Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DD15 still reading dork diaries

259 replies

philomenacunky · 08/05/2023 15:13

My dd turned 15 in feb. Shes a perfectly normal 15 year old and doesn't enjoy childish things. The other day though I saw her reading a Dork diaries book, is this normal for her age? If you're not aware these are books aimed at much younger children. I know she is capable of reading much more mature books than this, she reads things like Of Mice and Men, Macbeth, Christmas carol etc for school.

I haven't told her off for this I'm just very confused, why is she reading these books at her age? Aibu for thinking it's weird?

OP posts:
lemonaddde · 08/05/2023 19:54

philomenacunky · 08/05/2023 15:22

I'd rather her read something a bit innapropriate than dumb her brain down with children's books

Reading a book does not dumb your brain down. It does precisely the opposite.

How ridiculous are you?

You could clearly do with doing a bit of reading yourself to undumb your brain.

QueSyrahSyrah · 08/05/2023 19:52

At least I haven't resorted to childish, insulting usernames just yet

You have styled yourself as a notoriously dim TV character though. With your concern for higher intellect I'm surprised you even know who Philomena Cunk is. Aren't you too busy watching documentaries and listening to Radio 4 for light entertainment? Careful it doesn't start eroding your IQ 🙄

Dinobooklover · 08/05/2023 19:49

33 and love re-reading the hobbit, his dark materials and little women. I also often read YA fantasy aimed at teens. War and peace is also one of my favourite books..I sometimes re-watch cartoons and shows from my childhood too. Sometimes if life is stressful I want to read something or watch something easy and familiar simply for comfort.

Always4Brenner · 08/05/2023 19:30

56 and love rereading Malory Towers and St Claire’s I want some goosebumps books and some Judy Blume that sort of book whose the U.K. equivalent?

StripyHorse · 08/05/2023 19:26

What do you watch on TV OP? Is it purely University Challenge, Newsnight, Documentaries and dramatisations of classical literature? Or do you sometimes watch soaps, comedies, game shows or reality TV? No one seems to bat an eyelid when people relax in front of the TV and switch off.

Same with books. I'm a teacher and I have an English Lit degree. My reading is a bit eclectic. It really depends how much is going on in my life - I often don't want a book I have to think about.

Your DD is y10. She probably has a lot going on in school (ramping up ready for exams next year). Of all the ways that she could try and unwind, reading a children's book is hardly alarming.

Waterfallgirl · 08/05/2023 19:04

IrregularChoiceFan · 08/05/2023 18:47

Yep, 33 and have reread the Georgia Nicholson books quite a few times, they will never not be funny. Can't believe she died before releasing a set for adults.

@Iamclearlyamug @IrregularChoiceFan and @DrMirandaBailey thank you for the Georgia Nicholson recommendation, I’m a bit ( a lot) older than you I think and have never seen them. I still reread the Magic Faraway tree and the Enid Blyton stories of my childhood ( the St Clare’s books) and also reread Harry Potter and Michael Murpurgo all the books my DC loved too. I’m going to give these ago - and I’ll try to ensure my brain cells remain intact. 😁

maddiemookins16mum · 08/05/2023 18:59

I loved a familiar book from my younger years at that age, the Gemma books, the 12 day of July series with Kevin and Sadie, New Patches for Old etc etc, they were a sort of comfort blanket and familiar friend as I got older.

GoatHeartedPieFacedOwl · 08/05/2023 18:58

I'm at the "wrong" end of my 50's. I just re-read all of the "Murder Most Ladylike" books. They're great!. (I've also got an Allingham murder mystery, a thick, non-fiction tome about Elizabethan spycraft, a sci-fi and a Candice Braithwaite on the go in various parts of the house and at work.)

I'm also a librarian and am always happy to help with recommendations.
I've got one for you: any reading is good reading. Comfort reading is good for you. Belittling anyone for their choice of book is extraordinarily mean. Leave your daughter to read exactly what she wants to.

AlwaysGinPlease · 08/05/2023 18:52

philomenacunky · 08/05/2023 15:30

Obviously not 50 shades level of adult but something with a bit more depth than Dork diaries would be nice. And no I don't only watch documentaries but I certainly don't watch children's shows for fun!

Her sister (a year younger) is fully capable of reading Stephen king, classics, etc while she's stuck on dork diaries

Are you joking? How ridiculous, let her read what she wants ffs. Don't compare your children either. You sound very overbearing, that does not bode well for a good relationship with them.

LumpySpaceGoddess · 08/05/2023 18:51

At 15 I was reading all sorts but I was also still watching Nickelodeon and Cartoon Network! 🤣🤣🤣

SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius · 08/05/2023 18:47

Bottom line, @philomenacunky - do you want to put your daughter off reading altogether? Because if you do, then criticising what she chooses to read, and thinking she is thick for choosing something you don’t think is challenging enough, is a fine way of achieving that.

I reread the Chalet school stories while I was nursing, and went on to go to university and got a degree in Music and Politics - reading fiction intended for children did not harm my intelligence at all.

To be honest, it doesn’t sound as if you like your older dd as much as your younger one. Nothing but glowing words for the younger dd’s choice of reading matter, but the older one reads something from when she was younger and is doomed to become a dunce.

IrregularChoiceFan · 08/05/2023 18:47

DrMirandaBailey · 08/05/2023 17:22

I recently did a Georgia Nicholson re-read too! I was obsessed with them at 13 and it was so nice to revisit that.

OP I actively keep an eye out for old Jacqueline Wilson books in charity shops so that I can reread my favourites. Don't ever shame a child for reading, just because you don't like the books

Yep, 33 and have reread the Georgia Nicholson books quite a few times, they will never not be funny. Can't believe she died before releasing a set for adults.

ODFOx · 08/05/2023 18:37

She's not 'stuck on Dork Diaries'.

She's got plenty of thoughtful reading to do for school and is zoning out with something effortless/unchallenging.

It's called 'mental chewing gum': keeps the faculties ticking over while not using up any mental energy.

Leave her be.

mischlerischler · 08/05/2023 18:33

YABU.

You sound unpleasant.

darjeelingrose · 08/05/2023 18:30

How old are you, OP? I would say that with a 15 year old, you are probably early to mid 40s. Therefore you probably remember that Enid Blyton books were banned for many years in the UK for being racist and badly written.

That said, imagining that you are genuinely concerned, why don't you try and find out what some better titles would be for your daughter at her age. Not Stephen King, obviously, educate yourself first, but there is some great young adult literature out there, why not get her some Malorie Blackman?

tinytemper66 · 08/05/2023 18:29

philomenacunky · 08/05/2023 15:24

Not innapropriate per say but a bit more adult/mature

You are obviously unaware of the huge market of Young Adult Fiction. It is wonderful. Most of it starts from Year 5 upwards.

MayasMum0 · 08/05/2023 18:07

does it matter what she reads? get a grip.

Qilin · 08/05/2023 18:07

Thank goodness I have an e-reader!

Least people like the OP couldn't judge my reading material.

I am hope your DD invests in a kindle or similar soon - then she can read without her mum criticising her!

Qilin · 08/05/2023 18:06

I'm not "criticising" her, I'm worried for her intelligence

I don't think re-reading a book aimed at a couple of years younger than you are is going to reduce her intelligence levels. Do you, really?

Qilin · 08/05/2023 17:58

philomenacunky · 08/05/2023 15:22

I'd rather her read something a bit innapropriate than dumb her brain down with children's books

Please don't 'tell her off' - that would be unkind, and tbh ridiculous anyway!

Nothing wrong with a bit of comfort reading every now and then, in between other books.

I remember re-reading some of my childhood/teen books as I got older as a comfort. I have read, and re-read Harry Potter books - all children's books. I re-read Adrian Mole and The Secret Garden not that long ago - and I am MUCH older than your DD.

Nothing wrong with having a nice, non-taxing comfort read you can return to every now and again!

rattyroo · 08/05/2023 17:57

Why do you assume that reading books that are too easy are going to make her less intelligent?

As an ex teacher I strongly believe that children who read (no matter what they read) for pleasure and read regularly perform better academically than peers who are forced into it.

The parents who did what you're talking about doing succeeded only in crushing their children's love of reading.

You shouldn't see reading books as a list of titles to get through so you can move to the next level, increasing intelligence. Books are about using your imagination and getting lost it them. They are like watching a movie but in your mind. They are about feeling like you know the characters like they're your friends. There is nothing like a good book and a person who loves reading will carry that with them for the rest of their lives.

Mumsnet is so busy and I often read content a lot worse than this of course but something about this thread has made me feel really sad for your daughter. I used to devour books as a teenager and my mum would look out for ones by the same author and look out for new ones in the series I liked and bring them home for me excitedly, knowing how happy I would be. I'm so glad I had that.

OP, I am in my thirties and I have a good degree and a postgraduate qualification. I currently earn a good living and support my family. I've recently reread the Harry Potter, Twilight, Hunger Games, Mortal Instruments and Divergent series. If each page decreases my intelligence then maybe I need to let my work know as soon I'll probably just be a dribbling mess.

ColdHandsHotHead · 08/05/2023 17:49

Good grief, why shouldn't she read what she wants to? I picked up a Winnie the Pooh in a second hand bookshop the other week and was engrossed.

rowanoak · 08/05/2023 17:46

Who cares what she likes to read? Leave your poor daughter alone and stop judging her!

ReadersD1gest · 08/05/2023 17:43

philomenacunky · 08/05/2023 16:22

I'm not "criticising" her, I'm worried for her intelligence

What do you think will happen to her intelligence if she reads books that are young for her rather than Stephen King?

Notellinganyone · 08/05/2023 17:43

SocksAndTheCity · 08/05/2023 15:47

Reading it.

Per se. If we’re being pedantic. Which you are.

Swipe left for the next trending thread