Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if you have a problem with the burkini?

817 replies

Mvslimah · 07/05/2023 20:28

Honest answers please

would you give a woman (maybe Muslim maybe Jewish) a wide berth if you saw them wearing a burkini or modest (Ie fully covered) swimsuit at a pool?

if you see a woman wearing one do you give it a second thought or is it just a meh, who cares?

tia

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
NatashaDancing · 08/05/2023 12:51

AngryGreasedSantaCatcus · 08/05/2023 12:12

@NatashaDancing if you're so opposed to the word and the weight it carries then you should avoid those shops completely and /or write to them and campaign for a change of language.You know the shops that advertise and make it easy and mainstream to search for and use the term modest/modesty clothing.

I know, it's easier to badger the OP instead and have HER change the way way she speaks and translates things. Inconvenience HER and limit her easy ways out.

Rather hypocritical. I wouldn't shop somewhere that uses language that I find so offensive and upsetting/triggering.

The OP has been given alternative language to describe the style of clothing, yet she continues to insist there is no alternative to the word "modest". The OP is very keen that her sensibilities be respected but seems uninterested in any other.

Mvslimah · 08/05/2023 12:46

Socrateswasrightaboutvoting · 08/05/2023 12:23

@NatashaDancing I came here to write the exact same thing. 'Modest' is a provocative word in the context of the rights of women, which we are still fighting for. @Mvslimah You have been patient and taken the time to respond to many poster's questions, to explain and normalise the burkini. I see stereotypes from both sides of the debate on this thread. Oppressed, uneducated women vs alcoholic, druggie western girl ( who find peace and a home in warmth of Islam. Both are clichés, .

I am struggling with your posts. They seem less about the burkini and more about the normalising of the policing of women. The burqini and any other religion endorsed/encouraged styles of dressing are much more complicated and nuanced than that 'its just an item of clothing'. You should be able to enjoy the pool in peace with your family without judgement or scrutiny. Its interesting though, you have been very judgemental about the French and the choices they make for their country.

Do women really choose or is it the illusion of choice? Religion (Islam, Christianity, Judaism, Hinduism etc) has many positive and beneficial attributes but it is ultimately organised by people, usually men. The positive attributes are often outweighed by the patriarchal nature of an organised structure which often relegates women to supporting roles in their own lives. Would a woman really choose to allow her son to inherit more than her daughter, just by virtue of having a Y chromosome? For her daughter not be be able to have access to contraception or a safe abortion? To wait for man to give them permission to divorce? To cover their heads or from head to toe? These are questions I have when I think about all the various religions.

But I am french, well half french and I lived a good portion of my life there, I can tell you that it is institutional racism under the guise of la laïcité, or the guise of ‘hygiene’ or la santé publique or whatever. I lived in val d’Oise, so a banlieues to the north of Paris comprised of zeps (zone d’éducation primaire) aka ghettos and then more affluent areas, in the difference with how Muslims are treated is palpable. The capital of my préfecture is Argenteuil, where a pregnant woman who covered was physically targeted and the baby kicked to death and her put in ITU because of how she dressed. We left France because of how difficult it is to be a Muslim there.

you don’t understand fiqh but you seem to have some ill conceived notions about certain things (precisely why I’m not keen on adding more Islamic words to the English vernacular). Inheritance in Islam is under the guise that a woman never has to spend a penny on anyone other than herself, if that is not the case then the ruling is void, contraception is permissible, abortion up until 4/5 months is permissible (unless there is a danger to mothers life and then it is permissible at any stage) women don’t need permission to divorce, there are different process between a talaq (male instigated divorce) and khula (womens instigated divorce). Men are meant to cover their bodies too.

im not sure what I’ve said that means i police other people’s bodies have or that it should be normalised. It most definitely shouldn’t on either side of the fence, wear what you feel happy and comfortable and beautiful in, that will mean different things for different people and different phases in their lives. No choice is a free choice, they are all informed by things, trend, culture, personal sensibilities etc

OP posts:
itsgettingweird · 08/05/2023 12:44

Racking my brains as hard as possible I really cannot fathom how a pair of swim leggings and swim t shirt made from swimwear material can be more unhygienic than wearing a swim suit or bikini made from the same material. Confused

Socrateswasrightaboutvoting · 08/05/2023 12:23

@NatashaDancing I came here to write the exact same thing. 'Modest' is a provocative word in the context of the rights of women, which we are still fighting for. @Mvslimah You have been patient and taken the time to respond to many poster's questions, to explain and normalise the burkini. I see stereotypes from both sides of the debate on this thread. Oppressed, uneducated women vs alcoholic, druggie western girl ( who find peace and a home in warmth of Islam. Both are clichés, .

I am struggling with your posts. They seem less about the burkini and more about the normalising of the policing of women. The burqini and any other religion endorsed/encouraged styles of dressing are much more complicated and nuanced than that 'its just an item of clothing'. You should be able to enjoy the pool in peace with your family without judgement or scrutiny. Its interesting though, you have been very judgemental about the French and the choices they make for their country.

Do women really choose or is it the illusion of choice? Religion (Islam, Christianity, Judaism, Hinduism etc) has many positive and beneficial attributes but it is ultimately organised by people, usually men. The positive attributes are often outweighed by the patriarchal nature of an organised structure which often relegates women to supporting roles in their own lives. Would a woman really choose to allow her son to inherit more than her daughter, just by virtue of having a Y chromosome? For her daughter not be be able to have access to contraception or a safe abortion? To wait for man to give them permission to divorce? To cover their heads or from head to toe? These are questions I have when I think about all the various religions.

Mvslimah · 08/05/2023 12:23

Maireas · 08/05/2023 12:17

What do you mean, I don't know, @sashh ?
I know girls are Muslim because of what they wear. The Muslim boys wear the regular uniform. Now that uniform, if immodest for girls, is surely the same for boys? But it's not

Because the modesty requirements are different for a man that woman Islamically, largely just through some form of head covering. And that’s the point, you are meant to recognise Muslim women. Identity politics are Quranically cited as the reason to ‘draw your khimar (veil ) across your chest’. Muslim men should also be identifiable through a beard and trimmed moustache and non figure hugging clothing that covers from the navel to the knee

OP posts:
Mvslimah · 08/05/2023 12:19

AngryGreasedSantaCatcus · 08/05/2023 12:12

@NatashaDancing if you're so opposed to the word and the weight it carries then you should avoid those shops completely and /or write to them and campaign for a change of language.You know the shops that advertise and make it easy and mainstream to search for and use the term modest/modesty clothing.

I know, it's easier to badger the OP instead and have HER change the way way she speaks and translates things. Inconvenience HER and limit her easy ways out.

Rather hypocritical. I wouldn't shop somewhere that uses language that I find so offensive and upsetting/triggering.

This^

OP posts:
Maireas · 08/05/2023 12:17

What do you mean, I don't know, @sashh ?
I know girls are Muslim because of what they wear. The Muslim boys wear the regular uniform. Now that uniform, if immodest for girls, is surely the same for boys? But it's not

AngryGreasedSantaCatcus · 08/05/2023 12:12

@NatashaDancing if you're so opposed to the word and the weight it carries then you should avoid those shops completely and /or write to them and campaign for a change of language.You know the shops that advertise and make it easy and mainstream to search for and use the term modest/modesty clothing.

I know, it's easier to badger the OP instead and have HER change the way way she speaks and translates things. Inconvenience HER and limit her easy ways out.

Rather hypocritical. I wouldn't shop somewhere that uses language that I find so offensive and upsetting/triggering.

JustGotToKeepOnKeepingOn · 08/05/2023 12:00

Of course I notice it... things that go through my head: Is she hot? Is she happy to wear it? Maybe I should get one...? it must be great to be covered up (I burn really easily and have a body I don't really want to show off). Then I go and get an ice cream.

VyeBrator · 08/05/2023 11:56

Dwightlovesmichael · 08/05/2023 10:47

I am so wrapped up in my own problems, I would bet my house that I wouldn’t notice if they were naked.

And if I did notice, I don’t give a shit what anyone else wants to wear.

I am so wrapped up in my own problems, I would bet my house that I wouldn’t notice if they were naked.

If this is true (and I suspect it isn't), you'd be a danger to yourself and others in the water 😂

sashh · 08/05/2023 11:41

Maireas · 08/05/2023 09:44

Genuine question, @Mvslimah - so it's to identify a woman as Muslim. Why aren't men so identified? I teach many Muslim teenagers. I can always tell who the Muslim girls are, by veils and long black over garments. Not so the boys. They wear the regular uniform. Same situation with the men in my town, regular western clothes. No identification as Muslim apart from the occasional one with a small head covering.

But you don't know do you?

I was having a conversation with a couple of students, originally from Kosovo nd a colleague, my colleague, who happened to be Muslim said something and I reacted with, "These are good Muslim girls girls" and totally shocked my colleague.

The students always wore trousers but never headscarves. Incidentally that is exactly what this colleague wore.

@Mvslimah

I've had some interesting discussions with students about the term 'modest'. I never saw either of my grandmothers in trousers because they were brought up in a time when 'nice' girls didn't wear trousers unless you were in uniform in the war.

Even then most uniforms were skirts, female pilots were initially not allowed to wear trousers and only won the concession if they changed as soon as they got into the airstrip buildings.

Mvslimah · 08/05/2023 11:41

OhBeAFineGuyKissMe · 08/05/2023 11:33

Sorry if I offended. I think introducing new words is better as they don’t have all the baggage that the existing ones do.

I dislike the word modest in relation to clothing, and it is never applied to men’s clothes shops, as there is an implied virtue (and lack). But is haya clothing makes no sense then that isn’t a suitable alternative.

Full coverage, seems to cover it. No virtue words, just a simple description.

As I said earlier, I have no problems with what you choose to wear to go swimming. I wear a rash vest and shorts in the summer as I burn but a normal costume in an inside pool.

But you or the other insisting we refer to what the industry refers to as modest clothes, as haya clothes and insisting we introduce more Islamic words to the English vernacular when the ones that are already common place aren’t even used correctly is irksome. It might not have baggage for you, but what about us! Not only does it not make sense but it’s yet another Islamic concept that can be misused on the regular and then used against us

OP posts:
MargotBamborough · 08/05/2023 11:40

I will be honest, OP.

It makes me feel sad when I see women being held to different standards of modesty to men.

In certain parts of the world I've seen families on the beach where the man and children are wearing normal swimwear and enjoying the sun, and the woman is covered from head to toe. It makes me feel sad for her that she is expected to do this when her husband is not, and sad for her daughters that this is their future.

But if I saw you wearing a burkini at the swimming pool I would be glad that you had found a way to make swimming accessible to you, and I certainly wouldn't say anything or give you any funny looks.

OhBeAFineGuyKissMe · 08/05/2023 11:33

Mvslimah · 08/05/2023 11:04

But a willingness to learn is always appreciated so long as it’s not rooted in judgement :)

Sorry if I offended. I think introducing new words is better as they don’t have all the baggage that the existing ones do.

I dislike the word modest in relation to clothing, and it is never applied to men’s clothes shops, as there is an implied virtue (and lack). But is haya clothing makes no sense then that isn’t a suitable alternative.

Full coverage, seems to cover it. No virtue words, just a simple description.

As I said earlier, I have no problems with what you choose to wear to go swimming. I wear a rash vest and shorts in the summer as I burn but a normal costume in an inside pool.

elevenplusdilemma · 08/05/2023 11:21

Wouldn't bother me at all. I would probably notice as I don't live in a particularly diverse area so she would stand out as unusual, but I wouldn't give it any further thought.

NatashaDancing · 08/05/2023 11:18

AngryGreasedSantaCatcus · 08/05/2023 10:52

I presume you don't shop at M&S ,Next etc then? Since they have specific modest sections? In fact when searching for fully covered swimsuits there were two issues 1.not all of them were what OP would actually need and 2.the names in the shops (like next for example) actually said modest/modesty swimsuit.

So don't badger OP for being offensive if you're not prepared to boycott all the shops that are using it . They do more to promote the term than religious women ever will.

In answer to your question - no I wouldn't buy anything marketed as "modest".

EnaSharplesStout · 08/05/2023 11:06

@Mvslimah they are totally normal round here, it wouldn’t even register. Close fitting leggings and long sleeved top basically.

If I do think about it I think I wouldn’t want to wear the top because I hate the feeling of wet fabric on my arms… but weirdly I’m fine with it on my legs- I wear full length or 3 quarters leggings for wild/sea swimming all the time because it’s more convenient.

The only time I ever thought anything else was a family where the man was in speedo briefs but all the women/little girls were in massive baggy suits with long tunics over baggy trousers at a water park and they were getting caught up in everything, dragging the little ones down because they were so heavy and they were all constantly trying to pull them up/straight/un tangle them, while the man was happy as Larry swimming around. That felt unfair, especially on the children.

Mvslimah · 08/05/2023 11:04

monsteramunch · 08/05/2023 10:55

Also haya clothes makes no sense

Apologies I think a few of us misunderstood, while trying to be respectful and open to learning. Hopefully that was taken in the spirit it was intended.

But a willingness to learn is always appreciated so long as it’s not rooted in judgement :)

OP posts:
Mvslimah · 08/05/2023 11:03

monsteramunch · 08/05/2023 10:55

Also haya clothes makes no sense

Apologies I think a few of us misunderstood, while trying to be respectful and open to learning. Hopefully that was taken in the spirit it was intended.

Yes but this is the problem, halal and hijab are used frequently now in the English vernacular, but seldom in the correct context and often as a bit of a beating stick against Muslims. Conservative clothes or fully covered dresses and the like are marketed as modest, im sorry that offends you but I genuinely can’t think of another word in English that could adequately define them, because it’s not conservative because that to me implies no patterns or more of the jilbab style of clothes or older lady conservative Margaret thatcher clothes, it won’t be Islamic clothes or Jewish clothes as that alienates everyone else
as a Muslim in the UK I feel like I’m constantly having to either justify, apologise or just be on edge to not offend someone by my just being

OP posts:
monsteramunch · 08/05/2023 10:55

Also haya clothes makes no sense

Apologies I think a few of us misunderstood, while trying to be respectful and open to learning. Hopefully that was taken in the spirit it was intended.

CandidClarisse · 08/05/2023 10:54

I really like them. I've worn the 3/4 ones or short suits to a pool plenty of times, very comfortable and no pulling it out of your bum every 5 minutes Grin

AngryGreasedSantaCatcus · 08/05/2023 10:52

OhBeAFineGuyKissMe · 08/05/2023 10:40

I'm another who finds the word modest offensive. Use the word "haya" instead. People can cope with learning new words. The clothing equivalent of halal.

In English modest implies virtue and also clothes can be immodest. That is deeply offensive.

I presume you don't shop at M&S ,Next etc then? Since they have specific modest sections? In fact when searching for fully covered swimsuits there were two issues 1.not all of them were what OP would actually need and 2.the names in the shops (like next for example) actually said modest/modesty swimsuit.

So don't badger OP for being offensive if you're not prepared to boycott all the shops that are using it . They do more to promote the term than religious women ever will.

Mvslimah · 08/05/2023 10:51

Mvslimah · 08/05/2023 10:47

It’s not the clothing equivalent of halal…that’s actually offensive to me. fully coverage clothes (trying to avoid the term modest) are halal clothes or a halal outfit…

as a Muslim I’m not keen on introducing more Arabic or Islamic words to the English vernacular that will get misunderstood. Haya doesn’t refer to clothes, it’s basically a state of being that encompasses many parts.

Also haya clothes makes no sense

OP posts:
Dwightlovesmichael · 08/05/2023 10:47

I am so wrapped up in my own problems, I would bet my house that I wouldn’t notice if they were naked.

And if I did notice, I don’t give a shit what anyone else wants to wear.

Mvslimah · 08/05/2023 10:47

OhBeAFineGuyKissMe · 08/05/2023 10:40

I'm another who finds the word modest offensive. Use the word "haya" instead. People can cope with learning new words. The clothing equivalent of halal.

In English modest implies virtue and also clothes can be immodest. That is deeply offensive.

It’s not the clothing equivalent of halal…that’s actually offensive to me. fully coverage clothes (trying to avoid the term modest) are halal clothes or a halal outfit…

as a Muslim I’m not keen on introducing more Arabic or Islamic words to the English vernacular that will get misunderstood. Haya doesn’t refer to clothes, it’s basically a state of being that encompasses many parts.

OP posts: