour, behaviour management or how to teach.

Getting back to the point -the discussion was about whether SATs results are part of the information used to initially set in year 7, not what supposedly worked in your school 30-40 years ago. If you're going to argue that sets shouldn't exist, please find some more recent evidence.

Summerwhereareyou · 13/05/2023 08:37

@jenkel

Wow thank you. Your poor dd.

Horsetoday · 13/05/2023 07:34

OMG12 · 13/05/2023 06:55

Actually they were extremely effective

Thankfully they were against the primary school punishment policy - didn’t stop the teachers from attempting to implement them - but it did help with getting the teacher to stop.

Horsetoday · 13/05/2023 07:30

NEmama · 12/05/2023 21:56

Oh and anyone not seeing the need for sets.
You try teaching quadratic equations to some kids and others in the same year can't do 3x4
Yes this is the reality of secondary teaching

The reality for our dcs school is that with setting the teachers chose the level that the whole class had to sit at - kids get limits not targets.

Devonmummy80 · 13/05/2023 07:06

My dc school didn't set children in year 7, year 8 only maths.

OMG12 · 13/05/2023 06:55

Walkaround · 13/05/2023 05:59

Whole class detentions are a ludicrous idea.

Actually they were extremely effective

OMG12 · 13/05/2023 06:54

DietrichandDiMaggio · 13/05/2023 01:11

Setting by example is a great way and whole class detentions always worked as a child. Maybe if kids learned a bit more group responsibility in school it might be reflected better in society.

In what way did they work- do you really think the well behaved children were happy to be punished for something they didn't do? I'm sure as an adult you'd be happy to be disciplined for a colleague's inappropriate behaviour.

They created peer pressure on the naughty kids to behave. It’s really not that hard to work out.

WillowFae · 13/05/2023 06:08

Secondary schools tend to do CAT or MIDYIS testing in the autumn term of year 7. These then help decide the sets and targets.

my two never did SATS and they were just fine. Eldest is now at Uni having gained 3 excellent A Level results. In no way will SATS decide their future.

it is in the school’s best interest that they do well as it measures the school, not the children.

Walkaround · 13/05/2023 05:59

Whole class detentions are a ludicrous idea.

DietrichandDiMaggio · 13/05/2023 01:11

Setting by example is a great way and whole class detentions always worked as a child. Maybe if kids learned a bit more group responsibility in school it might be reflected better in society.

In what way did they work- do you really think the well behaved children were happy to be punished for something they didn't do? I'm sure as an adult you'd be happy to be disciplined for a colleague's inappropriate behaviour.

NEmama · 13/05/2023 01:09

@OMG12 said student is y11 she came to me last year from another school with undiagnosed sen. She is very weak. When I was at school she would probably have gone to a special school.

OMG12 · 13/05/2023 00:10

If a week of 40 minute papers in English and maths at age 10/11 is being used to stream kids for GCSEs aged 15/16 in a different school - the education system is massively failing many children.

OMG12 · 13/05/2023 00:07

DietrichandDiMaggio · 12/05/2023 20:14

I can’t see why teachers can’t teach mixed ability groups, they managed it perfectly well through my school life. There was a certain amount of leading be example from the good and bright kids, class detentions meant peer pressure to behave well.

It's not the responsibility of well-behaved/bright children to educate other children and class detentions are one of the worst methods of behaviour management.

Setting by example is a great way and whole class detentions always worked as a child. Maybe if kids learned a bit more group responsibility in school it might be reflected better in society.

OMG12 · 13/05/2023 00:01

jenkel · 12/05/2023 23:40

Her sat scores were low, so as she was reaching her low predicted grades they wouldn’t give her additional help, they would only help the children who were reaching lower than their predicted.

This is exactly the problem once labelled kids find it almost impossible to escape the expectations (or lack thereof) placed on them. Schools seem focused on statistics rather than ensuring kids meet their full potential. I suspect the only way round it is to hire private tutors

OMG12 · 12/05/2023 23:57

Gymrabbit · 12/05/2023 17:05

OMG12

you have proved time and again on this thread that you know less than fuck all about modern education and the types of children who are taught together yet you keep bleating on telling experienced teachers how to do their jobs.
And strangely not one practical suggestion, just platitudes.
if it’s so easy and you know so much, how come you’re not a teacher? I mean with your vast experience of once attending school it’s amazing that schools aren’t all ringing you up to ask for your expertise.

I really hope you have less of an attitude to your class, do you swear at them if they disagree with you?

How about setting work that can be approached at different levels? That’s what our teachers did. What subject do you teach. Schools have long dealt with kids of varying levels and often undiagnosed sen issues within one class. Why is it suddenly impossible?

I wouldn’t be a teacher because I couldn’t be arsed being surrounded by the extensive left wing views. I would get frustrated by the internal politics of teaching. I would be frustrated by the focus on getting kids through exams rather than education.

maybe if the government got rid of the targets, the pointless testing and paperwork it would leave teachers more time to address these issues.

OMG12 · 12/05/2023 23:42

NEmama · 12/05/2023 21:56

Oh and anyone not seeing the need for sets.
You try teaching quadratic equations to some kids and others in the same year can't do 3x4
Yes this is the reality of secondary teaching

If we are talking a 13/14 year old that can’t do 3x4 I would be seriously questioning the standard of education that child has received to date.

jenkel · 12/05/2023 23:40

Summerwhereareyou · 12/05/2023 22:36

@jenkel that's confusing what do you mean?
Her sats where low or high?

Her sat scores were low, so as she was reaching her low predicted grades they wouldn’t give her additional help, they would only help the children who were reaching lower than their predicted.

Summerwhereareyou · 12/05/2023 22:36

@jenkel that's confusing what do you mean?
Her sats where low or high?