Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if you have a problem with the burkini?

817 replies

Mvslimah · 07/05/2023 20:28

Honest answers please

would you give a woman (maybe Muslim maybe Jewish) a wide berth if you saw them wearing a burkini or modest (Ie fully covered) swimsuit at a pool?

if you see a woman wearing one do you give it a second thought or is it just a meh, who cares?

tia

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
Random789 · 08/05/2023 14:55

So sorry you had a bad experience, @Mvslimah. To anwer your question in your OP, no, it wouldn't bother me at all and I feel quite furious at the tutting wankers headshakers who made you feel uncomfrotable. What is WRONG with people?
Just the other day, there was a Muslim woman in my gym pool wearing a burkini-type swimwear covering. She was very young (about 20) and she was with an equally young non-Muslim woman who was wearing ordinary swimwear. They looked very sweet together and no-one turned a hair.
I do know from experience, though, that there are a couple of gym members that I would have expected to tut if they had been there. Not specifically from racism or Islamophobia (though I woldn't put that past them) but from a generally officious attitude that makes them feel like they have to police other gym users and invent spurious reasons for finding other people's behaviour unacceptable.
Like the woman who complained that a girl was using the jacuzzi when she was very slightly under the minimum age for it. The girl was creating ZERO problems and her mum explained that she had autism, and had been given permission by the management to use the jacuzzi because this was what she needed in order for the pool area to be a positive experience for her.
THe complaining woman was an absolute wanker and went on and on,despite the reassurance that the girl had permission. She tried to drag me into it and I politiely told her she was creating a problem about nothing. but I didn't do what I should have done - which was to tell her to shut the fuck up and threaten her with a complaint to the management. I feel ashamed about that because I never saw that girl and her mum at the pool again and I wonder if my lack of adequate support made things worse for them.

slimeandfearmetro · 08/05/2023 14:54

Mvslimah · 08/05/2023 14:26

Exactly! Black women are pressured to hide their blackness as to not make society feel uncomfortable. Black women have lost their jobs or been denied opportunities for having their natural hair… awful.

‘almost British but not quite, almost British just not white’

I restate my earlier point about how the humane actions is to accommodate other people's clothing etc as long.as it doesn't infringe on the rights of others. Muslim women should not have to choose between covering up and going swimming because the burkini doesn't infringe upon the rights of others. Black women shouldn't have to use corrosive chemicals and 200 celsius straighteners on their hair just to get a job or go to school because afro hair doesn't infringe upon the rights of others.

Socrateswasrightaboutvoting · 08/05/2023 14:47

My questions are not about clothing per se. I am not triggered by clothing, you do you. I am more interested in the relationship between women, religion and choice.

A woman spending money on herself is a straw man argument. How many women would really choose to only have 1/4 of their family estate? Why is this not 50/50, eg at least 50% in trust to share amongst the children equally. Why is a Y chromosome worth double an X in monetary terms? Why do his parents get 16th? I am genuinely curious as to how this reconciles with women having agency and value

I consider Islam no better or worse than any other organised religion. I just think they all have questions to answer.

Mvslimah · 08/05/2023 14:26

AngryGreasedSantaCatcus · 08/05/2023 14:21

It's like black people get pressured to have their hair look tidy,neat ,nice aka not in it's natural state.

Exactly! Black women are pressured to hide their blackness as to not make society feel uncomfortable. Black women have lost their jobs or been denied opportunities for having their natural hair… awful.

‘almost British but not quite, almost British just not white’

OP posts:
AngryGreasedSantaCatcus · 08/05/2023 14:26

@NatashaDancing nah, that's just skirting around the issue. Are you going to stop shopping at shops like M&S and Next?
Shops that require you to use the word modest to find what you are looking for if you are of a particular religious background or just want /need that style of clothing.

Change won't happen by bullying and forcing one muslim woman to bow down to your demands and insisting she changes.

Socrateswasrightaboutvoting · 08/05/2023 14:26

AngryGreasedSantaCatcus · 08/05/2023 14:21

It's like black people get pressured to have their hair look tidy,neat ,nice aka not in it's natural state.

You mean anglicised. An afro puff is neat, as are plaits or an afro, they will not necessarily be considered professional. Professional mean anglicised.

Mvslimah · 08/05/2023 14:24

Socrateswasrightaboutvoting · 08/05/2023 14:18

You talked about 'the French' not institutional racism, as you know there is very distinct difference. You choose to use the word modest and are cognisant of the impact of that word. Modest is a word steeped in judgment, and therefore you endorse the policing of women's bodies. This is isn't about Burkinis, it's propaganda.

Are you are really telling me that in return for only have to spend money on herself whilst her husband is alive, she willing chooses on his death that their son will inherit twice that of any daughters, and that his parents will inherit a larger portion than her?

For clarity the question on abortion/ contraception aimed at Catholiscism.
Head covering / dress - Plymouth Bretheran
Divorce - Judaism
Inheritance - Islam.

I wonder about female choice in ALL religions. My questions are less about oppression and more about agency.

No, i dont because it is a term used by an entire fashion industry. Are you triggered by skiing fit clothes?

also no because whilst he is alive she doesn’t have to spend a penny on herself, he is to do that. Now she can if she wants to, her money is hers but she is not obliged to spend on the household, him or even buy her own clothes, haircuts, food, days out it’s all on the husband. I think his parents actually get 1/6th. She gets 1/4 and his children the rest I believe and that is because Islamically a woman does not need to provide for herself or her children.

OP posts:
Socrateswasrightaboutvoting · 08/05/2023 14:23

slimeandfearmetro · 08/05/2023 13:17

None of this appalling treatment of Iranian and Afghan women is caused by women wearing full coverage swimwear. None of it will be stopped by the OP turning up at the pool tomorrow in a string bikini.

As for women not shaving their legs - at most they might get an odd look.

I got bullied at school by the boys for not shaving. You can't actually know how other people behave so stop pretending that you can predict how they will react in a given situation.

A common theme in the misfortune of women is men, whether that be in the family, education, work, religion or leisure. Not all men, but a significant number of the men in power.

AngryGreasedSantaCatcus · 08/05/2023 14:21

Mvslimah · 08/05/2023 13:00

^ there is also a huge amount of pressure on Muslims not to be too Muslimy, we can a little bit not too much or it looks like we don’t respect British values or we might draw too much attention to ourselves or might upset someone, and frankly most of us as sick of it.

a quote from the great Homi Bhabha comes to mind

It's like black people get pressured to have their hair look tidy,neat ,nice aka not in it's natural state.

Socrateswasrightaboutvoting · 08/05/2023 14:19

Socrateswasrightaboutvoting · 08/05/2023 14:18

You talked about 'the French' not institutional racism, as you know there is very distinct difference. You choose to use the word modest and are cognisant of the impact of that word. Modest is a word steeped in judgment, and therefore you endorse the policing of women's bodies. This is isn't about Burkinis, it's propaganda.

Are you are really telling me that in return for only have to spend money on herself whilst her husband is alive, she willing chooses on his death that their son will inherit twice that of any daughters, and that his parents will inherit a larger portion than her?

For clarity the question on abortion/ contraception aimed at Catholiscism.
Head covering / dress - Plymouth Bretheran
Divorce - Judaism
Inheritance - Islam.

I wonder about female choice in ALL religions. My questions are less about oppression and more about agency.

@Mvslimah I thought I lost my last post and rewrote a shorter version. Ignore this

Socrateswasrightaboutvoting · 08/05/2023 14:18

You talked about 'the French' not institutional racism, as you know there is very distinct difference. You choose to use the word modest and are cognisant of the impact of that word. Modest is a word steeped in judgment, and therefore you endorse the policing of women's bodies. This is isn't about Burkinis, it's propaganda.

Are you are really telling me that in return for only have to spend money on herself whilst her husband is alive, she willing chooses on his death that their son will inherit twice that of any daughters, and that his parents will inherit a larger portion than her?

For clarity the question on abortion/ contraception aimed at Catholiscism.
Head covering / dress - Plymouth Bretheran
Divorce - Judaism
Inheritance - Islam.

I wonder about female choice in ALL religions. My questions are less about oppression and more about agency.

Mvslimah · 08/05/2023 14:16

^ je suis française, im french of course all french people arent racist, I was a teacher and the other teachers were outraged that religion was banned in schools but Christianity was forced through teaching the bible as a text or book rather than as a religious one-

OP posts:
Mvslimah · 08/05/2023 14:14

Socrateswasrightaboutvoting · 08/05/2023 13:59

You didn't talk about French institutions you talked about 'the French'. This country is guilt of structural and institutional racism too. It doesn't make everyone racist though.

I understand that words do not necessarily translate neatly from one language to another. That's not really a good reason to keep using a word that was defined by men and is steeped in judgement and which others have told you is offensive. To push that as the narrative, given the definition of modesty it to endorse the policing of womens bodies IMO.

I was not clear in how I posed the questions I wonder about when I think about choice for women in the context of religion. They are not the sum of my questions just an example of the things I wonder. Only the question on wills was specific to Islam. The question on contraception and abortion was a question for Catholicism. The question on head covering /clothing was for religions like the Plymouth Brethren etc. The divorce question was relevant to Judaism. People often focus on Islam. I believe there are questions to be asked in the majority of organised religions.

In respect of inheritance, whilst I appreciate that you say a woman is not supposed to spend a money on anyone other than herself. Well that justifies the in heritance rules doesn't it? Where does that money come from? If her husband dies, would a woman chose to give their sons, twice that of her daughters. Would she really 'choose' to give her parents in-law a chunk of their estate which is more than she will receive?

Maybe I should start a new thread on ama about it because it is complicated, if a woman is a widow and his parents are dead then she gets 1/4 and the children the rest, but she would keep and invest the money to the children and give it them when they are of age, she’d also be encouraged to remarry and then that husband would provide for her and her children (in a traditional perfect Islamic society, which we know doesn’t exist so like Hudud the rules become murky) but there is an understanding that the parents if they are still alive would be taken care of, especially if they are elderly, as that child might have been supporting them

OP posts:
TwinkleSprite · 08/05/2023 14:04

Revealing clothes are seen as the norm. How are people complaining as if they're oppressed? Nobody looks at you funny for wearing shorts in the uk, please get over yourselves. It's well accepted. If others want to describe their clothes as modest they can. They don't need to call it conservative or full coverage to appease anyone else's paranoia.

I wear both modest and more revealing clothes, depending on the day. Not an issue. Nobody in the UK or anywhere in europe cares or thinks shorts/bikinis and such are immodest. It is the norm.

Socrateswasrightaboutvoting · 08/05/2023 13:59

You didn't talk about French institutions you talked about 'the French'. This country is guilt of structural and institutional racism too. It doesn't make everyone racist though.

I understand that words do not necessarily translate neatly from one language to another. That's not really a good reason to keep using a word that was defined by men and is steeped in judgement and which others have told you is offensive. To push that as the narrative, given the definition of modesty it to endorse the policing of womens bodies IMO.

I was not clear in how I posed the questions I wonder about when I think about choice for women in the context of religion. They are not the sum of my questions just an example of the things I wonder. Only the question on wills was specific to Islam. The question on contraception and abortion was a question for Catholicism. The question on head covering /clothing was for religions like the Plymouth Brethren etc. The divorce question was relevant to Judaism. People often focus on Islam. I believe there are questions to be asked in the majority of organised religions.

In respect of inheritance, whilst I appreciate that you say a woman is not supposed to spend a money on anyone other than herself. Well that justifies the in heritance rules doesn't it? Where does that money come from? If her husband dies, would a woman chose to give their sons, twice that of her daughters. Would she really 'choose' to give her parents in-law a chunk of their estate which is more than she will receive?

Cardimum · 08/05/2023 13:47

itsgettingweird · 08/05/2023 12:44

Racking my brains as hard as possible I really cannot fathom how a pair of swim leggings and swim t shirt made from swimwear material can be more unhygienic than wearing a swim suit or bikini made from the same material. Confused

Lol exactly! 😆

Btw people, I've just realised you can italicize emojis on here, like: 😑.

slimeandfearmetro · 08/05/2023 13:47

I wonder if any of the posters criticising the term "modest" as implying that mainstream fashion is "immodest" would see the term "plus size" and infer that smaller sizes are somehow "minus size" and get offended at being called "minus"? Or inferred that the non-petite clothes must be "grande" and got offended at being called "big" because that's what "grande" translates to? Because that's how ridiculous you are all being.

MirandaPr1estly · 08/05/2023 13:45

“Modest Fashion” as a concept has been around for a while now and it mostly caters for Muslim, Jewish and Christian women who wish to adhere to such a dress code. Several online stores have modest fashion section. It’s simply a descriptor and op used it appropriately. She has not once implied that women who do not wear burkinis are immodest or inferior, you have inferred that @NatashaDancing.

I also find your persistent attempts to police op’s perfectly reasonable language, hugely uncomfortable and bordering on bullying. Do you really think it’s fair or feminist to berate a single Muslim woman for the ills of Iranian and Afghan society, and use it as a stick to beat her with?

Mvslimah · 08/05/2023 13:22

RestingRoundFace · 08/05/2023 13:17

All this debating over how one woman uses the word 'modest'.
Yet the next time she needs to buy one she will still need to put the term in Google to get the best results, even from mainstream places.

That’s precisely my point. There is an entire industry built around this term, with a Fashion week, section on uk highstreet stores, on shein, on Amazon, on asos, on Pinterest , IG etc etc I could do on

it’s what I’ll need to type when I buy my holiday clothes, or else nothing will come up along the lines of what I’m after. It’s like being triggered by the term skinny fit because it inadvertently implies only thin people can wear it.

ps if anyone has seen any nice summer dresses with all the relevant parts covered but don’t look like curtains or if they are a sweat trap, feel free to post a link… ill be eternally grateful

OP posts:
RestingRoundFace · 08/05/2023 13:17

All this debating over how one woman uses the word 'modest'.
Yet the next time she needs to buy one she will still need to put the term in Google to get the best results, even from mainstream places.

slimeandfearmetro · 08/05/2023 13:17

NatashaDancing · 08/05/2023 10:16

You might want to read a bit more about the plight of women in Afghanistan or the protests by women in Iran. Link below might help.

As for women not shaving their legs - at most they might get an odd look.

https://www.womensvoicesnow.org/mahsa-amini?gclid=Cj0KCQjwu-KiBhCsARIsAPztUF3eBa5SMqdElh0URUJHeFRKcMp00IW7OBSzSrCRNpD1fQEdoygoRQQaAmlNEALw_wcB

None of this appalling treatment of Iranian and Afghan women is caused by women wearing full coverage swimwear. None of it will be stopped by the OP turning up at the pool tomorrow in a string bikini.

As for women not shaving their legs - at most they might get an odd look.

I got bullied at school by the boys for not shaving. You can't actually know how other people behave so stop pretending that you can predict how they will react in a given situation.

MirandaPr1estly · 08/05/2023 13:14

Mvslimah · 08/05/2023 10:23

It is nice isn’t it, on the pricey side, if you do get one they come up a bit small, so size up or you’ll be like me going down the water slides in dubai and the poppers flying open. Yeah so I’d Chuck on some flip flops and dry out just in that or if I went to a restaurant or a mooch around the shops say if on hols, I might put a sarong around or maybe a light chiffon/ linen kimono style shirt or something, big sunnies and a hat to protect my face from the sun,

maybe something like below, matched to the swimsuit of course

Firstly, I’m so sorry you experienced such ignorance @Mvslimah (on this thread as well as at the pool). Why anyone would hassle a woman on day out with her kids is beyond me and I hope it’s not put you off!

Secondly, that kaftan/outfit is sooo chic 😍 picturing it with a big slouchy leather bag and oversized sunnies.

toddles off to peruse Lyra

Mvslimah · 08/05/2023 13:00

^ there is also a huge amount of pressure on Muslims not to be too Muslimy, we can a little bit not too much or it looks like we don’t respect British values or we might draw too much attention to ourselves or might upset someone, and frankly most of us as sick of it.

a quote from the great Homi Bhabha comes to mind

OP posts:
Mvslimah · 08/05/2023 12:57

NatashaDancing · 08/05/2023 12:51

The OP has been given alternative language to describe the style of clothing, yet she continues to insist there is no alternative to the word "modest". The OP is very keen that her sensibilities be respected but seems uninterested in any other.

because it doesn’t make sense… haya clothing doesn’t make sense. The clothes are marketed as modest clothes it is how they are branded. Full coverage clothes doesn’t necessarily reflect them, Islamic clothes doesn’t either. You seem ardent on blaming me for an entire industry. On this thread I’ll oblige but that doesn’t change the industry, or how even other people commonly understand a more conservative personal style that doesn’t show too much of one’s body.

OP posts:
NatashaDancing · 08/05/2023 12:55

itsgettingweird · 08/05/2023 12:44

Racking my brains as hard as possible I really cannot fathom how a pair of swim leggings and swim t shirt made from swimwear material can be more unhygienic than wearing a swim suit or bikini made from the same material. Confused

The hygiene argument is nonsense.

I suppose it might make some sort of sense that men's swimshorts might be worn as non swimwear but in the context of a swimming pool I doubt anyone turns up wearing their shorts as every day outerwear and goes straight into the pool.