Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

FFS DONT feed horses in fields !!

358 replies

Thoroughbred5 · 07/05/2023 19:42

Honestly it blows my mind that this is still a problem but it is. Just wanted to post since it’s coming into nicer weather and more people will be out and about.

caught 3 separate families over the weekend feeding my horse treats when he was out in his field. I spoke to each and 2 were clearly annoyed but did stop, the third just threw their apples and other treats into the field anyway. We have signs, CCTV, double fencing, we have everything. Every summer is the bloody same- people feeding the horses.

DONT feed other people’s horses or ponies. Firstly, nobody is entitled to feed another persons animal. Secondly, you have no idea what that horses specific diet is. Would you be happy to pay for my horses laminitis bill? Or colic? And honestly, it’s best not to feed handfuls of grass either. It doesn’t matter that the horse is in a field full of grass. Feeding horses by hand in the field can cause jealousy amongst the herd and can cause horses to become nippy and bolshy towards people at fences and gates

It’s only may and already it’s a problem. I love the summer but I’m fed up of worrying if my horse is safe in his own field. Anyone else in the same position? And if your reading this and you’re one of the people who feed other people’s horses, please just fucking stop

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
ErrolTheDragon · 27/03/2024 10:35

Better the horse owners protect their own horses more and put preventative measures in place.

The op already has "signs, CCTV, double fencing, we have everything"

FayCarew · 27/03/2024 10:32

@ChedderGorgeous , who the f* would feed a hippo lemons?

ChedderGorgeous · 27/03/2024 10:30

Maverickess · 27/03/2024 08:28

If people choose to interact with an animal without the owners permission then the least they have is responsibility to educate themselves on that animal and not make it unwell and put it at risk.

I mean people don't really have the right to interact with an animal that they don't own at all, without permission, but if they decide to then they are taking on that responsibility.

Don't want to learn about 'equine cuisine' or more specifically horse management and the many issues and complications that can arise from them being fed stuff they shouldn't have? Or even stuff they can have, but by someone who isn't their owner and without the owners knowledge -
Then the answer is simple don't feed them!

It's not like horse owners are asking for you to do something for their benefit, or even the animals benefit, they're asking for you to be passive, not do anything other than look if you want to and carry on with your walk or whatever you're doing.

And horse owners do put measures in place to stop it happening, double fencing, signs, moving them away from public footpaths if possible, but people insist that they have a right to do what they want regardless and as we have seen on this thread are trying their damnedest to circumnavigate those measures - why don't those people bear some of the responsibility as it's them that's causing the issue?! Honestly some people will do anything to ensure that they never have to take any responsibility for their own actions.

I'd like to see that when a horse is fed by someone without permission, despite measures put in place to prevent it, it can be classed as criminal damage.

Better the horse owners protect their own horses more and put preventative measures in place.

Let's say you had a hippo (a river horse) but children at the zoo kept feeding it lemons. After putting "no lemons please!" posters up, and a sign on the dangers of lemons, the sensible thing would be to move the hippo away so the public couldn't feed it lemons even if they wanted.

Maverickess · 27/03/2024 08:28

ChedderGorgeous · 26/03/2024 16:26

But you are putting your horse at risk by relying on the public, who generally don't know equine cuisine restrictions, because you think they should. Safer to preemptively protect the horses better, surely.

If people choose to interact with an animal without the owners permission then the least they have is responsibility to educate themselves on that animal and not make it unwell and put it at risk.

I mean people don't really have the right to interact with an animal that they don't own at all, without permission, but if they decide to then they are taking on that responsibility.

Don't want to learn about 'equine cuisine' or more specifically horse management and the many issues and complications that can arise from them being fed stuff they shouldn't have? Or even stuff they can have, but by someone who isn't their owner and without the owners knowledge -
Then the answer is simple don't feed them!

It's not like horse owners are asking for you to do something for their benefit, or even the animals benefit, they're asking for you to be passive, not do anything other than look if you want to and carry on with your walk or whatever you're doing.

And horse owners do put measures in place to stop it happening, double fencing, signs, moving them away from public footpaths if possible, but people insist that they have a right to do what they want regardless and as we have seen on this thread are trying their damnedest to circumnavigate those measures - why don't those people bear some of the responsibility as it's them that's causing the issue?! Honestly some people will do anything to ensure that they never have to take any responsibility for their own actions.

I'd like to see that when a horse is fed by someone without permission, despite measures put in place to prevent it, it can be classed as criminal damage.

Onceuponatimeiwasaho · 27/03/2024 03:43

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

krustykittens · 26/03/2024 23:06

@Vanessasbag The reason why horse owners probably complained less in the past is because people probably had more manners than to feed other people's animals. I was always taught never to feed or touch other people's animals without permission. WE are not the entitled ones, YOU are, by thinking you have any right to tell someone how YOU will treat THEIR animal! One of my ponies nearly died last year because a family of holiday makers staying in the area fed him grass cuttings, despite me asking them not to and explaining why and despite me offering to bring him in and introduce him to the kids in a safe way and let them pet him. But it wasn't good enough for them, they wanted to do what they wanted with him, when they wanted. And he nearly died a very painful death! After this incident, I have no more patience or kindness left for the general public. Keep your hands to yourself! Lots of people have things I can't afford, I don't feel entitled to them anyway.

TheOriginalEmu · 26/03/2024 21:02

Vanessasbag · 26/03/2024 09:50

I think that for people who can't afford horses, and don't know that much about them, seeing a horse in a field is a delight, with young children especially. They want to stroke the horse, especially if the horse comes over to the gate, non-horsey people will think that the horse wants to say hello. They'll feel like they want to give the horse something, like a carrot. People used to be like that in my childhood and nobody every complained. A lot of horse owners now seem precious and entitled and forget that there are lots of people who would love to own a horse but cannot afford to.

People did complain about it. You can say hello and admire the animal without feeding it. It doesn’t exist for your entertainment unless you plan to chip in for the hundreds or thousands of pounds in vets bills you might incur by feeding them.
im in no way rich, my horses were cheaper than most peoples dogs to buy and I scrimp to afford their care going without a great deal of other things to afford them. So when someone hurts them because ‘they can’t afford a horse’ I say neither can I! And I then have to maybe put my horse to sleep if I can’t afford the veterinary treatment they’ll need because you can’t keep your hands to yourself!

CrappySack · 26/03/2024 18:59

ChedderGorgeous · 26/03/2024 16:18

Ultimately I think it's up to horse owners to protect the health of their horses adequately and not rely on members of the public, who don't know about specific horse diets, to do so. Clearly signs don't work, so the horses shouldn't be accessible to the public. Simple really.

Edited

I agree.

Horse owners should just pop a dome over their fields. Any dome-less owners deserve to have their horses killed for being so lazy.

/Sarcasm

Minimili · 26/03/2024 18:31

Thoroughbred5 · 08/05/2023 10:05

And if you actually bothered to read my OP- you would see I’ve done double fencing. It DOESNT work. Same with electric unfortunately and hedges. People just climb the gate and then climb the second gate. My horses are in the most remote field possible. It is not a problem unique to my yard- it’s everywhere because people are bloody idiots.

so what do you suggest eh? The horses never leave the stable?

Would it be possible to put CCTV or a doorbell camera up linked to your phone? You could put a sign up saying that you will post images on social media of people who are feeding the horses and risking making them seriously ill. People might not be as quick to do it if they know that others will be judging their actions.

You also have the intercom option on a ring doorbell so if you got a notification on your phone you could activate it and ask people to stop, if confronted directly they might not continue. There is even a voice changing option on some, If you change it to a man’s voice that might seem more authoritative - it shouldn’t but let’s face it if it’s a man feeding the horses they are more likely to listen to another man asking.
I have an anti tamper alarm on mine as well so if anyone tries to remove it an alarm goes off and it takes their photograph. I’d put a sign up saying this because someone would probably try to steal it, you could put multiple ones up.

Do you have a local Facebook group? I live in a town that has a group where horse owners post and explain the risks of feeding their horses, after one died they posted a picture of the dead horse and it was heartbreaking, a lot of people responded they had no idea that feeding them could make them ill and said they wouldn’t do it again. If you don’t have a local group you could post to a buying/selling group that gets a lot of traffic if you ask permission, I’ve seen people do that as well.

There are horses in a field very near to my house, the owners put a sign up saying “if you want to feed the horses you are welcome to bring your children on this time and this date and they can meet the horses supervised. Please do not feed them unless invited or you will might make them so ill it could kill them” They put a mobile number too. I actually went to feed them when I was passing on one occasion and there was quite a crowd, there were adults there alone and not just with children.
They ended up making money having a twice weekly “meet & greet”.
Obviously that was great for their circumstances but might not work for everyone, I’m guessing it depends on the horses needs and temperament and if you actually want to deal with hoards of people every week!

Until reading some posts on this thread I have to admit I was naive about approaching horses, I would never have fed one because I don’t think you should ever feed animals that don’t belong to you but I have stopped and petted a Shetland pony in a field by my house. I spent hours during lockdown sat by the fence talking and stroking it (I was desperate for company!) but reading some of people’s comments today has educated me that it’s not always a good idea to stroke random horses, in future if I don’t have permission I’ll just stand back and admire them.
At least some people on this thread today will have read what you’ve put and taken notice of it, I can’t believe anyone voted you as unreasonable but obviously that’s the problem that some people have this attitude.

I really hope you find a solution, I thought the pp who suggested putting fake beehives up had a good idea, there is no way I’d be approaching anywhere if I saw a beehive.
The fact is that you can put signs up and try your level best to educate people but some people are just unwilling to listen if it doesn’t suit them, you would think it’d be enough to stop people in their tracks if they knew they would cause suffering to the horses if you feed them but some people think it doesn’t apply to them.

I read once that if you put a sign up asking people to stop doing something then to address it as if it’s directed to them personally. If you put if YOU feed the horses then YOU risk making them ill and YOU could cause them a lot of suffering and pain then they might take more notice then if it’s just a general notice. Apparently it’s a psychological trick that is affective.

LilFoxes · 26/03/2024 17:35

Can only sympathise OP, I was at a zoo recently where I watch a parent hang a toddler horizontally over the meerkats. Firstly, the toddler was screaming, secondly meerkats are vicious little creatures but thirdly (and most importantly) parents didn't realise they were holding darling Matilda so her legs were against the high voltage wire under the ledge, inside the exhibit.

Moral of the story: people are entitled and thick. Suggestions - A sign that says 'electric fence is connected to mains to stop ponies biting idiots' or a 'bull in field' sign? Generally folk seem more wary of cattle... get an ACTUAL bullock for the field? I don't think there's a clear answer, maybe plant some stinging nettles or something equally ouchy around the fence line?

ErrolTheDragon · 26/03/2024 17:20

mitogoshi · 26/03/2024 16:34

@Throwyourkeysup

Not all horse owners mind their horses being fed which causes confusion too. My neighbours own horses which I occasionally feed for them, they allow all manner of treats! Perhaps signage is important if you have a horse which has a strict diet. I grew up giving sugar lumps to horses and whilst I know not to now, the older generation may not realise

Or simpler.... just work on the assumption that it's not ok to feed anything to another person's animal without their explicit permission?

Throwyourkeysup · 26/03/2024 17:16

Throwyourkeysup · 26/03/2024 17:06

Yes absolutely; the older generation may not realise, but presumably there is no good reason why they should take note of signs?

And your neighbour’s may have different reasons for allowing treats eg the horses are old, not ridden, extremely hearty types, or they may know the majority of people who are likely to pass by and feed. Just because one set of owners allows it, doesn’t mean that rule translates universally to all owners and their horses!

No good reason why they should NOT take note of signs I mean!

menopausalmare · 26/03/2024 17:16

.....or cats that hang out in Tesco Sunbury (#Belinda).

Throwyourkeysup · 26/03/2024 17:15

ChedderGorgeous · 26/03/2024 16:26

But you are putting your horse at risk by relying on the public, who generally don't know equine cuisine restrictions, because you think they should. Safer to preemptively protect the horses better, surely.

But if you go by that rule, only multi-millionaires would own horses and keep them in guarded enclaves with 24 hour security!

It really isn’t owners putting horses at risk from the public. It’s the other way around!

abbey44 · 26/03/2024 17:12

@Vanessasbag - how you have the nerve to call horse owners protecting their animals “precious and entitled” I just don’t know.

My sister’s much-loved horse (that she’d bred and brought up from a foal) got colic from someone feeding it something they shouldn’t have. She had an operation (£10,000) followed by six months’ box rest while the incision in her stomach healed. Unfortunately, as a result of complications, she ended up having to be put down. And all because someone - like you - thought they had the right to give her a “treat”.

So don’t give me “precious and entitled” and just stay away from animals that don’t belong to you.

Throwyourkeysup · 26/03/2024 17:06

mitogoshi · 26/03/2024 16:34

@Throwyourkeysup

Not all horse owners mind their horses being fed which causes confusion too. My neighbours own horses which I occasionally feed for them, they allow all manner of treats! Perhaps signage is important if you have a horse which has a strict diet. I grew up giving sugar lumps to horses and whilst I know not to now, the older generation may not realise

Yes absolutely; the older generation may not realise, but presumably there is no good reason why they should take note of signs?

And your neighbour’s may have different reasons for allowing treats eg the horses are old, not ridden, extremely hearty types, or they may know the majority of people who are likely to pass by and feed. Just because one set of owners allows it, doesn’t mean that rule translates universally to all owners and their horses!

LordPercyPercy · 26/03/2024 16:43

@ChedderGorgeous where do you suggest this mythical place is, accessible only to the horse owner yet nobody else.
Newsflash - people trespass. Knobheads that like bothering other people's animals are going to be happy to trespass.

peakygold · 26/03/2024 16:39

I imagine if the horses are super skinny and filthy, people feel sorry for them.

mitogoshi · 26/03/2024 16:34

@Throwyourkeysup

Not all horse owners mind their horses being fed which causes confusion too. My neighbours own horses which I occasionally feed for them, they allow all manner of treats! Perhaps signage is important if you have a horse which has a strict diet. I grew up giving sugar lumps to horses and whilst I know not to now, the older generation may not realise

countrygirl99 · 26/03/2024 16:34

ChedderGorgeous · 26/03/2024 16:26

But you are putting your horse at risk by relying on the public, who generally don't know equine cuisine restrictions, because you think they should. Safer to preemptively protect the horses better, surely.

You just leave anything animate or inanimate that doesn't being to you alone. No need to worry about cuisine restrictions then. Really very, very simple.

ChedderGorgeous · 26/03/2024 16:31

FayCarew · 26/03/2024 16:28

equine cuisine restrictions
Are you referring to the 2013 horse meat scandal? Smile

Now that would be an argument of many layers , with bechamel.

twistyizzy · 26/03/2024 16:30

ChedderGorgeous · 26/03/2024 16:26

But you are putting your horse at risk by relying on the public, who generally don't know equine cuisine restrictions, because you think they should. Safer to preemptively protect the horses better, surely.

OK and how do you suggest that happens? I know, block footpaths off so that entitled people don't endanger my animals.
If people are walking across field they should know, and abide by, the countryside code. People who think they have a right to feed other people's animals are likely the same ignorant twats who let their dogs run in amongst sheep and lambs!

FayCarew · 26/03/2024 16:28

equine cuisine restrictions
Are you referring to the 2013 horse meat scandal? Smile

ChedderGorgeous · 26/03/2024 16:26

twistyizzy · 26/03/2024 16:19

Just don't feed any animal that doesn't belong to you.
Simple really.

But you are putting your horse at risk by relying on the public, who generally don't know equine cuisine restrictions, because you think they should. Safer to preemptively protect the horses better, surely.

FayCarew · 26/03/2024 16:25

I bumped this thread because of a post on a different thread. 4 pages later and I'm quite glad I did.