Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To tell healthy, fit looking, well dressed beggar to get a job?

208 replies

duvetcovereddissident · 08/05/2023 16:00

He is not a local beggar, all of whom I know, and he does not in any way look homeless. He looks to be about 30, healthy and fit, - much fitter than me! Well dressed and clean - much better dressed than me!

He is sitting outside the door to the local supermarket, and put his leg out in front of me as I tried to enter and asked for money.

Less than 6 feet to his left is the door of a cafe, with a sign on it saying "waiter required - apply within". I know those cafe owners, and I am sure that if he had gone in there and asked for a trial shift, rather than settling down outside the supermarket, they would have taken him on for the day to see how he did. They have needed a new waiter for months.

I have every sympathy with homeless and rough sleepers, and people down on their luck. I just think this is a scammer though. He has arrived in the area looking for somewhere to beg, and will probably be going home tonight. He isn't a local man, as I said.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
MrsLighthouse · 10/05/2023 18:17

Wow. You are very invested in a man you don’t know anything about and a job that you’re not offering yourself . There are loads of factors here that could affect either of those things. Just be glad that it’s not your problem to solve and maybe have some compassion for another human who - even if he is a professional beggar -isn’t exactly living the high life 🙄

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 10/05/2023 17:42

It’s hilarious that the OP is all up in arms because they “know” the man she encountered is a scammer, but has no issues with the business owners she “knows” would offer a trial without checking rights to work and the likes.

Obviously rules and laws and doing the right thing only applies to certain people, but others can do as they like

shammalammadingdong · 10/05/2023 17:19

CriticalAlert · 10/05/2023 17:13

It's the easy way people find of buying into the lies about professional beggars, benefit scroungers, illegal immigrants etc. But they are content to carry on and fill themselves with the lies and hatred of the Daily Mail. All they have to do is look up some truthful facts.....I do despair for this country. Tories have been in for too long and now we have the most right wing government in history.

They aren't all lies though. It's not all "hatred". There ARE professional beggars, there are people who lie and cheat to gain an immigration advantage, there are people who cheat the benefit system....

Pretending everyone is genuine and good is as stupid as buying into the opposite. Like most things in life, its a spectrum, with the majority n the middle somewhere.

CriticalAlert · 10/05/2023 17:13

Pussycatbeen · 10/05/2023 09:43

Exactly. And remember that society always needs scapegoats: beggars, people on benefits, the sick and disabled, immigrants, all play a vital role in the functioning of our system and anyone who wants the country to carry on the way it is should be immensely grateful to those of us who perform this essential role for them...or would they like to swap?

It's the easy way people find of buying into the lies about professional beggars, benefit scroungers, illegal immigrants etc. But they are content to carry on and fill themselves with the lies and hatred of the Daily Mail. All they have to do is look up some truthful facts.....I do despair for this country. Tories have been in for too long and now we have the most right wing government in history.

Neededanewuserhandle · 10/05/2023 17:03

megletthesecond · 08/05/2023 17:18

As well as this never happening I doubt you've even had a job yourself. Employers don't let just anyone do a shift.

^this

mustgetoffmn · 10/05/2023 16:57

duvetcovereddissident · 08/05/2023 16:14

He wouldn't have needed it! I know those cafe owners, they would have given him a trial shift then and there.

Oh trial shifts! When my daughter was teen and her friends they all knew about unpaid trial shifts! Some establishment just didn’t bother with paid staff. But you seem very naive. Getting a job may be easy but if you have MH it can be another story for both you and employer keeping it. Remember homeless or jobless massive % have MH. Unfortunately in UK any available support has diminished.

mustgetoffmn · 10/05/2023 09:48

duvetcovereddissident · 08/05/2023 16:03

I have worked in homeless shelters for decades, and I just don't believe this one at all. I am normally for erring on the side of taking someone's word for it. But you can go to far! There are criminal gangs just working the streets with intimidation and demands, as well as victims I want to support.

It’s hardly big money though? Sitting on pavement all day? For the odd bit of cash thrown at you. Got to be something mentally wrong with the described person. I deal with job less people it’s not as simple as just getting a job it’s also being able to commit and do it. Many people find that very difficult

Pussycatbeen · 10/05/2023 09:43

CriticalAlert · 09/05/2023 18:38

Absolutely correct!!

Exactly. And remember that society always needs scapegoats: beggars, people on benefits, the sick and disabled, immigrants, all play a vital role in the functioning of our system and anyone who wants the country to carry on the way it is should be immensely grateful to those of us who perform this essential role for them...or would they like to swap?

Heyhoitsme · 10/05/2023 09:02

I wouldn't dare say anything to him. We have a professional female begger who hangs around Lidl. It's well known that she and her family live in a decent house. She's the granny. She's now started knocking on car windows asking for money. I don't know why Lidl put up with her.

StarDolphins · 10/05/2023 07:03

CrazyLadie · 10/05/2023 00:03

Another nasty judgemental ass

🤣 said the person calling someone nasty!

I am entitled to my opinion jist like you! My opinion still stands!

Firethehorse · 10/05/2023 03:39

You are getting a very hard time OP. It’s fantastic you devote so much of your time helping others.
Sticking his leg out to block you is the complete giveaway for me. I would find that intimidating and he could well actually trip people up.

Rubychews · 10/05/2023 03:03

have No idea about ops person but I have met som Begpackers and they are definitely on my list of people I’d like to tell to fuck right off.

ThistleTits · 10/05/2023 02:44

duvetcovereddissident · 08/05/2023 16:11

How would that stop him washing up?

Perhaps because the "job" was for a waiter and not a pot washer.
Things that have not happened 2023.

Mamanyt · 10/05/2023 00:22

I've always worked off of a statement that I heard my father make, many years ago. A man was asking for money. My father's friend refused him, but my father gave him a few dollars. Lonnie, my father's friend, said, "Andy, that man is going to buy liquor with that money, not gas for his car!" And Dad replied, "Lonnie, one day that man and I are going to stand before our Maker. I'd rather it be on his conscience that he lied to me than on mine that I refused to help someone based on what they might or might not do."

You cannot tell disabled by looking, not reliably. If you looked at me, you would not think that I am disabled. I am. I have vertigo, sometimes lasting for days at a time, I have persistent atrial fibrillation that has caused a stroke...oh, yeah, I've had a stroke, which messed up my short-term memory and my balance, I have emphysema.

Now, let me add to that, the fact that he stuck his leg out in front of you is absolutely absurd, and I'd have been outraged by that. No matter how much he needs money (and he may), he does not have a right to attempt to block your passage in any way, shape, or form. Because of that, I would probably have passed him by, but not because he looked clean and well-dressed.

CrazyLadie · 10/05/2023 00:03

StarDolphins · 08/05/2023 17:56

I can. Maybe he doesn’t want to work & just wants a play on peoples sympathies for a bit of extra money Just as likely as the alternative argument that he ‘could’ have MH issues or a hidden disability.

He ‘could’ just simply be someone that doesn’t want to contribute to society & pay their way. I’m not saying this is the case, but it does happen regularly so as much of a possibility.

Another nasty judgemental ass

CrazyLadie · 09/05/2023 23:54

doadeer · 08/05/2023 16:54

Does anyone even carry cash now to give to people asking?

I never give them money, instead I go to McDonald's or into a shop for a meal deal, ensuring I get their order so they get something they enjoy rather than any old crap

CrazyLadie · 09/05/2023 23:47

RaininSummer · 08/05/2023 16:20

If he is actually seeking work and doesn't have documents, the job centre will help with that and also even if homeless a person can get their universal credit entitlement payments so not penniless. Difficult to know if someone might have mental health issues but not so likely I would think if clean, well dressed and well spoken as its very tough to be on the streets and present like that. Sticking his leg out to obstruct is harassment.

I can assure you as someone with a life long debilitating mental health disorder that your assumptions are incorrect, severe mental health issues tend cause episodes where things fall apart in between you can seem very normal, we are also master at disguising how we feel and what is going on for periods of time them getting home and having nothing else to give. Please do not make assumptions about things you do not understand, it's that kind of attoride that makes the lives of people like me even harder than they are already

CrazyLadie · 09/05/2023 23:41

YouWonJayne · 08/05/2023 16:18

Are you Tory Boy?

This was one of my first thought too, what a horrid, judgemental person OP is coming across as.

CrazyLadie · 09/05/2023 23:36

duvetcovereddissident · 08/05/2023 16:03

I have worked in homeless shelters for decades, and I just don't believe this one at all. I am normally for erring on the side of taking someone's word for it. But you can go to far! There are criminal gangs just working the streets with intimidation and demands, as well as victims I want to support.

The issue just now is many people have become homeless since covid and CoL crisis, I have seen quite a few who obviously had decent jobs as they have de emt clothes etc but no home anymore. You sound very judgemental, the guy doesn't fit in your box so he is a scam artist

girlfriend44 · 09/05/2023 21:09

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 08/05/2023 16:05

Perhaps he could go and get himself a job. Perhaps there were reasons why that wasn't possible. You had absolutely no way of determining this simply from looking at him, and frankly, you should be ashamed of yourself for being so horribly ignorant and judgemental.

It is awful that homeless people have to deal with this kind of crap on top of actually being homeless.

Absolutely

Mind your own business op and go about your day.

Why anyone wants to start an argument with a homeless person is beyond me.

So much aggression around.

Macinae · 09/05/2023 21:01

I'm in disbelief at this post. You'd think having "worked in shelters" you'd be less ignorant to the realities of homelessness. You may have had a hunch but to verbalise that and subsequently make a post about it is baffling. You asked AIBU and yes, you were.

JenWillsiam · 09/05/2023 20:50

duvetcovereddissident · 08/05/2023 16:20

No, they would have paid him for the trial

Cash in hand? So break the law?

Mediocrates · 09/05/2023 20:24

Snippit · 09/05/2023 18:23

There used to be a young lady, clean and well dressed sitting on a clean sleeping bag with a book begging outside our local BM bargains.

The staff were furious, she was dropped off in the morning, sat there all day reading and begging, then was picked up in the evening. The staff warned us not to give her money or food, security were informed and she hasn’t been back since, quite unbelievable.

Who do you think was dropping her off and picking her up, @Snippit? Let me guess, it was a flashy car too? Didn’t speak to anyone, even to say thank you? Not interested in food or a warm drink, just cash?

All of those are classic signs of human trafficking. These people are watched, warned not to speak to anyone, and often punished if they don’t bring back a certain amount of money. So hardly “quite unbelievable” at all.

Mediocrates · 09/05/2023 20:20

OP you’re really very desperate to convince everyone that this guy is a “professional beggar” aren’t you?

Sitting on a cold floor, being spat on/sworn at/judged for an entirely unreliable income and zero financial security seems like an odd choice of profession to me.

If you’ve spent years working with homeless people then I’m sure you’re well acquainted with the concept of trafficking and forced labour - people forced to beg all day then hand over whatever they’ve ‘earned’ before a shift in a restaurant, a brothel, or whatever other business the traffickers own. So for someone with your experience it seems odd that you’ve reached for “professional beggar” as the only viable explanation.

Wimin123 · 09/05/2023 19:10

Never mind about the professional beggars - just keep paying your taxes mugs - more annoying are the eejits who say ‘educate yourself’ it’s so patronising and meaningless