Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if you have a problem with the burkini?

817 replies

Mvslimah · 07/05/2023 20:28

Honest answers please

would you give a woman (maybe Muslim maybe Jewish) a wide berth if you saw them wearing a burkini or modest (Ie fully covered) swimsuit at a pool?

if you see a woman wearing one do you give it a second thought or is it just a meh, who cares?

tia

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
Ginmonkeyagain · 08/05/2023 10:46

It's interesting the interpretatations of modest and I suspect it is a trnslation thing. As a white British woman I use the word modest most often on its wider sense to mean plain, inexpensive, small - eg a modest celebration or a modest buffet.

Clothing wise I am more likely to use the word "appropriate". For example I don't think it is appropriate to wear revealing clothes at work or to a formal wedding.

monsteramunch · 08/05/2023 10:45

But for what it’s worth I’m sorry if anyone found my use of the term modest offensive or like it made a value judgement about them and their worth. Simply put it’s easier to use it as everyone seems to know what it means

Cross posted and just saw this.

Appreciate you saying this.

Fully covered is definitely a better term IMO as it's much clearer and doesn't have room for anyone to project a perceived value judgement onto the phrase.

And re the phrase 'modest swimwear', while almost everyone my age (30s) would know what it meant I don't think that's as true of older age groups as it hasn't been a concept as visible to shoppers / in the press for that long in the grand scheme.

Anyway, thanks for reconsidering your language it's appreciated and I think useful to be respectful from both sides as I said.

Ludlow2 · 08/05/2023 10:44

Mvslimah · 08/05/2023 10:37

ive used it in response to questions asked and it is how the swim wear is referred to.

what about freedom of speech? Freedom to offend, I often see that on threads about Muslims, we should be able to mock our prophet and beliefs
, draw cartoons, burn Qurans because freedom of thought means freedom to offend. Only works one way I suppose but I’ll use fully covered in this instance

To be fair. That is how this swimwear is marketed so OP did not chose the word, the market did.

I would google modest swimwear when I buy swimwear for reasons given above.

I wear for choice to give me confidence so I can enjoy swimming. I dont want my own insecurities to take away that joy of myself in the open water.

TwinkleSprite · 08/05/2023 10:44

If I saw someone in a burkini, I'd think they want to continue to dress modestly but still enjoy life and do the things they enjoy.

Nothing wrong with that at all, it's great that Muslim women can still go swimming and respect their faith.

monsteramunch · 08/05/2023 10:42

what about freedom of speech? Freedom to offend, I often see that on threads about Muslims, we should be able to mock our prophet and beliefs , draw cartoons, burn Qurans because freedom of thought means freedom to offend. Only works one way I suppose but I’ll use fully covered in this instance

And that would be hypocritical if the same people saying those things on those threads were the ones saying they find the word modest in this context offensive, absolutely.

But actually I'm sure that like me, some or many of the people saying that are actually also ones who would discourage others from saying such things.

My post was respectful and measured but your response was quite sarcastic, I'm not sure why tbh.

But yeah I think fully covered is a more respectful term for all the reasons people shared on this thread when discussing why the word modest can be offensive to some. Or 'haya' as you've explained that term now and it makes sense to me plus I've learned something.

dig135 · 08/05/2023 10:42

I wouldn't stare or make comments but, being honest, it makes me feel a bit sad that the woman need to cover up (whether through their choice or their religion).

Similarly, I saw a girl under 10 wearing a long black robe on a sweltering day at Thorpe Park while her school friends were in shorts and T-shirts. They were running around on the climbing frame and she looked hampered by her outfit.

I feel the same when my SIL covers up to come to our house (she and my brother are Muslim) when it's just me and my school aged kids. I'm all for personal freedom but it does make me feel a bit uncomfortable.

OhBeAFineGuyKissMe · 08/05/2023 10:40

I'm another who finds the word modest offensive. Use the word "haya" instead. People can cope with learning new words. The clothing equivalent of halal.

In English modest implies virtue and also clothes can be immodest. That is deeply offensive.

Mvslimah · 08/05/2023 10:40

Mvslimah · 08/05/2023 10:37

ive used it in response to questions asked and it is how the swim wear is referred to.

what about freedom of speech? Freedom to offend, I often see that on threads about Muslims, we should be able to mock our prophet and beliefs
, draw cartoons, burn Qurans because freedom of thought means freedom to offend. Only works one way I suppose but I’ll use fully covered in this instance

But for what it’s worth I’m sorry if anyone found my use of the term modest offensive or like it made a value judgement about them and their worth. Simply put it’s easier to use it as everyone seems to know what it means

OP posts:
Handpickled · 08/05/2023 10:38

Sorry OP - in my area the Muslim community is largely Asian. The girls and women I spoke about are Asian Muslims though I suspect the social divide is reflected across most UK Muslim communities.

Ludlow2 · 08/05/2023 10:37

I prefer 'modest' swimwear for myself.
It gives me confidence.

I want to enjoy swimming without my own insecurities taking away that joy.

Mvslimah · 08/05/2023 10:37

monsteramunch · 08/05/2023 10:28

OP you keep saying that the word modest shouldn't be offensive and that people are wrong to believe it is offensive.

People have explained why they find it offensive in a number of ways. They've done so repeatedly.

I think if we are all keen to be tolerant of one another and respectful, that needs to work both ways and simply telling people they are in the wrong to find a term offensive isn't really on.

You've said that it's not a direct translation to the English language meaning of 'modest' but have continued to use it rather than the alternative wording you yourself used to explain why you don't feel the word modest should offend women.

Why not adapt your language so it is less likely to offend, in the spirit of tolerance and respect?

If a group of Muslim women found a term I used offensive, I can't imagine just flat out telling them they're wrong repeatedly. I would listen, take their response on board and adapt my language to use other wording that still makes sense to me but isn't offensive. We know that wording exists because you used it to explain why you don't believe modest should offend people.

Something to think about.

ive used it in response to questions asked and it is how the swim wear is referred to.

what about freedom of speech? Freedom to offend, I often see that on threads about Muslims, we should be able to mock our prophet and beliefs
, draw cartoons, burn Qurans because freedom of thought means freedom to offend. Only works one way I suppose but I’ll use fully covered in this instance

OP posts:
WashAsDelicates · 08/05/2023 10:37

What's wrong with 'immodest', anyway?

Plenty of people enjoy wearing immodest clothing in situations where they consider it would be appropriate.

I tried on a beautiful frock the other day, but rejected it because it was too modest. I wanted something with a lower neckline and closer-fitted on the waist to show off my curves. In other words, I wanted something less demure, more immodest.

You don't go into church in a bikini, because that would be immodest by the standards of the religion. You don't go into work in a bikini, because that would be inappropriate by the standards of office work. In both cases the inappropriateness is about how much flesh is bared, just that one situation labels it as an issue of modesty. Yet it's the same thing.

Ludlow2 · 08/05/2023 10:35

It is a style of address that you find appropriate individually to your culture or faith.

What OP may find modest is not everyone's interpretation.

We just need to accept that rather than fight over the word modest.

Handpickled · 08/05/2023 10:33

yes OP I said the Asian women with the least choice were from certain social groups but that takes me full circle to my disquiet with one woman’s choice (such as free choice is …) to wear a garment that is also used to oppress some women within the same religious community in this country and is forced at pain of death on other women from the same religious community but who live in other countries. I still support your choice, as I do that of my friends, I even understand what my friends say about why they have adopted more conservative forms of dress but I don’t like what else they symbolise.

Jonei · 08/05/2023 10:32

I would probably notice someone wearing it, but I don't have a problem with it.

AudibleEyeroll · 08/05/2023 10:31

girlfriend44 · 07/05/2023 20:32

I think what a shame, that they are bowing down to what a man says, when a man can do what they want.
They are agreeing to be treated like a second class citizen, men and women are equal.

I'm glad it's not me. It's time they came out of the dark ages.

as someone who wears modest swimwear - if DH told me to cover up I’d be booking a flight to the nearest nudist beach

monsteramunch · 08/05/2023 10:28

OP you keep saying that the word modest shouldn't be offensive and that people are wrong to believe it is offensive.

People have explained why they find it offensive in a number of ways. They've done so repeatedly.

I think if we are all keen to be tolerant of one another and respectful, that needs to work both ways and simply telling people they are in the wrong to find a term offensive isn't really on.

You've said that it's not a direct translation to the English language meaning of 'modest' but have continued to use it rather than the alternative wording you yourself used to explain why you don't feel the word modest should offend women.

Why not adapt your language so it is less likely to offend, in the spirit of tolerance and respect?

If a group of Muslim women found a term I used offensive, I can't imagine just flat out telling them they're wrong repeatedly. I would listen, take their response on board and adapt my language to use other wording that still makes sense to me but isn't offensive. We know that wording exists because you used it to explain why you don't believe modest should offend people.

Something to think about.

Neopolitan · 08/05/2023 10:27

I wouldn't have a problem with a woman wearing it, no. But I would if it were a little girl because I'd worry the message she was being sent, that in order to keep herself safe from men, and in order to be considered 'modest', she has to cover up her entire body. It sends the wrong message. Teens/adult women, go for it. I'd barely notice. But it does break my heart when I see little girls in them and in hijab.

Mvslimah · 08/05/2023 10:26

NatashaDancing · 08/05/2023 10:19

Yet you continue to use the word "modest" despite being told how offensive it is? This point was raised several pages ago.

because that is how the items are referred to, it’s how the brands who make them market them and I’m also using it in my explanation to you why I’m actually using the term in the first instance.

ive never encountered people being so triggered by this term, im not triggered by a Jewish woman explaining the M word to me, she wouldn’t consider my wearing trousers to be ‘modest’ (sorry couldn’t help using it here) but that’s her beliefs not mine…

OP posts:
CaptainMyCaptain · 08/05/2023 10:24

ohnonowwhat · 08/05/2023 01:03

I know a muslim who doesn't cover her hair or wear obviously 'modest' clothing for this reason; she considers that as we are in Britain, wearing non-western clothing stands out and announces to onlookers she is different and is therefore immodest as modesty demands she shouldn't attract attention to herself!

That is pretty much the only reason that I as a non Muslim, pale skinned, red head in my late 60s wouldn't wear a burkini. I would like to wear one but it would cause more attention and speculation than a conventional swimsuit so if I have to wear a swimsuit I get one with the most coverage I can get away with. I usually just keep my clothes on as i rarely go in swimming pools (it must be at least 5 years). My husband would probably prefer me to wear a bikini. I am not overweight, by the way, my physique is pretty good for my age tbh but I see no reason prove that to anyone else.

Mvslimah · 08/05/2023 10:23

cpphelp · 08/05/2023 10:14

The navy and gold Lyra one you pictured is gorgeous @Mvslimah
I'm not religious, but I'm SO tempted by that.... no sunscreen faff is my ideal!
Also, would you just put flip flops on with that, dry out, and wear to a beach bar for lunch for instance?

Sorry if I've got that all wrong.

It is nice isn’t it, on the pricey side, if you do get one they come up a bit small, so size up or you’ll be like me going down the water slides in dubai and the poppers flying open. Yeah so I’d Chuck on some flip flops and dry out just in that or if I went to a restaurant or a mooch around the shops say if on hols, I might put a sarong around or maybe a light chiffon/ linen kimono style shirt or something, big sunnies and a hat to protect my face from the sun,

maybe something like below, matched to the swimsuit of course

To ask if you have a problem with the burkini?
OP posts:
KimberleyClark · 08/05/2023 10:19

No I don’t.

NatashaDancing · 08/05/2023 10:19

Mvslimah · 08/05/2023 10:10

*it doesn’t imply

Yet you continue to use the word "modest" despite being told how offensive it is? This point was raised several pages ago.

NatashaDancing · 08/05/2023 10:16

Bagsundermyeyestoday · 08/05/2023 09:19

I don't know anyone well enough from that culture to be able to comment knowledgeably on that, but I thought some people don't mind (pr prefer) a burqua (and/or burquini), so I don't think you should impose your own Western views on other cultures and say they're inferior.
And as far as shaving their legs, can you imagine if women in the UK didn't? Or underarms? Or upper lips? I think the sexism is just as rife, just not overt.

You might want to read a bit more about the plight of women in Afghanistan or the protests by women in Iran. Link below might help.

As for women not shaving their legs - at most they might get an odd look.

https://www.womensvoicesnow.org/mahsa-amini?gclid=Cj0KCQjwu-KiBhCsARIsAPztUF3eBa5SMqdElh0URUJHeFRKcMp00IW7OBSzSrCRNpD1fQEdoygoRQQaAmlNEALw_wcB

5 Things You Need to Know About Protests Prompted by Mahsa Aminis Death Slide 1 (source_ Ozan Köse_AFP_Getty Images)

Mahsa Amini's Death: 5 Things You Need to Know

22-year-old Mahsa Amini was arrested in Tehran for "improperly" wearing her hijab. She died in police custody on September 16th, 2022.

https://www.womensvoicesnow.org/mahsa-amini?gclid=Cj0KCQjwu-KiBhCsARIsAPztUF3eBa5SMqdElh0URUJHeFRKcMp00IW7OBSzSrCRNpD1fQEdoygoRQQaAmlNEALw_wcB

Wisenotboring · 08/05/2023 10:16

I would notice, but not particularly care. The only time I have been bothered is when I have seen ladies come into the pool with full on clothes. Swimwear fabric that is not too voluminous seems the best option. Honestly, a
baggy shorts and t-shirt combo does irritate me as it just seems less hygienic and more prone to debris ending up in the pool..