Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if you have a problem with the burkini?

817 replies

Mvslimah · 07/05/2023 20:28

Honest answers please

would you give a woman (maybe Muslim maybe Jewish) a wide berth if you saw them wearing a burkini or modest (Ie fully covered) swimsuit at a pool?

if you see a woman wearing one do you give it a second thought or is it just a meh, who cares?

tia

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
TheGoogleMum · 09/05/2023 13:46

Why would it bother me? I don't like having too much skin on show myself

Bookworm20 · 09/05/2023 13:45

you’re seriously saying you’ve never seen a man on the beach or pool check out a woman in a revealing swimsuit? I have

And whose fault is that? The woman's, or the man's? Or both?
Should I not wear a swimsuit just in case some bloke checks me out?

I've also seen men check women out when they are wearing a 'normal' swimsuit. And normal clothes too.
I've also seen men talk to women absolutely normally without checking them out, even those in 'revealing swimsuits'.

I think it largely depends on the man. From the amount of modesty it seems is required in your religion, can the men not be trusted to treat women as equals and not view them as sex objects? To the point they must be covered head to toe at all times?

Some men are oogling idiots. Some are not.

If people want to follow a dress guidance of their religion because they want to, thats absolutely fine. But is this guidance? It seems like its more of a rule?
And your comment about seeing men checking out women in 'revealing swimsuit' is quite telling what you think about women wearing bikinis, so you've lost me now. We're all just tempting the men obviously.

No one at that pool should of made you feel bad, whatever your reason for wearing a burkhini was. That is just rubbish and they are not nice people, so ignore them. And equally no one should be shamed for wearing a bikini on a public beach. The difference though I think is that people know the woman wearing the bikini is doing so because its her choice to. Alot of people will think someone wearing a burkhini in blistering hot sunshine, is doing so because she has been told to.

Mvslimah · 09/05/2023 13:21

MargotBamborough · 09/05/2023 13:08

I agree @Curtain1980 that from a purely physical point of view wearing less swimwear can be more comfortable. Although given how rarely the opportunity to swim topless actually arises due to the higher standards of "modesty" required of women than men by even western countries, I don't actually know whether a woman with big boobs, like me, could comfortably swim for exercise without a top on. That said, physical comfort isn't the only kind of comfort, and I can think of loads of situations where I feel more psychologically comfortable covered up than baring my flesh. Like, if there were no other people on the beach I'd be most comfortable stark naked, but with my post baby body and other people around, I prefer to wear a not-too-skimpy swimsuit and maybe some other kind of cover-up as well. I totally agree with you though, that being covered from head to toe when on the beach for religious reasons deprives you of the opportunity to enjoy the feel of the sun and the water on your bare skin. I think I would feel far less uncomfortable with it if Muslim men did it too. But they don't.

To @Mvslimah: I have a question. You say that wearing a burkini is your choice and that you want to do it. What if you woke up tomorrow and didn't want to do it anymore? What if you woke up tomorrow and suddenly felt a strong desire to go to the swimming pool and swim in public wearing a bikini or one piece swimming costume? Would you feel free to do that?

I don’t understand the question? Because in your scenario I’ve decided I want to show my body so no longer care to adhere to Islamic clothing guidance? So obviously I’d just do it. It’s the feeling free bit i don’t get? Do you mean is there someone encouraging me to wear it or would I face criticism if I didn’t? But from who? My husband? He wouldn’t really care, secretly I do wish he had more gheerah but grass is always greener I suppose

OP posts:
Beezknees · 09/05/2023 13:13

I do not care a jot about who wears what. I expect the same courtesy to be extended to me though.

MargotBamborough · 09/05/2023 13:08

I agree @Curtain1980 that from a purely physical point of view wearing less swimwear can be more comfortable. Although given how rarely the opportunity to swim topless actually arises due to the higher standards of "modesty" required of women than men by even western countries, I don't actually know whether a woman with big boobs, like me, could comfortably swim for exercise without a top on. That said, physical comfort isn't the only kind of comfort, and I can think of loads of situations where I feel more psychologically comfortable covered up than baring my flesh. Like, if there were no other people on the beach I'd be most comfortable stark naked, but with my post baby body and other people around, I prefer to wear a not-too-skimpy swimsuit and maybe some other kind of cover-up as well. I totally agree with you though, that being covered from head to toe when on the beach for religious reasons deprives you of the opportunity to enjoy the feel of the sun and the water on your bare skin. I think I would feel far less uncomfortable with it if Muslim men did it too. But they don't.

To @Mvslimah: I have a question. You say that wearing a burkini is your choice and that you want to do it. What if you woke up tomorrow and didn't want to do it anymore? What if you woke up tomorrow and suddenly felt a strong desire to go to the swimming pool and swim in public wearing a bikini or one piece swimming costume? Would you feel free to do that?

ItsCalledAConversation · 09/05/2023 13:08

Not sure which way you want the voting to go?

I would notice it, as it’s unusual to see in the UK (but then I tend to notice other women anyway), and I’d think encouraging thoughts along the lines of @Mvslimah ”go get it my sister”. I would love to see more women enjoying sport in clothing they are comfortable in for the moment.

Mvslimah · 09/05/2023 13:06

Curtain1980 · 09/05/2023 12:44

OP have you sat in a Bikink in the sun and then sat in your Burkhini? You’re saying there is no difference but having sat in my swimming cossie in the sun then with just my bikini bottoms on the balcony in the sun I can tell you now I would not want to be covered head to toe, there is a huge difference.

It’s about comfort too, isn’t it just people need to think otherwise of the ‘male gaze’ so to speak? I mean I’ve been on holiday with friends and family and seriously I’ve never seen anyone of the males look anywhere other than my face when they talk to me. You’re all out in your swimsuits on the beach and no one is looking at anyone in any particular way. That’s why I think you do draw attention with a burkhini.

Have you worn a burkini? Because I’ve worn both, and I’ve worn a burkini in 45 degree heat and I can tell you it ain’t the burkini making me hot, it’s the sun.

id west a sun hat going to the shops to keep the sun off my face on a sunny day, as many do?

you’re seriously saying you’ve never seen a man on the beach or pool check out a woman in a revealing swimsuit? I have ,

OP posts:
OneTC · 09/05/2023 13:05

I'm strugling to see the choices here, seems like alot of things are dictated as to how you must do things - even how to think.

That's religion no? And on a broader level participation in society in general

Mvslimah · 09/05/2023 13:02

^string bikini not strong haha

OP posts:
Mvslimah · 09/05/2023 13:02

Bookworm20 · 09/05/2023 12:20

Muslim women couldn’t wear a traditional bathing suit in women only areas anyway… maybe a swimsuit with board shorts but that’s about it

Why not? I thought it was choice to wear what you want? But here you say women couldn't wear that? Says who?

I wouldn't judge anyone in a burkini for doing wearing it, but I would feel sorry for them, sorry, its just what I'd think. especially on a hot day. And I would think they were unable to wear a regular swimsuit because of religion dictating to them that it would be immoral. And so i'd feel for them. And I'd secretly seethe at their husbands enjoying the sun on their skin while their wife is covered up like a dirty little secret or something. Their bodies never to see the light of day.

If it was purely choice, then wear whatever you want. But the religion is dictating this, so it isn't a free choice at all.

You also said: modesty islamically is only a small part what you wear, it’s how you speak, how you act, how you think, how you behave, how you look (the physical act of looking at someone) and then how you dress.

I'm strugling to see the choices here, seems like alot of things are dictated as to how you must do things - even how to think.

If my dd asked why a woman was dressed in a burkini on scorching hot day on the beach, I honestly don't think she'd buy the answer 'because she wants to'. So I'd probably say she has to because of her religion. I don't know - what would be the best response OP, would be genuinely good to know what the best response to a question like that would be. I am very much each to their own, and have no problem with any religion, but I do struggle to understand one where it does look very, very unequal for women and men.

Perhaps I wasn’t explicitly clear, I should’ve said a woman who chooses to adhere to the Islamic dress code on modesty and her private parts, wouldn’t wear a bikini in front of women… bikini top and shorts yes but she’d need to have her navel to knee covered. She could be topless and just wear the shorts But no one would would be there to stop her as such

but you are superimposing your thoughts, onto that woman, it’s this poor Muslim woman paradigm. I’ve worn a ‘normal’ bathing suit when rented private villas and there is literally no difference except I don’t have to worry about suncream in the burkini. Again with the immoral, no one believes that, that’s the juxtaposition that some posters on this thread have created re the term modest, as they seem to think the modest fashion industry means that their clothes as this immodest or immoral or slutty

Islam is a way of life not just a religion but that’s like Christianity too. We’re encouraged to be kind and appropriate in our speech, to not think bad of others, to behave in a kind, considerate and appropriate way to our fellow humans but I don’t see anything problematic there.

tbh if you’re child asked personally I’d welcome a politely asked question from a child, some might not though so I’d go with because that’s how she feels comfortable, which is exactly what I’d say to my daughter if she asked why someone was wearing a strong bikini

OP posts:
Curtain1980 · 09/05/2023 12:44

OP have you sat in a Bikink in the sun and then sat in your Burkhini? You’re saying there is no difference but having sat in my swimming cossie in the sun then with just my bikini bottoms on the balcony in the sun I can tell you now I would not want to be covered head to toe, there is a huge difference.

It’s about comfort too, isn’t it just people need to think otherwise of the ‘male gaze’ so to speak? I mean I’ve been on holiday with friends and family and seriously I’ve never seen anyone of the males look anywhere other than my face when they talk to me. You’re all out in your swimsuits on the beach and no one is looking at anyone in any particular way. That’s why I think you do draw attention with a burkhini.

TinyPurpleFishes · 09/05/2023 12:39

Why not? I thought it was choice to wear what you want? But here you say women couldn't wear that? Says who?

We follow the word of our God. Many may see it as us being prohibited, but a lot of which is restricted is to protect us e.g. not drinking alcohol. There is a lot we don’t understand the reasons for as we’re just mere human beings, but we have faith that one day all will become clear, and that we will be rewarded for following the word of our Lord, as we believe Allah (swt) is both the All Knowing, and the Most Wise.

I don't know - what would be the best response OP, would be genuinely good to know what the best response to a question like that would be.

“This woman actively follows a religion where wearing full coverage clothing is recommended and therefore wears a full length swimsuit so she’s able to swim”.

It’s that easy. My child asked me why Sikh men wear large turbans on their head as they must be quite heavy, and I simply explained because he follows a religion where it is recommended he do so.

Bookworm20 · 09/05/2023 12:20

Muslim women couldn’t wear a traditional bathing suit in women only areas anyway… maybe a swimsuit with board shorts but that’s about it

Why not? I thought it was choice to wear what you want? But here you say women couldn't wear that? Says who?

I wouldn't judge anyone in a burkini for doing wearing it, but I would feel sorry for them, sorry, its just what I'd think. especially on a hot day. And I would think they were unable to wear a regular swimsuit because of religion dictating to them that it would be immoral. And so i'd feel for them. And I'd secretly seethe at their husbands enjoying the sun on their skin while their wife is covered up like a dirty little secret or something. Their bodies never to see the light of day.

If it was purely choice, then wear whatever you want. But the religion is dictating this, so it isn't a free choice at all.

You also said: modesty islamically is only a small part what you wear, it’s how you speak, how you act, how you think, how you behave, how you look (the physical act of looking at someone) and then how you dress.

I'm strugling to see the choices here, seems like alot of things are dictated as to how you must do things - even how to think.

If my dd asked why a woman was dressed in a burkini on scorching hot day on the beach, I honestly don't think she'd buy the answer 'because she wants to'. So I'd probably say she has to because of her religion. I don't know - what would be the best response OP, would be genuinely good to know what the best response to a question like that would be. I am very much each to their own, and have no problem with any religion, but I do struggle to understand one where it does look very, very unequal for women and men.

Mvslimah · 09/05/2023 11:29

LBFseBrom · 09/05/2023 11:21

Mvslimih
You asked why is there not an influx of immigrants to Islamic countries. I don't know about immigration as such but a great many people from here and elsewhere go to different places to work, often for years. What is more they seem to like it as well as the money they make. I've known quite a few who have worked in Bahrain, Saudi, Libya and Qatar.

I’ve not asked that, I’ve been asked that and said pretty much exactly as you did :)

OP posts:
LBFseBrom · 09/05/2023 11:21

Mvslimih
You asked why is there not an influx of immigrants to Islamic countries. I don't know about immigration as such but a great many people from here and elsewhere go to different places to work, often for years. What is more they seem to like it as well as the money they make. I've known quite a few who have worked in Bahrain, Saudi, Libya and Qatar.

OneTC · 09/05/2023 11:15

Can't be bothered because I always get called racist

I wonder why? 🤔

Mvslimah · 09/05/2023 10:58

margarine17 · 09/05/2023 10:33

Oh and most Muslim countries are not "developing " countries , unless you are including some Asian and African countries. Saudi Arabia, Qatar, Bahrain, UAE, Jordan, Turkey etc I think they'd be a bit insulted to be called 3rd world. No Western countries bombing them.
Iran and Iraq had a good crack at each other long before the Iraq war.
Muslim countries controlled a fair bit of the world for a long time.
No idea what's happened. But blaming other people for Islamic issues doesn't help.
Can't be bothered because I always get called racist - which is strange as Islam is not a race.
Have a restful night.

They are developing nations.

each of those counties has its problems for sure, some gigantic but so does the west and the UK and the US

Turkey is a secular democracy btw

perhaps rather than spewing hate, look up colonialism, the fall of the Ottoman Empire and the foundation of Saudi Arabia. All of this have been central in the regressive steps the Muslim world has taken over the last 100 years.

islamaphobia is rooted in racism and white supremacy because although there are white Muslims (such as myself) it is commonly viewed as this barbaric backward religion of the ‘other’ by the western world.

maybe if you always get called a racist, it might be time to sit back and reflect as to why?

OP posts:
Mvslimah · 09/05/2023 10:47

margarine17 · 09/05/2023 10:11

I'm not a nutter. I just don't live in the UK.
In answer to your answer .
Indonesia - has a province called Aceh - they have sharia law ( muslim again) and whip people who break certain laws.
Malaysia - check out the sedition act.
That's seriously the best you've got. And you call me a nutter.
Another question - why is there not an influx of immigrants to Muslim countries? It's always the other way. Do you never stop and think about that? Why do you live in the UK?

Firstly it’s not shariah law. It’s just shariah. Secondly, the shariah isn’t this evil thing to be afraid of, it encompasses many many many things, from healthcare for all, to freedom of religion, to the welfare state, education for all and then a tiny part of it is criminal justice.

you ‘allowed’ me 1 hr to reply to your post before you launched your islamaphobic tirade.

I’m aware of the aceh province, they have a great deal of independence from mainland Indonesia after a bit of a struggle so it’s not the central government.

sedition act? That it’s against the law to bring ill will or spread hatred on the grounds of religion? How awful.

you can’t be that stupid! Of course there are immigrants to other Muslim countries? The uae has a huge expat community and then immigrants from other part of the Muslim world, Malaysia has a sizeable Chinese and Indian community, saudi has western expats and workers from the far east and Indian subcontinent and Syrian and Palestinian refugees, Jordan has the same, Lebanon has the same.

I live here because I like roast dinners, am British (half British and half french) but I am a British citizen from birth, I have lived in Saudi as a child as an expat for 18 months for my parent’s work. why do you live where you live?

really crucially maybe you should ask yourself what does any of the above have to do with swimwear? Or is it just an opportunity for you to try to justify your opinions on Muslims?

OP posts:
margarine17 · 09/05/2023 10:33

Oh and most Muslim countries are not "developing " countries , unless you are including some Asian and African countries. Saudi Arabia, Qatar, Bahrain, UAE, Jordan, Turkey etc I think they'd be a bit insulted to be called 3rd world. No Western countries bombing them.
Iran and Iraq had a good crack at each other long before the Iraq war.
Muslim countries controlled a fair bit of the world for a long time.
No idea what's happened. But blaming other people for Islamic issues doesn't help.
Can't be bothered because I always get called racist - which is strange as Islam is not a race.
Have a restful night.

margarine17 · 09/05/2023 10:11

Mvslimah · 09/05/2023 07:33

because it was 6:30am you nutter, I was asleep!

lets not idealise the western ‘democratic’ nations, we are far from ideal.

let me point out to you a fact that should be very simple, most Muslim majority countries are either third world or developing nations, you cannot compare developed first world countries with a penchant for invading and or bombing said developing countries with those countries and go haha you guys are so backward

ps to answer your question, Indonesia and Malaysia

I'm not a nutter. I just don't live in the UK.
In answer to your answer .
Indonesia - has a province called Aceh - they have sharia law ( muslim again) and whip people who break certain laws.
Malaysia - check out the sedition act.
That's seriously the best you've got. And you call me a nutter.
Another question - why is there not an influx of immigrants to Muslim countries? It's always the other way. Do you never stop and think about that? Why do you live in the UK?

recyclemeagain · 09/05/2023 08:59

Also @SoreThroatAgain having checked again I see you responded to my comment where I'm clearly saying the people at the pool did not uphold British value in that they were intolerant and unaccepting. So I can only presume you tagged me to cause an argument since you chose to read something into my comment that just isn't there.

recyclemeagain · 09/05/2023 08:56

@PollyThePixie @SoreThroatAgain
I understand there's a lot of posts to read through but by leaping on mine perhaps you missed my multiple responses to similar comments.
I have stated repeatedly that I myself grew up in Saudi so I have personal experience that I'm referring to. And I have not stated that British values mean to exclusively wear revealing swimwear or anything like that. I've stated that British values are about acceptance and fairness, and pointed out the same does not apply when western women live in places like Saudi (again, in my lived experience which you can see I have briefly discussed with OP)
Hopefully you both simply rushed to respond to my first post and didn't just choose to dismiss me already clearing this up.
Have good days both of you.

Mvslimah · 09/05/2023 07:33

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

because it was 6:30am you nutter, I was asleep!

lets not idealise the western ‘democratic’ nations, we are far from ideal.

let me point out to you a fact that should be very simple, most Muslim majority countries are either third world or developing nations, you cannot compare developed first world countries with a penchant for invading and or bombing said developing countries with those countries and go haha you guys are so backward

ps to answer your question, Indonesia and Malaysia

OP posts:
Mvslimah · 09/05/2023 07:28

margarine17 · 09/05/2023 06:33

How were you brought up that you think you need to hide your face in public? At least your husband was well raised.

simply put, I wasn’t. I lived in Saudi but not as a Saudi because I’m not, expats live in very expat communities and I went to an international school.

as you don’t know my husband or his family it makes me giggle that you think he was well raised… like most families they’ve got their issues, some definitely would not evoke sentiments of being well raised. They don’t like the face veil because it’s not their culture.

ive worn it myself, not for pure motivations on believing it to be the correct or preferred way for a Muslim woman to dress but actually that I was going somewhere and I didn’t want to be recognised and or approached

OP posts:
margarine17 · 09/05/2023 07:23

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Swipe left for the next trending thread