Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think it's ok for my baby to gag while learning to eat solids?

32 replies

TheBerry · 08/05/2023 12:25

First of all, I HATE seeing my baby gag. It makes my heart stop. I'm terrified he'll choke.

However, I've done my research and read everything the NHS and WHO has to say and watched videos and they're all saying that although a baby gagging can look alarming it's normal and even a necessary part of development.

My boy is nearly 8 months, has no teeth yet, but is advanced with his motor skills. We give him toast and soft cooked veg and sometimes he gags a bit but not too much.

Today I was at my mum's and he was really shovelling the toast in and then he started gagging quite loudly and threw up the milk he'd just drank. He was fine and kept trying to eat more toast after.

I did find it scary to watch but I knew he was gagging not choking. I tried to be calm about it. Mum was horrified and thinks he was close to choking and that babies shouldn't be allowed to gag.

I showed her stuff from the NHS website and a video of a baby gagging which looked and sounded similar to what had just happened. She says she just disagrees with the NHS.

I'll admit I'd be quite happy to not feed him finger foods because the gagging does scare me but at the same time I'm trying to be rational. Mum just thinks it's wrong and that I won't listen to anybody else's opinion - but it's not my opinion per se it's the NHS's!

AIBU and he shouldn't be allowed to gag that much? Or is that amount of gagging ok, even when he throws up?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Skybluepinky · 08/05/2023 17:56

Perfectly normal for them to gag, make an appointment with yr HV and see if there are any weaning courses available or they would be able to go through it with u.

Tessisme · 08/05/2023 17:54

I just feel so rattled and my confidence has gone because mum had such a strong reaction to it and we argued.

Please don't let this undermine your confidence. You are tuned into your own baby, you've done your research and you know that gagging is normal (if a bit scary). A baby's gag reflex is activated sooner than that of an older child or adult. My MIL was horrified at the amount of food DS1 used to cram in his mouth. She would say 'That baby's going to choke'. Not even using his name - that baby - as if she was disassociating herself from the imagined medical emergency that was about to unfold😂 'That baby' is almost 15 and still shovels his food down like a gannet!

You're doing a great jobFlowers

yummiee · 08/05/2023 15:46

I'm with your mum. I don't like it at all. I saw it as a sign that they're not quite ready yet with both of mine.

My son also gagged on toast and threw up. I took it easier for a while and tried again a month or so later and then it never happened again.

Eventually they'll learn, no need to watch them gagging and no need to be really competitive with the weaning/ finger foods if you ask me. There's so much pressure today to get them to eat by themselves really early. Both of mine were weaned in a very relaxed way and it they gagged on stuff I took a step back for a bit. Eventually they both learned. Even if some babies were ' ahead ' at some points during the process, it wasn't a big deal.

By the time they were 1, they'd caught up. No harm done and no having to nervously watch my babies gagging and / or throw up. There's too much pressure on it these days. They will learn eventually without having all the gagging and choking. My kids eat fine now and I didn't need to go through prolonged gagging..

Fandabedodgy · 08/05/2023 15:31

Gagging is completely normal. It's how baby stops choking from happening

It's also not the unpleasant experience that adults have.

Gagging is a good thing.

amidsummernightsdream · 08/05/2023 15:29

I know everyone will say its normal but I didnt like it. I still offered finger foods but at our own pace. The ‘throw em anything you’re having’ didnt intuitively feel right to me, so I didn't.

Dixiechickonhols · 08/05/2023 15:23

It definitely depends on intent. If it’s coming from I know best and he’ll only have purée on my watch that’s not on.
If it’s from a I’m not comfortable letting him gag on toast on my watch can he have toast with you for breakfast and I’ll give him whatever you send or some of what we are having whatever you prefer that’s different.
If she’s only minding him occasionally it will be a none issue soon as he will be over gagging.
Different foods at Grandma’s is quite normal my mum used to feed mine custard and rice pudding and other things I never made.
It’s normal to be extra careful when it’s not your child.

MiniStormInATeacup · 08/05/2023 14:20

@Dixiechickonhols I understand your point but I do not understand GP or GP inlaw willfully believing they know best and deciding they will do that and not listening to what is wanted.
I did use childcare and they preferred we had gone down the BLW path as baby was easier for them to feed then purely puree fed babies. But on the occasions baby was left with family I expected some cooperation in carrying out my wishes.
My mum was very good at just going along with what I wanted -MIL not so much. Guess who I ask to look after Baby/child the most now?

@TheBerry you need to decide how important this is to you. There are different foods to try - banana has been suggested. My mum whilst nervous was good at feeding omelet cut into strips and scrambled egg. Brioche toast is slightly softer. Boiled dippy eggs with shell removed. These are foods she can remember feeding me alongside the puree and mushed up veg. You are doing a great job and it is up to you to decide if this is an important issue to stand up for.
A gagging baby Is scary and I do appreciate your mum (or anyone else looking after baby will want to ensure they are ok) but babies actually fo get better and the gagging phase only lasts a short while (if memory serves)

SparklyBlackKitten · 08/05/2023 14:10

Ditch the toast.

MaisieDaisyMay · 08/05/2023 14:07

You're doing well. Keep reading to build your confidence! As a pp mentioned the Gill Rapley book is good. Gagging is important, it teaches them
so much. The book (from
memory, I think it was that one, but there's probably loads online now!) explains which foods are best and what size to cut different things -and why.

I'm 54, so possibly close to your mums age.

my mum lived overseas so that made life easier, she'd have hovered over the babies with the ambulance on speed dial trying to get me to purée everthing 🤣

Donyour research re cooked/uncooked foods & how to cut things for the best, no chocking. gagging fine!!

Dixiechickonhols · 08/05/2023 13:56

MiniStormInATeacup · 08/05/2023 13:05

@Dixiechickonhols the problem I had with my mother and MIL was they were from the puree and spoo. feed generation and I was militantly BLW. When spoon feeding you by pass the gag reflex and don't teach a child where it is which was why I never did it. I also never put any good in babies mouth for them - they did it all by hand so they were in control (I was not happy to find MIL putting strawberries in the babies mouth)

This was my hill and I was prepared to die on it - other stuff didn't bother me and I don't judge how other people feed their children as such - just wanted my choices respected.

Like I said if her mum is minding baby when she works so potentially 15 out of 21 meals a week with grandma then yes it will need addressing and maybe a rethink of childcare.
But if it’s literally granny babysitting one a month or something then it’s not a big issue if granny does things differently.

Curtains70 · 08/05/2023 13:23

TheBerry · 08/05/2023 13:18

@Brunilde yes he shovels it in until it’s a big clump so maybe I need to stop letting him have so much at once.

I just feel so rattled and my confidence has gone because mum had such a strong reaction to it and we argued.

Show her with some other food. Banana is a good one. Toast was always a problem for us because it goes into one big clump. My LO used to store it all in the roof of her mouth like a little hamster and just keep shoving it in!

TheBerry · 08/05/2023 13:20

I’ve told her I just want her to do her own research, rather than just basing her opinions on an emotional/visceral reaction, but she’s straight out said she’s not interested in doing that! Which I do find annoying. Same mindset as an antivaxxer or flat earther or something.

OP posts:
TheBerry · 08/05/2023 13:18

@Brunilde yes he shovels it in until it’s a big clump so maybe I need to stop letting him have so much at once.

I just feel so rattled and my confidence has gone because mum had such a strong reaction to it and we argued.

OP posts:
Hugasauras · 08/05/2023 13:10

Gagging is totally normal. Babies have very sensitive gag reflexes and while they're getting used to food they will gag. Both of mine have gagged while weaning but have never choked. It doesn't sound or look very nice but it's totally normal.

Brunilde · 08/05/2023 13:08

You're right that gagging is absolutely normal but just be aware of the risks of certain foods. Bread and toast were a big issue for as a DS would shove it all in his mouth a d it would clump. This can easily be a choking risk. If they gagged so much they vomited I'd be concerned that could have been choking. Both of mine gagged but only for a second and never threw up because of it.

MiniStormInATeacup · 08/05/2023 13:05

@Dixiechickonhols the problem I had with my mother and MIL was they were from the puree and spoo. feed generation and I was militantly BLW. When spoon feeding you by pass the gag reflex and don't teach a child where it is which was why I never did it. I also never put any good in babies mouth for them - they did it all by hand so they were in control (I was not happy to find MIL putting strawberries in the babies mouth)

This was my hill and I was prepared to die on it - other stuff didn't bother me and I don't judge how other people feed their children as such - just wanted my choices respected.

Abergale · 08/05/2023 13:01

I understand it’s ok /normal but I understand why she worries! As long as she isn’t trying to tell you what to do it doesn’t really matter

MiniStormInATeacup · 08/05/2023 13:01

If you read the Gill (Jill?) Rapley bookd on BLW. She will agree that gagging is totally fine and a normal human reflex that protects babies from choking. Babies gag on food that passes a certain point in their mouth if they haven't properly chewed it and this protects them from choking - something about this being a reflex cave babies would have had as pureed food was unavailable ☺️.

Real choking is much quieter than gagging.

Your baby needs to learn to chew properly and believe me even at 8 months with little to no teeth he will chew his food better than you can imagine. I can remember my 7 month old really gnawing on a steak in a restaurant at this age much to the horror of my family.

bunnypenny · 08/05/2023 13:00

The saying for gagging/choking and when to step in is:

noisy and red, let them go ahead.

quiet and blue, they need help from you.

Dixiechickonhols · 08/05/2023 13:00

Unless she’s minding him full time and feeding him majority of his meals I’d just let her do her thing for the occasional meal.
When he’s at nursery or childminder he’ll be eating different food to what you give.

Teapottie · 08/05/2023 12:58

A baby's gag reflex is further forward in their mouths than ours, so it's partly they're learning and party because of biology effectively why they gag when weaning. It is important to recognise the difference between gagging and choking and personally I'd recommend everyone do a first aid course to build confidence (they're free here for all new parents not sure about in the UK though).

TheBerry · 08/05/2023 12:57

Thanks guys, we did already go on a first aid course with her.

I did try to show her some stuff online but she’ll only read one sentence and then just say stuff like she’s not going to change her mind.

I did try to push it and she’s got angry said I need to let it go, so I’ll just drop it now. Doesn’t matter if she just gives him purées when he’s with her I guess.

OP posts:
Dixiechickonhols · 08/05/2023 12:56

I’d also say that surely it’s better for to intervene too soon than too late, babies and small children have sadly died from choking on food.
It’s not her child and she’s bound to be extra careful.

VestaTilley · 08/05/2023 12:54

I don’t recall my DS gagging, and it’s not something I’d want to risk.

Dixiechickonhols · 08/05/2023 12:53

It sounds quite distressing to watch. Mine never came anywhere near to choking, I suspect your mum is from my era of spoon feeding and mashed food. It would have been seen as bad parenting to let a baby almost choke.
You’ve explained to mum that this is current advice and are carrying on.
I’d not make a big deal if it with mum. And if she is watching him not worry if she doesn’t feed exactly as you do.
Maybe both go on a paediatric first aid course.
Advice changes and by time you are a granny it may well have changed again.