Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Lunch guest. AIBU to feel hurt?

458 replies

Tabitha1960 · 07/05/2023 15:57

I'm a single lady in my sixties and have very few female friends so made a vow to make extra efforts to try to make some.

Having chatted to a local divorcee in her early 50s a few times, I initially knew her through her job and then from bumping into her now and again and stopping for a chat. As she seemed to like me and we have things in common, I invited her to my house for Sunday lunch. I asked her if roast lamb and all the trimmings would be OK and her eyes lit up, and she said something like, "oooh yummy, that would be lovely!" She lives about a mile away and chose to walk to mine arriving at 1pm.

As you can imagine I was rushed off my feet all morning not just preparing all the food from scratch but tidying and cleaning the kitchen-diner and making everything nice for her.

Lunch was ready when she arrived so I served up and everything went perfectly. It took us about half an hour to eat the meal at a leisurely pace, she was all smiles and compliments and we chatted a little in between bites, she telling me about her two grown up children and four grandchildren. She complimented the food and my house and seemed to really enjoy my company. That is why what happened came as such a shock. As I was clearing away the plates, at 1.40pm she received a text message on her phone. She read it and stood up, smiling, and saying cheerily, "Oh, that was my son, he's already on his way to pick me up. Thank you for a lovely lunch!" Then she picked up her bag and collected her jacket and walked out of my front door to wait for her son's car.

I pretended to be all breezy and smiley and perfectly happy with her departure, but I wasn't really. She was here for literally 40 minutes. When we agreed the date she didn't say she would have to squeeze me into a busy schedule. She made no mention of having anything else to do on that day. I felt gutted because I had assumed it was an "open-ended" lunch in which we'd have dessert, then coffees, then sit around chatting and having a laugh and getting to know one another for a couple of hours. I imagined she'd offer to help with the dishes (which I would of course have refused).

As I tackled the pile of washing up I felt really upset, and even shed a couple of silly tears. What she did felt rather rude and I felt "used". Three hours preparing for her visit, and another hour clearing up, for 40 minutes of her company!

Had it been some kind of emergency of course I would not mind but I don't understand why she told her son to come and collect her at 1.40pm when she knew I'd gone to the trouble of a roast and "all the trimmings."

Isn't there a saying or proverb about "eating and running?"

This was a few weeks ago. We have since interacted on Facebook with lighthearted and witty comments on each others' walls, but she has not asked to meet up again. I'm sad because I really like her and she seemed to like me a lot.

AIBU?

Yes, you are BU -- it only takes 40 minutes to eat lunch so she was right to arrange collection at 1.40pm.

No, you are not BU - she was very rude leaving so quickly

OP posts:
Athlebad · 08/05/2023 20:29

It possible that's she's just someone who already has enough people in her life and isn't looking for new friends.

For a people pleaser, it's difficult to say no to someone's invitation. So maybe she's said yes to the invite because she didn't want to be hurtful and say a flat no. But has then felt awkward about it and created a get-out plan as she was worried about it not going well.

Was the way she did it rude? Yes. Did she misjudge how long it would be reasonable to stay for? Definitely.

But I think you have to be prepared that just because someone is friendly in passing, it doesn't mean they necessarily want to start a friendship with you.

As others have said, suggesting a brief, low-input meet up would be a better plan in future. And then being alert to subtle signals that the other person may not want to pursue it further (eg them not suggesting another meet up). Try not to take it personally, some people don't have time/energy/space for new friends in their lives.

1AngelicFruitCake · 08/05/2023 20:18

Hi OP
you sound lovely. I was on the opposite side of this with someone I met as an acquaintance. She was quite full on to start with, suggesting full days out, suggesting cocktails then meal etc out. I didn’t want to do this because I struggle to commit this amount of time to my existing friendships as it is. I like this lady but a quick drink would do to start with, which I did suggest! It’s a shame because she backed off from me and I do like her.

I do think this new friend of yours was rude and hurtful but don’t let it deter you from pursuing new friendships.

Solonge · 08/05/2023 19:55

Eudaimonia5 · 07/05/2023 16:11

I think you've both been a bit unreasonable.

A full lunch with all the trimmings is a bit much for a potential new friend. You say you expected her to stay for dessert and then coffee which sounds like several hours. It would have been better to meet her for a casual lunch or just coffee. Either that or invite her round for something light like sandwiches.

The lunch with all the trimmings and hours or chatting sounds great for a friend you're close to but not for someone who you usually just bump into. She's a new potential friend, you're both still deciding whether you get on well enough to be proper friends.

She's been unreasonable for only staying for 40 minutes. She could have stayed for an hour. But maybe she got freaked out by all the effort you'd gone to and kind of felt that you'd taken her hostage for the whole day.

Op said that new friend had pre arranged her son to collect her. So it wasnt something done in haste after feeling that Op was too intense.

katemulberrybush · 08/05/2023 19:54

I bet she thought there'd be others there. Group situation

katemulberrybush · 08/05/2023 19:54

Was there wine? What did you drink?

Dibbydoos · 08/05/2023 19:43

Hi OP, I too would be upset if someone did this to me. And of course dessert and coffee/tea is customary. Wtf was she thinking of? Did she think it'd be awkward? How horrid of her to preempt a quick leave without mentioning anything to you...

Please know you did a lovely thing. Well done.

rRef meeting new people, how about joining a woman's group nearby? I found a few through an internet search near me that look interesting. I haven't been yet, but get dates I can make are later this month.

Maybe if you do offer to host, arrange a bring and share meal so everyone brings something different - main, sides, desserts. One of my friends does this a lot with several people - they always work out great! And she themes them - curry, BBQ, sunday dinner etc.

Hoping you find friends who deserve you soon x

Bloopsie · 08/05/2023 18:42

To let you put in all that effort and then stay just long enough to eat is rude, biscuits and tea if that,would have been more appropriate for that short visit

Missingpop · 08/05/2023 18:39

What incredibly bad manners, are there any local craft groups you could join; maybe tge local WI; possibly a mature ladies exercise group; thankfully not everyone would behave in this manner & moire would appreciate your hospitality & kindness, so don’t be put off there are bound to be many ladies who are in the same position as you, wanting to make friends so do keep trying x

NannaKaren · 08/05/2023 18:26

She is rude.
do not ask her over again unless you are invited first to her and if you enjoy her company …
try and volunteer or join some clubs following your interests to make more like minded friends.
she was awfully rude !

Hooplatoo · 08/05/2023 18:08

Not too intense. Sunday lunch is not a snack, it's a lovely occasion which takes a lot of prep. 40 minutes is a cup of tea and a biscuit.

ReadersD1gest · 08/05/2023 16:54

Clarabell77 · 08/05/2023 15:56

You’re obviously not that familiar with it then. My first post was tongue in cheek, it couldn’t be any more fitting of the definition. My second post was in response to you stating it was quite a leap - it wasn’t, it was tongue in cheek, but to go from thinking something to saying it isn’t a leap.

God, you seem to have tied yourself in knots in an effort to be entertaining.
Shame it fell so flat 🤣

Clarabell77 · 08/05/2023 15:56

ReadersD1gest · 08/05/2023 15:24

It may just be a poor choice of words but to write something like that you have to think it, therefore I’m not sure saying it out loud is quite the leap you are claiming
I am, yes. What you've written above isn't an example of this 🤷🏻‍♀️

You’re obviously not that familiar with it then. My first post was tongue in cheek, it couldn’t be any more fitting of the definition. My second post was in response to you stating it was quite a leap - it wasn’t, it was tongue in cheek, but to go from thinking something to saying it isn’t a leap.

ReadersD1gest · 08/05/2023 15:24

Clarabell77 · 08/05/2023 15:19

Are you familiar with the phrase “tongue in cheek”?

It may just be a poor choice of words but to write something like that you have to think it, therefore I’m not sure saying it out loud is quite the leap you are claiming
I am, yes. What you've written above isn't an example of this 🤷🏻‍♀️

Clarabell77 · 08/05/2023 15:19

ReadersD1gest · 08/05/2023 15:06

So you're sticking to your suggestion that op may have said this out loud to her guest?!

Are you familiar with the phrase “tongue in cheek”?

ReadersD1gest · 08/05/2023 15:06

Clarabell77 · 08/05/2023 12:21

To refer to people with autism as having something “wrong” with them, whether on a public forum or not isn’t really acceptable. It may just be a poor choice of words but to write something like that you have to think it, therefore I’m not sure saying it out loud is quite the leap you are claiming.

The guest may be neurodiverse, the OP might also be judging by her behaviours, but it doesn’t mean there’s something “wrong” with them.

So you're sticking to your suggestion that op may have said this out loud to her guest?!

RachelGreep87 · 08/05/2023 14:17

LozengeShaped · 08/05/2023 14:04

Well, the guest was a woman in her early 50s. Up until recently, it wasn't the norm for people in their 50s and 60s to be in houseshares.
I think the OP is the landlady, and this has always been quite a common scenario for a single woman or a widow.

That is fine, I'm just suggesting it may have made the guest feel uncomfortable.

There are often threads where an OP arranges a meetup with a friend and then the friend wants to bring others along which upsets the OP. These tend to be split between the "more the merrier" brigade and the ones who feel like this changes the dynamic.

Similarly, it is a different dynamic having an intimate lunch alone in a house with someone versus having the cast of Friends milling around the place. The guest may not be into that.

For what its worth, I do ultimately think the guest was being rude.

LozengeShaped · 08/05/2023 14:04

Well, the guest was a woman in her early 50s. Up until recently, it wasn't the norm for people in their 50s and 60s to be in houseshares.
I think the OP is the landlady, and this has always been quite a common scenario for a single woman or a widow.

WomanBitingATowel · 08/05/2023 13:46

smurfette1818 · 08/05/2023 12:58

Agreed with a pp above, not sure why some posters get such a thrill from blaming OP, clutching at straws in doing so. There must be a reason (which is OP's fault entirely that made the guest displayed such a weird behaviour) So far we got:

  • OP is too intense, how dare she had a vision how the afternoon was going to go. She must be lonely.
  • the lunch feels more like a romantic date
  • maybe OP asked whether the rude guest is autistic
  • a university vibe from house share
  • guest does not see her son often or had to fit in with his schedule
  • various health and mental health reasons
  • Sunday is a busy day and people have things to do and generally don't have time to hang out for hours after lunch (even though someone has gone through the effort to make a nice lunch for you and that's why you are invited for)
  • She did not bring a gift? oh maybe she hasn't had sufficient life experiences and doesn't understand social norms (despite being 50 years old)
  • and the winner is: OP needs to examine herself, carefully considers how she come across, there must be something wrong with the vibe she emits she needs to ask for feedback from her housemates and work on herself

OP is a kind, thoughtful and generous person, she has done absolutely nothing wrong here. The guest is by any standard the off one and lack of social graces. This is about her not OP.

And yet the OP says she struggles to make friends with women, so this type of misunderstanding/mismatch of expectations may well be a pattern it would help her to understand. Yes, it could well be that the guest is simply a rude, socially ill-attuned person (as suggested by her failure to bring any form of gift with her, however token, as well as her abrupt departure), but there is also something potentially slightly ‘off’ about the misjudgement that saw the OP ask someone she barely knows in passing over to her house for a meal that took so much intensive work to prepare for, and the over-investment in exactly how the afternoon would unroll that left her in tears. The OP, who admits to struggling with friendships, posted here for objective responses, so ‘There, there, you’re lovely and she’s a cow’ isn’t necessary that helpful. Maybe the OP is indeed lovely and the guest is a cow. Or maybe there were a few more shades of grey in this encounter, even if they don’t necessarily exonerate the guest.

Katherine1985 · 08/05/2023 13:25

Yes!! Great summing up of the batshittery on this thread @smurfette1818

smurfette1818 · 08/05/2023 12:58

Agreed with a pp above, not sure why some posters get such a thrill from blaming OP, clutching at straws in doing so. There must be a reason (which is OP's fault entirely that made the guest displayed such a weird behaviour) So far we got:

  • OP is too intense, how dare she had a vision how the afternoon was going to go. She must be lonely.
  • the lunch feels more like a romantic date
  • maybe OP asked whether the rude guest is autistic
  • a university vibe from house share
  • guest does not see her son often or had to fit in with his schedule
  • various health and mental health reasons
  • Sunday is a busy day and people have things to do and generally don't have time to hang out for hours after lunch (even though someone has gone through the effort to make a nice lunch for you and that's why you are invited for)
  • She did not bring a gift? oh maybe she hasn't had sufficient life experiences and doesn't understand social norms (despite being 50 years old)
  • and the winner is: OP needs to examine herself, carefully considers how she come across, there must be something wrong with the vibe she emits she needs to ask for feedback from her housemates and work on herself

OP is a kind, thoughtful and generous person, she has done absolutely nothing wrong here. The guest is by any standard the off one and lack of social graces. This is about her not OP.

LuckySantangelo35 · 08/05/2023 12:47

daisymoonlight · 08/05/2023 12:37

LOLOL You'd be rude to someone who made lunch for you just because living with housemates at age 60 "isnt the norm". Wow. Glad I dont have friends like you if you can manage to be polite to people based on whether their living arrangements are considered "normal" in your eyes. Geez.

@RachelGreep87

⬆️ sums it up really well

whether this woman approves or disapproves of OP living in a flat share, it doesn’t mean she can be rude

daisymoonlight · 08/05/2023 12:37

RachelGreep87 · 08/05/2023 12:03

Well, the guest was a woman in her early 50s. Up until recently, it wasn't the norm for people in their 50s and 60s to be in houseshares.
It gives off a university vibe and maybe she was put off by that.

LOLOL You'd be rude to someone who made lunch for you just because living with housemates at age 60 "isnt the norm". Wow. Glad I dont have friends like you if you can manage to be polite to people based on whether their living arrangements are considered "normal" in your eyes. Geez.

RachelGreep87 · 08/05/2023 12:21

ReadersD1gest · 08/05/2023 12:07

If op lived in a house with her family, they'd have been strangers to the guest too.
You're really reaching here, determined to blame her rude as fuck behaviour on the "odd" atmosphere 🤨
Do you also have issues with social interactions?

Family isn't quite the same. Based on my experience of flatshares (in London anyway) people just keep to themselves, mostly staying in their own spaces unless they need to use the kitchen. I would be very conscious of spending too long in the kitchen as it could mean depriving others of their chance to make a meal.

It also makes the idea of getting to know one another over the course of a few hours a bit awkward when Jane from upstairs could pop in at any moment to get her Muller Corner from the fridge.

Clarabell77 · 08/05/2023 12:21

Stripedbag101 · 08/05/2023 06:43

why would OP have said this at lunch? She has said this on an anonymous forum in response to suggestions the guest may have behaved rudely because she is ND.

why on earth would you assume OP would have said this to her. Is a really odd leap to make.

To refer to people with autism as having something “wrong” with them, whether on a public forum or not isn’t really acceptable. It may just be a poor choice of words but to write something like that you have to think it, therefore I’m not sure saying it out loud is quite the leap you are claiming.

The guest may be neurodiverse, the OP might also be judging by her behaviours, but it doesn’t mean there’s something “wrong” with them.

ReadersD1gest · 08/05/2023 12:07

RachelGreep87 · 08/05/2023 12:03

Well, the guest was a woman in her early 50s. Up until recently, it wasn't the norm for people in their 50s and 60s to be in houseshares.
It gives off a university vibe and maybe she was put off by that.

If op lived in a house with her family, they'd have been strangers to the guest too.
You're really reaching here, determined to blame her rude as fuck behaviour on the "odd" atmosphere 🤨
Do you also have issues with social interactions?