Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if you have a problem with the burkini?

817 replies

Mvslimah · 07/05/2023 20:28

Honest answers please

would you give a woman (maybe Muslim maybe Jewish) a wide berth if you saw them wearing a burkini or modest (Ie fully covered) swimsuit at a pool?

if you see a woman wearing one do you give it a second thought or is it just a meh, who cares?

tia

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
cpphelp · 08/05/2023 10:14

The navy and gold Lyra one you pictured is gorgeous @Mvslimah
I'm not religious, but I'm SO tempted by that.... no sunscreen faff is my ideal!
Also, would you just put flip flops on with that, dry out, and wear to a beach bar for lunch for instance?

Sorry if I've got that all wrong.

BogRollBOGOF · 08/05/2023 10:14

I swim in different pools/ sessions/ settings with varying intentions and choose my swimwear accordingly. In a 5⁰C lake in winter, it's full neoprene including a hood so only my face is uncovered. I'm also happy to wear bikinis at the other end of the scale. I often use a rash vest for sun protection if outside, or if I CBA to incur shaving rash, or if I'm having more of a splash session with the children and I'm in and out of the water because it's more of a consistent feeling on the skin. One pool I go to is in a very mixed community; I went one day last year wearing (clean) cycling shorts over my cossie because I was protecting some chaffing incurred while running. In some pools, my swimwear choices are normal, in some, they are more unusual.

My sons wear shortie wet suits as they feel the cold easily.

Choices of practical swimwear that facilitates swimming is a good thing for all.
Practical headwear that facilitates other sports such as running are also positive, and inclusive.

SaulSobieski · 08/05/2023 10:14

LolaSmiles · 08/05/2023 10:09

SaulSobieski
Out of interest did you manage to find any nice rash vests? Most of the ones I've seen have been quite plain and sporty.

They do tend to be sporty/surf-y.

Amazon has some nice ones.... Not getting onto the ethical issues of Amazon.

SaulSobieski · 08/05/2023 10:12

Capitulatingpanda · 08/05/2023 10:11

Honestly first thought that pops into my head is it's a pretty good way of reducing cancer risk and sun damage to skin.

Some people do wear them for that reason.

Was Nigella Lawson not one of them.

Growlybear83 · 08/05/2023 10:11

SparklyBlackKitten · 08/05/2023 09:14

I would look
And judge
And feel sorry

Because of these women were born in a different country without the islam and their misogynist beliefs: they would be able to be free

So yeah

Interesting. So how would you judge my daughter? She was raised in London by two white middle class parents; my husband is an agnostic, I'm an atheist, and my mum was a very committed Christian. I was careful to never indoctrinate my daughter in any way. She had a very active social life during her teens and 20s, had boyfriends from about 14, drank as much as anyone else during her teens and at university, dabbled in various drugs, had lots of sexual relationships.

She loved studying and went on to do a masters before travelling for a year. My daughter then lived in Egypt for a while and ended up moving to Jordan three and a half years ago. She had often said that she was looking for something 'more important' in her life, and she studied a number of religions during her 20s. She met her husband two and a half years ago and it was clear from the outset that they are soulmates. She converted to Islam about 18 months ago, having learnt a great deal about the religion. We wondered if her husband had pressured her in any way to convert, and talked to him about it at length, when he asked my husbands permission to ask her to marry him. It was clear that he had put no pressure on her at all to convert and I wasn't surprised by her decision because she had already told me that she thought mush of the religion made sense to her. We'd spent quite a lot of time with her husband before there was even a suggestion of her converting, and it was lovely to see that he just adores her for who she is. He knows all about her past and accepts it without hesitation. My daughter's decision to wear a hijab was entirely her choice and She has said many times that she finds the way she dresses now is liberating.

As an atheist I don't profess to understand her decision to convert to any religion, whether Islam, Christianity, or anything else, but she has never been anywhere near as happy, calm, or contented as she is now. Her husband cherishes her and is genuinely a very good man. As a mother, I can't ask for any more for her.

Capitulatingpanda · 08/05/2023 10:11

Honestly first thought that pops into my head is it's a pretty good way of reducing cancer risk and sun damage to skin.

SaulSobieski · 08/05/2023 10:11

Mvslimah · 08/05/2023 10:08

Well swimming in an abaya is stupid and dangerous, I know where I used to live in Saudi women did the same unless it was a private beach and they wore ‘modest swimwear’. There is a school of thought, most likely in this region where they have a similar school of jurisprudence that burquinis aren’t modest enough it probably has to do with that, but you can get some very baggy ones and swim dresses that basically look like abayas but aren’t deadly in the water, so hopefully women would wear that now

i won’t go into multiple wives here

Thet weren't attempting to swim in an abaya, they couldn't, they were just paddling the the very edge of the surf. That's my point.

It was very limiting and inconvenient; while their husbands were in shorts a BD a short sleeved polo.shirt.

I would be glad to see a Muslim woman in a Burkini compared to that; at least she can swim and enjoy the water properly.

Mvslimah · 08/05/2023 10:10

*it doesn’t imply

OP posts:
Mvslimah · 08/05/2023 10:10

NatashaDancing · 08/05/2023 10:08

You could just describe your swimsuit as "full coverage" or your dresses as "long" "long sleeved"

There are other meanings of "modest" e.g unassuming in the estimation of one's abilities or achievements or humble. It's almost "immodest" (in the sense of those meanings) to make such a thing about wearing "modest" clothes

But it’s not just a long sleeved swim suit because that makes it seem like a normal cozzie with long sleeves… I used modest because that’s what I type into google if I’m looking to buy one. I doesn’t imply you are immodest

OP posts:
LolaSmiles · 08/05/2023 10:09

SaulSobieski
Out of interest did you manage to find any nice rash vests? Most of the ones I've seen have been quite plain and sporty.

Mvslimah · 08/05/2023 10:08

SaulSobieski · 08/05/2023 10:00

What I found weird in Qatar (not away from the beach - women and men were wearing pretty much the same thing with the same amount of coverage away from the beach, unless thexwinan chose to cover her face and or hands, which was not the majority) .... Was that women were in the beach - not even wearing a burkini - but wearing an abaya, head scarf etc. .... While the man with them was wearing shorts and a short sleeve polo shirt.

I have to say I did think wtf.

So "modest" dressing is required for women at all times in public, but not men.

If the men had also worn their usual thobe and headscarf on the beach (with the accompanying level of inconvenience for a beach) - absolutely fine with me. But they didn't.

To make it even more wtf, when I was in west Africa a Dutch guy told me he was told off for wearing shorts in Ivory Coast - due to them not being modest. So clearly strict interpretation means no showing off your (even lower) legs for men in shorts. Yet this was fine for many of the men on the beach in Qatar, while their wives were stuck in an abaya , only able to paddle a bit holding the hem up.

If you want to dress modestly - make it males and females; only way it's equal.

Though tbh, with polygyny/multiple wives to one man built into the religion (though I understand it's not that common depending on the country); how is it ever equal anyway. I know theoretically the wife/wives don't have to stay if he does that (?) but ateotd it's not easy to leave for a no of reasons.

Well swimming in an abaya is stupid and dangerous, I know where I used to live in Saudi women did the same unless it was a private beach and they wore ‘modest swimwear’. There is a school of thought, most likely in this region where they have a similar school of jurisprudence that burquinis aren’t modest enough it probably has to do with that, but you can get some very baggy ones and swim dresses that basically look like abayas but aren’t deadly in the water, so hopefully women would wear that now

i won’t go into multiple wives here

OP posts:
AngryGreasedSantaCatcus · 08/05/2023 10:08

I assume none of the women objecting to the word modest clothing buy clothes from high street shops that have a modest clothing section?

NatashaDancing · 08/05/2023 10:08

Mvslimah · 08/05/2023 09:10

Exactly! It’s a difficult word to translate

You could just describe your swimsuit as "full coverage" or your dresses as "long" "long sleeved"

There are other meanings of "modest" e.g unassuming in the estimation of one's abilities or achievements or humble. It's almost "immodest" (in the sense of those meanings) to make such a thing about wearing "modest" clothes

SaulSobieski · 08/05/2023 10:06

Yet this was fine for many of the men on the beach in Qatar

Also in Dubai.

(I don't know if they were Qatari/Emirati people or Muslim people visiting from other countries).

SaulSobieski · 08/05/2023 10:04

Anyway on a purely "see a woman in a Burkini at the beach or pool' without thinking a out deeper significance .... I wouldn't give a fuck and would not avoid her or judge her.

I would be glad she had the opportunity to swim, rather than only paddling at the most in an abaya.

I'm very fair skinned and can't be bothered with sunscreen so I wear a rash vest with at least elbow length sleeves and lycra leggings regularly myself anyway. The only difference is the lack of skirt.

SaulSobieski · 08/05/2023 10:00

What I found weird in Qatar (not away from the beach - women and men were wearing pretty much the same thing with the same amount of coverage away from the beach, unless thexwinan chose to cover her face and or hands, which was not the majority) .... Was that women were in the beach - not even wearing a burkini - but wearing an abaya, head scarf etc. .... While the man with them was wearing shorts and a short sleeve polo shirt.

I have to say I did think wtf.

So "modest" dressing is required for women at all times in public, but not men.

If the men had also worn their usual thobe and headscarf on the beach (with the accompanying level of inconvenience for a beach) - absolutely fine with me. But they didn't.

To make it even more wtf, when I was in west Africa a Dutch guy told me he was told off for wearing shorts in Ivory Coast - due to them not being modest. So clearly strict interpretation means no showing off your (even lower) legs for men in shorts. Yet this was fine for many of the men on the beach in Qatar, while their wives were stuck in an abaya , only able to paddle a bit holding the hem up.

If you want to dress modestly - make it males and females; only way it's equal.

Though tbh, with polygyny/multiple wives to one man built into the religion (though I understand it's not that common depending on the country); how is it ever equal anyway. I know theoretically the wife/wives don't have to stay if he does that (?) but ateotd it's not easy to leave for a no of reasons.

Mvslimah · 08/05/2023 09:59

Desperatetime · 08/05/2023 09:50

Doesn't bother me but they do look like the grim reaper a bit

You think?

To ask if you have a problem with the burkini?
OP posts:
LadyRoughDiamond · 08/05/2023 09:59

I welcome new options! Just come back from a holiday in the far east where people of all nationalities were wearing versions of modest swimwear. After a couple of days I started to think that the various tops and bottoms were a good, practical way to avoid sunburn and invested in a rash vest for snorkelling.
A friend in the uk has started swimming in board shorts and a rash vest because she can’t be bothered with a restrictive and more revealing cozzie. Apparently that’s becoming popular amongst younger people now.

Ginmonkeyagain · 08/05/2023 09:56

I see muslim men in our area wearing skull caps and loose trousers and overshirts or robes, especially on Fridays.

Muslims came from a wide variety of racial and cultural background therefore dress will be as influenced by culture as religion.

Maireas · 08/05/2023 09:51

True, because the Muslim boys are dressed exactly the same as the other boys, no difference. The girls are really set apart.
It's very noticeable, but as you say may be the community rather than the religion.

Mvslimah · 08/05/2023 09:50

Handpickled · 08/05/2023 09:28

Maybe women only areas? To feel the sun on your skin? Really? As opposed to all women having the right to go where they want whether in a bikini or burkini. The vitamin D issue is a serious one that remains a big issue for women and especially babies in the Asian community.

It’s beyond crass to equate wearing a burka with a desire to hide your PJs or lack of satirical flair. Liking the burkini as a style rather than representative of a philosophy is also odd.

I usually swim in long shorts and a long sleeved rash vest as am so pale is sunburn that is my problem. I am nearly as covered up as someone in a burkini, although mine are form fitting as I couldn’t tolerate flapping, other than when I change in the open air at the side of the beech or lake when I love a short burst of air bathing. That’s the fundamental difference between what the different outfits signify. Mine comes with more choice and no implication I am modest or unable to mix with male strangers. That said I would always vocally defend any woman’s rights to wear what they want and despair of countries like France as their lack of tolerance will imprison the very women they proposed would be liberated by the law changes while encouraging more general anti Muslim abuse, like the OP suffered.

Muslim women couldn’t wear a traditional bathing suit in women only areas anyway… maybe a swimsuit with board shorts but that’s about it

OP posts:
Desperatetime · 08/05/2023 09:50

Doesn't bother me but they do look like the grim reaper a bit

Mvslimah · 08/05/2023 09:49

Maireas · 08/05/2023 09:44

Genuine question, @Mvslimah - so it's to identify a woman as Muslim. Why aren't men so identified? I teach many Muslim teenagers. I can always tell who the Muslim girls are, by veils and long black over garments. Not so the boys. They wear the regular uniform. Same situation with the men in my town, regular western clothes. No identification as Muslim apart from the occasional one with a small head covering.

Well they should be, that’s why they are told to also dress modestly, nothing form fitting and covered from the navel to the knee and keep a beard, there are certain haircuts they can’t have either. I think like with many cultures because of the patriarchy men’s appearances aren’t policed as heavily as women’s, and you can see that manifested in some Muslim families

OP posts:
Mvslimah · 08/05/2023 09:45

Handpickled · 08/05/2023 09:36

OP ‘there may well be some family pressure’ is a glib summary of the enormous pressure placed on girls and women within the Muslim community to do all sorts of things including wearing certain clothes. I loathe the impact I see on bright capable teenage girls who always are subject to religious judgement across all faiths. In the UK this is a big class or social divide issue too but too many of those girls at the bottom of that divide get little control over their lives.

I was exclusively talking about adult women who wear a face veil. All of whom that I know have chosen as adults and their husbands and a lot of their family do not like it.

what you’re referring to is largely a social class issue to do with education and is way to complex to delve into here. There are many families who will take the approach of puberty and you cover but there’s nothing that then about ‘covering’ that would intrinsically stop a young girl from achieving. What you’re talking about is mosque education held in higher regard than state education, no encouragement for school exams, maybe even the opposite, removed from school at the nearest opportunity, and groomed for marriage, to perhaps a relative from back home very very young, so choice there is a mere illusion, it may not be a forced marriage as such but there’s never really been an option to say no. In these circumstances what women do or do not have to wear is the least of their problems

OP posts:
Maireas · 08/05/2023 09:44

Genuine question, @Mvslimah - so it's to identify a woman as Muslim. Why aren't men so identified? I teach many Muslim teenagers. I can always tell who the Muslim girls are, by veils and long black over garments. Not so the boys. They wear the regular uniform. Same situation with the men in my town, regular western clothes. No identification as Muslim apart from the occasional one with a small head covering.

Swipe left for the next trending thread