Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To thinks SATs don’t really matter?

362 replies

whodawhodaeho · 09/05/2023 08:12

DD is year 6 and her class teacher( and year head) has told them that if they don’t do well in SATs then they’ll be put with the disruptive, badly behaved kids in ‘big’ school. Ie put in lower sets forever

I have told her this is nonsense - that the new school will assess her themselves up til Oct half term then stream sets for certain subjects (which they do - her DB is there ) and the SATs don’t matter.
And they continually assess and move kids around according to ability/ progress through school terms/ years

YABU - yes they matter, and yes secondary school will pay attention to the results

YANBU - they don’t really matter

OP posts:
MamaBear4ever · 11/05/2023 07:37

They are used as a predictor of GCSE grades. Worked in my daughters favour as her reports are all exceeding expected target which gives her a boost. It's all nonsense and they are moved about sets depending on progress

Dibbydoos · 11/05/2023 07:24

Like most things in life they're a measure at the moment and count only at that time. But they do count.

Saying they're disruptive classes etc in senior school is sadly true - some kids shouldn't educated the same as others because they're not academic.I let's hope the school has things in place. I used to be jealous of those kids in my school because they went to work places to gain experience, had people from business come talk to them and did classes about skills (1980's has been classed outstanding school since metrics came in), whilst we were grinding away for Os and As. Admittedly, most of the 6th form went to uni but some practical experience of tge world of business would have helped.

Justalittlebitduckling · 11/05/2023 07:21

they’ll be put with the disruptive, badly behaved kids in ‘big’ school

What a horrible thing for the teacher to say. I’ve taught some absolutely lovely bottom/lower sets and some “disruptive, badly behaved” kids who were incredibly bright and in higher sets. And what about the children who are doing their best but simply aren’t going to achieve highly; how is this going to make them feel?

It’s possible the school would organise sets based on SATS results in year 7 but they would quickly move a child who was clearly in the wrong set.

Copasetic · 11/05/2023 07:20

Their SAT results do stay with them all their school live. My son is year 7 (with two older sisters who as they have big age gaps all did different versions of SATS) and his grade predictions are all generated from his year 6 SATS. Whilst they are tested regularly and movement is made I think it is harder to move sets than to have been put in them initially - though this is only a gut feeling. I think the head is very wrong but it’s hard to exactly say they don’t matter when they follow you through school. My middle child revised for her SATS, did lots of past papers and got put in to the level 6 papers (in the days when 4b was the grade they were striving for) and consequently unnaturally inflated her grade meaning that she went though school with all 8/9 predictions which sometimes were hard to meet, so they do affect your future grade predictions that appear on reports with a comparison to where you are now.

Teateaandmoretea · 11/05/2023 07:19

H12345 · 11/05/2023 07:17

My daughter is currently in secondary school and unfortunately all classes via the top set are very disruptive with standard to poor results, top sets do amazingly well and are full so you’ve got to work hard to keep your space.

Her teacher might have been telling her the truth for your area after having kids at secondary or hearing stories about it…. It’s that simple.

So SATS are very important they will put your child with children of similar abilities even if it’s reassessed. In the first few months all the kids make new friends so getting good results from SATS will without a doubt put them in a better position starting secondary school.

The school is dreadful if that’s really the case.

Teateaandmoretea · 11/05/2023 07:18

whodawhodaeho · 11/05/2023 07:12

‘I'm afraid SATs results stay with them as they use them to predict GCSE results ‘

That absolutely staggers me given the change in circumstances for many kids between the age of 10/11 and 14+ -
what if their primary wasn’t very good? Or they had disruption with teachers changing that year? Or they were ill a lot? Or their family circumstances were disruptive - ill parent/s, divorcing parents, had to go live with grandma? Had to change school?
Or parents decided to tutor for the SATs?

I give these examples as they’re all real world examples of friends and acquaintances

Well it’s one of the ways the government measures how well schools do. At whole cohort level there is probably some relationship. At individual level it is totally meaningless however.

The primary curriculum is narrow, highly predictive and dull. Compliant linguistic types tend to overachieve but a lot of other kids find it boring and restrictive.

I think a lot of people are trying to put whole school measured into individuals. Probably some not very good schools do that too. They definitely do move kids up and down sets at the school dd2 is going to - baffled by the person who said that never happens!

H12345 · 11/05/2023 07:17

My daughter is currently in secondary school and unfortunately all classes via the top set are very disruptive with standard to poor results, top sets do amazingly well and are full so you’ve got to work hard to keep your space.

Her teacher might have been telling her the truth for your area after having kids at secondary or hearing stories about it…. It’s that simple.

So SATS are very important they will put your child with children of similar abilities even if it’s reassessed. In the first few months all the kids make new friends so getting good results from SATS will without a doubt put them in a better position starting secondary school.

whodawhodaeho · 11/05/2023 07:17

‘and letting her have an 11pm bedtime unless the audition is the final stage for something life changing.’

possibly. Certainly inspirational.

OP posts:
whodawhodaeho · 11/05/2023 07:14

Again, I know DD secondary isn’t overly interested in SATs. It’s mixed ability classes for everything til at least the end of October half term and then flexible after that.
Her DS has been there 2 years and has been moved up 3 x in subjects

OP posts:
Ugzbugz · 11/05/2023 07:12

Suzannargh · 09/05/2023 08:35

You could say the same about GCSEs and A Levels - they don’t define you and life will work out right regardless of grades.

However it is an important assessment measure both for the children and the school and in some cases will define which set they’re put in. YABU for downplaying the importance and letting her have an 11pm bedtime unless the audition is the final stage for something life changing.

No other isn't.

No-one in history has asked for someone's year 6 SAT results for a job in adult hood.

Its mainly for the school as another poster said.

Those that didn't take them in lockdown haven't been affected.

whodawhodaeho · 11/05/2023 07:12

‘I'm afraid SATs results stay with them as they use them to predict GCSE results ‘

That absolutely staggers me given the change in circumstances for many kids between the age of 10/11 and 14+ -
what if their primary wasn’t very good? Or they had disruption with teachers changing that year? Or they were ill a lot? Or their family circumstances were disruptive - ill parent/s, divorcing parents, had to go live with grandma? Had to change school?
Or parents decided to tutor for the SATs?

I give these examples as they’re all real world examples of friends and acquaintances

OP posts:
Tumbleweed101 · 11/05/2023 07:01

My daughter didn't do them due to being in year 6 through lockdown and then a messed up start into y7. She has done fine and the school has put her into the expected groups based on her ability without a problem. The results of SATS did follow my older daughter through school as a marker for progress but jumped levels when she proved she was good at subjects.

Melomelop · 11/05/2023 07:01

I’m so glad you took her to the audition! My DD is unsure whether to go to an open audition on Saturday. She’s naturally quite shy but loves to sing and dance and I think it would be a great experience for her even though I don’t think she’d get a part. I’m not pushing her though, leaving it completely up to her whether she wants to do it or not. I just think she’d love the audition process and it would help her confidence. Good luck for the rest of your DD SATs week - if she works hard, it doesn’t matter what she gets ❤️

Caramac555 · 11/05/2023 06:47

Perhaps in a couple of years time when the current year 9 do their GCSEs, without the schools having any SAT results for that year group, there'll be some statistically backed argument that SATs have no great benefit.

Melomelop · 11/05/2023 06:46

I’m a maths teacher at a secondary school. At my school we don’t set the kids until Oct half term as we know SATs aren’t truly representative of the pupils ability (biggest problem we have is pupils getting tutors and doing exceptionally well in SATs but then really struggling at secondary as they don’t have the natural ability as others).

The biggest impact they have is on target grades. I would rather a pupil just does the best they can do and gets a realistic target grade to work towards. One that is too high (usually those coached and pushed through SATs) means that the pupils often feel rubbish as it looks like they are constantly underperforming. One that is too low, we get complaints from parents that we're not setting the bar high enough (we can’t change the target grades!). I’d say just let the kids be and do their best.

Also, academics aren’t everything and I’d definitely take my kid to an audition if they wanted to go! It’s important to also do things that bring the kids joy (as well as a challenge) which is what auditions will do. I doubt it will have much of an impact on the result anyway!

This is just my thoughts though, and not all schools are the same of course.

YukoandHiro · 11/05/2023 06:34

Depends on the secondary school. Staggeringly some use them in GCSE prediction.

Caramac555 · 11/05/2023 06:32

My SEN kid is struggling through SATS this week.

I've told him they can't be that important because his sister is doing well and she never even got to sit them due to Covid.

My experience of our ofsted outstanding rated secondary school is that they are constantly assessing the kids and reshuffling classes. They all had to do CAT tests in year 7. They're trying to squeeze every last drop of potential out of the cohort, not leaving then to languish based on one set of SAT'S results and in house marked assessments from primary schools (and they're not always overly trusting of some primary schools assessment capabilities).

Mainlinethehappy · 11/05/2023 06:17

isitalloveryet · 11/05/2023 00:13

I'm afraid SATs results stay with them as they use them to predict GCSE results - yes they use them to set them in maths/English in year 7 and they do retest them and they may move sets based on results.

I know schools where the SATS results are used as an indicator of what the student could go on to achieve, and targets are set as a result of that, but the predicted grades come much later, from the teachers who by then know the student well. It’s not unusual for students to have royally messed up the SATS, have low target grades as a result, but then high predicted grades once the GCSE teachers realise their potential. The reverse is also very true - some students ace the SATS but then plateau and are saddled with high GCSE indicator grades which they will never meet - and so go on to constantly feel they are underachieving. I have DC who have been both these examples - it hasn’t affected their happiness, but it was a struggle getting the able-but-not-good-in-SATS one recognised - he had to “prove” himself a lot.

Imisssleep2 · 11/05/2023 06:14

Obviously children should try their best with their SATs (some schools near me used to not sure if still do have entry requirements) but the teacher should not be trying to scaremonger them. The secondary school will assess each pupil for themselves. When i was at school we spent the first year with all lessons apart from (textiles, cookery and woodwork) in our forms with a completely random mix of abilities, we took exams/assesments at the wnd of the year and that along with the teacher assessment determined what tier we went into for the 2nd and 3rd year before more SATs and like you say if someone is in the wrong group, ie improved or struggling they would move around as needed so each pupil is learning at the level and speed most suitable for them. At my school if you were in top tier it would mean you would get entered into the higher level exam papers, if in middle it would depend on the pupil if higher or foundation based on teacher views and pupil wants, then lower set would be entered at foundation level to help everyone get the best grades possible.

TheNefariousOrange · 11/05/2023 05:22

So at my school they are set based on SATs and whilst there is an element of fluidity, you can only move up if someone else moves down, which is rare so some kids to miss put until they are properly re-set for GCSE classes, but which point it's too late for the bottom set.

We also base out gifted and talented programme on SATs scores. There are a couple of subjects that start in year 8 that are only available to those that get and average score of 110 in their SATs.

They are also used to form predicted grades for GCSE.

chloe11b · 11/05/2023 01:51

Because they don't really. The exams that do matter are the actual GCSE's and a levels

Kittycat37uk · 11/05/2023 01:43

All exams are there for is to turn everyone into clones. They really should be teaching kids proper life skills such as cooking cleaning and budgeting money. I don't believe in any exams that makes everyone answer the same questions that at the end of the day don't even matter.

Elfer13 · 11/05/2023 00:47

Absolute waste of time at 10 years years old with some home tuition by me my dd was arguing with a teacher about probability and dx by dy squared. Teacher didn't have a clue what she was on about and said you'll be in the lower set at senior school. Lol, but the teacher could sing "the wheels on the bus really well"

BoldandBright · 11/05/2023 00:28

SATs are only done for the government’s/league tables benefit. They have no purpose for the children and should be scrapped imo. Yanbu.

isitalloveryet · 11/05/2023 00:13

I'm afraid SATs results stay with them as they use them to predict GCSE results - yes they use them to set them in maths/English in year 7 and they do retest them and they may move sets based on results.

Swipe left for the next trending thread