Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think that if your partner pays part of the mortgage off you are not then expected to pay them back!

114 replies

whattheactual121 · 08/05/2023 13:56

So, this is really difficult to explain but here goes. My husband and I have been married for 3 years. I have a daughter from a previous marriage (deceased husband). We are really happy and have a great life but we have very different attitudes to money and we seem to talk about it a lot and find ourselves on completely different pages. The house we live in was my house. He has a house elsewhere that he worked hard to get and loves so does not want to sell it or rent it out (which I can understand) so it is a kind of holiday home (although I am not allowed to call it that!). A couple of years ago when the interest rates went up it was decided (I thought WE had decided but...) that hubbie would use 50k he had invested to pay off part of the mortgage, I also paid 50k at the same time, leaving us with only a small mortgage but naturally we both had a lot less ready cash. Simple, so I thought. Now, he is saying that this has used up a lot of his liquid assets and the deal was that it was the best use of the money at the time but that he thought he would get it back and now I am going back on what we discussed by clearly having no intention paying it back. I am flabbergasted and completely confused. He says he is really cross that I have gone against what was discussed. I of course assumed that once money goes to the mortgage that's it, you don't expect someone to reimburse you. In his defence, he is referring to the fact that I have rental properties that I had said could be used to pay off the mortgage, but that was my plan before we were married, since then I was really thinking that these will be a retirement fund, particularly as now is such a bad time to sell. He worries about money a lot and has been unemployed for a few months (between contracts) and doesn't cope with this uncertainly and stress. But this is not the first time he's mentioned it, before was when he was in a very well paid contract. Overall we are really financially secure and have no reason to worry, certainly a lot better off than most. However he still sees things very much 'yours' and 'mine' and cannot see 'ours'. I won't change his attitude, but am I losing my mind thinking that it was fair to assume that the money he paid off the mortgage was put into the joint property, out home and that's that? He says I should not have assumed that.

OP posts:
MrsTerryPratchett · 08/05/2023 15:16

I think you need two things. Counselling and legal advice. You both need to know where you stand legally in the case of death, disability, divorce etc. And then couple's counselling to work out why you are feeling this way. With all the facts in hand.

There are clearly lots of emotions attached to money, property and so on. You need help to unpick them. So does he.

3BSHKATS · 08/05/2023 15:15

First of all if you divorced he would not be entitled to half the property, he'd be entitled to a percentage + his £50,000
Give him his £50,000 back and his marching orders (Royal themed response)

RoseRobot · 08/05/2023 15:14

MrJollyLivesNextDoor · 08/05/2023 14:27

So he had £50k readily available

He used this to pay down the mortgage (you did the same) leaving a small mortgage with low monthly repayments

He is now saying he expected to get this money back

Where from exactly?? It's paid down the mortgage! Does he expect you to remortgage now to repay him? What on Earth would have been the point of it all??

Good point. You can offer to remortgage and point out that his monthly repayments would go up. Hmm

raincamepouringdown · 08/05/2023 15:13

Charge him rent; tell him you'll be paying him back out of that since he clearly sees the house you both live in as 'your' house and his house as 'his.

Tell him to get over himself and rents his house out if he feels 'cash poor'. Your house is lived in; his can be as well.

Your marriage doesn't sound like it's going anywhere. If it's a relatively new marriage, I'd get legal advice about ending it to keep your rental properties out of his hands...

RoseRobot · 08/05/2023 15:13

If you are married, the house is now a joint asset isn't it? How can you pay someone back for something that belongs to them?

He has invested in the home in which he lives. But if he's only been there for 3 years, 50k is quite a sum. It was foolish not to discuss terms and just 'assume' them.
It might be wise to think of selling both houses and jointly buying a new one which belongs to you equally, and repaying yourselves both 50k investments so you each have a chunk of money to do what you want with.

whattheactual121 · 08/05/2023 15:13

Dungaree · 08/05/2023 15:11

You have rental properties (plural), own your own home and he has a house as well. So as a couple you have a minimum of 4 properties (morally suspect) and you are fighting over money. Whole situation is tasteless to me.

Agree, it is. I don't see anything to fight about. We are very lucky.

OP posts:
Pinkdelight3 · 08/05/2023 15:13

It all feels like your arrangements are predicated on splitting up. He's keeping the house so he can go and live there when you split up. He's worried about losing the 50k if you split up. Does it never sink in that you could stay married and it's actually his marital/family home that the money is invested in? Or is he really still in the mindset of boyfriend and expecting to bolt at any moment?

whattheactual121 · 08/05/2023 15:12

Pinkdelight3 · 08/05/2023 15:11

This is crackers. He can't complain about feeling short on funds when he has a whole house of his own sitting empty indefinitely. Couldn't deal with such a weirdo, sorry.

It's not quite as weird as it sounds tbh, but it is a major factor in my thinking. Equally, I can't be seen to be pressuring him into selling.

OP posts:
ItsBritneyBitchhhh · 08/05/2023 15:11

tikkanaan · 08/05/2023 13:59

Sounds messy- divorce him

😂 don’t mean to laugh but I love how you jumped to the most drastic solution. That’s definitely something that I’d do haha

Dungaree · 08/05/2023 15:11

You have rental properties (plural), own your own home and he has a house as well. So as a couple you have a minimum of 4 properties (morally suspect) and you are fighting over money. Whole situation is tasteless to me.

Pinkdelight3 · 08/05/2023 15:11

whattheactual121 · 08/05/2023 15:03

yup, just sitting there.

This is crackers. He can't complain about feeling short on funds when he has a whole house of his own sitting empty indefinitely. Couldn't deal with such a weirdo, sorry.

PollyPeptide · 08/05/2023 15:09

rwalker · 08/05/2023 14:54

You’ve only have a short marriage do he wouldn’t get a lot if anything he’s not on mortgage or deeds he’s paid 50k
basically he’s fucked if u split
he could kiss bye bye to 50k

This is how I see it, too. For such a short marriage, with the op having a child, they'd probably leave with what they brought in. And he's 50k light.

whattheactual121 · 08/05/2023 15:08

PollyPeptide · 08/05/2023 15:07

No, because her house is her house. She's the only person on the deeds. And his house is his. He's the only person on the deeds.

I don't know what was said in the discussion. This is clearly what the op thought was being agreed on. But maybe he doesn't agree that's what was discussed.

I've suggested putting him on the deeds and he's not interested. It's all about the cash.

OP posts:
PollyPeptide · 08/05/2023 15:07

Truestorypeeps · 08/05/2023 14:50

But they are married? What's mine is yours and what's yours is mine, no?

OP, say to him that he gave the £50k and that at NO POINT (I'm assuming) was a loan and repayment of the money ever discussed!

No, because her house is her house. She's the only person on the deeds. And his house is his. He's the only person on the deeds.

I don't know what was said in the discussion. This is clearly what the op thought was being agreed on. But maybe he doesn't agree that's what was discussed.

whattheactual121 · 08/05/2023 15:03

SocksAndTheCity · 08/05/2023 15:02

So neither he nor you want to live in the 'holiday house' but he doesn't want anybody else to either?

Is he just planning to keep a spare empty property sitting there gathering dust for ever or does he have some future ideas for it?

yup, just sitting there.

OP posts:
SocksAndTheCity · 08/05/2023 15:02

So neither he nor you want to live in the 'holiday house' but he doesn't want anybody else to either?

Is he just planning to keep a spare empty property sitting there gathering dust for ever or does he have some future ideas for it?

Crikeyalmighty · 08/05/2023 15:02

I think this isn't really about the houses- more about the fact he's feeling vulnerable due to not currently working and not as much surplus cash as he expected- my own view would be to see if he can be on the deeds without being on the mortgage (I don't see why not but I'm not an expert) personally though I think he's mad not selling the place he owns but you rarely go to and banking the cash , and by the way if he's put on the deeds on your house - I think the reverse should be true on his house

xyxygy · 08/05/2023 15:00

whattheactual121 · 08/05/2023 14:50

A lot of this is emotional. He doesn't want to be on the mortgage as he is mortgage free and doesn't want to be saddles with a mortgage again (albeit a tiny one). The 'holiday house' cannot be rented out as he does not want anyone else there. It took me a long time to feel accepted there, but that's a whole other story!

Having his name on the mortgage and having his name on the deeds to the house are not the same thing, though. As he effectively owns part of the house - assuming you don't just give him the money back - then a substitute for the money is a legal document to that effect.

It doesn't need to be a complicated or contentious thing, it's simply protecting his assets because neither of you can see the future. For example, off the top of my head...you're in an accident, and for whatever reason are deemed not to have capacity - one of your family could make the case that he isn't acting in your best interests, get power of attorney and take the house away from him (including his share) regardless of what's in your will because legally you're the sole owner of the property.

It's not always about messy stuff like trust or emotional attachment. Just get a solicitor to draw up a document to that effect, stating his share in the house, and you're golden - assuming, of course, that he accepts that you don't have a spare £50k lying around.

Instantkarmaa · 08/05/2023 14:59

It reads like he lent you 50k to bring your mortgage payments and interest down. He now wants the money back without the high interest the bank would have added.

Seems like an alright deal to be honest.

You would have been paying it anyway so at least you'll save some money in the long run.

Chocbuttonsandredwine · 08/05/2023 14:58

I think once you’ve resolved the £50k issue I think you need to sit down and sort your finances out and try and untangle everything as neither of you sound happy with the current situation. It almost seems like he wants everything separated which is fine, but he can’t have it both ways.

if you give him his £50k back then he should be paying half of the bills plus “rent” which isn’t just half of your remaining mortgage as you’ve used money from your savings to decrease that, and he’s effectively kept his “savings”

he sounds quite mean to be honest.

I hope your daughter is well taken care of should anything happen to you. Out of interest who would inherit his house?

TooOldForThisNonsense · 08/05/2023 14:56

I can’t get my head round how many houses you have between you or money sloshing around. I’m quite glad I don’t have much money if this is typical of the kind of issues it causes

rwalker · 08/05/2023 14:54

You’ve only have a short marriage do he wouldn’t get a lot if anything he’s not on mortgage or deeds he’s paid 50k
basically he’s fucked if u split
he could kiss bye bye to 50k

gogogoji · 08/05/2023 14:52

I'm really quite confused by the arrangement and don't have a clue really but just wanted to pop in to say in the case of divorce, he will likely have claim on your house as he is living in it so it is the marital home. You may not have a claim on his as you have never lived in it so it may be ring fenced as a pre-marital asset. If this is the case, he absolutely should be paying the £50K towards the house you live in

whattheactual121 · 08/05/2023 14:50

theGooHasGone · 08/05/2023 14:46

IMO this is a way more complicated situation than just "we both put 50k down on the mortgage" - you're married, so how are bills and income split otherwise? You say he's having trouble with "ours", but surely he's getting the better end of this deal at the moment as he isn't generating any income?

In general, I'd expect your joint income to be subsidising him while he's out of work. You both put 50k down on the mortgage (which he probably shouldn't have, but hindsight is 20/20) as it made sense at the time so as a result, he now has lower monthly payments to worry about which will make his life a little easier when searching for work.

I can appreciate that he feels a little cash poor at the moment, but that shouldn't be an issue as long as the joint family finances can keep him afloat and he is actively searching for new work. It sounds like he's perhaps a little ashamed of the fact that he isn't bringing anything in at the moment and rather than focus on that, he's getting angry about the fact that he overleveraged himself to put 50k down on a mortgage.

Is the "holiday home" just sitting empty with no tenants at all? That seems like a waste of money to me, even if it doesn't have a mortgage. It could be generating an income for him. Failing that he could sell it and recoup his 50k.

At the very least I think he should be on the mortgage for the house you both live in. He's contributing to it so he deserves a share of the equity. If he doesn't want that I'd probably be questioning why.

A lot of this is emotional. He doesn't want to be on the mortgage as he is mortgage free and doesn't want to be saddles with a mortgage again (albeit a tiny one). The 'holiday house' cannot be rented out as he does not want anyone else there. It took me a long time to feel accepted there, but that's a whole other story!

OP posts:
Truestorypeeps · 08/05/2023 14:50

PollyPeptide · 08/05/2023 14:16

Cross posted. Having read your last post, yes, if I were him, I'd expect t get my £50,000 back.

But they are married? What's mine is yours and what's yours is mine, no?

OP, say to him that he gave the £50k and that at NO POINT (I'm assuming) was a loan and repayment of the money ever discussed!