Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if you have a problem with the burkini?

817 replies

Mvslimah · 07/05/2023 20:28

Honest answers please

would you give a woman (maybe Muslim maybe Jewish) a wide berth if you saw them wearing a burkini or modest (Ie fully covered) swimsuit at a pool?

if you see a woman wearing one do you give it a second thought or is it just a meh, who cares?

tia

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
Mvslimah · 08/05/2023 20:10

recyclemeagain · 08/05/2023 20:01

@Mvslimah Saudi is where I'm basing my experience. I lived there myself as a child so my memories are based on that experience.

Ooh where? I lived there too! I lived not too far from dammam, jubail if you’ve heard of it?

but Saudi, as you know was and is still rife with hypocrisy in terms of its royals and government, almost laughably so, so they really shouldn’t be held up as an ideal Muslim society which was the image they tried to portray: They’ve made efforts to modernise, which is why I would visit again so it may not be as you remember it

OP posts:
Mvslimah · 08/05/2023 20:06

Barnbrack · 08/05/2023 20:02

What are you allowed to hit him with?

It’s not stated, but given that the statistics for DV are predominantly men as the perpetrators and women as victims these ayat give the absolute maximum that a man can go to under extreme circumstances. This must be viewed in the context of pre Islamic Arabia where violence against women was rife and women were buried alive, beaten to death etc

OP posts:
recyclemeagain · 08/05/2023 20:03

@SleepDreamThinkHuge thank you I was not aware of this being the case. I appreciate the correction and that is good to hear. I lived in Saudi for my childhood so my view may be different because of that.
I am so happy to hear this is not the case as broadly as I had thought.

Barnbrack · 08/05/2023 20:02

Mvslimah · 08/05/2023 19:40

well i think that guy is a Saudi and that video is most likely from prior to 2017 or the attempts to modernise Saudi. This is the kind of video that makes every other Muslim roll their eyes.

about the beating your wife, I can’t see that video it was the same hijab one so I can’t comment but I’m familiar in what he’s talking about. It’s the maximum that a man can go to when arguing his wife, he can hit her with a blade of grass or a napkin.

What are you allowed to hit him with?

recyclemeagain · 08/05/2023 20:01

@Mvslimah Saudi is where I'm basing my experience. I lived there myself as a child so my memories are based on that experience.

recyclemeagain · 08/05/2023 19:59

@AngryGreasedSantaCatcus that is my point and you've said it more clearly than I did so I appreciate that.
Exactly as you've said we don't pick and choose which values to uphold, and equally we don't get to pick and choose which values to uphold in countries such as Saudi where I have previously lived.
My point was the difference in what is expected of someone like myself in Saudi compared to if a Saudi woman resides in England. It should be fine for me to uphold my values there in the same way they should be allowed (and are allowed) to uphold theirs over here.

recyclemeagain · 08/05/2023 19:55

@slimeandfearmetro oh 100% yes agree the people at the pool weren't upholding British values at all.
I was pointing out the reason someone else may have mentioned the values. I do agree with what you're saying.

ArcticSkewer · 08/05/2023 19:42

Mvslimah · 08/05/2023 19:19

But in the vast majority of Muslim countries that have a good amount of western tourism, non Muslims aren’t expected to cover up, unless in a place of worship. The only exception I can think of is saudi or iran and i don’t imagine many white British holiday makers heading off to Saudi for some sun

A few of those muslim countries also ban burkinis from some of their hotel/country club pools - notably Tunisia and Egypt, possibly also Morocco. It's as much a class based decision there as anything - richer locals don't like them, lowers the tone.

Mvslimah · 08/05/2023 19:40

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

well i think that guy is a Saudi and that video is most likely from prior to 2017 or the attempts to modernise Saudi. This is the kind of video that makes every other Muslim roll their eyes.

about the beating your wife, I can’t see that video it was the same hijab one so I can’t comment but I’m familiar in what he’s talking about. It’s the maximum that a man can go to when arguing his wife, he can hit her with a blade of grass or a napkin.

OP posts:
LolaSmiles · 08/05/2023 19:34

That's just as bigoted as the anti Muslim brigade. Why does female empowerment have to mean excessive flesh on show? What's wrong with being curious about what it really means to have choice and agency as a woman? Whether that be under the watchful patriarchal gaze of a religion or the faux liberation of a patriarchal atheist/agnostic consumerist society and everything in between?People, especially women, are fascinating, what is wrong with curiosity?
I think you might have got the wrong end of the stick. I wasn't saying I agree that female empowerment means excessive flesh on show. I was observing that for some people they seem to equate female empowerment with every inch the embodiment of male gaze expectations, which is why so many people seem to to argue that they're empowered and free and liberated by their swimwear choices but women who cover up are oppressed.

I'm all up for curiousity about social structures and their effect on women. It's why I'd say I lean towards radical feminism. It's also why I'm especially curious (and cynical) about ideas of feminism and female empowerment that embody male gaze.

slimeandfearmetro · 08/05/2023 19:30

recyclemeagain · 08/05/2023 19:03

I know people are being flippant about the British culture and values comment but I do see the point in it.

As a woman, if I were to go to Muslim countries I would be expected to cover up and not express myself in the way I could here in England. However a woman from a Muslim country is not expected to come here and not express her values/faith. England is a Christian country at its core but we do not expect everyone to live/dress/adhere to Christian values.

Now I am in no way saying that we should expect Muslim women to dress in the way Christian, agnostic or aetheist women dress etc. Of course not, that would be controlling, judgemental and ridiculous.
However if it would be controlling, judgemental and ridiculous for that to happen, how is it not controlling, judgemental and ridiculous when Muslim countries enforce such expectations on non-Muslim women?
I do not mean this to be xenophobic (that's the word you're looking for rather than racist) I'm just pointing out the inequality and possible reason behind the British values comment.

how is it not controlling, judgemental and ridiculous when Muslim countries enforce such expectations on non-Muslim women?

It is controlling, judgemental and ridiculous. One of our British values is that, unlike the French and the Saudis, we aren't overly prescriptive about what women wear because it's controlling, judgemental and ridiculous. We do better than that.

Does it not occur to you that the people at the pool who were hostile to OP were failing to uphold British values?

AngryGreasedSantaCatcus · 08/05/2023 19:25

recyclemeagain · 08/05/2023 19:03

I know people are being flippant about the British culture and values comment but I do see the point in it.

As a woman, if I were to go to Muslim countries I would be expected to cover up and not express myself in the way I could here in England. However a woman from a Muslim country is not expected to come here and not express her values/faith. England is a Christian country at its core but we do not expect everyone to live/dress/adhere to Christian values.

Now I am in no way saying that we should expect Muslim women to dress in the way Christian, agnostic or aetheist women dress etc. Of course not, that would be controlling, judgemental and ridiculous.
However if it would be controlling, judgemental and ridiculous for that to happen, how is it not controlling, judgemental and ridiculous when Muslim countries enforce such expectations on non-Muslim women?
I do not mean this to be xenophobic (that's the word you're looking for rather than racist) I'm just pointing out the inequality and possible reason behind the British values comment.

  1. We like to pretend we are better than those countries. It's a false equivalence.
  1. Some of those values are tolerance and liberty /freedom. That is why we don't impose our rules on others. That's why OP wearing what she wants is an expression of those rights and values. You don't get to pick and choose which values should be respected .

Honestly the mental gymnastics are mindboggling!

Jonei · 08/05/2023 19:25

RachelGreensHair · 08/05/2023 19:06

It's true though. Why the need to have your butts hanging out?

I don't think that matters either tbh. I mean the butt hanging out look isn't a great look, but it's not my butt so I don't care.People can just live their own lives, wear what they want, for whatever reason, and let others do the same.

Mvslimah · 08/05/2023 19:21

RachelGreensHair · 08/05/2023 18:40

@Mvslimah sister you have my full support. There's a South Asian board here that you may find useful. The racism on MN is pathetic.

Thanks babe! I’m not south Asian, so I’ve never really ventured on to those boards, don’t want to take up space in a south Asian woman’s space

OP posts:
Mvslimah · 08/05/2023 19:19

recyclemeagain · 08/05/2023 19:03

I know people are being flippant about the British culture and values comment but I do see the point in it.

As a woman, if I were to go to Muslim countries I would be expected to cover up and not express myself in the way I could here in England. However a woman from a Muslim country is not expected to come here and not express her values/faith. England is a Christian country at its core but we do not expect everyone to live/dress/adhere to Christian values.

Now I am in no way saying that we should expect Muslim women to dress in the way Christian, agnostic or aetheist women dress etc. Of course not, that would be controlling, judgemental and ridiculous.
However if it would be controlling, judgemental and ridiculous for that to happen, how is it not controlling, judgemental and ridiculous when Muslim countries enforce such expectations on non-Muslim women?
I do not mean this to be xenophobic (that's the word you're looking for rather than racist) I'm just pointing out the inequality and possible reason behind the British values comment.

But in the vast majority of Muslim countries that have a good amount of western tourism, non Muslims aren’t expected to cover up, unless in a place of worship. The only exception I can think of is saudi or iran and i don’t imagine many white British holiday makers heading off to Saudi for some sun

OP posts:
13Bastards · 08/05/2023 19:18

I go to a ladies only swimming session and lots of women wear these, or even short wetsuits - doesn't bother me at all. I do hope they don't think less of me in my usual cossie

Socrateswasrightaboutvoting · 08/05/2023 19:13

@CampervanKween What ethnicity are you? @RachelGreensHair What ethnicity are you?

RachelGreensHair · 08/05/2023 19:11

SleepDreamThinkHuge · 08/05/2023 19:07

Been Dubai, Turkey and Morocco where a lot of people wear bikinis so that negates your point.

I think many would have a shock if they visited Islamabad and saw how people dress there. Same in dubai, Turkey, Egypt and many other Muslim countries.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 08/05/2023 19:08

RachelGreensHair · 08/05/2023 19:01

British values are wearing a bikini that shows off more than your knickers and bra do. The less fabric the better apparently. Means you're empowered.

Ah yes, the 'liberation' of being expected to expose as much of your body as a random man might want to see at any time. It's their right, apparently, and any woman who doesn't want to for any reason at all, but particularly if they might have a religious belief, or perhaps a dangerous view that it's their body and they choose how much or how little of it to expose, is insolently rejecting the white male gaze and thereby Our Entire Way of Life.

SleepDreamThinkHuge · 08/05/2023 19:07

recyclemeagain · 08/05/2023 19:03

I know people are being flippant about the British culture and values comment but I do see the point in it.

As a woman, if I were to go to Muslim countries I would be expected to cover up and not express myself in the way I could here in England. However a woman from a Muslim country is not expected to come here and not express her values/faith. England is a Christian country at its core but we do not expect everyone to live/dress/adhere to Christian values.

Now I am in no way saying that we should expect Muslim women to dress in the way Christian, agnostic or aetheist women dress etc. Of course not, that would be controlling, judgemental and ridiculous.
However if it would be controlling, judgemental and ridiculous for that to happen, how is it not controlling, judgemental and ridiculous when Muslim countries enforce such expectations on non-Muslim women?
I do not mean this to be xenophobic (that's the word you're looking for rather than racist) I'm just pointing out the inequality and possible reason behind the British values comment.

Been Dubai, Turkey and Morocco where a lot of people wear bikinis so that negates your point.

RachelGreensHair · 08/05/2023 19:06

It's true though. Why the need to have your butts hanging out?

RachelGreensHair · 08/05/2023 19:05

Me.

recyclemeagain · 08/05/2023 19:04

RachelGreensHair · 08/05/2023 19:01

British values are wearing a bikini that shows off more than your knickers and bra do. The less fabric the better apparently. Means you're empowered.

Wow who's xenophobic now!

recyclemeagain · 08/05/2023 19:03

I know people are being flippant about the British culture and values comment but I do see the point in it.

As a woman, if I were to go to Muslim countries I would be expected to cover up and not express myself in the way I could here in England. However a woman from a Muslim country is not expected to come here and not express her values/faith. England is a Christian country at its core but we do not expect everyone to live/dress/adhere to Christian values.

Now I am in no way saying that we should expect Muslim women to dress in the way Christian, agnostic or aetheist women dress etc. Of course not, that would be controlling, judgemental and ridiculous.
However if it would be controlling, judgemental and ridiculous for that to happen, how is it not controlling, judgemental and ridiculous when Muslim countries enforce such expectations on non-Muslim women?
I do not mean this to be xenophobic (that's the word you're looking for rather than racist) I'm just pointing out the inequality and possible reason behind the British values comment.

RachelGreensHair · 08/05/2023 19:01

British values are wearing a bikini that shows off more than your knickers and bra do. The less fabric the better apparently. Means you're empowered.

Swipe left for the next trending thread