Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Guess which year these spellings are for

280 replies

Todaynotalways · 08/05/2023 18:11

... English primary school... Which school year/age do you think these spellings are suitable for...?

Guess which year these spellings are for
OP posts:
SpringNotSprung · 08/05/2023 22:18

We moved our eldest shortly after the head at a state primary wrote "last year there was a 100 extra dinners served for Christmas". There was no hope really of an excellent education for the children once seeing that.

I always thought teachers had to have English O'Level/GCSE/CSE1 for admission to teacher training college. If that was the standard of a state education in the late 70s, it is reprehensible that her poor grammar was not sorted out at teacher training college.

The disappointment of many parents was palpable. The head might have got away with it at a school where the parents were not very well educated.

Clementinesucks · 08/05/2023 22:17

I would have said year 3. I’m amazed they are year 1.

newmum1976 · 08/05/2023 22:05

Year 2? Much too hard in my opinion, but we’ve had some similar for year 2 ds.

Potplant19 · 08/05/2023 22:02

Circumference
Dilapidated
Queue
Circumstance

I still remember some of the spellings from one weekly test I had at primary school 25 odd years ago, which I think was Year 5. Bloody hated it. Unless we got 8/10 we had to resit at lunchtime. It took me all week until I got there, and still didn't get queue right. We had to do a spelling test and dictation, I remember the dictation being about a man called Augustus with a dilapidated suitcase. And I remember feeling like a real failure by Friday.

SkankingWombat · 08/05/2023 22:00

It would be an interesting experiment to test them 'cold' on one of last month's lists... I suspect many DCs will have forgotten most of the spellings. My DCs' school have recently sacked off weekly look/cover/write lists followed by a Friday test, as they found the spellings were mostly learnt purely for the test and soon forgotten (although I'm not sure I rate their new app-based approach either TBH). I agree with the PP, that unless these are words they are using or reading regularly, they just won't remember the spellings at this stage.

Based on average ability, that list looks suitable for the bulk of yr3 IMO OP, but it doesn't surprise me it would be set for much younger DCs given the general trend to push hard and treat them like little learning robots whilst ignoring developmental appropriateness. Before the weekly lists were binned, we would have 10 spellings (DCs are yr 2 & 4). 8 would be either from the NC list for the DC's year or following a recently-covered rule (eg 'ly' suffix). The last 2 would be either 'challenge' words from an upper year's NC list or trickier words from the current class topic.

FabFitFifties · 08/05/2023 22:00

Y2

Todaynotalways · 08/05/2023 21:54

Fink · 08/05/2023 21:38

Speaking as a teacher, I don't think anyone in the profession, either state or independent, believes that the quality of teaching is markedly different either way (except in certain independents who routinely employ unqualified teachers and don't offer on the job training so they're just expected to pick up pedagogy as they go), and I wasn't aware that parents thought so either. There are many reasons why parents choose an independent education, class sizes and facilities probably being the top two, but I don't think many people are under the illusion that the teachers are better.

This is exactly why we chose an independent, smaller classes. Esp for those first few years, a class of 15 children felt like a massive benefit.

It is a double edged sword though, it makes the difference between the top performers and the rest more obvious. Everyone seems to know how 'good' everyone else is at every subject. And that's hard to tackle when they're so young.

OP posts:
pinksquash13 · 08/05/2023 21:53

I'm a teacher and have worked a lot on spellings as the school lead. There's evidence to support the fact that spelling tests are largely pointless and don't improve spelling (as pupils forget them as soon as the test is done). Tests do promote spelling at school / home as an 'important thing' so that's one reason why they're still used. What helps spelling is application of words. I guess like anything, using it again and again. Practice. As others have stated, there should be a context which is why themed spellings are helpful e.g. topic words when learning about electricity (bulb, switch, circuit, current) with the idea that pupils write these words many times. I do think learning the year 1 and 2 common exception words (Google it) is helpful. The yr3/4 and 5/6 curriculum words are challenging but give you an idea of the expected level. Personally, I'd encourage your daughter to not be so worried about the score but rather on her spelling in her school books. How does she do with her everyday writing? I would ask the teacher if everyone has the same words. Could she have the level down? And I would mention it again if she was becoming very demoralised as this is the opposite of what learning should be like.

LiveAHappyLifeBePositive · 08/05/2023 21:50

SamPoodle123 · 08/05/2023 21:36

I guess year 1 straight away when I saw the words and then saw that I was correct in my guess! I saw another poster wrote about people boasting if they wrote year 1, but that was my initial thought and my dc are in a state school year 4 and 6.

Is there any point in boasting on an anonymous forum.

🤣🤣🤣 it’s a spelling chat so I found myself cross checking all my spellings 🤣

RunAwayTurnAwayRunAwayTurnAway · 08/05/2023 21:43

Y3, although it wouldn't really surprise me if they were for younger.

Fink · 08/05/2023 21:38

Redebs · 08/05/2023 21:32

Just goes to show that you don't get better teachers in independent schools!

Speaking as a teacher, I don't think anyone in the profession, either state or independent, believes that the quality of teaching is markedly different either way (except in certain independents who routinely employ unqualified teachers and don't offer on the job training so they're just expected to pick up pedagogy as they go), and I wasn't aware that parents thought so either. There are many reasons why parents choose an independent education, class sizes and facilities probably being the top two, but I don't think many people are under the illusion that the teachers are better.

Viviennemary · 08/05/2023 21:37

Year 4

GirlOfTudor · 08/05/2023 21:36

Age 8?

SamPoodle123 · 08/05/2023 21:36

I guess year 1 straight away when I saw the words and then saw that I was correct in my guess! I saw another poster wrote about people boasting if they wrote year 1, but that was my initial thought and my dc are in a state school year 4 and 6.

Todaynotalways · 08/05/2023 21:34

NewNovember · 08/05/2023 21:12

Oh I was going to say 1985 😳

Ahhahahhaa

OP posts:
Redebs · 08/05/2023 21:32

Todaynotalways · 08/05/2023 18:18

YEAR ONE!!!

I forgot to say it's an independent school. Which may make a difference.

But I am tired of DD (just 6) struggling with her spellings every week, it's starting to put her off literacy.

She usually cobbles together a 7 or 8 out of 10 by practicing every night. But some weeks it's a 3 or 4, which really dents her confidence.

They just seem so hard!

Maybe because I went to a state primary (35 years ago)... I was just wondering if this is normal.

Just goes to show that you don't get better teachers in independent schools!

Clumsykitten · 08/05/2023 21:31

Yeah, that’s madness. I hope for your daughter’s sake it doesn’t reflect a cramming/hot house approach to the rest of schooling. At 5/6 lots of other countries would still have them doing entirely play-based learning. Agree with people saying - you are paying for this, you could choose to pay for something else!

I definitely couldn’t spell those words aged 5/6, although i probably could have read and defined them if asked. I got pretty much straight top grades throughout my later years and got a 2.i from Cambridge so I reckon your daughter will be just fine.

Salsi · 08/05/2023 21:20

I thought age 8… this is deffo hard. My child is now at a (top 3) academic private secondary, but went to a state primary, to give context. Also worth mentioning, kids develop at their own pace. Eg in year 2 DS could spell just about anything, but in year 1 his spelling was zero.

Secnarf · 08/05/2023 21:18

My daughter (state primary) definitely had ‘school’ in a weekly spelling list in either year 1 or 2. She was also able to spell ‘pyramid’ and ‘cylinder’ in year 2, but not year 1. I can’t remember whether they were in a spelling list, but they came up over and over again in maths, so she might have learned them that way. I am pretty sure that ‘science’ has not been in a spelling list yet, but again, it comes up a lot, and she knew how to spell it.

She’s now year 3. I’ve just asked her, and she can spell ‘thistle’, ‘glisten’ and ‘enormous’. They have definitely not been in a spelling list. I could see ‘glisten’ and ‘enormous’ coming up in comprehension or in a writing assignment, but was surprised she knew ‘thistle’.

Your spelling list looks a bit disparate. There are 2 words of ‘s as st’ and 2 words of ‘i as y’. Although science and school both begin ‘sc’, they are very different, and then ‘enormous’ is out there by itself.

In our school, in year 1 and 2 they consisted of 7 words following the same rule or two alternative spellings (e.g. -ey and -y) plus 3 exception words, so it was more obvious what they were trying to teach them.

SpringNotSprung · 08/05/2023 21:18

We moved our ds from an outstanding cofe SW London leafy state school to a SW London Tatler endorsed SW London independent in 2004, at the end of Y3. He was very behind in English and that's what he excelled at.

In Y3 he was taught to spell gauge as gauge and the teacher marked the corrected version wrong and told me off for complaining.

State standards were and are I suspect, an utter disgrace.

GetTheGoodLookingGuy · 08/05/2023 21:14

Y2

Shesellsseashellsunluckyshespoor · 08/05/2023 21:14

Appropriate for?? I’d say Y5 or Y6

In reality I’m going to assume they are Yr2 or 3 😓

NewNovember · 08/05/2023 21:12

Oh I was going to say 1985 😳

Babycakes6 · 08/05/2023 21:11

Todaynotalways · 08/05/2023 18:18

YEAR ONE!!!

I forgot to say it's an independent school. Which may make a difference.

But I am tired of DD (just 6) struggling with her spellings every week, it's starting to put her off literacy.

She usually cobbles together a 7 or 8 out of 10 by practicing every night. But some weeks it's a 3 or 4, which really dents her confidence.

They just seem so hard!

Maybe because I went to a state primary (35 years ago)... I was just wondering if this is normal.

Really?! My DC is doing this in Year 3 😳

Ponderingwindow · 08/05/2023 21:09

I was going to guess 2.

my recommendation would be to change how you work the list.

we would practice in the car or while doing other chores. Practicing spelling multitasks very well with the mundane day to day tasks.

when you have to actually study, dd liked to be physical. We would use sticky notes and run around and hit the letters Or you can jump on them.

Swipe left for the next trending thread