Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DP has loads of ‘stuff’

114 replies

Al991 · 08/05/2023 08:13

I’ve been working really hard to declutter our house because it’s really chaotic and it’s impacting my mental health. We have plenty of space but if feels like we don’t because there’s ‘stuff’ everywhere.

it’s hard to describe what it is! LOTS of old and paperwork, arts and craft stuff, keepsakes etc. I’m starting to realise almost none of it is mine and I have no attachment to it - it love to just see it all go in one fell swoop. My clutter has already been thrown out. I’m not trying to live in a show home here, I just want to be able to live somewhere without dodging literal heaps of miscellaneous items…

I’ve tried to address this with DP before who becomes very agitated, talks about this stuff being important to him, holding memories etc. He mentions that the stuff cost money at the time (of course it did) and it’s a waste to throw out even if it doesn’t get used so in my mind that money is wasted already. He doesn’t seem to see any value in living somewhere that isn’t piled up with clutter. AIBU to wish he would see sense?

OP posts:
KCIII · 09/05/2023 07:34

Sympathies OP, same here. I very little attachment to ‘things’ and get stressed with clutter. When I look in our garage and loft it is full of his stuff that never sees the light of day but that absolutely cannot be touched. In some ways I’ve learned to recognise his feelings are as valid as mine are, yet it does seem it’s me who is doing all the compromising and it causes a lot of issues.

DustyLee123 · 09/05/2023 07:26

My DH had two classic cars he did up, and often they had to go to the garage so that was a cost too. After the last one he got rid of all the stuff and said never again, yet he keeps dropping in the conversation that he wants another. It’s a no from me. If he wants one he can go and live somewhere else with it, I’m not doing that again.

modgepodge · 08/05/2023 22:13

Sirius3030 · 08/05/2023 09:29

Dear heavens. Is this where gaming takes you? I’m glad we never started 😮

He doesn’t really even game any more!! But still won’t get rid of stuff.

He’s currently doing up an old car as a project, this has led to even more crap being left lying around the house. I am hoping this is at least temporary….

Al991 · 08/05/2023 10:27

CeriB82 · 08/05/2023 09:22

I absolutely loathe it. DH is the same.

old football programs
old bank statements
old books form his time at school (he’s fucking 60)
books, old mortgage statements,

everything. It does create a lot of tension

when he’s at work im at work so cant do much as he will watch when i tidy up

i swear when he dies i will have the biggest bonfire

feel free to join me

😂 so glad it’s not just me! The bloody bank statements!!

OP posts:
FangsForTheMemory · 08/05/2023 09:37

If you can get him to sort it out, maybe some of it is saleable? Also once it’s boxed up, I’d have a ‘one in one out’ rule.

Sirius3030 · 08/05/2023 09:29

modgepodge · 08/05/2023 08:25

Fully sympathise as my husband is like this. He likes to buy games consoles and ALL the accessories (special chairs with steering wheels and pedals and stuff built in). Said chair was used for 3 months or so until he completed the game. Once he’s completed it, it won’t be played again. He could have sold the chair at that point for say 50% of what he paid with it. But no. It cluttered the house for 5 or 6 years literally never being used until he was eventually persuaded to sell it for about 10% what it cost. We also have boxes and boxes of games which are never played but can’t possibly be parted with. They are now boxed and waiting to go in the roof (for what purpose, I’m not sure).

I do recommend at least boxing and putting in the attic/garage/spare room.

Dear heavens. Is this where gaming takes you? I’m glad we never started 😮

lavenderlou · 08/05/2023 09:26

Ijustdontcare · 08/05/2023 09:17

Yes, I wonder why your DH is paranoid about you throwing out things that are sentimental to him, It's not like you have been doing it in the past and still do it.

You do know by secretly throwing away stuff you are making hoarding tendencies worse.

I have thrown away about 10 mugs. He has never even noticed.

lavenderlou · 08/05/2023 09:25

There is a big range between a minimalist and a potential hoarder! I'm in no way a minimalist and not particularly houseproud. My house is reasonably cluttered and fairly untidy most of the time, as houses with kids tend to be. However, it's liveable and can be passable for guests within an hour or so.

It would be deeply unpleasant to live in if we didn't contain DH's "stuff". We have a garage that still has unopened boxes from when we moved 8 years ago. There is baby paraphernalia in there although our youngest child is almost 10.

CeriB82 · 08/05/2023 09:22

I absolutely loathe it. DH is the same.

old football programs
old bank statements
old books form his time at school (he’s fucking 60)
books, old mortgage statements,

everything. It does create a lot of tension

when he’s at work im at work so cant do much as he will watch when i tidy up

i swear when he dies i will have the biggest bonfire

feel free to join me

Ijustdontcare · 08/05/2023 09:17

lavenderlou · 08/05/2023 08:33

Cross post. My DH also checks bin bags - even if I'm clearing out the kids stuff. I have learned to do it when nobody is around as I don't want him passing his irrational thoughts onto the DC.

Certain things (eg his ridiculous mug collection) I managed to judiciously reduce over along period of time but that won't solve most of the issues.

Yes, I wonder why your DH is paranoid about you throwing out things that are sentimental to him, It's not like you have been doing it in the past and still do it.

You do know by secretly throwing away stuff you are making hoarding tendencies worse.

Al991 · 08/05/2023 09:10

bussteward · 08/05/2023 09:01

Clutter affects mental health: it’s affecting her, the solution is to bin it all. It’s affecting him because he’s hanging onto, who knows – random old MOT certificates for a car they don’t have, every birthday card he’s ever been given, even the one from a summer job where he can’t remember the people; dried-up paints and glue sticks for craft projects he’ll never do – instead of dealing with his issues. The solution is to deal with his issues and bin it all.

Clutter takes up time: it’s stuff that has to be cleaned, stored, moved, tidied. It also takes up mental space: you can see it, it starts to creep into your brain. Both of those things tend to impact women more as women still bear the brunt of household labour and emotional labour/mental load. It’s not the pile of paperwork that’s the problem so much as having to think about the pile of paperwork: I’m lucky in that both DP and I have an office, so I can have a clear room and he can have his room filled with the stuff. I no longer have to think about it or see it, which reduces my mental load and my physical load – no moving it off the dining table or clearing space on cupboards for actual useful things. It still creeps across the house, though, so before I can start to cook dinner I have to move a pair of sunglasses, a pair of headphones, a tangle of important wires, an iPad, some random bits of post, a jumper, and some tech doodad. That’s a whole extra step before I’ve got out a chopping board, which is harder to get out of the cupboard than it needs to be because of all the sentimental/useful/just in case cooking stuff he insists we hang on to. Life is hard and hours are short: full time jobs, small children, fewer leisure hours – and a lot of time can be clawed back by having less stuff. Not just the time spent hauling it about the house to clear space for tasks, but with less stuff you can have a smaller house, thus a smaller mortgage, thus a less demanding job.

It’s not necessarily minimalism – I own pointless things, like a bud vase. It’s wanting to live your life without having to move junk off a chair before you can even sit down.

1000% this!!!

OP posts:
illiterato · 08/05/2023 09:08

One thing I do ( albeit more for the kids than Dh) is that I have designated “no crap” zones- the main one is the kitchen island which is kept completely clear at all times unless being used to cook/ peel etc. Anything left on there will get binned, or at least I bear no responsibility for what happens to it so no point in them coming up and saying “ but where’s my phone/ magazine/ jumper? I left it here”.

Also everyone has one plastic filing box for stuff that absolutely has to be kept in hard copy. It’s in there or it’s in the bin. Cannot stand piles of paper everywhere

bussteward · 08/05/2023 09:01

Northernparent68 · 08/05/2023 08:35

Why is the minimalist always right on these threads

Clutter affects mental health: it’s affecting her, the solution is to bin it all. It’s affecting him because he’s hanging onto, who knows – random old MOT certificates for a car they don’t have, every birthday card he’s ever been given, even the one from a summer job where he can’t remember the people; dried-up paints and glue sticks for craft projects he’ll never do – instead of dealing with his issues. The solution is to deal with his issues and bin it all.

Clutter takes up time: it’s stuff that has to be cleaned, stored, moved, tidied. It also takes up mental space: you can see it, it starts to creep into your brain. Both of those things tend to impact women more as women still bear the brunt of household labour and emotional labour/mental load. It’s not the pile of paperwork that’s the problem so much as having to think about the pile of paperwork: I’m lucky in that both DP and I have an office, so I can have a clear room and he can have his room filled with the stuff. I no longer have to think about it or see it, which reduces my mental load and my physical load – no moving it off the dining table or clearing space on cupboards for actual useful things. It still creeps across the house, though, so before I can start to cook dinner I have to move a pair of sunglasses, a pair of headphones, a tangle of important wires, an iPad, some random bits of post, a jumper, and some tech doodad. That’s a whole extra step before I’ve got out a chopping board, which is harder to get out of the cupboard than it needs to be because of all the sentimental/useful/just in case cooking stuff he insists we hang on to. Life is hard and hours are short: full time jobs, small children, fewer leisure hours – and a lot of time can be clawed back by having less stuff. Not just the time spent hauling it about the house to clear space for tasks, but with less stuff you can have a smaller house, thus a smaller mortgage, thus a less demanding job.

It’s not necessarily minimalism – I own pointless things, like a bud vase. It’s wanting to live your life without having to move junk off a chair before you can even sit down.

BanditsOnTheHorizon · 08/05/2023 08:59

Can you get him a garden space or garage that he can store his stuff in? That way it's his own space and it's not in the house. Maybe then he'll also realise how much crap, sorry valuable stuff he has

Al991 · 08/05/2023 08:56

I appreciate those suggesting compromise. He is stubborn as a brick wall which makes him lovable in some situations but definitely not this one! That being said, maybe I can make some baby steps with him and get some of those big 64l boxes.

I don’t think the minimalist is ‘always right’ btw. I think I probably am a bit of a minimalist but I’m not exactly Marie Kondo. I’ve got my own stuff I keep that’s sentimental but it fits in one drawer. I feel like DH just buys stuff for no reason with no regard for where it goes.

OP posts:
Cherryana · 08/05/2023 08:45

I think you have to play the long game and ‘step’ this for your husband as it’s emotional not logical.

Do you have anywhere like a shed where this stuff can go? Ask for a compromise- I don’t want to through your stuff away but can we organise it and store it away. You can still get to it but it’s not in the house.

Then get large 64l boxes that stack on one another and put ‘stuff’ in categories.

Once it has been in the shed for 6 months - revisit again with husband and he can say if he has used it or not. He will not get rid of half the stuff - he will still want to keep things. Let him.

Six months later (so a year later) look through it again. And he will voluntarily get rid of more because it will have lost some of its emotional value.

Also the benefits of living in a clutter free environment will start to outweigh the clutter eg easier to clean and keep tidy.

I have done this system before but in a work situation when I was a new manager. I guess I could have binned the stuff but this way I definitely won hearts and minds.

BereavedSid · 08/05/2023 08:41

I love being in holiday accommodation, cleaning up minimal stuff, nothing that will come in handy or has the burden of memories.
DH is pretty ruthless but my mum spent literally decades cleaning around my dad's stuff which always expanded 10% more than the available space. He's not been dead a week and she's cleared an absolute ton.

DustyLee123 · 08/05/2023 08:39

Schroedingersimmigrant · 08/05/2023 08:37

Did you break a gift he got on purpose?
That's low.
Imagine he did that yo your stuff, people would tell you to call Women's aid😳

He accidentally broke something of mine that had great sentimental value. Instead of telling me he disguised what he had done, so I feel no regret.

Schroedingersimmigrant · 08/05/2023 08:37

DustyLee123 · 08/05/2023 08:36

I ‘accidentally’ smashed a brandy glass, when cleaning out the kitchen cupboards, that he never used but had been given to him. The small things do add up and make you feel better.

Did you break a gift he got on purpose?
That's low.
Imagine he did that yo your stuff, people would tell you to call Women's aid😳

travelingtortoise · 08/05/2023 08:37

Northernparent68 · 08/05/2023 08:35

Why is the minimalist always right on these threads

What makes you say she's a minimalist?

Schroedingersimmigrant · 08/05/2023 08:36

Northernparent68 · 08/05/2023 08:35

Why is the minimalist always right on these threads

I do wonder too. I am more concerned about secret throwing stuff away. I would divorce DH if he had so little respect for me and ky things tbh

DustyLee123 · 08/05/2023 08:36

I ‘accidentally’ smashed a brandy glass, when cleaning out the kitchen cupboards, that he never used but had been given to him. The small things do add up and make you feel better.

travelingtortoise · 08/05/2023 08:36

@Al991 it might be embarrassing for guests, AND if it's all in one place like that he may see just how much stuff there really is. When it's scattered all over the place it's hard to understand the quantity.

Do you think he'd be open to that as a compromise to start with?

Northernparent68 · 08/05/2023 08:35

Why is the minimalist always right on these threads

Schroedingersimmigrant · 08/05/2023 08:35

Al991 · 08/05/2023 08:31

To be fair in my head it looks like a hoarders house. In real life it looks like a messy house with probably a bit too much stuff. But in a way I feel that doesn’t matter - it’s affecting my mental health the way it is.

Yeah containing it to one room should work then.

Swipe left for the next trending thread