Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DP has loads of ‘stuff’

114 replies

Al991 · 08/05/2023 08:13

I’ve been working really hard to declutter our house because it’s really chaotic and it’s impacting my mental health. We have plenty of space but if feels like we don’t because there’s ‘stuff’ everywhere.

it’s hard to describe what it is! LOTS of old and paperwork, arts and craft stuff, keepsakes etc. I’m starting to realise almost none of it is mine and I have no attachment to it - it love to just see it all go in one fell swoop. My clutter has already been thrown out. I’m not trying to live in a show home here, I just want to be able to live somewhere without dodging literal heaps of miscellaneous items…

I’ve tried to address this with DP before who becomes very agitated, talks about this stuff being important to him, holding memories etc. He mentions that the stuff cost money at the time (of course it did) and it’s a waste to throw out even if it doesn’t get used so in my mind that money is wasted already. He doesn’t seem to see any value in living somewhere that isn’t piled up with clutter. AIBU to wish he would see sense?

OP posts:
DustyLee123 · 10/05/2023 06:49

Can he have a room in the new house, like a study, where he can display it and clean it himself ?

BatshitCrazyWoman · 10/05/2023 06:17

Will you be the one dusting the stuff 'on display' OP? Because if it's just you cleaning, you get the final say on that!

Some stuff is best in cupboards, and framed photos, plants and vases of flowers are to be displayed. I'd not be able to cope with piles of crockery on shelves 😱

There definitely has to be compromise - not just one person saying I want to keep everything, and the other person having to put up with that. And anyway, eventually there's no room to keep everything in an average UK house.

Very glad I live alone - I have a normal amount of stuff, but like to.donate useful things that I'm not using to charity, so that they can be used by someone else. It seems very wasteful to me to keep stuff but not use it. I have a neat, tidy home with nothing in the loft/garage 😁

Al991 · 10/05/2023 05:45

Another interesting point, we are moving and I was talking about where we are going to put things, how we are going to decorate etc and DH started talking about putting stuff on display on shelves. Stuff like crockery in the kitchen, board games in the living room etc. New place has LOADS of storage - we can put it all in a cupboard and have a nice calming environment but he still wants it all out.

Makes me think of what PP have said about some wanting the cleanliness and lack of stuff while others crave being surrounded by things.

Again I was treated like the villain for not wanting crap on display - think we are going to compromise and agree to have small amounts of stuff out even though I hate it.

OP posts:
Al991 · 10/05/2023 05:40

I am so glad I made this post - I feel a lot less alone in this now. I know some people disagree but it is really frustrating!!!

I agree the need to hoard signifies a mental health hang up, but if they aren’t doing anything to address it that doesn’t make it any less frustrating - especially when I bring it up and it’s treated like I’m some sort of villain. MY mental health is being impacted by never having a tidy living space.

Solidarity with those who have a DH that hoards piles of crap.

OP posts:
OldandTired66 · 09/05/2023 17:24

Our garage is crammed to the rafters with 'stuff that will come in handy one day' (bits of wood, millions of screws, bolts, nails, old paint and varnish tins, ancient tools) to the extent our bikes have to be kept in the 'dining' room. The minute I clear a shelf or a cupboard he just sees as an opportunity to fill with more crap. I bought myself a nice little keter shed for my gardening stuff. Within days he had added several piles of surplus plumbing odds and ends. It drives me insane.

Unicorn34 · 09/05/2023 15:35

I am in the same position with my husband and 22yr old. Both of them have separation anxiety with their "stuff". Husband is models and books, child is fluffy toys and clothes/make up. It can actually bring me to tears. I have to climb out of bed every day as there is no room to walk, the loft is full of models and the sheds (3) are full. I try to tidy and I do understand the difficulties for them but feel like moving out!

I have started to do things little by little and throw things away that (hopefully) won't be missed. I've taken this week off work to tidy up but am constantly being watched!

I'm relieved to hear I'm not the only one - thank you all!

DuesToTheDirt · 09/05/2023 14:36

CheersForThatEh · 09/05/2023 13:21

And as a person who had to clear out a deceased estate, i found it emotionally exhausting and best done decisively.

I have to say it made me have my own massive clear out as the last thing I want is someone having an emotionally hard time throwing my things away when I've passed. Hopefully a long time away! But it changed my mindset and I am a regularly clearer-outer now!

DH and I cleared my mum's house when she moved into a care home. It's a large house, so although she wasn't a hoarder there was a lot of stuff. However, it only took us 4 days to sort things into keep/give away/bin, because we didn't have emotional attachment to most of it, and we don't have the space in our own house for a lot of extra stuff.

In contrast, her idea of "clearing out" was just painful. She went through a shelf of cookery books one time and only got rid of about two. At this point she was physically unable to do a lot of cooking, had barely used some of the books, but still wouldn't get rid them, e.g. a book on microwave cooking - "It's the only microwave cookery book I've got, I'd better keep it." Despite her never having done microwave cookery before, and being unlikely to start aged 80!

carpool · 09/05/2023 14:04

My husband is a bit like this. I think we have paperwork going back 50 years!
On the other hand we have a fairly big house and a lot of his 'stuff' is actually quite valuable, although none of the family will want it when we are no longer here. So he is attached to these things and is never likely to get rid of them himself, but knows we will have to eventually. We are now older and retired and he has been diagnosed with cancer (treatable but not curable) so he has started thinking about having a clear out of the less valuable things and paperwork as agrees with me we don't want to leave our kids with a nightmare to sort out. Unfortunately as a result of the cancer treatment he now has less energy and strength, so I am not sure now much we will actually get done. If you are young and fit take heed of this and don't wait until it is (becoming) too late. I would actually love to downsize to make our lives easier but he says we can't as a smaller property wouldn't fit all our stuff!!

Tiddlypomtiddlypom · 09/05/2023 13:43

His mental health need to hoard does not trump your need for clean clarity of living space. His signifies an unresolved issue, and he should seek therapeutic support to deal with it. Being ‘stubborn’ is not excuse if he’s taking precisely no steps to tackle his issues and his mounds of crap, either with therapy or organising into storage boxes.

While I know that’s the reasonable approach, I’d be so tempted to just bag it and bin it when he’s not there. 😬

JassyRadlett · 09/05/2023 13:35

What's really helped me in this situation, which is similar to yours, is to recognise to myself that his emotional need to keep these things is no less valid than my emotional need not to feel like the clutter is swallowing me whole. And that the less judgemental, more objective I am, the better results I get.

I guess it's understandable - when I describe stuff as pointless clutter, he hears 'I want you to throw away your memories, they're pointless.' Because regardless of what I think, these things are stuff he values and feels an emotional attachment to. And so he responds in an emotional way, just as I do when he frames my wanting clear surfaces as 'trying to erase him from the house.'

I find it better to frame it as my need, not his failing. So: having this stuff sitting on the filing cabinet/piano lid/on top of the books on the shelves really bothers me. Can we find somewhere else for it?' Because even though I obviously think my point of view is the most rational and correct, it's not objectively so and framing it that way is counterproductive.

I won't lie, we still have way more stuff than I'd like. There are whole boxes in the loft that haven't been touched in more than a decade. There are tense negotiations over which of the kids' toys can be donated or sold. But we've made progress, and we're both probably not 100% happy with where we are but that's a lot better than one of us feeling great and the other one totally unhappy about it.

aloris · 09/05/2023 13:24

Not sure I agree re online banking. Our bank was bought by another bank and all banking records from before the purchase were removed from online access. You can download individual bank statements and save them to a hard drive but I have had hard drives that failed so I'm not sure that is a good backup either. On the other hand, I have only a couple of times in my life had to go into banking records that were older than a few months. Usually when I look at my banking records it's routine, to ensure that my monthly statement checks out (all checks I wrote were dealt with by the recipient, nothing weird on my statements that suggest identity theft, etc). I have had to go into statements less than a year old to prove I paid a contractor, things like that.

So for me, what drives me to keep printouts of various records is if I know I'll need that record years in the future. So all our retirement savings accounts we keep printouts. Medical records. If I close a credit card account I keep the record from the credit card company proving I close the account. That sort of thing. I also keep a couple of utility bills from each year, and copies of old leases so I can prove where I have lived. Tax documents. That sort of thing.

CheersForThatEh · 09/05/2023 13:21

And as a person who had to clear out a deceased estate, i found it emotionally exhausting and best done decisively.

I have to say it made me have my own massive clear out as the last thing I want is someone having an emotionally hard time throwing my things away when I've passed. Hopefully a long time away! But it changed my mindset and I am a regularly clearer-outer now!

Ktime · 09/05/2023 13:21

Ijustdontcare · 08/05/2023 09:17

Yes, I wonder why your DH is paranoid about you throwing out things that are sentimental to him, It's not like you have been doing it in the past and still do it.

You do know by secretly throwing away stuff you are making hoarding tendencies worse.

If he can't even tell his wife has got rid of a mug, how sentimental was it to him?

thecatsmeows · 09/05/2023 13:21

@Peregrina None, is the answer to that question.

The worst part to me is, that he isn't taking stuff out with the idea that he will have it instead, but he expects me to keep it! I've lost fucking count of the number of times I've had to say yell 'I haven't got the fucking room!'

CheersForThatEh · 09/05/2023 13:19

I'd work this angle....

It's a waste if it isnt sused. So who is going to use it and when? Should craft supplies go to the charity shop or is he going to put a date on the calendar to do a craft activity with the kids?

His collections...where can it be displayed and enjoyed or can he donate it to an auction for his favourite cause? If not, marketplace.

I think he needs to understand properly that stuff isnt memories and if it isnt used then its wasted anyway.

Peregrina · 09/05/2023 13:09

If I've decided something is rubbish, it's rubbish!

Quite. and what business has someone else deciding that your property is theirs to keep?

thecatsmeows · 09/05/2023 12:52

Well I am a minimalist, always have been and my boyfriend of 14 years has known that from the start.

I moved around a lot as a child/teenager (not military) and was taught not to be sentimental about 'things'. Boyfriend isn't a hoarder but does seem to have trouble with throwing stuff out. I live on my own in a tiny flat so keeping it clear of junk is vital to me, and my mental health - I'm bipolar and mess really stress me out! So yes, in my situation, in my own living area I am the one who is 'right'... at nearly 55 with two marriages behind me I'm in no hurry to live with another man again anyway.

If I decide to have a sort out of my stuff I always do it when I'm on my own - like others have posted, if my boyfriend is here he does start looking in the bin bags, which really fucking winds me up. If I've decided something is rubbish, it's rubbish!

PinkCherryBlossoms · 09/05/2023 12:52

I’ve come to think there are 2 types of people. Nesters who feel a comfort from being surrounded by the things they love. And those who prefer a more functional home. Who just want the necessitates for daily living. And having the odd cushion or vase doesn’t make someone less of a “function” person. Neither is right or wrong. But people from different sides living together is going to cause issues.

The missing part of this is that the person who wants to keep lots of non functional things because they like them will, unless the household enjoys abundant space and resources, create a lot of labour for the people they live with because of their preference. The same doesn't apply in reverse. Because let's be honest, we're clearly not talking about the odd vase here. The OP made that clear.

Peregrina · 09/05/2023 12:48

Multiple bin bags of crap have been removed - more to go this weekend!

But you have to be vigilant or the crap builds up again. Old flyers from Domino's Pizza, old newspapers, mixed in with unopened correspondence which ought to be attended to.....

I worked in an Office which had a major relocation. We strictly limited in what we were allowed to take with us. Within six months you could see who the hoarders were - their desks were awash with stuff, which could only have been acquired since the move.

OhComeOnFFS · 09/05/2023 12:45

There's absolutely no point in holding on to bank statements if you bank online as you can scroll through them to your heart's content.

There's no point in keeping a paper copy of any documents, really. Set up a good digital filing system with lots of folders (eg electricity bills 2002) and scan everything in or take a photo and file it. Would he agree to that?

Peregrina · 09/05/2023 12:42

My late husband was like OP's partner. Stuff kept for the sake of keeping it. E.g brought home from work when he retired - folder after folder of notes from work meetings from 40 years earlier. Plus stuff from his childhood which had been in his mother's loft for 50 years but was now vitally important. Then all cluttered in together and tossed in the garage or the spare bedroom, or when the kids were away from home, dumped in their rooms when we had visitors and needed to 'tidy'.

Do you know what? I miss him, I do not miss his clutter. Why was clutter of decades more important than my comfort now? I never got an answer. I never found a decent compromise either, but we could have had a better life if we hadn't been working around clutter.

Whichwhatnow · 09/05/2023 12:38

Ugh I feel your pain OP. My husband can't bear to part with things 'just in case' they somehow become of use again, or if they're still in decent condition, or if there's any emotional attachment. We live in a small one bed flat and really don't have the space. Every surface is covered in crap and we have endless storage boxes from Ikea that just get stuffed with stuff and piled up. Like you it has really been affecting my mental health, especially as I work from home so feel like the walls and piles of stuff are closing in on me all day!

I recently cracked and insisted on having a clear out. We're only part way through but I've had to be really assertive. Examples of 'stuff' that has been thrown out/charity shopped this weekend just gone -

  • books that have never and will never be read
  • Clothes that are in good condition but that DH will never fit into again (unless he goes on a major diet which seems unlikely!)
  • Gifts he has bought me (he has a tradition of buying multiple small novelty gifts for eg Valentines - all very cute but I really don't need or want to keep a novelty stuffed toy or ornament from Poundland that has just been piled up on a shelf since Valentines Day 2019)
  • Random cables and chargers from phones etc that neither of us have or are likely to ever have again
  • Stuff like irons or food processors that still work but I have never used or seen DH use in the 5 years we have been together
  • Bits of uniform from a job DH had several years ago
  • Paperwork like bank statements from years ago which is all available on online banking anyway
  • Dining room chairs (we do not have a dining room or table(!!!) so these have just been placed in a corner of the kitchen, then also covered in piles of crap)
  • So much more!

My god it has been liberating. Multiple bin bags of crap have been removed - more to go this weekend! I don't have any advice other than to really push - ask him to tell you exactly when he last used X item or what value Y item brings to your lives.

Good luck!

EmpressSoleil · 09/05/2023 12:26

Why is the minimalist always right on these threads

I always wonder the same thing. I’m female and I like my stuff. I am not a hoarder like you see on those shows. I don’t have empty milk cartons and newspapers piled up and I doubt OPs DP does either. It would negatively affect my mental health if someone wanted to come in and sweep it all away out of sight. My house is clean and tidy but yes I have things. It makes me happy to see them.

I’ve come to think there are 2 types of people. Nesters who feel a comfort from being surrounded by the things they love. And those who prefer a more functional home. Who just want the necessitates for daily living. And having the odd cushion or vase doesn’t make someone less of a “function” person. Neither is right or wrong. But people from different sides living together is going to cause issues.

A friend of mine swept away all her partners stuff and the home became quite minimalist. She then started complaining he’d become a workaholic. He has his own business and lo and behold he’d moved all his favourite stuff there. So would rather spend time in his office than the house.

All that being said. I would be willing to compromise on how much I keep, have out. But it would have to be compromise. Not just me getting rid of everything.

PinkCherryBlossoms · 09/05/2023 12:17

Northernparent68 · 08/05/2023 08:35

Why is the minimalist always right on these threads

Obviously people have already called you on the minimalist part. But there's also the reality that we don't have particularly big homes in the UK, so many if not most of us simply wouldn't have the room for this kind of behaviour without it causing detriment to other family members.

AutumnCrow · 09/05/2023 12:12

@bussteward, may I just say what a brilliant, thought-provoking post that was. Thank you.