Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

BIL requesting to stay in my bedroom

191 replies

Revnol · 09/05/2023 06:23

I'm 28 and currently living with my parents, not uncommon for people from my (Mediterranean) culture. It works okay for us, but one of the biggest benefits is that this setup enables my siblings and I to care for my mother who has had very serious health problems for most of my life.

Recently, we've had to move into a short term rental as our family home is in need of some fairly significant renovations.

We've found a comfortable home in a popular town in Devon. Two weeks into the stay my sister asked if she and her fiance could have my room for the week when they visit (annual leave).

I have been a people please for most of my life but I am starting to realise I need to stand up for myself where appropriate. So I said sorry but no. Not only would the logistics of changing rooms be annoying but this is very much my space/sanctuary. As you can imagine living with family can be claustrophobic so I very often retreat to my room when necessary.

It has got back to me my sister's fiance is annoyed. The room they will be in has a double bed but is not able to accommodate much else. But it is nicely decorated and clean. Whereas the room I'm in is much larger.

AIBU to say no? BIL's attitude/sense of entitlement had really rubbed me up the wrong way. BIL, who im beginning to see has a selfish streak, has a very strained relationship with his family and would NEVER ask this from his own bio sister. So, why me?

I was "given" the bigger room as my sister is often away for work and I'm not. I.e silly to have the big room sitting empty part of the time

AIBU?

OP posts:
Coffeetree · 09/05/2023 11:21

Revnol · 09/05/2023 10:18

Why is she passing on these comments?

So my brother and I did ask ourselves this very question as she's only making them both look terrible.

My sis shared a screenshot of the msg chain after she told BIL rooms were not swapping. I can only assume she didn't think the request was an overly entitled one. No clue.

So call her out on that. "Sis, I'm deleting that screenshot as it appears to be of a private conversation". We're not changing g the room arrangements. Looking forward to seeing you.

Twobyfour · 09/05/2023 11:13

This thread is similar to the step son who wanted his step brother turfed out of his loft room with ensuite, when he stayed an extra weekend per month.

In both cases the “guest’s” expectations are too high!

Merangutan · 09/05/2023 11:12

What a CF he is! He doesn’t get to request rooms like he’s booking a hotel. He belongs in the guest room and should be grateful he’s being offered a private room with a large bed and not sleeping on an inflatable bed in the living room. Or the garden shed, where he actually belongs. It’s unbelievably entitled of him to expect you to be willing to turf yourself out of your own bedroom because he wants it. It’s not a spare room - it’s an occupied one! Stand your ground, OP!

dentydown · 09/05/2023 10:59

Travelodge do lovely spacious rooms… if they don’t want to stay in the guest room for free, perhaps they need to pay for a hotel.

caringcarer · 09/05/2023 10:56

Stick to your guns. You are the daughter and your needs come before your sister's fiancé.

MeridianB · 09/05/2023 10:54

Also, when CF sis first brought up the idea (in person, BIL not present) I did list of a bunch of reasons kmmediately why it wasnt a good idea. One being I'm emotional right now due to a break up and need my space. She said "yhat's what I told!"/"I told him that!" SEVERAL times.

Same as the screenshots, I'd ask her to explain/justify why she is raising this and why she thinks it's acceptable to even ask. Make her think.

CabernetSauvignon · 09/05/2023 10:51

Revnol · 09/05/2023 10:30

So in their defense it is a single room with a double room shoved in. Just enough space either side.

It's just a room to sleep in for them, surely that's enough space.

I cannot imagine going to stay with my in-laws and announcing that the spare room wasn't good enough for me so one of the family must give up their room. It's just bizarre.

Revnol · 09/05/2023 10:49

Also, not that it makes a difference but HE is the one choosing to place himself in this situation. My parents have not specifically invited him (there is an open invitation policy).

Also, when CF sis first brought up the idea (in person, BIL not present) I did list of a bunch of reasons kmmediately why it wasnt a good idea. One being I'm emotional right now due to a break up and need my space. She said "yhat's what I told!"/"I told him that!" SEVERAL times. Which just makes me speculate re the kind of conversation there was where my CF sis expressed why I wouldnt go for it. Suggests he was pushing for it imo.

OP posts:
MeridianB · 09/05/2023 10:49

Revnol · 09/05/2023 10:18

Why is she passing on these comments?

So my brother and I did ask ourselves this very question as she's only making them both look terrible.

My sis shared a screenshot of the msg chain after she told BIL rooms were not swapping. I can only assume she didn't think the request was an overly entitled one. No clue.

Next time she does this I'd just respond with 'Why are you sending me this?' Make her really think about what she's doing and why and how it looks. Because it's not normal to do this.

His estrangement from his whole family suggests he has form for tantrums when he doesn't get his own way. Don't let him intimitdate or make you question yourself!

martinisforeveryone · 09/05/2023 10:48

If it’s a room with space around a double bed it’s not a single room. I agree with @Whatevergetsyouthroughthenight

I disagree with
’But I can see that if everyone (including CF sister) contributes equally to the family budget, and it is a house you are ‘staying in’, rather like an extended holiday let, rather than ‘living in’, there could be more of an expectation that people move rooms to suit different circumstances. E.g smaller room because CF Sis is away half the time v bigger room when there are 2 of them.’

While you’re living there it’s your base, your home and your full time bedsitting room trumps their short visit.

@Revnol you say your sister is a plain speaker, nothing wrong with that. I suggest you take the same approach.

Do not be forced to give in to their wishes, not by them, or your parents. If it’s mentioned again just scoff and say it’s terribly entitled of him to want to turf me out when there’s sis’s permanent room sitting there all the time, why would anyone think like that?

Katherine1985 · 09/05/2023 10:47

Different

Katherine1985 · 09/05/2023 10:47

Hbh17 · 09/05/2023 10:36

We have always given up our room when we have guests, because it's the nicest one in the house. I don't understand why someone wouldn't prioritise their guest's comfort, tbh.

@Hbh17 in an update OP said they were offered her parents’ large room which wouldn’t have inconvenienced them as they only sleep there, but fiancé wouldn’t hear of it.

We’ve offered our room sometimes. Hosts in Italy have always given us their own room which I didn’t want to accept but was told it was a mark of hospitality to give the ‘best room’. Definitely didn’t cultural norms

OrderOfTheKookaburra · 09/05/2023 10:47

Hbh17 · 09/05/2023 10:36

We have always given up our room when we have guests, because it's the nicest one in the house. I don't understand why someone wouldn't prioritise their guest's comfort, tbh.

Because my guests are not my PRIORITY. My own family is. Would I pay for accommodation somewhere for myself? Yes. Would I pay for someone else? No. Why should that suddenly change because they more in my house?

MeridianB · 09/05/2023 10:44

Revnol · 09/05/2023 10:30

So in their defense it is a single room with a double room shoved in. Just enough space either side.

Don't defend them! Their demands are indefensible! It's for a week - not a lifetime.

OrderOfTheKookaburra · 09/05/2023 10:44

Did she show you because she somehow thought you would want to do what he wants just like she does? A very misconstrued idea of just how wonderful her fiancé is?!

longwayoff · 09/05/2023 10:44

Tell him to stay elsewhere if your offer isnt up to scratch. Unbelievable behaviour.

2Rebecca · 09/05/2023 10:43

We've never given up our bed for guests. It's our bed plus our clothes are in it and our lives don't stop just because we have visitors. Our guest room is for guests. If there are too many guests for the rooms then some of them have to stay elsewhere or they don't all come at once. Visiting someone doesn't have to mean staying in their house and having a cheap holiday

MaggieFS · 09/05/2023 10:42

I've been pondering this, because my gut reaction is that he's being a complete CF.

But thinking it over...they're coming for a week and their only space, for two of them during that week, is a single bedroom with a double bed shoved in.

I think in our family. We probably would have organised the room swap in advance anyway.

I think it was fair enough of him to ask, but as you've said no, he should accept gracefully.

It's the behaviour afterwards which is more concerning, but it's also not clear if he just said to your sister 'well that's annoying' which would be normal chat between a couple, or has made more of a thing of it.

OneTC · 09/05/2023 10:41

Nanny0gg · 09/05/2023 09:18

So what percentage do you think are furnished?

It's about 50%

SchoolTripDrama · 09/05/2023 10:40

@OneTC Yes! They very much are! Ask any letting agent. I viewed quite literally HUNDREDS of properties over 19 years (primarily due to demand always being so high so for every property I ended up being success with, I'd already been turned down for 50+) Not one was furnished.

I've just looked on Rightmove for my big town (PLUS 20 miles!) and not one single property is furnished, besides holiday let's. Not one!

Tiddlypomtiddlypom · 09/05/2023 10:39

Hbh17 · 09/05/2023 10:36

We have always given up our room when we have guests, because it's the nicest one in the house. I don't understand why someone wouldn't prioritise their guest's comfort, tbh.

Does this man seem deserving of prioritisation? Nah.

Also, I wouldn’t give up my bed for anyone. It’s weird. I sleep in it all the time. Guests beds are rarely used and so are fresher and nicer for guests, surely?

My inlaws always had their eye on our room, but then they liked to poke around my drawers and under the bed. So I’m not entirely sure of their motives for wanting it. They never got it, anyway. We have beautiful guest rooms and they can ‘slum’ it in one of those.

Katherine1985 · 09/05/2023 10:38

Maybe he’s projecting his problems with his own siblings into your family life, not head on but via your sister. Such that her relationship with you will worsen over time.

Also, even if he doesn’t have natural male entitlement attitude he’s picked up that your mum does, and that your parents want to please him and is leveraging that to your disadvantage.

Seems like you’ve got his number though. Just keep coming back to that baseline certainty that he wouldn’t give his room up for a sibling and partner

DisquietintheRanks · 09/05/2023 10:36

YANBU but I am quite impressed that he tolerates living in his Mil's home so she can be cared for. Not many people would go for that - if my dh suggested it it would be a very firm "absolutely not" and I love my MiL.

Maybe this will be the push he needs to make a better arrangement

Hbh17 · 09/05/2023 10:36

We have always given up our room when we have guests, because it's the nicest one in the house. I don't understand why someone wouldn't prioritise their guest's comfort, tbh.