Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if you have a problem with the burkini?

817 replies

Mvslimah · 07/05/2023 20:28

Honest answers please

would you give a woman (maybe Muslim maybe Jewish) a wide berth if you saw them wearing a burkini or modest (Ie fully covered) swimsuit at a pool?

if you see a woman wearing one do you give it a second thought or is it just a meh, who cares?

tia

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
margarine17 · 08/05/2023 01:08

ohnonowwhat · 08/05/2023 01:03

I know a muslim who doesn't cover her hair or wear obviously 'modest' clothing for this reason; she considers that as we are in Britain, wearing non-western clothing stands out and announces to onlookers she is different and is therefore immodest as modesty demands she shouldn't attract attention to herself!

This actually makes more logical sense. Walking around covered from head to toe in black cloth does tend to make you stand out.

margarine17 · 08/05/2023 01:06

Mvslimah · 08/05/2023 00:31

For some it is, for most in the UK I’d say. Saudi used to be a cultural norm so not really but now it’s less and less common, obviously in the likes of Afghanistan it’s not a choice

ive worn the face veil but my husband hates it, he won’t be seen with me in it. I’ve had an odd reaction, I’ve had people shake their heads at me and then people (Muslims) just assume I’m ultra religious, both problematic . It’s very very unusual in his family, they do sort of make fun of women who wear it, gharabeeb soud, black crows

But everyone who wears a burkini is doing it freely? Unless they live in Afghanistan or large parts of the Middle East. Is that what you are saying?
So Saudi Arabia and Afghanistan are Muslim but not really Muslim ? Or a different type of Muslim?

AngryBirdsNoMore · 08/05/2023 01:04

Mvslimah · 08/05/2023 00:21

But modest in this context is the closest translation of haya حياء but Arabic is a complex language so the English doenst quite map so it’s not as straight forward as modest / immodest or decent/ indecent

حياء covers everything speech, mannerism, behaviour, inflection, bashfulness, dress, tone, gait etc. I’m using modesty here because it is the most accessible when talking to majority non Muslim people because the assumption is they won’t know Islamic terms.

hijab is more used (again wrongly) to refer to covering the woman’s body in a more dichotomous sense ie a hijabi or non hijabi.

ive also never ever encountered a Muslim triggered by the term modesty. I myself would argue it’s used sometimes as a beating stick against women by some very misogynistic cultures/ scholars/ individuals but it’s bSed on a very superficial and oversimplification of the concept of haya

I’ve never met anyone in real life triggered by the word modesty.z

ohnonowwhat · 08/05/2023 01:03

slimeandfearmetro · 08/05/2023 00:52

haya حياء

Translatable to reservedness, diffidence, humbleness, discretion, unassuming?

Your burkini is akin to what quakers call "plain dress", it's not about covering your body so much as about trying to be discreet.

I know a muslim who doesn't cover her hair or wear obviously 'modest' clothing for this reason; she considers that as we are in Britain, wearing non-western clothing stands out and announces to onlookers she is different and is therefore immodest as modesty demands she shouldn't attract attention to herself!

Ilovetea42 · 08/05/2023 01:01

I think it's up to the individual what they wear and I'd have no further thought than that- it has nothing to do with me. And I find it sad that posters are jumping to the conclusion that women only do this under men's authority- many women choose to wear more modest clothing eh burkini/ burkha etc because they feel its the best way for them to practice their faith. To me empowerment is allowing women to choose their own personal expression. So I also wouldn't assume they'd been forced to do it.

ohnonowwhat · 08/05/2023 00:54

Mvslimah · 08/05/2023 00:21

But modest in this context is the closest translation of haya حياء but Arabic is a complex language so the English doenst quite map so it’s not as straight forward as modest / immodest or decent/ indecent

حياء covers everything speech, mannerism, behaviour, inflection, bashfulness, dress, tone, gait etc. I’m using modesty here because it is the most accessible when talking to majority non Muslim people because the assumption is they won’t know Islamic terms.

hijab is more used (again wrongly) to refer to covering the woman’s body in a more dichotomous sense ie a hijabi or non hijabi.

ive also never ever encountered a Muslim triggered by the term modesty. I myself would argue it’s used sometimes as a beating stick against women by some very misogynistic cultures/ scholars/ individuals but it’s bSed on a very superficial and oversimplification of the concept of haya

I appreciate that it doesn't have quite the same meaning but do you see that the British meaning is outdated and sexist? This is my issue. I do know not all women have a problem with it, but it is very much one of my pet hates - I think the casual and accepted use of this sort of term keeps the notion of a woman's character being linked to her attire in our culture, whether consciously or otherwise. And though you may say you don't think women who don't wear 'modest' clothing are sluts, or trying to attract men etc (and I believe you!) there are certainly some who do; I remember a few years ago some woman was being interviewed and mentioned that she wore the hijab because she wasn't trying to attract men. The interview wasn't about that, actually can't remember what it was about but I remember how she said it offhandedly as though it were obvious that if you showed your hair you were trying to attract men. That got my back up! That's just one example, there have been many I've seen or read where women have suggested that if you didn't want male interest you would cover yourself, and that the reason western women don't is because we're dressing for men - even in this thread! That interpretation of the term 'modest' is very much in line with the old British one and I think it's important to make the distinction between wearing full-coverage clothing because your religion asks it and wearing full-coverage clothing because to do otherwise would be trying to attract men. I think using the term 'haya' would be ideal, especially as it would help make the distinction - and we've managed to cope with 'halal', 'hijab' etc so would probably get used to it! But obviously this is just my opinion, I am not expecting you to convince the rest of the UK to adopt the new expression 😁

Finally, I have encountered more than one muslim woman who has been 'triggered' by the term, they have told some pretty horrible stories about how their communities have treated them and have worked hard to get away from them. However, I'm only talking about three women in total so I doubt they're representative! I have met a few more though who were raised in muslim communities and are now confirmed atheists and they also have some pretty horrible stories...

slimeandfearmetro · 08/05/2023 00:52

haya حياء

Translatable to reservedness, diffidence, humbleness, discretion, unassuming?

Your burkini is akin to what quakers call "plain dress", it's not about covering your body so much as about trying to be discreet.

NeedCoffeeNowPlease · 08/05/2023 00:46

Just for the original question - I'd notice but not mind and not give it a second glance. If you're in the sun, all the better for sun protection. I would only object if my choosing to wear something else was made an issue by you or anyone who judged my swimsuit to be 'immodest'. It's actually pretty modest but still a standard swimsuit.

slimeandfearmetro · 08/05/2023 00:42

NatashaDancing · 08/05/2023 00:34

Your long answer doesn't address the points of how offensive your use of the term "modest clothing" is.

Guess you're also offended by chapter seven of Mary Wollstonecraft's Vindication of the Rights of Women?

parmesansally · 08/05/2023 00:39

I wouldn't have any negative thoughts about it. The only thing I'd be thinking (and maybe looking as pondering) would be if it was comfortable ie does sand get stuck in there? Think lots of people wear them for different reasons, ie Sun protection

NotBloodyCovid · 08/05/2023 00:35

I don't have a problem with it but i must say i feel sad when i see dad and son in front of car and mother sitting in back. I feel sad when i see the burkas on ladies in hot weather and father n children in t-shirts and shorts. Just wrong

NatashaDancing · 08/05/2023 00:34

Mvslimah · 08/05/2023 00:21

But modest in this context is the closest translation of haya حياء but Arabic is a complex language so the English doenst quite map so it’s not as straight forward as modest / immodest or decent/ indecent

حياء covers everything speech, mannerism, behaviour, inflection, bashfulness, dress, tone, gait etc. I’m using modesty here because it is the most accessible when talking to majority non Muslim people because the assumption is they won’t know Islamic terms.

hijab is more used (again wrongly) to refer to covering the woman’s body in a more dichotomous sense ie a hijabi or non hijabi.

ive also never ever encountered a Muslim triggered by the term modesty. I myself would argue it’s used sometimes as a beating stick against women by some very misogynistic cultures/ scholars/ individuals but it’s bSed on a very superficial and oversimplification of the concept of haya

Your long answer doesn't address the points of how offensive your use of the term "modest clothing" is.

Mvslimah · 08/05/2023 00:33

CampervanKween · 08/05/2023 00:26

All religion is mediaeval nonsense so I guess we are never going to agree here. I will leave you to it.

I don’t have a problem with birkinis for the record.

I do see a double standard that the men wear western clothing and the women do not. I would have more respect for them if both were equally covered.

I wear western clothes, in fact it’s 97% of what I wear.

OP posts:
Mvslimah · 08/05/2023 00:31

margarine17 · 08/05/2023 00:26

OP - out of interest do you find the burka and niqab as a choice for women too?

For some it is, for most in the UK I’d say. Saudi used to be a cultural norm so not really but now it’s less and less common, obviously in the likes of Afghanistan it’s not a choice

ive worn the face veil but my husband hates it, he won’t be seen with me in it. I’ve had an odd reaction, I’ve had people shake their heads at me and then people (Muslims) just assume I’m ultra religious, both problematic . It’s very very unusual in his family, they do sort of make fun of women who wear it, gharabeeb soud, black crows

OP posts:
Rinkydinkydoodle · 08/05/2023 00:30

OP, I’m really sorry a group of proudly ignorant people felt the need to spoil your swim. I think burkinis look sporty and practical.

To the posters saying they think you covering your skin is oppression, and that you’re being controlled by a man, I’d say they could maybe take a wee moment and think about why so many posters on here are saying they’d also quite like to wear something that covered their bodies; not for religious purposes, but to hide perceived flaws.

Lots of women in Britain are subjugated by a manufactured tyranny of female perfection. There are hundreds of posts on here about ways to get ourselves closer to how women are ‘meant’ to look and every single week we read pained messages, women distraught over their weight, the natural signs of ageing, breast size, every imaginable aspect of their physical appearance.

Maybe it’s all been a construct of the patriarchy to distract us, and God knows how much money is made every year by the deliberate creation and exploitation of life-long female insecurities, but there’s abundant proof anywhere online or in print media a person cares to look; so many of us are ashamed of ourselves and fear the judgement of others, to the point we see our bodies as a battle to be won. So we’re hardly all skipping around in some utopia of perfect freedom, are we?

NatashaDancing · 08/05/2023 00:27

Summer567 · 07/05/2023 23:01

I think your comment is rather disgusting, modesty can mean one thing to you and a totally different thing to me. It's not your place to make judgements, who an earth are you to make rules on what is acceptable in society.

You and the OP are making judgements by your use of the offensive phrase "modest clothing"

CampervanKween · 08/05/2023 00:26

All religion is mediaeval nonsense so I guess we are never going to agree here. I will leave you to it.

I don’t have a problem with birkinis for the record.

I do see a double standard that the men wear western clothing and the women do not. I would have more respect for them if both were equally covered.

margarine17 · 08/05/2023 00:26

OP - out of interest do you find the burka and niqab as a choice for women too?

ForPeaceSake · 08/05/2023 00:25

Whataretheodds · 07/05/2023 20:45

I would have no issues with the individual woman wearing it.

I do have an issue with cultures that make women feel they have to cover up like that while men get to wear swim shorts.

Muslim men are not supposed to wear swim shorts. They should be covered at least from the navel to the knees.

RobertaFirmino · 08/05/2023 00:24

CampervanKween · 08/05/2023 00:15

It's not their choice in Iran though and other countries. They are being murdered for refusing to cover up.

That is not the fault of Islam. Nowhere in the Quran does it say that women who do not cover themselves should be murdered. This is the fault of extremist males. The patriarchy.
Many hideous things are done to women in the name of Christianity. Yet the Bible teaches forgiveness. Again, this is the fault of extremism.

slimeandfearmetro · 08/05/2023 00:23

CampervanKween · 08/05/2023 00:20

No-one is doing that though.

Apart from the people giving OP the side-eye and muttered criticism at the pool, and the people on here saying the burkinis are unfeminist...

Mvslimah · 08/05/2023 00:21

ohnonowwhat · 08/05/2023 00:09

Immodest is the antonym of modest therefore by calling certain clothes modest you are implying others are immodest, and immodest is always an insult. You may not think this consciously and you may not care at all what other women wear but using the term 'modest' is offensive as in British history/culture it essentially means 'appropriate for a female' when used to refer to clothing. As you presumably know, until the 20th Century British women wore long skirts and the shortening of the hemline was an important part of the evolution of women's rights, along with other freedoms in what we wore such as bikinis, hot pants etc. Essentially, women fought very hard for the right to be able to wear whatever the hell they liked and not be judged for it - or called immodest - thereby challenging the notion that a woman's character is indicated by her clothing, though let's face it, we're nowhere near achieving that; if a woman is in a skimpy mini-dress she will still almost certainly be treated differently than a woman in a demure twinset, and though I'm no expert there are certainly a lot of whispers that a rape victim wearing revealing clothing is often treated differently to one wearing a baggy jumper. I think that is wrong and that's the problem I have with the term, it suggests a link between what someone is wearing and their behaviour - as you say yourself, modesty is far more than just clothing and in wider British culture it tends to refer solely to behaviour nowadays; I don't think we should go back to including clothing. And because I have an issue with you using outdated misogynistic terms you feel "real animosity" in my words towards muslims?! It's actually pretty unpleasant to accuse someone of islamophobia for disagreeing with you (though convenient). You'll no doubt be surprised to learn that there are actually muslims who don't use the term as it is considered offensive, and no doubt utterly shocked to learn not all muslims even dress 'modestly' (and I think also don't appreciate being called immodest). I assure you I react the same if I hear anyone of any culture, religion or skin colour using the term, and almost always it's white western women.

But modest in this context is the closest translation of haya حياء but Arabic is a complex language so the English doenst quite map so it’s not as straight forward as modest / immodest or decent/ indecent

حياء covers everything speech, mannerism, behaviour, inflection, bashfulness, dress, tone, gait etc. I’m using modesty here because it is the most accessible when talking to majority non Muslim people because the assumption is they won’t know Islamic terms.

hijab is more used (again wrongly) to refer to covering the woman’s body in a more dichotomous sense ie a hijabi or non hijabi.

ive also never ever encountered a Muslim triggered by the term modesty. I myself would argue it’s used sometimes as a beating stick against women by some very misogynistic cultures/ scholars/ individuals but it’s bSed on a very superficial and oversimplification of the concept of haya

OP posts:
CampervanKween · 08/05/2023 00:20

No-one is doing that though.

slimeandfearmetro · 08/05/2023 00:19

CampervanKween · 08/05/2023 00:15

It's not their choice in Iran though and other countries. They are being murdered for refusing to cover up.

Pressuring British muslim women to wear conventional swimwear won't improve the situation in Iran and will make it worse for muslim women in the UK.

JuvenileEmu · 08/05/2023 00:19

AngryGreasedSantaCatcus · 08/05/2023 00:16

OP is not responsible for that.

Of course, non Muslim women only ever wear clothes for themselves, what men think of them is completely irrelevant Hmm

Swipe left for the next trending thread