Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To thinks SATs don’t really matter?

362 replies

whodawhodaeho · 09/05/2023 08:12

DD is year 6 and her class teacher( and year head) has told them that if they don’t do well in SATs then they’ll be put with the disruptive, badly behaved kids in ‘big’ school. Ie put in lower sets forever

I have told her this is nonsense - that the new school will assess her themselves up til Oct half term then stream sets for certain subjects (which they do - her DB is there ) and the SATs don’t matter.
And they continually assess and move kids around according to ability/ progress through school terms/ years

YABU - yes they matter, and yes secondary school will pay attention to the results

YANBU - they don’t really matter

OP posts:
Skybluepinky · 09/05/2023 09:37

Utter rubbish they get retested at secondary school.

x2boys · 09/05/2023 09:36

Mintmeanderings · 09/05/2023 09:08

Well, some kids in the bottom sets will be there because they don't care about school and don't do a tap of work and want to mess about with their friends instead. Surely? Just like some will be there because they have issues, at home or otherwise, that prevent them working to their full potential. It's not all going to be diligent, hard-working, low-ability students now is it? It'll be a mix.
Still plenty of messers in the higher-abilty sets too btw and I don't think the year head should have said what she did.

And many will just not be academic ,just because kids are less academic doesn't mean 'they have behavioural issues.

Harebrain · 09/05/2023 09:36

The disruptive, badly behaved kids are not confined to the lower sets. They’re everywhere.

Dulra · 09/05/2023 09:34

Piony fair enough but judging from the comments here streaming does seem to happen in a lot of schools posters kids are going to

SoTedious · 09/05/2023 09:33

Reading back over all the comments I can see why your education system is in disarray it really really seems to focus on assessment and streaming kids at such a young age, doesn't happen at all in Ireland.

I was thinking this too - Wales don't have SATS either.

Honestly if I were you OP I'd let her do the audition and tell her that SATS are about checking whether the school is doing a good job, not about her. They really have no bearing on how well she will do at GCSE, sounds like your secondary school is a clean slate anyway, if they do their own testing.

I really dislike the culture of piling on the exam pressure at this age, and the idea that lower sets = bad. I always told mine that setting is about grouping kids in a way that helps the teacher teach effectively, so that they can go at the right pace for everyone.

GeneralFerret · 09/05/2023 09:33

They don't really matter on an individual basis as in nobody will ever ask an adult what they got in their SATS.

However, one of the academy trusts around here use them to put the children into bands with X being the higher achievers and Y being the lower. The Y band children are barred from triple science, MFL at GCSE whatever progress/aptitude yhey show throughout KS3 and must do one non GCSE subject at KS4 (a Cambridge national or btec).

That said my son was in Y band and is all set to study biomedical sciences at university so it hasn't held him back in the long run just really effected his self esteem and none of the boys he was friends with at school with are studying A levels so he has lost that peer group as they have less in common now they all earn on their apprenticeships which is a shame as they are nice boys.

whodawhodaeho · 09/05/2023 09:31

‘She might miss out on the extra interventions in year 11 as she is already meeting or exceeding her targets ‘

Not for one second do I think that the results my 10 year old gets this week in SATs are going to matter when she’s 16.

OP posts:
Piony · 09/05/2023 09:31

Dulra · 09/05/2023 09:04

Reading back over all the comments I can see why your education system is in disarray it really really seems to focus on assessment and streaming kids at such a young age, doesn't happen at all in Ireland. Kids go into secondary schools at age 12/13 (they are in primary school for 8 years and secondary for 5 or 6). They are generally in mixed ability form classes and do get divided up into higher or ordinary level in second year but only in English, Maths and Irish, this is based on how they have done in the subject throughout the year and is often in consultation with a parent and the child particularly if they are borderline. After Junior cert (our GCSE equivalent) they choose 7 subjects for Leaving cert (A Levels) and some of them are mixed ability some again divided into higher or ordinary but it is done subject to subject. so you can be higher level in one and ordinary in another, there is also option for Leaving cert applied which is more vocation based.
Your children seem to be streamed so young and there seems to be so much exam and assessment pressure at such a young age. When have they time to develop their confidence, self esteem, self discovery?

That's really not the case. Ours are separated into 2 wide bands for maths only in Y7 and I think MFL in Y8. That's it. My 16 year old is only in setted for Maths, English and French. My understanding is that full on streaming is very rare in English schools. There's been a huge push towards mixed ability teaching for years now.

This rubbish the head is spouting about children being condemned to disruptive lower sets is nonsense. That is kind of the point of the thread.

x2boys · 09/05/2023 09:31

whodawhodaeho · 09/05/2023 08:12

DD is year 6 and her class teacher( and year head) has told them that if they don’t do well in SATs then they’ll be put with the disruptive, badly behaved kids in ‘big’ school. Ie put in lower sets forever

I have told her this is nonsense - that the new school will assess her themselves up til Oct half term then stream sets for certain subjects (which they do - her DB is there ) and the SATs don’t matter.
And they continually assess and move kids around according to ability/ progress through school terms/ years

YABU - yes they matter, and yes secondary school will pay attention to the results

YANBU - they don’t really matter

The teacher needs to think about what have said ,it's not only badly behaved disruptive kids ha are in lower sets,,not every child is academic ,my son is 16 now he starts is GCSE,s next week he's never been academic ,he's also been very ill this year and been in hospital so we are not pressuring at all regarding his exams what will be will be
he is however a very mature lovely young man and I have always been told he's an absolute credit to me so he's certainly not either disruptive or badly behaved

Wheelz46 · 09/05/2023 09:31

My eldest child's high school did base their sets on the SAT scores when they first moved up, however, they have since moved them around to different sets based on their abilities they now know they are capable of.

I disagree with the head of year's comment about children who have lower ability. Yes, we are all human but that comment is beyond cruel and extremely shameful coming from a teacher.

My youngest struggles academically but he is one of the most well behaved kids in his class so to categorise his personality based on his academics is out of order and the teacher, in my opinion, should be disciplined for making such a cruel comment!

SprinkleRainbow · 09/05/2023 09:31

Year 2 SATs are definitely a measure of the schools teaching not the students academic ability.
Year 6 is that plus giving secondary school the baseline of where they should expect each student to be. That being said in your specific case as you know the school doesn't stream sets until they've done their own assessments I really wouldn't worry about it.

And I think it's absolutely ridiculous that any school who uses SATs for setting abilities wouldn't shuffle them round if they find a child is above the set ability in general. Some kids just don't test well.

JulieHoney · 09/05/2023 09:29

SATS are bullshit. They are measuring the school, not the child.

As soon as mine arrived in high school they were assessed and streamed, SATS had no bearing on them whatsoever.

MintyIguana · 09/05/2023 09:23

MaggyNoodles · 09/05/2023 09:16

Our experience was that the secondary school my children went to kept students on the 'flight path' predicted by their SATS results.
Both my children did exceptionally well in their SATS due to the primary schools hothouse approach to SATS revision.
My children could not keep up the level they achieved at SATS and so were always reported as 'working below' throughout secondary school. Coupled with the pandemic, this had a devastating effect on both of them in terms of confidence and relationship to learning.
High school refused to deviate from the flight path apparently they (my DC) just weren't trying hard enough.

In your position, I would find out how your secondary school uses the SATS information and what they do if this is missing. I'd also find out what your primary school reports when there is no SATS info for a child. And then make your decision.
I believe it is possible to take SATS late, but you would need to work with your school to do this.

Not all schools use the flight path approach. Ours doesn't partly for the exact reasons you give here. I would definitely be against it as DD2 is very bright but not necessarily going to do great in SATs she's sitting this week. Thankfully the school she's going to does not use sats for initial form settings and does not use flight path approach. They liaise with the primary schools to discuss each student and then assess and move sets accordingly later on.

IsGoodIsDon · 09/05/2023 09:23

Maybe we have kids at the same school OP as we had the same message about the sats. I’ve downplayed it to DD.

I didn’t go to school here and find it so strange they even have sets, couldn’t believe they do it. Surely it’s better for everyone to have all mixed ability. Why should well behaving kids who struggle academically be put in lower sets that often includes the more disruptive kids?

It’s unbelievable, these kids then don’t get the chance to improve as they are marked as lower sets from the get go and also have the more difficult behaved children to top it off. I’m gobsmacked that we pigeonhole children so early on, they are only 11.

why can’t a teacher challenge the more academically minded kids in a mixed set classroom. None of the schools where I’m from, primary and secondary stream kids and apart from it benefiting a few of the higher achieving kids it doesn’t benefit the majority.

StrawberrySquash · 09/05/2023 09:19

That's a terrible message to send out. Sets are so that each child can work to their ability. Not good children and bad children, although top sets do tend to be easier to manage.

Dulra · 09/05/2023 09:16

Mintmeanderings
You have contradicted yourself in your post. What you have basically said is there are messers in all sets which is true so again highlights how wrong the Head was in her claim they are just in the lower set.

MaggyNoodles · 09/05/2023 09:16

Our experience was that the secondary school my children went to kept students on the 'flight path' predicted by their SATS results.
Both my children did exceptionally well in their SATS due to the primary schools hothouse approach to SATS revision.
My children could not keep up the level they achieved at SATS and so were always reported as 'working below' throughout secondary school. Coupled with the pandemic, this had a devastating effect on both of them in terms of confidence and relationship to learning.
High school refused to deviate from the flight path apparently they (my DC) just weren't trying hard enough.

In your position, I would find out how your secondary school uses the SATS information and what they do if this is missing. I'd also find out what your primary school reports when there is no SATS info for a child. And then make your decision.
I believe it is possible to take SATS late, but you would need to work with your school to do this.

elliejjtiny · 09/05/2023 09:16

I would be furious it a teacher said that to one of my dc. My dc4 is in the bottom set as he has MLD. He's not disruptive and he's not naughty (although the ones who are disruptive often have undiagnosed or diagnosed but not supported SEN). There are many children in the bottom sets who are perfectly lovely people but just struggle with anything academic.

whodawhodaeho · 09/05/2023 09:13

Thing is, I could probably tell you right now what GCSEs DD will choose and how she’ll do in them, and this opp which will mean a late night ahead of testing the next day could be life changing.
or at the very least inspire DD in ways that school just can’t.

OP posts:
whodawhodaeho · 09/05/2023 09:11

‘However, what the teacher said to them was outrageous.’

Other parents complained to teacher/ head but honestly, I think the teacher is a very good teacher and everyone’s human…

OP posts:
QuintanaRoo · 09/05/2023 09:11

Dulra · 09/05/2023 08:28

then they’ll be put with the disruptive, badly behaved kids in ‘big’ school
Did the head really say this? What a disgusting comment to make about children that may not be great academically, I am shocked with this comment would seriously question the Head and is also well known that referring to secondary as "big" is so outdated how old is the Head?

This.

and what a way to scare all the year sixes about the transition. I’d be complaining.

Mintmeanderings · 09/05/2023 09:08

Needmorelego · 09/05/2023 08:27

If the teacher really said that then I would put in a formal complaint.
Children in the bottom sets aren't there because they are "badly behaved".
Revolting thing to say about children.
Teachers who say things like that shouldn't be anywhere near children.

Well, some kids in the bottom sets will be there because they don't care about school and don't do a tap of work and want to mess about with their friends instead. Surely? Just like some will be there because they have issues, at home or otherwise, that prevent them working to their full potential. It's not all going to be diligent, hard-working, low-ability students now is it? It'll be a mix.
Still plenty of messers in the higher-abilty sets too btw and I don't think the year head should have said what she did.

VenusClapTrap · 09/05/2023 09:06

SATS are such bollocks. Ds has become so bored this year with endless practice papers. It’s all they’ve done. It really annoys me that so much focus is put on this when they could be learning new, interesting things that would motivate them so much more.

MintyIguana · 09/05/2023 09:05

Eldest daughter didn't do SATs due to Covid. She also didn't do nearly as well as her peers in the cognitive abilities test that they took at the beginning of y7. However her school test and reset regularly and she's now top set for everything with marks way beyond her CAT score band average. So neither of those tests have really impacted her. If anything it's given her confidence that if she works hard she does well.

Dulra · 09/05/2023 09:04

Reading back over all the comments I can see why your education system is in disarray it really really seems to focus on assessment and streaming kids at such a young age, doesn't happen at all in Ireland. Kids go into secondary schools at age 12/13 (they are in primary school for 8 years and secondary for 5 or 6). They are generally in mixed ability form classes and do get divided up into higher or ordinary level in second year but only in English, Maths and Irish, this is based on how they have done in the subject throughout the year and is often in consultation with a parent and the child particularly if they are borderline. After Junior cert (our GCSE equivalent) they choose 7 subjects for Leaving cert (A Levels) and some of them are mixed ability some again divided into higher or ordinary but it is done subject to subject. so you can be higher level in one and ordinary in another, there is also option for Leaving cert applied which is more vocation based.
Your children seem to be streamed so young and there seems to be so much exam and assessment pressure at such a young age. When have they time to develop their confidence, self esteem, self discovery?

Swipe left for the next trending thread