Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To thinks SATs don’t really matter?

362 replies

whodawhodaeho · 09/05/2023 08:12

DD is year 6 and her class teacher( and year head) has told them that if they don’t do well in SATs then they’ll be put with the disruptive, badly behaved kids in ‘big’ school. Ie put in lower sets forever

I have told her this is nonsense - that the new school will assess her themselves up til Oct half term then stream sets for certain subjects (which they do - her DB is there ) and the SATs don’t matter.
And they continually assess and move kids around according to ability/ progress through school terms/ years

YABU - yes they matter, and yes secondary school will pay attention to the results

YANBU - they don’t really matter

OP posts:
IsItHalfTermYetHelp · 10/05/2023 19:26

My children’s sats results were on every termly report from year 7 to year 11 and they plus the cat results gave their sets and gcse grade predictions so yes they do matter and are used by secondaries!

Gymrabbit · 10/05/2023 17:37

Wheelz46

It’s not that we judge all lower set students as disruptive it’s that from years of experience we know that in a lower set a far higher percentage of students will be so.
In top sets you are likely to get a maximum of 3-5 difficult students, in bottom sets around 10, sometimes more.
sometimes students are disruptive because they cannot access the work at all and those students will almost always be in bottom sets.
most teachers feel very sorry for the weak academically but beautifully behaved children who are stuck with feral kids who are not interested in learning at all.

YouWonJayne · 10/05/2023 16:55

My kids school don’t do them. I’m sure they will still somehow get an education.

The focus on exams is so unhealthy and damaging I really think our system needs to adopt the USA style of education where you have a grade point average which reflects work done over the year, and there’s opportunities for extra credit to improve it.

Learningalongtheway · 10/05/2023 16:54

My son is in year 7 now. He was put in bottom set for English because he didn't do well on his English sat paper. All of their classes have been based on the SAT results. Which is such a shame.
They are this week taking exams to be used to change classes depending on results so they've done well over 6 months first. And yes he is with a lot of unruly children so I'm hoping he will get moved up this time

Windowcleaning · 10/05/2023 16:08

@JussathoB thanks. I have nothing but sympathy for the teachers who have to work within these rigid, top-down frameworks. I think the problem is less the Progress 8 framework per se than there is no flexibility built in.

Wheelz46 · 10/05/2023 14:38

@Boomboom22 I don't have any personal experience in schools regarding behaviour and sets, only what my eldest has mentioned to me. My eldest is in the top sets and has told me a number of stories regarding the disruptive ones. If someone is naturally disruptive, I wouldn't have thought it mattered how academic you are.

My youngest, when he attends high school is likely to be in the lower sets as he struggles academically and has always worked towards expectations. I do worry about him being categorised as a disruptive child, he is far from this, obviously the teachers will soon realise this when they come to teach him but it does have me questioning whether teachers judge the lower set children before they have even met them.

Boomboom22 · 10/05/2023 14:18

OK but being realistic, as a teacher, there are more disruptive kids in lower sets but it's actually compounded by the fact that top set kids can cope with it and catch up themselves if required, bottom sets need teacher attention to be on teaching not behaviour management as they will not be able to understand it by themselves or with lots of noise around.
So labelling either by sats result, class/ses and speech codes, ethnicity etc shouldn't be relevant but it is. Also teachers don't know your kids that well, especially at the start of yr7 and the rest of ks3 as lessons might be shared on infrequent so it might be a little while before anyone twigs your child is in the wrong set, if they even allow movement between sets. And your kid might perform to the level they think they are expected to and just assume secondary is easier, so not achieve to their ability. So yr6 matter even though they shouldn't. Plus process 8 is the key performance measure for schools.

Wheelz46 · 10/05/2023 10:58

@srin This is part of the problem, assuming someone who is in bottom set is likely to be disruptive, so far from the truth from experience with my own children. Many children who meas around can still do well academically.

My eldest is extremely academic and in top sets for all his subjects and from what he has told me there is more than a handful of kids that sound like they run rings around the teacher.

My youngest is not academic at all and is likely to not get a grade on one of his SAT assessments when his time comes. Without being bias, he probably is the most well behaved kid in his classroom. It saddens me that people judge someones personality based on the set they are in.

Always told mine, as long as they work to the best of their ability, then I am one proud mum, irrelevant of the results!

Conkersinautumn · 10/05/2023 08:19

They are meaningless. Because of the hot housing that goes on most secondary schools carry out their own testing after the summer and they've got a few years before exam sets to find their actual abilities. They do set the percentages for gcse grades from the cohorts SATs AND in the shit secondary schools students are marked against their 'expected' from their SATs. Decent secondary schools obviously this isn't a problem.

whodawhodaeho · 10/05/2023 08:13

Had a chat with a deputy head teacher friend ( in our local authority) who told me to go, the SATs are fairly pointless as far as she's concerned for kids, but important to school. She also seconded that the next school for DD put very little store by them and does their own assessments .

So we went! Don't think DD will get the part, I think she's a bit young, but it was a amazing experience and she's met some people who have inspired her, and who could influence a lot for her when a bit older if she still goes down this route.
DD went to bed about an 1.5 hrs later than normal and has just got up ( we live very close to school) and seems fine!

Thanks for the input and good luck for all your kids in these stupid tests!

OP posts:
Vitriolinsanity · 09/05/2023 23:33

Here's my take.

When parents of 4 year olds are picking schools they look at Ofsted reports, SAT results and whether the uniform makes their child look cute.

By Y6, they send the kids in leggings and trainers, don't bother with PE kit, argue the arse out of the importance of SATs vs life changing opportunities the night before.

What does it matter if we agree or disagree SATs are important, you've decided for your child and if she zeds out in tomorrow's test you've decided that's less important than her big opportunity.

Beesandhoney123 · 09/05/2023 23:15

Bonkers comment. Expect its not the first one from the head, so presume your dc don't believe every word he/ she says.

just say do your best and it will be fine. In secondary, teachers sort it all out anyway. Just don't spend summer grilling dc on maths etc! If they aren't great at a subject, it's better to be in a group that goes slower, time to learn. It doesn't mean they will be tagged as useless forever at school. They do the same exams in the end.

JussathoB · 09/05/2023 23:10

@Windowcleaning im so sorry to read your post ( secondary school teacher for nearly 20 years). This fills me with despair. The way these statistics and targets, developed from sats, are used is an absolute farce at times. Well done to you and your DD for coping so well with these frustrations, I can only hope you are able to continue so that DD gets the education and training she wants eventually.
Unfortunately teachers can do nothing about these systems, they are required to use them. For some children and parents the targets etc can be a guide to how children should/could progress so they meet a certain need but the it’s stupid that so much of the education system is based on them.

Boomboom22 · 09/05/2023 23:00

They matter because the gov use them to measure the specific path a child who achieved that should take for progress 8 headline score at gcse. Therefore when schools are trying to improve results they may use target grades to set interventions etc.
So a yr6 achieving very well who actually is not greater depth might be pushed harder and a yr6 who is very bright but terrible at tests is expected a 5 and not pushed at all.
It's not good practice but it is how schools are judged.
It is perhaps a fairer measure than % 5 good gcses as it accounts for low scorers who achieve a 3 or 4 which is actually quite a good result for them.

Yazo · 09/05/2023 22:56

They don't matter, seriously this culture of exam stress is so damaging. People have been doing exams forever and very well at them actually, the recent thing of kids sick with anxiety is terrible and starts with this nonsense in Y6. Personally I went to a shocking primary and was in the bottom set for a few things for a while, I had wonderful teachers and moved up quickly, such is life. We need to normalise these things (if they happen) it's really not the end of the world anyway. Working hard is important and good grades to a certain extent, but I don't think this type of pressure gets anyone anywhere.

Srin · 09/05/2023 22:51

Bottom sets do have more than their fair share of badly behaved kids. Where do people think the kids who mess around and do no work end up? The teacher shouldn’t have said it, but the children will find out for themselves next term.

PintoMilk · 09/05/2023 22:38

Yabu. Of course they matter. Why sugar coat and wrap kids in cotton wool? They need at least some pressure to achieve. Personal pride if nothing else.

Windowcleaning · 09/05/2023 22:25

I would love to say that SATs don't matter in secondary school, but my experience is that unfortunately they do.

My dd didn't get her SATs results (whole year group annulled, not the children's fault) and it's been a complete PITA for the whole of secondary school. Yes, they set according to CAT tests, but my dd's targets were based on her getting the lowest possible SAT score so basically failing. Despite my asking several times that her targets be adjusted, they weren't, so dd went through KS3 with every teacher expecting very little of her. Despite her doing well and knowing that the low expectations were because of her non-existent SATs results, this really affected her confidence and self-esteem.

At the beginning of Y10, the school looked at the data, decided which students needed to 'show progress' and moved my dd to lower sets. She was doing work that she'd done in primary school. They wouldn't move her up, basically because it made no difference to their data how she did.

I moved her to another school (not just because of this although actually learning something is what children go to school for) and she was put in low sets as the data from her previous school showed her targets to be very low. She quickly worked her way up, but missed out on vital parts of the curriculum with set-hopping. We're lucky enough to have been able to afford some tutoring in subjects where she missed enormous chunks, and she's pretty much caught up now.

The lack of SATs results meant that her predicted GCSE grades were lower than she scored in her mocks (computer algorithm put a ceiling on what she could be predicted). Although these were adjusted, it wasn't in time for her to miss out on a sixth form offer that she wanted.

I cannot wait for her to finish KS4 and never have to think about bloody SATs again.

Her younger sister didn't do SATs (one of the covid years). Schools seem to have coped with whole year groups with just teacher assessment from primary school, and it's a crying shame that they couldn't have abolished the SATs altogether.

Skyblue92 · 09/05/2023 22:04

As a teacher YANBU they are pointless. As you’ve said when DD starts year 7, she will be given baseline assessments, have CAT testing all in the first half term, sometimes the first month and they are used to set/re set classes

DietrichandDiMaggio · 09/05/2023 21:57

DS11 is completely fed up with his SATs preparations, and has found year 6 really boring, when it should be the fun final year of primary school. I've told him that back in the olden days my last year of primary was spent doing a bit of work in the morning then rounders on an afternoon. It was such a fun year, and it's really sad that today's Y6s are so bogged down with tests instead.

Presumably that was pre National Curriculum? Even if they didn't sit SATs, there's still lots to cover in the year 6 curriculum.

Labraradabrador · 09/05/2023 19:32

‘Exams measure what they need to measure’ - do they thought? I would argue that they measure what they can, often a poor approximation of the actual skill set we are aiming to develop.

x2boys · 09/05/2023 14:37

Back in the day I sat something called Richmond tests in junior 4 as it was then and apparently they were used to.stream us in high school🤔
I remember having to.do them again in he first year of high school.,I started high school,in 1985 so it was a long time ago.

whodawhodaeho · 09/05/2023 14:20

'All the people saying they only reflect what the school is doing, that’s not true is it? Many secondary schools use them for setting in year 7…. At least initially or for the first year or two..'

well, clearly it depends on the school, but DD's doesn't. They have mixed ability until the end of October then have assessments, and that continues in any subject that setting is used in.

And any school that take the results of such limited tests at aged 10/11 and uses them to judge the ability of a child for one or to years, really isn't that good a school.
Particularly as the gap between summer born kids and autumn born can be hug in primary but very quickly closes in secondary.

OP posts:
Phos · 09/05/2023 14:20

I think it depends on the secondary as to how the grades are used. I remember our first maths and English lessons in year 7, the teacher went down the register and read our what we all got.

I dont really like this idea of teaching kids they mean nothing and all this “they don’t measure how wonderful you are as a person” Exams measure what they need to measure.

BHRK · 09/05/2023 14:13

All the people saying they only reflect what the school is doing, that’s not true is it? Many secondary schools use them for setting in year 7…. At least initially or for the first year or two.

Swipe left for the next trending thread