Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think that if your partner pays part of the mortgage off you are not then expected to pay them back!

114 replies

whattheactual121 · 08/05/2023 13:56

So, this is really difficult to explain but here goes. My husband and I have been married for 3 years. I have a daughter from a previous marriage (deceased husband). We are really happy and have a great life but we have very different attitudes to money and we seem to talk about it a lot and find ourselves on completely different pages. The house we live in was my house. He has a house elsewhere that he worked hard to get and loves so does not want to sell it or rent it out (which I can understand) so it is a kind of holiday home (although I am not allowed to call it that!). A couple of years ago when the interest rates went up it was decided (I thought WE had decided but...) that hubbie would use 50k he had invested to pay off part of the mortgage, I also paid 50k at the same time, leaving us with only a small mortgage but naturally we both had a lot less ready cash. Simple, so I thought. Now, he is saying that this has used up a lot of his liquid assets and the deal was that it was the best use of the money at the time but that he thought he would get it back and now I am going back on what we discussed by clearly having no intention paying it back. I am flabbergasted and completely confused. He says he is really cross that I have gone against what was discussed. I of course assumed that once money goes to the mortgage that's it, you don't expect someone to reimburse you. In his defence, he is referring to the fact that I have rental properties that I had said could be used to pay off the mortgage, but that was my plan before we were married, since then I was really thinking that these will be a retirement fund, particularly as now is such a bad time to sell. He worries about money a lot and has been unemployed for a few months (between contracts) and doesn't cope with this uncertainly and stress. But this is not the first time he's mentioned it, before was when he was in a very well paid contract. Overall we are really financially secure and have no reason to worry, certainly a lot better off than most. However he still sees things very much 'yours' and 'mine' and cannot see 'ours'. I won't change his attitude, but am I losing my mind thinking that it was fair to assume that the money he paid off the mortgage was put into the joint property, out home and that's that? He says I should not have assumed that.

OP posts:
theGooHasGone · 08/05/2023 14:49

Oh - and I'm also assuming that you didn't shame or browbeat him into putting the 50k down on your mortgage. If it was his decision entirely to do it, I don't see why it's such a problem. You both put an even share into the house you both live in to keep the payments low. That sounds entirely fair to me and you're both benefitting from it.

Oldnproud · 08/05/2023 14:48

How much a month have the mortgage repayments reduced by since you each put in the £50,000? He's benefitting from his 'investment via that, isn't he?

theGooHasGone · 08/05/2023 14:46

IMO this is a way more complicated situation than just "we both put 50k down on the mortgage" - you're married, so how are bills and income split otherwise? You say he's having trouble with "ours", but surely he's getting the better end of this deal at the moment as he isn't generating any income?

In general, I'd expect your joint income to be subsidising him while he's out of work. You both put 50k down on the mortgage (which he probably shouldn't have, but hindsight is 20/20) as it made sense at the time so as a result, he now has lower monthly payments to worry about which will make his life a little easier when searching for work.

I can appreciate that he feels a little cash poor at the moment, but that shouldn't be an issue as long as the joint family finances can keep him afloat and he is actively searching for new work. It sounds like he's perhaps a little ashamed of the fact that he isn't bringing anything in at the moment and rather than focus on that, he's getting angry about the fact that he overleveraged himself to put 50k down on a mortgage.

Is the "holiday home" just sitting empty with no tenants at all? That seems like a waste of money to me, even if it doesn't have a mortgage. It could be generating an income for him. Failing that he could sell it and recoup his 50k.

At the very least I think he should be on the mortgage for the house you both live in. He's contributing to it so he deserves a share of the equity. If he doesn't want that I'd probably be questioning why.

PollyPeptide · 08/05/2023 14:43

whattheactual121 · 08/05/2023 14:23

Really? I'm genuinely interested to know why. You would be paying towards a house you live in and call home. Showing commitment, investing in that property. I don't see where the concept of paying it back comes in?

You both came into the marriage with a property. He owns a property and you own a property. Why should he pay off your mortgage to your property?
I don't see you choosing to live in your property as opposed to his property having anything to do with it. If you were living in his property, I'd expect you to pay off your own mortgage, as well. I'd never expect you to pay off his mortgage (if he had one) if it wasn't half yours, either.

whattheactual121 · 08/05/2023 14:42

CantFindTheBeat · 08/05/2023 14:35

It sounds like the £50k was his safety net, OP.

If he's out of work, I can totally see how he would be feeling anxious and worried about not having it.

Even though you are both asset-rich, it sounds like he, at least, is cash poor which is not a comfortable position to be in.

What plans can you both put in place to help him re-build his savings?

You're right, I think that's the case. He was supposed to be starting a contract in Jan and that fell through. There isn't much around at the moment otherwise he would have been working and would feel better I think. Even so, he has mentioned this before.

OP posts:
whattheactual121 · 08/05/2023 14:41

Soontobe60 · 08/05/2023 14:38

You say that if you die he will get the house - what about your child??? Surely they should get the house?

There are other assets that she would get.

OP posts:
whattheactual121 · 08/05/2023 14:40

Livinghappy · 08/05/2023 14:37

It sounds like he was expecting OP to sell one of her rental properties to pay him back and cover the remaining mortgage- based on previous conversations

I agree with this. If you divorced he may not get his 50k back (it depends on a number of factors) so I think I can see where his insecurity is coming from. You would have multiple properties whereas he would have 1 property and hardly any cash.

This just makes him feel you have a better deal and makes the relationship unbalanced. He would have to rely on you and that might feel scary to him. I would pay the 50k back so that he can decide how to invest the money.

That all sounds very sensible. I will need to give this some thought.

OP posts:
whattheactual121 · 08/05/2023 14:39

JudgeRudy · 08/05/2023 14:32

I just want to clarify I have this correct.
You and your husband both have additional properties/money plus the shared family home you live in (which used to be just yours in your previous marriage). You have a mortgage on this property.
At one time it made financial sense for your OH to liquidate some of his investments and use the money from that to pay off some of the mortgage on the family home. Presumably he was getting poor returns and mortgage interest had increased. You had considered selling one of your rental properties but instead you both decided to each raise £50k leaving you with a small mortgage on the family home.
Your OH financial security has changed as he now has no secure income and has used his 'safety net' to pay off the mortgage.

It seems to me that he now wants his £50k back so he can spend/count/invest independently. You don't have a spare £50k unless you sell one of your rental properties. You were going to do that initially.

If all that is correct this is about your OH having independent money to draw on. He can't do that unless he sells the family home which no-one is intending to do. Somehow he needs his £50k back so you can either remortgage, sell something, or offer him a share in the home. It could be a mix.
The challenge then comes with how to calculate what you owe.
What would his £50k investment be worth?
If you had not taken the £50k would you have been better off with your old mortgage, or with a remortgage now?
Would he accept say £25k and £25k share of family house (presumably to be inherited by your son)? Could you 'give' him a share of your rental?
It all sounds rather anal to me but I'm guessing it's come up because your OH feels insecure. If you had known this was his plan ie let's use his money for time being whilst interest rates suit, what different decisions would you have made. How ever you work it, if one of you looses out you should half/share the loss.

@JudgeRudy you have done a fantastic job of summarising the situation here! It is all very anal to me, but he has worked hard and given up a lot to get where he has financially and now he sees his financial independence going. I can understand that. He's not ready to take the leap of faith to seeing that it is all 'ours' anyway.

OP posts:
Seriouslynotseriously · 08/05/2023 14:38

PollyPeptide · 08/05/2023 14:16

Cross posted. Having read your last post, yes, if I were him, I'd expect t get my £50,000 back.

It’s the marital home! Of course she should not pay him back!

Soontobe60 · 08/05/2023 14:38

You say that if you die he will get the house - what about your child??? Surely they should get the house?

Throwncrumbs · 08/05/2023 14:38

I’d tell him to fuck off out of my house, can’t be doing with tight fisted men, he’s living there the fuckwit!

Livinghappy · 08/05/2023 14:37

It sounds like he was expecting OP to sell one of her rental properties to pay him back and cover the remaining mortgage- based on previous conversations

I agree with this. If you divorced he may not get his 50k back (it depends on a number of factors) so I think I can see where his insecurity is coming from. You would have multiple properties whereas he would have 1 property and hardly any cash.

This just makes him feel you have a better deal and makes the relationship unbalanced. He would have to rely on you and that might feel scary to him. I would pay the 50k back so that he can decide how to invest the money.

CantFindTheBeat · 08/05/2023 14:35

It sounds like the £50k was his safety net, OP.

If he's out of work, I can totally see how he would be feeling anxious and worried about not having it.

Even though you are both asset-rich, it sounds like he, at least, is cash poor which is not a comfortable position to be in.

What plans can you both put in place to help him re-build his savings?

Jaxhog · 08/05/2023 14:33

Maybe you should charge him rent instead?

youhavenoidea123 · 08/05/2023 14:32

It sounds like he was expecting OP to sell one of her rental properties to pay him back and cover the remaining mortgage- based on previous conversations.

OP has now decided not to sell the rental property, but had not communicated this to her DH. I'm guessing this is because the mortgage is manageable now it's smaller.

I can see both sides. Sounds like the DH feels financially vulnerable while he's between contracts with no liquid assets.

JudgeRudy · 08/05/2023 14:32

I just want to clarify I have this correct.
You and your husband both have additional properties/money plus the shared family home you live in (which used to be just yours in your previous marriage). You have a mortgage on this property.
At one time it made financial sense for your OH to liquidate some of his investments and use the money from that to pay off some of the mortgage on the family home. Presumably he was getting poor returns and mortgage interest had increased. You had considered selling one of your rental properties but instead you both decided to each raise £50k leaving you with a small mortgage on the family home.
Your OH financial security has changed as he now has no secure income and has used his 'safety net' to pay off the mortgage.

It seems to me that he now wants his £50k back so he can spend/count/invest independently. You don't have a spare £50k unless you sell one of your rental properties. You were going to do that initially.

If all that is correct this is about your OH having independent money to draw on. He can't do that unless he sells the family home which no-one is intending to do. Somehow he needs his £50k back so you can either remortgage, sell something, or offer him a share in the home. It could be a mix.
The challenge then comes with how to calculate what you owe.
What would his £50k investment be worth?
If you had not taken the £50k would you have been better off with your old mortgage, or with a remortgage now?
Would he accept say £25k and £25k share of family house (presumably to be inherited by your son)? Could you 'give' him a share of your rental?
It all sounds rather anal to me but I'm guessing it's come up because your OH feels insecure. If you had known this was his plan ie let's use his money for time being whilst interest rates suit, what different decisions would you have made. How ever you work it, if one of you looses out you should half/share the loss.

Piony · 08/05/2023 14:31

"However he still sees things very much 'yours' and 'mine' and cannot see 'ours'."

The deeds need to change. I can see why he's unhappy putting 50k into the house that is held only in your name. You may think it's now "our house" but he thinks it's still yours, and legally it still is.

He is trying to rewrite the agenda in making you "pay him back". He put £50k into the house and he pays half the mortgage, that affects what proportion of the house he now owns. Does he expect you to pay him back his mortgage contribution every month and if not, why not? A lump sum payment is no different.

whattheactual121 · 08/05/2023 14:31

Sheepsheepeverywhere · 08/05/2023 14:28

So do you get your 150 a month back off his own previous home?

Previous home makes no money - just sits there. Costs 5k per year in council tax! plus loads of maintenance. We go down there maybe 4 times per year. It is purely emotional connection.

OP posts:
Tiddlypomtiddlypom · 08/05/2023 14:31

In your will, I mean.

Tiddlypomtiddlypom · 08/05/2023 14:31

Put the house in your daughter’s name.

xyxygy · 08/05/2023 14:31

Surely the logical thing to do is to put the house in both your names, since you both paid the mortgage? That is paying him back, since he then owns part of it.

The "if we divorce" justification for not paying him back or putting his name on the deeds is tenuous, because if you have a great lawyer and he only has a good one, that'd be relatively easy to argue your way out of, and you're potentially unfairly £50k to the good.

The fact is that neither house is a joint property, because he owned one outright (I think?) before you married, and yours is only in your name (even though he's paid for a significant portion of it).

RonObvious · 08/05/2023 14:28

That’s so bizarre. I would have presumed the same thing as you - you’re combining finances in the effective manner. And if you were to separate at any point, surely his money would be worth more if kept invested in the house?

Sheepsheepeverywhere · 08/05/2023 14:28

So do you get your 150 a month back off his own previous home?

MrJollyLivesNextDoor · 08/05/2023 14:27

So he had £50k readily available

He used this to pay down the mortgage (you did the same) leaving a small mortgage with low monthly repayments

He is now saying he expected to get this money back

Where from exactly?? It's paid down the mortgage! Does he expect you to remortgage now to repay him? What on Earth would have been the point of it all??

whattheactual121 · 08/05/2023 14:24

Needanewnamebeingwatched · 08/05/2023 14:22

Surely all your properties and all his will belong to both of you now you are married.

So he has helped pay for one of your joint properties 🤷‍♀️

That's what I thought, but apparently I should not have presumed???

OP posts: