Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask how you came to terms with the fact a relative was not going to change

53 replies

horismallow · 08/05/2023 13:07

My sister doesn’t treat me very well and I don’t think she has capacity or wish to change. I feel sad in some ways as our kids will never grow up knowing each other well or seeing each other as cousins aside from very occasionally at their grandparents house

DH is an only child so we’ve no other adult relatives of our age or even close which is sad to think about. My wish for closeness within the wider family is meaning I am putting up with unsavoury treatment from my sister when what I really need to do is accept she’s not going to change and come to terms with this. Does anyone have any tips?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
ZoraMipha · 09/05/2023 05:52

HamBone · 08/05/2023 22:34

This is a great way to approach family relationships, @ZoraMipha , I wish my Dad was like you!

This is the approach we’ve taken with DH’s family, they’re all nice enough people, but we know that we couldn’t turn to his parents or siblings in an emergency or crisis, they simply wouldn’t help us, because they don’t care that much. So we have no expectations of them, we’re all nice to each other on a superficial level-but good friends are the people we can rely on.

It makes me abit sad if I think about it as I’d like to be part of a close knit family so I deliberately don’t think about it. Brooding wouldn’t change anything.

I have just found a lot of comfort in friends to be honest and I find that I love my best friends in just the same way as family.

I'm part of a close-knit friendship group and really that is a family :)

EineReiseDurchDieZeit · 08/05/2023 23:58

I was doing amazingly well at close to no contact with my sibling - a hopefully temporary situation has put the mockers on this. The day I never have to see them again will be like a weight lifted

OrderOfTheKookaburra · 08/05/2023 23:51

One of my sisters absolutely WOULD respond and help in an emergency and that's what makes it so very sad. But in day to day life she is so bloody bossy she seems to think I am completely incapable of adulting and constantly lectures me on what I should be doing, down to the most minor of things.

She will always focus on the negative aspect of what I am saying rather than just sympathising (can't complain about a colleague's behaviour as I will just get a lecture on my inadequate people management skills, and not just be allowed to offload because that person is a dick and today I'd had enough). It's exhausting.

When I've pulled her up on it she is very tearful that I feel like this and manages to hold her tongue for a few weeks but then reverts back.

She doesn't INTEND to be horrid. She says she absolutely respects me as an adult and is gobsmacked at how I've felt over what she has said. A lot of it comes from being over protective of me as I've gone through some seriously horrid crap in my life.

I'm just so sad I can't just chat to her anymore because she always has to be right and the advisor. She is incapable of stopping, no matter how many times I have pulled her up on it and she has tried to reign it in. What is ridiculous is that they are about inconsequential things eg she likes being minimalist and she kept on lecturing me on reducing how much stuff I have even though I told her I would NEVER want to be minimalist like that. According to her when you need something you go out and buy only what you need. Never buy things on special, never buy the cheaper, larger pack, because you buy it ONLY when you absolutely need it or you might buy too much if you buy on special and have to (shock, horror) store it until you might need it again.... and she will go on and on and on about these stupid inconsequential things until I pretend I have to get off the phone due to x, y or z.

She's mildly bossy with another sibling that she is in contact with, and not at all bossy with a second. But the remaining siblings also have little to do with her because of what she is like.

I don't want to go NC, but I am just so sad that I can only talk about meaningless inconsequential things because it's hurtful when she behaves like this over things that actually matter to me.

SoyMarina · 08/05/2023 23:09

So much great advice on this thread.
I am lucky to live in a different country to my relatives so maintaining ‘low contact’ is very easy.
I used to dread having to go back for family occasions but since my father died 2 years ago (my mother died some years before him) I finally feel free!

Sunnycornwallanddevon · 08/05/2023 22:59

HamBone · 08/05/2023 22:45

I’m sorry that you’re experiencing this as well, @Sunnycornwallanddevon. It’s so frustrating, because you just want to have a nice relationship with them for the remaining years, but they can be so nasty! It’s not cognitive issues such as dementia, it’s bad temper and enjoying having a go at someone!

One of my friends has problems with her Mum and we’ve agreed that at least we’re learning how NOT to behave towards our adult children. 😂

Totally agree! It's so sad and depressing, the Stately Homes thread on here has helped me enormously, have you ever looked at it? xx

HamBone · 08/05/2023 22:45

I’m sorry that you’re experiencing this as well, @Sunnycornwallanddevon. It’s so frustrating, because you just want to have a nice relationship with them for the remaining years, but they can be so nasty! It’s not cognitive issues such as dementia, it’s bad temper and enjoying having a go at someone!

One of my friends has problems with her Mum and we’ve agreed that at least we’re learning how NOT to behave towards our adult children. 😂

Sunnycornwallanddevon · 08/05/2023 22:39

HamBone · 08/05/2023 18:35

The best way I've coped with this is by mentally disconnecting from relatives who I know won't change . I've not gone NC with anyone but am what you would describe as low contact.

@Hadroncollideer This is how I cope with my elderly Dad (85). He’s often horrible to me, but I know he only has a few years left so I help and support him, but I’m emotionally detached. When he’s being horrible, it just washes over me. I know my Auntie feels the same way, she helps because he’s old and unwell, but he’s destroyed any feeling we had towards him. 🤷

Absolutely the same situation here, hugs to you xxx

Annoyingwurringnoise · 08/05/2023 22:39

I’ve had this with my mother. I have excepted that she is who she is and she can’t and won’t change. I’ve still had to go no contact with her though because I found her toxicity too much. She’s fine most of the time, but I’m so on edge walking on eggshells and dreading her next attack that I find it emotionally damaging to be in her company. It’s not what I’d choose, but for the sake of my own self preservation I’ve been left with no other option.

Thepossibility · 08/05/2023 22:38

My priority is raising my children to be healthy, happy, well rounded individuals.
Them listening to adults spewing toxicity and seeing their mother accept being treated poorly because “family" is very damaging for them. So the toxic people are completely cut off.
They chose the behaviour, they chose the consequences.

HamBone · 08/05/2023 22:34

ZoraMipha · 08/05/2023 18:59

I accept my family for who they are and I love them all, but mostly I try not to place expectations on them. They are who they are and some of them are very different to me. Thats OK.

I have filled a lot of gaps by making good, solid friendships who have a more similar outlook to me.

This is a great way to approach family relationships, @ZoraMipha , I wish my Dad was like you!

This is the approach we’ve taken with DH’s family, they’re all nice enough people, but we know that we couldn’t turn to his parents or siblings in an emergency or crisis, they simply wouldn’t help us, because they don’t care that much. So we have no expectations of them, we’re all nice to each other on a superficial level-but good friends are the people we can rely on.

It makes me abit sad if I think about it as I’d like to be part of a close knit family so I deliberately don’t think about it. Brooding wouldn’t change anything.

CuriouslyDifferent · 08/05/2023 22:32

Stop eating your time.

There’s two types of family…. Those related by blood, those who choose to be.

Focus on those who choose to be. Blood is thicker, but can just bing up the works if it’s not the right kind.

I binned off my entire family about 15 years ago. I have no regrets. I have a happier life filled with people who care, that I care about. My sister and father, are very welcome to each other and think I’m the odd one out. I’m fact I stepped outside my family bubble of weirdness to understand what they have/do/behave like, isn’t normal, healthy or good for anyone.

XBealtaine · 08/05/2023 22:26

I dont know how to do that. I'm on my second therapist now. Still no idea how to give up.

CheersForThatEh · 08/05/2023 22:24

Build your own life and accept you arent friends.

TakeMe2Insanity · 08/05/2023 22:24

I’m not going into specifics but you really need to work hard. You need to almost mourn that the relative that you’d ideally like doesn’t exist and the relative who you have is reality. Once that’s done you you’ll find it easier to not look at said relative in a wistful manner, wanting the close family because the reality of what you want can’t happen because they aren’t that person.

XBealtaine · 08/05/2023 22:23

@wychiep00 ☕💐

Coffeeisnecessary · 08/05/2023 22:20

Thank you for this thread op. I feel a lot of grief for my family set up not being what I hoped it would be, I'm grateful for a lot in my life but I always expected different relationships which are just not possible with the family members I have. It's useful to read the way others deal with it.

wychiep00 · 08/05/2023 22:10

ugh LESS than!

wychiep00 · 08/05/2023 22:09

I spent 50 years chasing after my mother begging her to love me. She never changed, consistently choosing the sibling who abused and SA'd me over me. She's been gone 13 years now; I am NC with my 3 siblings. The abuser is dead to me, one brother is as narcissistic as my mother was, and the third? His wife became so verbally abusive to me that I had to go NC with them as well.

It's been years and years of therapy to accept that there was NEVER anything I could have done to change them and that continuing to allow them to treat me with anything left than respect was killing me. I don't really miss them anymore. I miss the illusion that our family was fine and I just needed to find the right key to fit in. I mourn the family I should have had and didn't. But I am so much more content now, and the energy I'm no longer spending on them is being poured into my 19 year old niece and the baby she's giving birth to on Friday. I feel at peace with it all now.

ZoraMipha · 08/05/2023 18:59

I accept my family for who they are and I love them all, but mostly I try not to place expectations on them. They are who they are and some of them are very different to me. Thats OK.

I have filled a lot of gaps by making good, solid friendships who have a more similar outlook to me.

Totalwasteofpaper · 08/05/2023 18:47

I'm with @Bargellobitch on this.

With my family members who i cant / wont go NC with.
i just very carefully manage any/all interactions to set us up for minimum friction / maximum success. Sometimes it works sometimes not.

I also imagine they are characters (like in immersive theatre) not real people and then i care alot less when they say horrific things because i find it funny.

One family member congratulated me on my baby dd not having "a scrap of fat on her" and that it was good she wouldnt have weight problems like i do . It just nuts. You cant take it seriously...

StellaF · 08/05/2023 18:39

I distanced myself from my sister more than 10 years ago and have never regretted it. She died last year without us having any kind of reconciliation, my brother keeps trying to make me feel bad about myself for this. I don’t and I won’t. If he keeps pushing it, I’ll grey rock him too.

HamBone · 08/05/2023 18:35

The best way I've coped with this is by mentally disconnecting from relatives who I know won't change . I've not gone NC with anyone but am what you would describe as low contact.

@Hadroncollideer This is how I cope with my elderly Dad (85). He’s often horrible to me, but I know he only has a few years left so I help and support him, but I’m emotionally detached. When he’s being horrible, it just washes over me. I know my Auntie feels the same way, she helps because he’s old and unwell, but he’s destroyed any feeling we had towards him. 🤷

TheShellBeach · 08/05/2023 18:05

Also, I know perfectly well that my children cannot bear either of my sisters. So I've thing them they I do not even want my sisters at my funeral.

TheShellBeach · 08/05/2023 18:03

horismallow · 08/05/2023 17:53

Thank you. Do you ever review it with yours? Or is it your final choice?

Just occasionally, I ask myself if I'd like to see my older sister.
Then I remember what she did to me and my children, and what she has said about other people (so I know she'd be saying similar things about me) and I shrug. And realize that I do not need that cruelty and negativity in my life.