Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think that if your partner pays part of the mortgage off you are not then expected to pay them back!

114 replies

whattheactual121 · 08/05/2023 13:56

So, this is really difficult to explain but here goes. My husband and I have been married for 3 years. I have a daughter from a previous marriage (deceased husband). We are really happy and have a great life but we have very different attitudes to money and we seem to talk about it a lot and find ourselves on completely different pages. The house we live in was my house. He has a house elsewhere that he worked hard to get and loves so does not want to sell it or rent it out (which I can understand) so it is a kind of holiday home (although I am not allowed to call it that!). A couple of years ago when the interest rates went up it was decided (I thought WE had decided but...) that hubbie would use 50k he had invested to pay off part of the mortgage, I also paid 50k at the same time, leaving us with only a small mortgage but naturally we both had a lot less ready cash. Simple, so I thought. Now, he is saying that this has used up a lot of his liquid assets and the deal was that it was the best use of the money at the time but that he thought he would get it back and now I am going back on what we discussed by clearly having no intention paying it back. I am flabbergasted and completely confused. He says he is really cross that I have gone against what was discussed. I of course assumed that once money goes to the mortgage that's it, you don't expect someone to reimburse you. In his defence, he is referring to the fact that I have rental properties that I had said could be used to pay off the mortgage, but that was my plan before we were married, since then I was really thinking that these will be a retirement fund, particularly as now is such a bad time to sell. He worries about money a lot and has been unemployed for a few months (between contracts) and doesn't cope with this uncertainly and stress. But this is not the first time he's mentioned it, before was when he was in a very well paid contract. Overall we are really financially secure and have no reason to worry, certainly a lot better off than most. However he still sees things very much 'yours' and 'mine' and cannot see 'ours'. I won't change his attitude, but am I losing my mind thinking that it was fair to assume that the money he paid off the mortgage was put into the joint property, out home and that's that? He says I should not have assumed that.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Mix56 · 08/05/2023 21:20

I think you need to pay him back, only because he's a as Dick, & Id want the security of owning my own house,
He can then pay rent ti you, or the equivalent if half your new mortgage repayments, in food, insurance etc.
I would leave all my money to my child.
He wants "separate" give it to him

Firstmonthfree · 08/05/2023 19:44

I would rewrite the wills to leave everything in trust to your daughter. I don’t know why you would leave him the house or anything while he is such a tight-fisted bastard.

I would stop paying for any fun stuff beyond the things that you really want and only pay your and your daughters shares on days out.

id ask him to sign a document stating he has no interest in the house and start on a repayment plan for the £50k on that basis.

if he wants anything like his share of food shopping paid for whilst he’s between contracts then you can take that out of the repayment money.

ThinWomansBrain · 08/05/2023 19:33

@xyxygy £150 a month - the OP must have had some equity in the property when he moved in.

theGooHasGone · 08/05/2023 18:59

Would you have put 50k down on the mortgage if he hadn't done the same? Assuming you each pay half the mortgage per month, it doesn't seem fair that you'd pay down a chunk of your own cash while he keeps his, given that he's also now benefitting from lower monthly payments for the roof over his head - especially useful when you don't have much income.

If he can't get his head around the idea then seemingly the only choice is to do what others suggest earlier - remortgage the house to get 100k out of it and pay each of you your 50k back. Then weep at the pointlessness of the entire thing.

I feel like there's a lot more that isn't being addressed here in terms of how bills are split and how blended your finances are as a whole. It's odd to me that he seems to want to keep this 50k totally separate given that you're married. What does he even want the money for? Someone offering him 20% returns on a crypto scam?!

whattheactual121 · 08/05/2023 18:38

xyxygy · 08/05/2023 17:49

Where was it said that he's refusing to be on the deeds of the house? As far as I can see, he only said he didn't want to be on the mortgage.

He also said he's not interested in being on the deeds - doesn't solve anything as far as he's concerned.

OP posts:
FictionalCharacter · 08/05/2023 18:35

MrJollyLivesNextDoor · 08/05/2023 14:27

So he had £50k readily available

He used this to pay down the mortgage (you did the same) leaving a small mortgage with low monthly repayments

He is now saying he expected to get this money back

Where from exactly?? It's paid down the mortgage! Does he expect you to remortgage now to repay him? What on Earth would have been the point of it all??

Exactly. It’s bizarre for him to want the money “back” at this point, if that wasn’t what was agreed at the time.

Godlovesall26 · 08/05/2023 18:34

This is way too complicated for me, but the only thing I’d say is consult a solicitor on your own to very clearly ring fence your daughter’s assets should anything happen to you.
I have no clue who’s right or wrong, the whole thing seems strange, I wouldn’t count on him being the noble guardian who leaves everything to your daughter (no clue of your and DD ages, but he could remarry for ex). Either way I’d just focus on your daughter, and I guess you’ll see with time how he evolves, but he’s not someone I’d trust to financially manage my child at this stage anyway.

GracePalmer33 · 08/05/2023 18:27

I don't understand the situation - too many houses and information is too confusing.

sandyhappypeople · 08/05/2023 18:20

It makes sense to me..

he obviously had plenty of capital when the 50k was paid into the mortgage and plenty of work lined up, now his work has dried up, and he’s worried he’s going to run out of funds, if that’s genuinely the case, then he was in too precarious of a position to offer the 50k in the first place, he’s assert rich and cash poor, unless there’s something going on with his finances that you aren’t privy to?

If it was a ‘loan’ I find it hard to believe that he wouldn’t have made sure you knew that was the case to be honest, but if you’re in a position to remortgage one of your rentals I’d be inclined to give him the 50k back and draw a line under it.

theres tax implications and complications if you start changing ownership of properties over so it makes sense to keep them separate, but because of the complexities of the situation it would be prudent to get some legal/financial advice if you haven’t already, for your daughters sake more than anything.

frankgu · 08/05/2023 18:00

You have rental properties (plural), own your own home and he has a house as well. So as a couple you have a minimum of 4 properties (morally suspect) and you are fighting over money. Whole situation is tasteless to me.

It's all a bit bizarre

phishfoodforlife · 08/05/2023 17:59

The OP said earlier he needs to be on the deeds but he brushes it off @xyxygy

Wishihadanalgorithm · 08/05/2023 17:58

I think you should give him the £50k back. Then you both see a solicitor and each ring fence your respective properties so, that should you split, neither gets a penny from the other’s properties.

He also has to pay rent to live in your property, just one lump sum and the OP manages all of the bills, rather like a landlady.

This sounds quite cold but if DH wants “fair” then give him fair.

xyxygy · 08/05/2023 17:52

ThinWomansBrain · 08/05/2023 17:50

He is living in your house that he feels no obligation to contribute towards?
Charge him rent.
Back rent for the last three years will resolve a chunk of the £50k, ongoing rent will pay it off, then you'll be quids in.

Errr...it's already been said that he pays half the mortgage on top of the £50k he put in. How is that not contributing?

ThinWomansBrain · 08/05/2023 17:50

He is living in your house that he feels no obligation to contribute towards?
Charge him rent.
Back rent for the last three years will resolve a chunk of the £50k, ongoing rent will pay it off, then you'll be quids in.

xyxygy · 08/05/2023 17:49

phishfoodforlife · 08/05/2023 17:44

Yes this! Putting aside the other properties for a moment, having a house sat empty is disgusting.

I'm really confused by all this because this guy is refusing to be on the deeds or the mortgage but willingly put 50k into the house with no discussion about needing this back. I would wonder if he is planning to leave and doesn't think he'll get this money back if they divorce.

Where was it said that he's refusing to be on the deeds of the house? As far as I can see, he only said he didn't want to be on the mortgage.

phishfoodforlife · 08/05/2023 17:44

Dungaree · 08/05/2023 15:11

You have rental properties (plural), own your own home and he has a house as well. So as a couple you have a minimum of 4 properties (morally suspect) and you are fighting over money. Whole situation is tasteless to me.

Yes this! Putting aside the other properties for a moment, having a house sat empty is disgusting.

I'm really confused by all this because this guy is refusing to be on the deeds or the mortgage but willingly put 50k into the house with no discussion about needing this back. I would wonder if he is planning to leave and doesn't think he'll get this money back if they divorce.

FishChipsMushyPeas · 08/05/2023 17:29

who does his house go to in the event of his death? I can't understand him allowing it to sit empty.

theGooHasGone · 08/05/2023 17:24

whattheactual121 · 08/05/2023 14:50

A lot of this is emotional. He doesn't want to be on the mortgage as he is mortgage free and doesn't want to be saddles with a mortgage again (albeit a tiny one). The 'holiday house' cannot be rented out as he does not want anyone else there. It took me a long time to feel accepted there, but that's a whole other story!

I get that, but if he cares so much about being mortgage free I don't quite see why he gave you 50k towards a house that he has no rigid legal claim to outside of a short marriage. He should have just shouldered the increased monthly interest payments. I agree that if he wants his money back so badly then you can start charging him back rent for the lack of contribution to the family home.

Tell him to get over himself and rents his house out if he feels 'cash poor'. Your house is lived in; his can be as well.

I couldn't agree more with this comment. He either needs to shit or get off the pot. At the moment it sounds a lot like he's keeping the other property as a "backup" in case this life doesn't work out and he needs somewhere to go and live in a hurry. It's very bizarre to have a property just collecting dust that nobody is allowed to live in.

Keha · 08/05/2023 17:09

I'm not sure on this one. I can see a scenario where you don't discuss it in that much detail so he sees it as more of a loan/money he'd get back and you see it differently. I get that you are married but I think if you have relatively separate finances then I wouldn't necessarily feel comfortable handing over 50k towards a house I don't actually own. I imagine his issue is less about what he would get if you died/divorced and more about how much readily available cash he has. I think I would be asking him what he expects you to do to pay it back? Sell a rental property? How does he feel about money generally? Is it separate or combined? DH and I have fully combined finances so this wouldn't be an issue for us but that potentially has other complications.

Oldnproud · 08/05/2023 17:01

caringcarer · 08/05/2023 16:53

Do by both paying off £50k on your house each the mortgage is only £300 pcm. What would it be if neither of you paid £50k off of the mortgage? I'd give him back the £50k even if I had to get a loan. But I'd be charging him half of what mortgage would have cost if neither paid off £50k and I'd be making my will out in favour of DC. He sounds obsessed with money. The fact is he has a house, empty that could be let out if he needs money. He chooses to keep it empty and still has to pay £5k a year on expenses for it. I hope this comes from his money not yours or joint money. He should pay half of all bills e.g. gas, electricity, water, council tax and food as he'd have to pay those wherever he lived. I'd also be telling him being mean with money is not a good look and you don't find it attractive.

Yes, this is pretty much how my mind is working, too.

NurseCranesRolodex · 08/05/2023 16:59

Is he on your mortgage, in your will etc? Are you an equal partner in his other assets? Have you got all this written down so that he can't claim ownership over your DD should anything happen to you, have you safe guarded the money that would have been due to only your daughter from her late DF's share in your property? Get it sorted, sounds like a bloody mess....

PollyPeptide · 08/05/2023 16:59

LakieLady · 08/05/2023 15:57

It doesn't necessarily work like that in the event of a split though. In a divorce, the matrimonial home is an asset of the marriage, even if it's only in the name of one party (as I know to my cost).
'

Wouldn't that depend on how long you were married for, though? I can't think that 3 years would give him much if any stake.

MrsTerryPratchett · 08/05/2023 16:53

Legal advice.

Counselling.

caringcarer · 08/05/2023 16:53

Do by both paying off £50k on your house each the mortgage is only £300 pcm. What would it be if neither of you paid £50k off of the mortgage? I'd give him back the £50k even if I had to get a loan. But I'd be charging him half of what mortgage would have cost if neither paid off £50k and I'd be making my will out in favour of DC. He sounds obsessed with money. The fact is he has a house, empty that could be let out if he needs money. He chooses to keep it empty and still has to pay £5k a year on expenses for it. I hope this comes from his money not yours or joint money. He should pay half of all bills e.g. gas, electricity, water, council tax and food as he'd have to pay those wherever he lived. I'd also be telling him being mean with money is not a good look and you don't find it attractive.

IloveJudgeJudy · 08/05/2023 16:46

Who pays the cost of his house that’s standing empty?

If you return the £50k will his rent and expenses go up accordingly?