Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To thinks SATs don’t really matter?

362 replies

whodawhodaeho · 09/05/2023 08:12

DD is year 6 and her class teacher( and year head) has told them that if they don’t do well in SATs then they’ll be put with the disruptive, badly behaved kids in ‘big’ school. Ie put in lower sets forever

I have told her this is nonsense - that the new school will assess her themselves up til Oct half term then stream sets for certain subjects (which they do - her DB is there ) and the SATs don’t matter.
And they continually assess and move kids around according to ability/ progress through school terms/ years

YABU - yes they matter, and yes secondary school will pay attention to the results

YANBU - they don’t really matter

OP posts:
Tallulasdancingshoes · 09/05/2023 09:03

My school use them to help inform setting and set GCSE targets, so they are important to some extent. But they are not the be all to end all. There is much more to life than SATs. The headteacher is wrong to worry the children in this way, they won’t gain anything from it and panicking them will only make things worse. And for the record, I teach a low ability year 7 class who are beautifully behaved. They’re a lovely class to teach, so the statement was wrong anyway.

MermaidEyes · 09/05/2023 09:02

Needmorelego · 09/05/2023 08:37

What I don't understand about sats and the whole "it can lead to predicted grades at GCSE" thing is sats are just English and Maths. How can the results children get in English and Maths have any indication of how well they will do in GCSE history/geography/textiles/drama/design/Spanish/PE/science/food tech/dance/music......
You could be an amazingly talented actor, artist, sports person or just really really obsessed with history - but not great at maths so scored low on sats.
(Sorry - not really relevant to your post @whodawhodaeho. Just me rambling...

This exactly. How a child performs at 11 is no measure of how they're going to perform in completely different subjects at 16. SATs determining GCSE grades is my bugbear. As another pp just said, it leaves kids feeling like they're forever underperforming.

3WildOnes · 09/05/2023 09:01

Needmorelego · 09/05/2023 08:37

What I don't understand about sats and the whole "it can lead to predicted grades at GCSE" thing is sats are just English and Maths. How can the results children get in English and Maths have any indication of how well they will do in GCSE history/geography/textiles/drama/design/Spanish/PE/science/food tech/dance/music......
You could be an amazingly talented actor, artist, sports person or just really really obsessed with history - but not great at maths so scored low on sats.
(Sorry - not really relevant to your post @whodawhodaeho. Just me rambling...

Well it's ridiculous but that is exactly how they do it.
Target grades for all subjects are generated from ks2 sats.

The problem with letting your daughter have a late night is that if she underperforms in her sats due to this it could have knock on effects. She might miss out on the extra interventions in year 11 as she is already meeting or exceeding her targets (which are actually too low for her) or she might be excluded from taking triple science or being entered into higher tiers. Sats likely have some bearing in sets whatever the teachers say.

However, what the teacher said to them was outrageous.

bobby81 · 09/05/2023 08:59

They really don't matter at all. I feel sorry for primary schools though, they're obviously under a lot of pressure to get results. Neither of my DC did particularly well in SATs & it hasn't made any difference at secondary school.

MermaidEyes · 09/05/2023 08:56

When my dd started secondary school the disruptive badly behaved kids were all in the top sets so that argument doesn't wash. Half of them were just too smart and bored. Personally I'm not a big fan of SATs as if they get top marks it just sets them up to feel like failures when they struggle to achieve the 8s and 9s predicted at GCSE.

whodawhodaeho · 09/05/2023 08:55

The head of year deffo said this - in fact DD didn’t tell me at first, cos she thought teacher was addressing ‘naughty’ boys not her anyway - it came via other parents and confirmed by DD.
All reports were a version of - ‘naughty kids, bottom sets’ which I assume teacher went with over saying something like ‘thick kids’

OP posts:
Gymrabbit · 09/05/2023 08:54

Needmorelego

sorry, I don’t know as I’m not involved with the setting. However, there are normally only 1 or 2 who don’t have a SATs mark and at my school we certainly don’t have children who have gone private previously.
mistakes are made though. Last year I had a girl in my bottom set who I realised the first time I marked her book was very good at my subject so I insisted she was moved up. She is actually top 10 in the whole year so no idea what happened! I’m assuming she hadn’t done SATs…..

CoozudBoyuPuak · 09/05/2023 08:53

Yanbu

Obviously it is in the Head's personal interests to make the y6s do their very best in SATs but the only thing really being tested is the quality of the school.

I think that it would be better if schools themselves were never allowed to know the individual SATs score of any given pupil. Primary schools could still be judged on the overall profile of SATs outcomes across all their pupils and comparisons made to the profile of the end-of KS1 phonics assessments might be relevant for assessing the quality of education delivered overall across KS2 but they don't need to know the individual scores of pupils who are leaving soon anyway.

Likewise the main function of y6 SATs results for senior schools should be for setting benchmarking for how much progress their students might make across KS3&KS4 but that would be better managed if the senior schools only had access to information that gave them a broad understanding of the overall cohort e.g. they have a higher than average proportion of kids who struggle with literacy etc, or the knowledge that 5% of their cohort has the potential to reach absolutely excellent results in maths with the right quality teaching, but without the capacity to label any given child as "expected" to get mostly 9s at GCSE, or "expected" to struggle.

Individual students could still have access to their scores, but with an expectation that it should be kept private and no one else has a right to know the number because it's none of their business.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 09/05/2023 08:53

A huge number of secondaries do cognitive ability tests in September, if not earlier. It's a lot more useful to see raw ability than seeing how well primary have taught to the test possibly cheated and covers all those who were absent.

whodawhodaeho · 09/05/2023 08:53

@Gymrabbit your school sounds a bit bit shit if that’s the case! And I’m not just being defensive because I know for certain that DD secondary doesn’t do this … but to put kids in a set and leave them there based on literacy and numeracy results in year 6 seems absolutely lazy to me.
Ludicrous in fact. I have no doubt DD will be somewhere in the middle/ too-ish in results and I would hope that any primary school who had a good pupil who got ‘ poor’ SATs results would note that in the report that goes across with them to the new school.

OP posts:
saltrocking · 09/05/2023 08:52

Shocking thing for the head to say!. Poor kids must be so worried. Nothing like piling pressure on a ten/eleven year old who's already going to be nervous about high school.

My dd school pushed her hard through SATS. Extra lessons after school, loads of homework. And she did amazing in them. But what happened is her next school did use them grades to place her in top sets. And my dd couldn't maintain that level of work without the extra lessons and one to one sessions she was getting in primary. This lead to her getting quite bad anxiety and she felt a failure. I insisted they dropped her right down to take some pressure off and let her work up gradually. She then did much better.

I wish they'd get rid of SATS

Piony · 09/05/2023 08:51

I agree it's a stupid thing to tell kids... hopefully she has paraphrased at least.

But at some schools Y6 is all about SATS. No one wants to be told that the thing they've been working on, almost full time, for months, is irrelevant and doesn't matter. I'd be pretty hurt if someone whose opinion I value told me the work project I'd been doing full time, for months, is irrelevant and pointless.

For some kids they are part of the story of identifying difficulties. That can be those who struggle in Y6, or those who fly through SATS and then "falling off the curve" later on. I have one child who did them and one who didn't, because of COVID, and the one who did them has been easier to secure support for.

Willmafrockfit · 09/05/2023 08:49

come on we did exams in 1977 to show what set to be in in comprehensive school.
although the teacher's comments dont sound the best

Needmorelego · 09/05/2023 08:47

@Gymrabbit what does your school do for children who don't take sats?
Where I live quite a lot of children go to private school for primary (where they don't take sats) but state for secondary. How do you decide which sets they go in?

Gymrabbit · 09/05/2023 08:47

TeenDivided

It’s not that low ability kids are disruptive but it is true that disruptive kids are likely to be in low sets since they muck about and don’t listen. Unfortunately this means that beautifully behaved low ability students in many cases don’t get the level of teaching they should as the teacher is too busy with crowd control.

BuffaloCauliflower · 09/05/2023 08:46

If the Head actually said that I’d make a formal complaint. Awful way to speak about kids who may be less academically able for whatever reason. And yes it’s silly to make such a big thing of SATS.

Gymrabbit · 09/05/2023 08:45

At the secondary school where I work the students are set before they arrive based on SATs. They do some tests here too but they don’t move sets based on them.
It may be that not many schools do this (at my last school students were set after 4 weeks based on our tests) but definitely a student who didn’t bother in their SATs would end up in a low set at my school and may find it hard to get out again.

tellmewhentheLangshiplandscoz · 09/05/2023 08:43

TeenDivided · 09/05/2023 08:33

I really hate how lower ability kids are classed as disruptive.

That said, some schools use SATs for initial setting, others don't. No good school would keep a child in the wrong set just because of SATs results.

However, Secondary schools are measured on improvement from SATs to GCSEs, and this may impact who they choose to give interventions to. Also some schools do reports based on base SATs score and do too well you'll be forever 'underachieving'. So SATs do matter.

This . So much.

DD now 14 would absolutely be classed as lower ability in most subjects, no unusual circumstances or SEN, she just unfortunately really struggles and despite my pushing throughout primary just fell through the cracks probably because she was a good kid and not disruptive.

She works so bloody hard though. Her results never reflect her efforts, it genuinely hurts my heart sometimes to see.

By comparison her incredibly clever and bright cousins (whose academic achievements are constantly shoved down our throat) can just do the minimum if they want.

Sad
Dulra · 09/05/2023 08:40

However it is an important assessment measure both for the children and the school and in some cases will define which set they’re put in.
So surely all the more important not to stress young kids out about it because they have not yet developed the skills to deal with nerves and stress so it is likely to do more harm than good. Keeping them calm, playing it down is far more likely to help. The Head needs to find a better way of dealing with disruptive kids than frightening the life out of them! We were fed this kinda of crap back in the 80s the world will end if you don't do well in whatever exam thought we moved on from this 🙄

Needmorelego · 09/05/2023 08:37

What I don't understand about sats and the whole "it can lead to predicted grades at GCSE" thing is sats are just English and Maths. How can the results children get in English and Maths have any indication of how well they will do in GCSE history/geography/textiles/drama/design/Spanish/PE/science/food tech/dance/music......
You could be an amazingly talented actor, artist, sports person or just really really obsessed with history - but not great at maths so scored low on sats.
(Sorry - not really relevant to your post @whodawhodaeho. Just me rambling...

Suzannargh · 09/05/2023 08:35

You could say the same about GCSEs and A Levels - they don’t define you and life will work out right regardless of grades.

However it is an important assessment measure both for the children and the school and in some cases will define which set they’re put in. YABU for downplaying the importance and letting her have an 11pm bedtime unless the audition is the final stage for something life changing.

whodawhodaeho · 09/05/2023 08:33

‘then they’ll be put with the disruptive, badly behaved kids in ‘big’ school
Did the head really say this? ‘

the head of hear year did - a good teacher usually but can be a bit unorthodox at times.
DD said they were doing revision and lots of kids were messing around- so I suppose it came out of frustration.

DH is flapping about the late night tonight - DD usually in bed around 9pm - but this is an unusual opp for her and even if she is a bit tired tomorrow I’m not sure it would really affect her ‘performance’ in SATs - she is where she is

OP posts:
DisquietintheRanks · 09/05/2023 08:33

Somewhere inbetween. They aren't everything and they aren't nothing either. If your child can't reach the expected standard because they haven't mastered the contents then that's obviously going to reflect in their ability to perform at secondary but yes, most secondaries will carry out some testing themselves - and later look at class performance.

Stupid thing to tell a child regardless, was it really a teacher who said that? Shame on them if so.

TeenDivided · 09/05/2023 08:33

I really hate how lower ability kids are classed as disruptive.

That said, some schools use SATs for initial setting, others don't. No good school would keep a child in the wrong set just because of SATs results.

However, Secondary schools are measured on improvement from SATs to GCSEs, and this may impact who they choose to give interventions to. Also some schools do reports based on base SATs score and do too well you'll be forever 'underachieving'. So SATs do matter.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 09/05/2023 08:31

Dulra · 09/05/2023 08:28

then they’ll be put with the disruptive, badly behaved kids in ‘big’ school
Did the head really say this? What a disgusting comment to make about children that may not be great academically, I am shocked with this comment would seriously question the Head and is also well known that referring to secondary as "big" is so outdated how old is the Head?

I honestly really doubt that's been said by the Headteacher tbh... far more likely to have come from one of the other kids.