Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if you have a problem with the burkini?

817 replies

Mvslimah · 07/05/2023 20:28

Honest answers please

would you give a woman (maybe Muslim maybe Jewish) a wide berth if you saw them wearing a burkini or modest (Ie fully covered) swimsuit at a pool?

if you see a woman wearing one do you give it a second thought or is it just a meh, who cares?

tia

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
Mvslimah · 09/05/2023 20:36

Socrateswasrightaboutvoting · 09/05/2023 19:46

Still cant articulate my though process. I have a stinking head cold a the moment. Its the fact that you do not seem to question the role of women in what is clearly a patriarchal structure. Your focus seem to be on women rather that holding men to account, who in most cases are the issue. Surely it is time to adapt the teaching to a more modern society. I would be asking the same question if you were part of any other other organised religion. This isn't about Islam rather religion in general, as a patriarchal structure. As a woman ( and before anyone asks, no I am not going to define it) I want my daughter to know her worth and have agency. Not sure if that makes sense.

But you don’t know me, so you don’t really know what I do pushback on, but the thing is I quite like Islam the way it is, I don’t necessarily like Muslims and what Muslims do, there is a distinction to be made there.

i have no once said that women are responsible for the actions of men, that is your inference. I’ve replied as to why Muslim women do such and such and have given a broad factual answer. Now according to some I probably don’t dress modestly enough, but I’d challenge if anyone pulled me up on that.

why does the religion need to be adapted when it has been this way for 1400 years? Tbe religion itself isn’t the problem, it is how it has been interpreted and slowly twisted to suit the needs to specific governments to legitimise their regime cough saudi cough FYI changing the religion or what’s termed a bid’ah is a huge sin. Things of course need to be viewed In their historical context, and some scholarly issues need to be reclassified as to where they sit in terms of the sharia, but that’s not Islam as such, that’s an interpretation of it (usually a man’s interpretation which is why some very patriarchal things have seeped in). You may or may not who knows be interested to know that under the Ottoman Empire, homosexuality across the Muslim world that was ruled by the ottomans was decriminalised, non Muslims could visit Mecca and medina and there was a real drive toward pluralism. The amount of hudud or hadd punishments enacted by Muslims judges across the entire Muslim world, prior to the formation of Saudi, was so small you could count it on one hand, the Muslim caliphates were the original welfare states that guaranteed non Muslims, especially Christians and Jews, equal rights, freedom of religion and protection the likes that other societies of the time hadn’t seen. One of the first universities in the world was founded by a Muslim woman… these are all things that are part of the faith that have got eroded with the foundation of Saudi Arabia and their aggressive promulgation of their version of Islam.

OP posts:
ClemFandango1 · 09/05/2023 20:31

I've been looking at swimwear marketed to Muslim women because I am incredibly hairy and genuinely don't want to faff with hair removal in order to swim.

Have also wondered what little kids in the middle east wear as I want something loose and long for my 18 month old that protects from the sun but is cool to wear, and there's bugger all like that here.

Pearfacebananapoop · 09/05/2023 20:16

I'd think fair play. I'd much rather see someone in a burkini having fun and enjoying themselves than sat miserable fully clothed on the beach.

Whatkindofuckeryisthis · 09/05/2023 19:46

I’d notice as it’s not the norm but I wouldn’t care.

MargotBamborough · 09/05/2023 19:46

Yeah except that our laws aren't made on the basis of Anglican Christianity.

Socrateswasrightaboutvoting · 09/05/2023 19:46

Still cant articulate my though process. I have a stinking head cold a the moment. Its the fact that you do not seem to question the role of women in what is clearly a patriarchal structure. Your focus seem to be on women rather that holding men to account, who in most cases are the issue. Surely it is time to adapt the teaching to a more modern society. I would be asking the same question if you were part of any other other organised religion. This isn't about Islam rather religion in general, as a patriarchal structure. As a woman ( and before anyone asks, no I am not going to define it) I want my daughter to know her worth and have agency. Not sure if that makes sense.

getfreddynow · 09/05/2023 19:45

Thanks both, I found your comments on France and church interesting.

Inkypot · 09/05/2023 19:44

MargotBamborough · 09/05/2023 18:48

Yeah I would say that even now, the Catholic religion has more influence over the laws of France, a supposedly secular country, than Anglican Christianity does over the laws of the UK, where it is the country's official religion and the head of the church is literally also the head of state.

Tbf anglican Protestantism is basically Catholicism with the king in the pope's place.
Said as someone who converted from Episcopalian (Anglican) to Catholic. They're ultimately the same basic values and Anglican was set up by the head of state anyway so that kind of says a lot.

MargotBamborough · 09/05/2023 18:48

Yeah I would say that even now, the Catholic religion has more influence over the laws of France, a supposedly secular country, than Anglican Christianity does over the laws of the UK, where it is the country's official religion and the head of the church is literally also the head of state.

Mvslimah · 09/05/2023 18:40

getfreddynow · 09/05/2023 18:32

Some slightly unsavoury anti french sentiment from the OP on this thread. Separation of state from religion by French institutions was for other historical reasons surely not a 21st cent anti Muslim conspiracy , but a legacy of French attitudes to the Catholic Church?

I AM FRENCH

but The french state is not a truly secular one. Religion is banned In schools but the bible is taught as a text, covered up swimwear is banned under the guise of hygiene, as pp said a Catholic would be exercising their civil liberties to protest abortion, the country is built on catholic values, i believe sarkozy even said so himself

OP posts:
MargotBamborough · 09/05/2023 18:38

getfreddynow · 09/05/2023 18:32

Some slightly unsavoury anti french sentiment from the OP on this thread. Separation of state from religion by French institutions was for other historical reasons surely not a 21st cent anti Muslim conspiracy , but a legacy of French attitudes to the Catholic Church?

I think it's a fair comment actually.

Respect for the principle of laïcité is something that is only really demanded of religious minorities. There are many French people who will say France is a secular country when it suits them and also that France is a Catholic country when it suits them.

getfreddynow · 09/05/2023 18:32

Some slightly unsavoury anti french sentiment from the OP on this thread. Separation of state from religion by French institutions was for other historical reasons surely not a 21st cent anti Muslim conspiracy , but a legacy of French attitudes to the Catholic Church?

MargotBamborough · 09/05/2023 18:02

Mvslimah · 09/05/2023 17:52

Well I’ve not been to a public pool so that’s why.. seems like it’s how the institutional french racism covertly discriminates against the Muslim and Jewish minorities

I think secularism is really just a stick to beat minorities with, since it doesn't seem to apply to Catholics.

If you are a good Catholic protesting against same sex marriage or the liberalisation of IVF laws or abortion, you are just exercising your right to free speech, not trying to make your religious beliefs form the basis of laws in a supposedly secular country, apparently.

Mvslimah · 09/05/2023 17:52

MargotBamborough · 09/05/2023 17:36

I've never been to a public swimming pool which didn't have and enforce this rule. Private/hotel pools don't have the same rule.

Well I’ve not been to a public pool so that’s why.. seems like it’s how the institutional french racism covertly discriminates against the Muslim and Jewish minorities

OP posts:
MargotBamborough · 09/05/2023 17:36

Mvslimah · 09/05/2023 17:15

Is that enforced though because I’ve been to quite a few pools in France and he’s worn his shorts and I my burkini and no one has batted an eyelid, there were lots of people dressed the same? Is there an exception for tourists?

I've never been to a public swimming pool which didn't have and enforce this rule. Private/hotel pools don't have the same rule.

PlainJanePerfect · 09/05/2023 17:35

If it's a swimsuit burkini, I don't think anything of it. If it's going in the water fully clothed, I tend to keep an eye because sometimes it means an infrequent swimmer or someone who can struggle with heavy, wet fabric.

AngryBirdsNoMore · 09/05/2023 17:33

Keep reporting islamophobic posts but @mnhq are declining to delete….

Mvslimah · 09/05/2023 17:26

Also @MargotBamborough that’s the point isn’t it, scratch the surface and many of our accepted norms like high heels or basically underwear for swimming may also be used as tools of oppression.

im assuming your french but I’m desperately trying to find the quote from Foucault on the power of subverting a tool of oppression into a tool of power but I cant… 😥

OP posts:
AngryBirdsNoMore · 09/05/2023 17:17

margarine17 · 09/05/2023 10:11

I'm not a nutter. I just don't live in the UK.
In answer to your answer .
Indonesia - has a province called Aceh - they have sharia law ( muslim again) and whip people who break certain laws.
Malaysia - check out the sedition act.
That's seriously the best you've got. And you call me a nutter.
Another question - why is there not an influx of immigrants to Muslim countries? It's always the other way. Do you never stop and think about that? Why do you live in the UK?

Stop attacking OP because she’s muslim. She isn’t responsible for all Islam and every Muslim.

Mvslimah · 09/05/2023 17:15

MargotBamborough · 09/05/2023 17:03

Ah, well you could write a feminist essay just about high heels, I think!

By the way, in France (where I live) your husband wouldn't be allowed to wear knee length shorts at the swimming pool. It's Speedos or nothing. He would he required to cover his head though for hygiene reasons. Even if he happens to be completely bald. 🙃

Is that enforced though because I’ve been to quite a few pools in France and he’s worn his shorts and I my burkini and no one has batted an eyelid, there were lots of people dressed the same? Is there an exception for tourists?

OP posts:
NeverDropYourMooncup · 09/05/2023 17:05

MargotBamborough · 09/05/2023 17:03

Ah, well you could write a feminist essay just about high heels, I think!

By the way, in France (where I live) your husband wouldn't be allowed to wear knee length shorts at the swimming pool. It's Speedos or nothing. He would he required to cover his head though for hygiene reasons. Even if he happens to be completely bald. 🙃

Did you notice the post where the OP said she's half French? I suspect she isn't in need of somebody informing her what is or isn't allowed in France.

MargotBamborough · 09/05/2023 17:03

Mvslimah · 09/05/2023 17:00

No choice is a free choice, it’s all influenced by something or other and it oppressive in iran because of the act of compulsion not the garment itself… that line of reasoning can extend to everything though, high heels trafficked sex workers are forced to wear them, and skimpy revealing tops and clothes.

Ah, well you could write a feminist essay just about high heels, I think!

By the way, in France (where I live) your husband wouldn't be allowed to wear knee length shorts at the swimming pool. It's Speedos or nothing. He would he required to cover his head though for hygiene reasons. Even if he happens to be completely bald. 🙃

Mvslimah · 09/05/2023 17:00

MargotBamborough · 09/05/2023 16:55

Yes, we've all seen men walking around topless in non swimming scenarios, and isn't that telling? I don't feel free to swim or sunbathe wearing just a pair of bikini bottoms, even though that is a situation in which being half naked is not actually weird, but Dave over here feels free to walk down the street wearing just a pair of shorts as soon as the thermometer hits 23 degrees. Not a care in the world for people who may feel awkward or embarrassed or nauseated by the sight of his flabby man boobs, and if any woman did objectify him, he'd probably see it as a compliment rather than an act of aggression.

As for Muslims, it all seems rather context specific. However, I do remain sceptical about the idea that it is a completely free choice, knowing as I do that putting a bikini top on isn't a completely free choice for me, but something I do because being as unclothed as men are is not acceptable in society.

And I struggle with the idea of women completely voluntarily choosing to wear the same garments which are used to oppress other women in countries like Iran.

No choice is a free choice, it’s all influenced by something or other and it oppressive in iran because of the act of compulsion not the garment itself… that line of reasoning can extend to everything though, high heels trafficked sex workers are forced to wear them, and skimpy revealing tops and clothes.

OP posts:
MargotBamborough · 09/05/2023 16:55

Mvslimah · 09/05/2023 16:31

Well I’ve definitely seen men walking around topless in the heat of summer. I think women still walk a fine line in the west with what they wear, too skimpy an outfit and she’s a slut or provocatively dresses, too conservative and she’s a frump. I think women are subject to much more policing than men are with regards to their outfit choice, this isn’t just exclusive to Muslims.

but I think you’re making a crucial mistake in thought of equating less clothes with more liberation or somehow being ‘unfair’ to women, aside from oppressive theocracies, Muslim women don’t feel that way. Traditional dress in arab countries for a man is a thobe and red and white check head covering, for women it’s a black abaya and light chiffon scarf called a shayla. The abaya is like a cloak of a coat… In Pakistani is a Salaam kameez for both, with a dupatta for the women, it’s not as if Muslim men are ok to wear speedos and women have to suffer in a thick burqa.

plus actually the abaya is super cool… it’s a light weight maxi dress and women often just wear it with a vest and shorts underneath or maybe just their underwear if out in the heat, the shayla is like a piece of chiffon, not hotter than a sun hat

Yes, we've all seen men walking around topless in non swimming scenarios, and isn't that telling? I don't feel free to swim or sunbathe wearing just a pair of bikini bottoms, even though that is a situation in which being half naked is not actually weird, but Dave over here feels free to walk down the street wearing just a pair of shorts as soon as the thermometer hits 23 degrees. Not a care in the world for people who may feel awkward or embarrassed or nauseated by the sight of his flabby man boobs, and if any woman did objectify him, he'd probably see it as a compliment rather than an act of aggression.

As for Muslims, it all seems rather context specific. However, I do remain sceptical about the idea that it is a completely free choice, knowing as I do that putting a bikini top on isn't a completely free choice for me, but something I do because being as unclothed as men are is not acceptable in society.

And I struggle with the idea of women completely voluntarily choosing to wear the same garments which are used to oppress other women in countries like Iran.

Mvslimah · 09/05/2023 16:39

^salwaar kameez, stupid autocorrect

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread