Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Lunch guest. AIBU to feel hurt?

458 replies

Tabitha1960 · 07/05/2023 15:57

I'm a single lady in my sixties and have very few female friends so made a vow to make extra efforts to try to make some.

Having chatted to a local divorcee in her early 50s a few times, I initially knew her through her job and then from bumping into her now and again and stopping for a chat. As she seemed to like me and we have things in common, I invited her to my house for Sunday lunch. I asked her if roast lamb and all the trimmings would be OK and her eyes lit up, and she said something like, "oooh yummy, that would be lovely!" She lives about a mile away and chose to walk to mine arriving at 1pm.

As you can imagine I was rushed off my feet all morning not just preparing all the food from scratch but tidying and cleaning the kitchen-diner and making everything nice for her.

Lunch was ready when she arrived so I served up and everything went perfectly. It took us about half an hour to eat the meal at a leisurely pace, she was all smiles and compliments and we chatted a little in between bites, she telling me about her two grown up children and four grandchildren. She complimented the food and my house and seemed to really enjoy my company. That is why what happened came as such a shock. As I was clearing away the plates, at 1.40pm she received a text message on her phone. She read it and stood up, smiling, and saying cheerily, "Oh, that was my son, he's already on his way to pick me up. Thank you for a lovely lunch!" Then she picked up her bag and collected her jacket and walked out of my front door to wait for her son's car.

I pretended to be all breezy and smiley and perfectly happy with her departure, but I wasn't really. She was here for literally 40 minutes. When we agreed the date she didn't say she would have to squeeze me into a busy schedule. She made no mention of having anything else to do on that day. I felt gutted because I had assumed it was an "open-ended" lunch in which we'd have dessert, then coffees, then sit around chatting and having a laugh and getting to know one another for a couple of hours. I imagined she'd offer to help with the dishes (which I would of course have refused).

As I tackled the pile of washing up I felt really upset, and even shed a couple of silly tears. What she did felt rather rude and I felt "used". Three hours preparing for her visit, and another hour clearing up, for 40 minutes of her company!

Had it been some kind of emergency of course I would not mind but I don't understand why she told her son to come and collect her at 1.40pm when she knew I'd gone to the trouble of a roast and "all the trimmings."

Isn't there a saying or proverb about "eating and running?"

This was a few weeks ago. We have since interacted on Facebook with lighthearted and witty comments on each others' walls, but she has not asked to meet up again. I'm sad because I really like her and she seemed to like me a lot.

AIBU?

Yes, you are BU -- it only takes 40 minutes to eat lunch so she was right to arrange collection at 1.40pm.

No, you are not BU - she was very rude leaving so quickly

OP posts:
BadgerFacedCoo · 07/05/2023 16:51

She's sent the "say you need to get me now" text. She waited out the front ffs. Like a young woman on a dodgy date.

I'd suggest trying groups rather than one on one. If friendships don't come easy it can be useful to be in a group and measure you're own behaviour and how it would be perceived in a less intense setting.

Thighlengthboots · 07/05/2023 16:50

IF thats the kind of person she is you have dodged a bullet there- she sounds staggeringly rude/entitled. I wouldnt be interacting with her any more on FB. When people show you who they are- believe them the first time. If you carry on trying with this person you'll likely get more of the same selfish behaviour.

There are plenty of decent people out there OP- dont give up!

YaWeeFurryBastard · 07/05/2023 16:49

Itchyfleet · 07/05/2023 16:12

Oh OP don’t listen to people saying you are intense or stifling or had odd expectations.

you offered a very kind invite which was accepted and you graciously went to a lot of effort to make it pleasant for your guest.

her departure sounds odd and rude and I wonder if she is a bit lacking in social graces. Did she bring a gift or contribution at all? Has she mentioned returning the invitation?

it sounds like any friendship with her will be on her terms which is brief and superficial.

you sound lovely - a wonderful hostess and kind friend. Don’t let it put you off- keep searching for groups and new friends and you will find someone more on your wavelength in time.

Agree with this. You sound lovely, thoughtful and a kind person willing to make the effort.

WorldOutThere · 07/05/2023 16:49

Whilst your psychology and expectations could be seen as a little detailed and intense, your actions absolutely weren’t.

She was downright rude. If you go to someone’s house for a roast you stay at least a couple of hours.

She used you for a delicious meal. At least you know now. Don’t let this put you off. Most decent people don’t behave like this.

This is about her not you. Roll your eyes and move on.

NeedToChangeName · 07/05/2023 16:49

Eudaimonia5 · 07/05/2023 16:11

I think you've both been a bit unreasonable.

A full lunch with all the trimmings is a bit much for a potential new friend. You say you expected her to stay for dessert and then coffee which sounds like several hours. It would have been better to meet her for a casual lunch or just coffee. Either that or invite her round for something light like sandwiches.

The lunch with all the trimmings and hours or chatting sounds great for a friend you're close to but not for someone who you usually just bump into. She's a new potential friend, you're both still deciding whether you get on well enough to be proper friends.

She's been unreasonable for only staying for 40 minutes. She could have stayed for an hour. But maybe she got freaked out by all the effort you'd gone to and kind of felt that you'd taken her hostage for the whole day.

@Eudaimonia5 I agree with this. You were kind to go to so much trouble, but perhaps a bit much for a casual acquaintance

TakingTheCake · 07/05/2023 16:48

Any chance her son was early? Could be that, as the walked there, she was later to arrive than she expected?

I can understand staying for 1.5 or two hours or something on a first occasion, as not wanting to overstay. But 40 mins does sound very odd!

Pinkdelight3 · 07/05/2023 16:48

She was very rude and should be ashamed of behaving that way. Better to know and not persist with anything more than a very minor friendship. Definitely don't expect her to reciprocate with invitations as she's made it clear she's got other priorities. Save your energies for people who'll value your time and the effort you go to.

mainsfed · 07/05/2023 16:47

She was rude but don’t worry, most people aren’t like that.

Next time invite people for a coffee first so you can see that gore before investing time and effort and money in cooking for them.

User57632678383 · 07/05/2023 16:46

YANBU. I remember once an ex close friend who had over time ditched me for other people randomly reached out and said we should go out and catch up and we arranged a Saturday night. I got dressed up and was really excited to see her again except when we got to the pub we ordered a drink and after a few minutes she let me know she “can’t stay long as I’m out with X, Y and Z tonight”. We left after that drink and she went on her merry way to spend time elsewhere and I remember going home feeling really sad and stupid and also wondering why she’d suggested meeting in the first place if she was busy, it was as if she felt she was doing me a favour?

What your friend did was rude and I would be in no hurry to invite her again!

Curtain1980 · 07/05/2023 16:45

Wow OP what a caring kind thing to do and she was not a good person to do this, I imagine she could have text her son and said not yet (maybe it was one of those where they say do you want collecting or are you ok to stay?)!

Dragonsandcats · 07/05/2023 16:45

honeyimstillfree · 07/05/2023 16:09

it’s a bit strange that you’d planned how the afternoon would go in your head, even down to her offering to help wash up. maybe she sensed that you’re a bit intense?

I don’t think that’s strange, I think the expected afternoon was in line with social norms. If I went to a friend’s for Sunday lunch I’d expect to stay to eat, have a chat and offer to help clear up.

daisymoonlight · 07/05/2023 16:44

NewNovember · 07/05/2023 16:42

She probably just had to fit in with when her son was free.

Then she should have been honest from the start about when she had to leave or arranged an earlier starting time. She knew OP was cooking a roast- it wasnt a surprise.

Jobsharenightmare · 07/05/2023 16:44

I can take 40 mins in McDonald's so I think this was so rude.

AnElegantChaos · 07/05/2023 16:44

LividHouse · 07/05/2023 16:04

You do sound quite intense, with a clear vision of how it “should” have gone.

It’s possible she found that stifling.

Oh for goodness sake, why do so many MN'ers get such a thrill out of this 'you do sound quite intense' bullshit when the OP clearly doesn't. Says more about you than OP.

I think if you continue this friendship OP it will always be on her terms and ultimately very frustrating for you so I would just wind that one down. You sound lovely, and I'm sure you'll find other friends who will appreciate your efforts - PP's suggestion about coffee and cake is a good one. This woman was bloody rude btw and I'm not surprised you were upset.

ReadersD1gest · 07/05/2023 16:44

NewNovember · 07/05/2023 16:42

She probably just had to fit in with when her son was free.

Why? It was within walking distance, in fact she managed to walk there without difficulty.

AngryGreasedSantaCatcus · 07/05/2023 16:43

Does she drive/was able to make her way home on her own , or did she actually need that lift?

Spookysnake · 07/05/2023 16:43

NewNovember · 07/05/2023 16:42

She probably just had to fit in with when her son was free.

She could have walked home!!

CremeEggThief · 07/05/2023 16:43

YANBU and anyone on this thread hinting it's possibly partly your fault is BU! After going to all that effort and expense too!😥

Xmasbaby11 · 07/05/2023 16:43

I agree with you - 40 mins is nothing, definitely eating and running! I often meet friends for lunch or coffee - we work, we have kids, life is busy- and we’re up front about how long we have. A quick coffee would be an hour, though 2 hours if time. Lunch at least 90mins. She should have been honest beforehand if she was pushed for time and had other plans, perhaps changing either plans with you or ds.

hope you have more luck with other friends op.

NewNovember · 07/05/2023 16:42

She probably just had to fit in with when her son was free.

daisymoonlight · 07/05/2023 16:41

TBH you sound very lonely, and like you had one vision of how the afternoon was going to go, and she had a different vision for it

Nope- dont agree at all. OP made her "vision" explicitly clear- she invited her for a lamb roast sunday dinner and this person was happy to attend and very clear on what the plans involved. No confusion there- she ate and ran. Thats incredibly rude.

Spookysnake · 07/05/2023 16:41

You sound lovely, and I'm sorry she behaved like that! I'd have expected to stay at least a couple of hours, and would have sent a thank-you card and suggested a nice treat to reciprocate. I hope you find someone nicer to share your generosity with!

coloursquare · 07/05/2023 16:41

40 mins is rude, but I agree with the poster who said that a roast lunch with a "vision" of how it will pan out into a few hours of chatting etc is a bit intense for someone you hardly know.

Next time I'd suggest a coffee with a new person.

mastertomsmum · 07/05/2023 16:40

PuffinsRocks · 07/05/2023 16:01

TBH you sound very lonely, and like you had one vision of how the afternoon was going to go, and she had a different vision for it, and neither of you communicated that to one another. That's all. I don't think anyone was unreasonable here. She might not have wanted to overstay her welcome and maybe took it literally when you invited her around "for lunch". I do think she should have offered to help with the washing up but maybe she assumed you had a dishwasher.

Nobody just stays for 40 mins, it’s downright weird. The OP feels how anyone treated like that would feel

woodhill · 07/05/2023 16:39

So rude of her

So sorry OP