Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think that if your partner pays part of the mortgage off you are not then expected to pay them back!

114 replies

whattheactual121 · 08/05/2023 13:56

So, this is really difficult to explain but here goes. My husband and I have been married for 3 years. I have a daughter from a previous marriage (deceased husband). We are really happy and have a great life but we have very different attitudes to money and we seem to talk about it a lot and find ourselves on completely different pages. The house we live in was my house. He has a house elsewhere that he worked hard to get and loves so does not want to sell it or rent it out (which I can understand) so it is a kind of holiday home (although I am not allowed to call it that!). A couple of years ago when the interest rates went up it was decided (I thought WE had decided but...) that hubbie would use 50k he had invested to pay off part of the mortgage, I also paid 50k at the same time, leaving us with only a small mortgage but naturally we both had a lot less ready cash. Simple, so I thought. Now, he is saying that this has used up a lot of his liquid assets and the deal was that it was the best use of the money at the time but that he thought he would get it back and now I am going back on what we discussed by clearly having no intention paying it back. I am flabbergasted and completely confused. He says he is really cross that I have gone against what was discussed. I of course assumed that once money goes to the mortgage that's it, you don't expect someone to reimburse you. In his defence, he is referring to the fact that I have rental properties that I had said could be used to pay off the mortgage, but that was my plan before we were married, since then I was really thinking that these will be a retirement fund, particularly as now is such a bad time to sell. He worries about money a lot and has been unemployed for a few months (between contracts) and doesn't cope with this uncertainly and stress. But this is not the first time he's mentioned it, before was when he was in a very well paid contract. Overall we are really financially secure and have no reason to worry, certainly a lot better off than most. However he still sees things very much 'yours' and 'mine' and cannot see 'ours'. I won't change his attitude, but am I losing my mind thinking that it was fair to assume that the money he paid off the mortgage was put into the joint property, out home and that's that? He says I should not have assumed that.

OP posts:
AskMeMore · 08/05/2023 16:46

BadNomad · 08/05/2023 16:13

It sounds like he wants to keep the houses separate. He owns his house and you own the house you're all living in. I'm guessing he sees it as he's paying "rent" for living there and the £50k was a loan to help you out by reducing the overall mortgage. But he wants his £50k back now because he's worried about money. He doesn't want your house.

But he isn't paying rent. £150 a month is way below any market rent in a house share.

Ffsmakeitstop · 08/05/2023 16:36

His argument doesn't make sense. I don't think it sounds like he offered a loan in the first instance. If he had done that op would have gone with her original plan to maybe sell one of her rental properties.
I don't know the answer though.

StrawberryWater · 08/05/2023 16:35

You need to go and see a solicitor.

The only thing that should be protected is his 50k (and any other money he’s paid towards the mortgage) which I would find a way to release back to him (either by selling a rental property or whatever other means you have) since he’s being so ridiculous about it.

After that you should make sure that everything you own is protected and protected for your daughter. Your house will likely be regarded as a pre marital asset and I would make sure he couldn’t touch it, my money or any assets going forward and once he has his precious 50k back you wouldn’t need to give him any more money (and certainly not half of your home).

EllaPaella · 08/05/2023 16:30

This is bonkers. You are married so you both own equal share of the house you are living in by default.
If you aren't married then obviously you should be putting him on the mortgage now that he has invested so much of his own money.
Are you actually married OP?

Aquamarine1029 · 08/05/2023 16:20

This doesn't bode well for your marriage, at all.

I would be making sure, right now, that your child's inheritance is 100% protected should you suddenly die. I wouldn't trust him as far as I could throw him.

JudgeRudy · 08/05/2023 16:19

Your situation brings to mind one of the first adult books l read as a teen, The Pearl by John Steinbeck. Rather than bringing Kino and his family good fortune, it stopped them from enjoying the life they had. Ultimately insecurity and mistrust destroyed them.
Your husband could do well to read it and take heed.

notquitesoyoung · 08/05/2023 16:18

What's the regular monthly household split like? Is the burden of DH's empty house solely on him or are marital funds contributing to those costs?

BadNomad · 08/05/2023 16:13

It sounds like he wants to keep the houses separate. He owns his house and you own the house you're all living in. I'm guessing he sees it as he's paying "rent" for living there and the £50k was a loan to help you out by reducing the overall mortgage. But he wants his £50k back now because he's worried about money. He doesn't want your house.

GOODCAT · 08/05/2023 16:05

I can see his point of view. You keep your finances separate, so he pays off £50,000 from a debt you owe. In his position I would either want to be repaid or to get £50,000 worth of interest in the house it is secured against which is still solely owned by you. What happens on death or divorce isn't relevant.

If on the other hand, you joined your finances and put everything in joint names, that would be different.

If he told you it was a gift, that would also be different.

It sounds as though you didn't discuss it and both made assumptions.

whynotwhatknot · 08/05/2023 16:01

yeah tell him you'll pay t back monthly

how the ell does he expect you to raise 50k and at what point did he say he wanted it back

whattheactual121 · 08/05/2023 15:58

Napoleonsjosephine · 08/05/2023 15:54

Sorry I’m confused, why do you call out his house and drop in like it’s irrelevant uou own multiple properties and had committed to using those to pay the mortgage?

i can only assume it’s to sway answers to agree with you, if so, what’s the point of this, do you Reallu need the validation?

I don't see it as calling out - it's relevant to the situation because it is a significant asset so it's not like he has nothing, plus it is not contributing. My rentals provide income that supports the family. The house we live in is our home. Having another 'home' is a luxury.

OP posts:
LakieLady · 08/05/2023 15:57

PollyPeptide · 08/05/2023 15:07

No, because her house is her house. She's the only person on the deeds. And his house is his. He's the only person on the deeds.

I don't know what was said in the discussion. This is clearly what the op thought was being agreed on. But maybe he doesn't agree that's what was discussed.

It doesn't necessarily work like that in the event of a split though. In a divorce, the matrimonial home is an asset of the marriage, even if it's only in the name of one party (as I know to my cost).
'

Napoleonsjosephine · 08/05/2023 15:54

Sorry I’m confused, why do you call out his house and drop in like it’s irrelevant uou own multiple properties and had committed to using those to pay the mortgage?

i can only assume it’s to sway answers to agree with you, if so, what’s the point of this, do you Reallu need the validation?

AskMeMore · 08/05/2023 15:50

And do not put him on the deeds but allow him to keep his assets for himself.

AskMeMore · 08/05/2023 15:47

If he really wants 50/50 pay him back and charge him market rent and stop paying more than half your fair share.
You are either partners who share money, or you are 50/50 properly. What he wants advantages him financially to your detriment.

EvelynKatie · 08/05/2023 15:46

I thought you couldn’t be on deeds without being on the mortgage? He would then have to pay stamp duty based on the mortgage.

PollyPeptide · 08/05/2023 15:45

whattheactual121 · 08/05/2023 15:08

I've suggested putting him on the deeds and he's not interested. It's all about the cash.

If you'd said that at the time of paying off the mortgage, his name was put on thedeeds, I'd say he shouldn't expect his 50k back. But that didn't happen. The offer of it now is not useful to him because he needs the cash. It doesn't matter whether in practical terms he needs it or not, emotionally he clearly does.
I don't know how long he's been living on his own for but it does often change your mindset to your financial situation and your sense of security and independence.

Desperatelyseekingcommonsense · 08/05/2023 15:39

So are you now supposed to remortgage for 100k. He has 50 you have 50 to invest then both pay half the mortgage or are you supposed to sell your assets so he can live at low cost?

Honestly the fairest thing is if he gives you half the value of the house minus 50k and goes on the deeds. If he doesn’t want to own your house then he should pay rent.

Mortimercat · 08/05/2023 15:37

whattheactual121 · 08/05/2023 14:13

Well you are right that we did not discuss terms. I really didn't think it was necessary! I suppose that's what I am asking, AIBU to think that this is a very normal and straightforward thing. We were just paying off part of the mortgage of a house that we both live in, that is our home. We are married so it will be his if anything happens to me anyway. If we divorce he can take half the house anyway!
To be clear, it is the mortgage on the house we live in (that was mine before, the mortgage is in my name only, he does not want to be on the mortgage). The house he has has no mortgage. We split the mortgage payments each month, but it is only around £150 each.

Well you marriage is pretty short so no things won’t be split 50:50 should you divorce in the early days. If you split up within the next couple of years, he is actually quite exposed as you haven’t put the house in joint names. It is all quite a confusing set up and I think you should have discussed it a bit better beforehand.

Starseeking · 08/05/2023 15:35

This really sounds like he is cross he no longer has his £50k to hand, despite living almost rent-free (paying minimal expenses).

I would remortgage the house you both live in to shut him up on this point.

Going forward, I would charge him the monthly going rate for a spare room with all bills included in your town.

Keep all your properties in your name, and see a solicitor/accountant tomorrow about wrapping all your assets into a trust for your DC, in case the worst happens to you.

As you are married, there is a real risk that everything (unless you take proactive steps to avoid it) will go to him on your death, and given he's fighting about this £50k when you are alive, I can't see him willingly making provision for your DC if you are not around.

MrJollyLivesNextDoor · 08/05/2023 15:28

Tinkerbyebye · 08/05/2023 15:23

Personally I would look into a remortgage for the £50k and then tell him that his share will be xx to cover it, as you have invested £50k to reduce the mortgage so won’t be paying extra, and at tha5 time he can go on the deeds

the other option is to sell a rental and repay the whole mortgage, but with him not in the deeds. I would the. I would also ensure all rental properties are in your name only as well as any other assets and would separate all finances

I would then change my will to make sure that everything goes to your daughter as he has his own house anyway

This would be my course of action aswell

Tinkerbyebye · 08/05/2023 15:23

Personally I would look into a remortgage for the £50k and then tell him that his share will be xx to cover it, as you have invested £50k to reduce the mortgage so won’t be paying extra, and at tha5 time he can go on the deeds

the other option is to sell a rental and repay the whole mortgage, but with him not in the deeds. I would the. I would also ensure all rental properties are in your name only as well as any other assets and would separate all finances

I would then change my will to make sure that everything goes to your daughter as he has his own house anyway

primoseyellow · 08/05/2023 15:21

I can understand you ring fencing some of your assets for your daughter in your will.
But you are married and a team so I would not expect the money to be paid back, surely its all joint now as husband and wife.

It sounds like you are flatmates, lending and borrowing money and keeping a tally. How do you manage day to day expenses?

Changeling78 · 08/05/2023 15:20

What’s his deal with his house? Why can’t he a) live in it or b) make use of it. Also, why did he put 50k off the mortgage if he was going to ask for it back?

OnMyWayToSenility · 08/05/2023 15:17

I'd want to know why he suddenly needs 50k???

He's being completely unreasonable and there will be a reason why he needs this money.

I agree with you, he's being selfish and there are other things at play here.