Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if you have a problem with the burkini?

817 replies

Mvslimah · 07/05/2023 20:28

Honest answers please

would you give a woman (maybe Muslim maybe Jewish) a wide berth if you saw them wearing a burkini or modest (Ie fully covered) swimsuit at a pool?

if you see a woman wearing one do you give it a second thought or is it just a meh, who cares?

tia

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
Maireas · 08/05/2023 16:43

The eyelashes and fake tans are fashionable. Those girls and women are making a choice. They're not going against a religious instruction if they choose not to wear them/do that. It's about freedom of expression. Sadly, in many countries, women don't have this.

Fandabedodgy · 08/05/2023 16:41

I couldn't care less what others wear

Theluggage15 · 08/05/2023 16:38

Random789 · 08/05/2023 16:10

So many women and girls have adopted an appearance that is unnatural, and takes time, effort, money and anxiety to maintain. Pancake make-up, fake tan, duck lips, false eyelashes, tattoos, anorexia, piercings. I think I'd like to ask them, not a woman in a burkini "What is it that you think is so wrong with women's bodies that their natural form has to be hidden? What kind of pressure are you under to conform? Wouldn't you like to be free?

And the suggstion that covering up implies a judgement that women's bodies are offensive and men can't control themselves? - that suggestion seems to make a lot of assumptions about religious observation. Many religious rules function simply as an opportunity to turn yourself towards god at various times of the day - when you get dressed, when you eat, etc. It almost doesn't matter what the rule is. Following it is just a chance to make a small rededication in your faith

God what a snobbish comment. Perhaps these young women enjoy their fake tan and eyelashes, perhaps they enjoy expressing themselves with tattoos. I know this thread is all about how marvellous it is to see women covered up in ‘modest’ clothing but there’s absolutely no need to be bitchy about other women. And you’re comparing anorexia to piercings?!!

The vast majority of religions are patriarchal crap.

Mvslimah · 08/05/2023 16:33

SoreThroatAgain · 08/05/2023 15:50

Yes it feels like bullying. And I rarely say that.

Glad to see it’s not just me who was feeling that, thank you!

OP posts:
Random789 · 08/05/2023 16:10

So many women and girls have adopted an appearance that is unnatural, and takes time, effort, money and anxiety to maintain. Pancake make-up, fake tan, duck lips, false eyelashes, tattoos, anorexia, piercings. I think I'd like to ask them, not a woman in a burkini "What is it that you think is so wrong with women's bodies that their natural form has to be hidden? What kind of pressure are you under to conform? Wouldn't you like to be free?

And the suggstion that covering up implies a judgement that women's bodies are offensive and men can't control themselves? - that suggestion seems to make a lot of assumptions about religious observation. Many religious rules function simply as an opportunity to turn yourself towards god at various times of the day - when you get dressed, when you eat, etc. It almost doesn't matter what the rule is. Following it is just a chance to make a small rededication in your faith

dig135 · 08/05/2023 16:04

*feel

dig135 · 08/05/2023 16:03

And that’s just one area. Open your eyes.

Am I not allowed to have a different view? I don't feed the need to tell people who have a different opinion to 'open their eyes'.

SleepDreamThinkHuge · 08/05/2023 16:02

need to realize

SleepDreamThinkHuge · 08/05/2023 16:02

People not to realize not everyone wants to wear a bikini. Anything to help participation and getting more women to swim is surely a great thing. Aren't we supposed to remove barriers and be inclusive to all people and help them rather than say "that is disgusting or offensive." You do not get to be offended on behalf of others. I see a lot of comments here that are very ignorant. It is the same with Ramadan we get white women feeling sorry for Muslims "oh not another month of them starving themselves." Most Muslims I know love Ramadan and participate fully in it so I do not get why we get comments to feel sorry for Muslims when most do not complain about it.

SoreThroatAgain · 08/05/2023 15:56

dig135 · 08/05/2023 15:46

You think the UK is a ‘wonderful place’ to be a woman?

Yes, I think it's pretty good considering. There's a lot of focus on gender pay parity and board representation. We have personal freedom, we can wear whatever we want and same-sex relationships are legal.

Unless there's a utopian country I'm not aware of?

Goodness. Yes we have got some things right. But so much still isn’t.

Eg Have you not come across young women feeling pressure that they have to dress up for events, show flesh to look sexy? Their boyfriends wanting them to look a certain way. Employers thinking women should wear skirts not trousers. This stuff goes on. Do you think that’s all free choice?

And that’s just one area. Open your eyes.

Newnamenewname109870 · 08/05/2023 15:52

It concerns me that people would actually be bothered by it. Why would you want another woman to take off he me clothes? She needs to be comfortable. Not everyone wants revealing swimsuits. Especially not with kids to pull them down 😂

AngryGreasedSantaCatcus · 08/05/2023 15:52

Ironically, if the UK was such a good place for women, full of equality,freedom bla bla bla women would not get so triggered and offended by "modest" clothing. Because the implication of immodest and all the issues associated with it, wouldn't exist/actually matter anymore.

You can't have it both ways.

Random789 · 08/05/2023 15:50

slimeandfearmetro · 08/05/2023 13:47

I wonder if any of the posters criticising the term "modest" as implying that mainstream fashion is "immodest" would see the term "plus size" and infer that smaller sizes are somehow "minus size" and get offended at being called "minus"? Or inferred that the non-petite clothes must be "grande" and got offended at being called "big" because that's what "grande" translates to? Because that's how ridiculous you are all being.

lololol, slimeandfearmetro.. Are people really managing to get hung up about the use of the term 'modest' or 'modestwear'. I thought it was just a widely accepted fashion industry term. Like the term 'casual wear' which, afaik doesn't imply that everyone in a suit is uptight.

SoreThroatAgain · 08/05/2023 15:50

MirandaPr1estly · 08/05/2023 13:45

“Modest Fashion” as a concept has been around for a while now and it mostly caters for Muslim, Jewish and Christian women who wish to adhere to such a dress code. Several online stores have modest fashion section. It’s simply a descriptor and op used it appropriately. She has not once implied that women who do not wear burkinis are immodest or inferior, you have inferred that @NatashaDancing.

I also find your persistent attempts to police op’s perfectly reasonable language, hugely uncomfortable and bordering on bullying. Do you really think it’s fair or feminist to berate a single Muslim woman for the ills of Iranian and Afghan society, and use it as a stick to beat her with?

Yes it feels like bullying. And I rarely say that.

mamabear715 · 08/05/2023 15:49

I've skipped to the end, @Mvslimah , as it's such a long thread, (apart from reading some of your replies) but I am very sad that anyone would care what you wore. :-(
I'm so sorry that you've had to put up with such awful behaviour. :-(

dig135 · 08/05/2023 15:46

You think the UK is a ‘wonderful place’ to be a woman?

Yes, I think it's pretty good considering. There's a lot of focus on gender pay parity and board representation. We have personal freedom, we can wear whatever we want and same-sex relationships are legal.

Unless there's a utopian country I'm not aware of?

ExpatinQatar · 08/05/2023 15:43

It has been very interesting to live in the Middle East and it has definitely broadened and shifted my views on many things. Qatar is very multicultural so even though it is predominantly Muslim, the Muslim population is from dozens of countries. The Muslim population is mostly made up of nationals (Qatari), arabs from MENA nations, South Asians (India, Pakistan, Sri Lanka), East Africans (Sudan, Ethiopia, Somalia), South East Asians (Philippines, Indonesia), and a smattering of other countries (Iran, Turkey, etc).

The interpretations of modesty and appropriate dress here are vast. There is no one understanding. Although women are subserviant / submissive to men in Islam, they are not inferior, and how that subserviance is enacted varies greatly by household. Arab and Muslim women here are far more dominant, assertive, outspoken, opinionated, and argumentative than I ever thought I would see in an Islamic country. They are not submissive in a quiet, passive, obedient way but more in following the tenets of Islam and submitting to the teachings and 'rules' of Allah and Islam. Many women are quite devout in their faith and are mostly focused on what Allah would think and what is required of them within Islam and not as concerned about what men would think. While there are very conservative families where the women are more tightly controlled, that is not the majority of them at all. When it comes to swimming, the different beaches and pools here have varying dress codes so women can go where they want and wear what they want. I can go to a beach who no dress code and wear a bikini if I want and there are also beaches that require women to cover. There are also women only beaches where Muslim women wear typical one and two piece swim suits as there are no men on the beach. Same with pools. There are companies that make sporty hijabs and burkinis that are more suitable for female athletes who need aerodynamic gear. There is nothing unhygenic about a burkini - it is just more fabric. Just like a one piece isn't more unhygenic than a bikini!

SoreThroatAgain · 08/05/2023 15:43

‘Modest’ is a marketing term for these clothes. I am not sure it’s fair to blame the OP solely for this. I get the objection but a whole different remarketing would need to happen to change this.

SoreThroatAgain · 08/05/2023 15:37

fairywhale · 07/05/2023 22:59

Because it goes against the values of most people in this country such as freedom, liberty, equality and tolerance. All the things that make it a wonderful place for a woman to be here.
You are suggesting woman's body is offensive. This would be a new and alien concept in the UK. As well as that men can't contain themselves if they look at your hair or elbow or whatever.
You are suggesting that women are to be covered up but men don't particulary need to. This goes against the principles of equality in this country.
And there is no logic to it, the more on display, the more desensitised we are. No need to start sexualising parts of body that have never been even considered sexual.
There is no freedom in that choice. Most people in the communities where women do that are conditioned from birth into that "choice" and are strictly punished for making a different choice once older.
You can argue it's your choice but if you think about it, it is not. There is often shaming, rejection, ostricising and, as you well know, even worse repercussions for making a different choice. Plus the expectation, conditioning and brainwashing from birth.

‘Because it goes against the values of most people in this country such as freedom, liberty, equality and tolerance. All the things that make it a wonderful place for a woman to be here.’

You think the UK is a ‘wonderful place’ to be a woman? No sexism, no gender pay gap? No issues with women expecting to be attractive, shave everywhere etc? Oversexualised clothes for young girls? Lack of promotions for women? Poor maternity care? Poor health care in general? Work-life balance issues? DV? Sarah Everard and all the similar cases?

Glad you think it’s so great. But just because we have it better than women in some parts of the world, does not mean we don’t have far to go still.

YoungandHopeful · 08/05/2023 15:25

@Mvslimah I disagree. I think it’s different to feel that is wrong for women and girls having to cover themselves from top to toe. To never feel the sun or the breeze on their skin at least in public. Having to swim in a burkini or sit covered in back on a beach in the heat.

Mvslimah · 08/05/2023 15:14

YoungandHopeful · 08/05/2023 15:11

I don’t really see the comparison between a burkini and Afro hair. I saw a woman in a burkini in my pool yesterday. I did look at her because it looks so uncomfortable. It was loose and seemed to be hanging off her. I suppose tight clothing like wet suits are not permitted. It looked really restrictive and I felt sorry for her. Bet her DH didn’t wear one!

They aren’t a direct comparison but I think it’s more they are markers of being different or an other

OP posts:
YoungandHopeful · 08/05/2023 15:11

I don’t really see the comparison between a burkini and Afro hair. I saw a woman in a burkini in my pool yesterday. I did look at her because it looks so uncomfortable. It was loose and seemed to be hanging off her. I suppose tight clothing like wet suits are not permitted. It looked really restrictive and I felt sorry for her. Bet her DH didn’t wear one!

Mvslimah · 08/05/2023 15:06

Brittl · 08/05/2023 14:59

You should then know how hard it is for a divorced or widowed Muslim woman to remarry a good man . Many only want never married.

Which is why I caveated some of my replies to this question with in a perfect Islamic society which we know doesn’t exist and the reason I did that was because some people are backward and this preoccupation with virgins or unmarried women is pervasive. Saying that I know many remarried divorcés and it is actually a sunnah

OP posts:
Socrateswasrightaboutvoting · 08/05/2023 15:05

Brittl · 08/05/2023 14:59

You should then know how hard it is for a divorced or widowed Muslim woman to remarry a good man . Many only want never married.

There is that problem again. Men.

Brittl · 08/05/2023 14:59

Mvslimah · 08/05/2023 14:14

Maybe I should start a new thread on ama about it because it is complicated, if a woman is a widow and his parents are dead then she gets 1/4 and the children the rest, but she would keep and invest the money to the children and give it them when they are of age, she’d also be encouraged to remarry and then that husband would provide for her and her children (in a traditional perfect Islamic society, which we know doesn’t exist so like Hudud the rules become murky) but there is an understanding that the parents if they are still alive would be taken care of, especially if they are elderly, as that child might have been supporting them

You should then know how hard it is for a divorced or widowed Muslim woman to remarry a good man . Many only want never married.