Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Lunch guest. AIBU to feel hurt?

458 replies

Tabitha1960 · 07/05/2023 15:57

I'm a single lady in my sixties and have very few female friends so made a vow to make extra efforts to try to make some.

Having chatted to a local divorcee in her early 50s a few times, I initially knew her through her job and then from bumping into her now and again and stopping for a chat. As she seemed to like me and we have things in common, I invited her to my house for Sunday lunch. I asked her if roast lamb and all the trimmings would be OK and her eyes lit up, and she said something like, "oooh yummy, that would be lovely!" She lives about a mile away and chose to walk to mine arriving at 1pm.

As you can imagine I was rushed off my feet all morning not just preparing all the food from scratch but tidying and cleaning the kitchen-diner and making everything nice for her.

Lunch was ready when she arrived so I served up and everything went perfectly. It took us about half an hour to eat the meal at a leisurely pace, she was all smiles and compliments and we chatted a little in between bites, she telling me about her two grown up children and four grandchildren. She complimented the food and my house and seemed to really enjoy my company. That is why what happened came as such a shock. As I was clearing away the plates, at 1.40pm she received a text message on her phone. She read it and stood up, smiling, and saying cheerily, "Oh, that was my son, he's already on his way to pick me up. Thank you for a lovely lunch!" Then she picked up her bag and collected her jacket and walked out of my front door to wait for her son's car.

I pretended to be all breezy and smiley and perfectly happy with her departure, but I wasn't really. She was here for literally 40 minutes. When we agreed the date she didn't say she would have to squeeze me into a busy schedule. She made no mention of having anything else to do on that day. I felt gutted because I had assumed it was an "open-ended" lunch in which we'd have dessert, then coffees, then sit around chatting and having a laugh and getting to know one another for a couple of hours. I imagined she'd offer to help with the dishes (which I would of course have refused).

As I tackled the pile of washing up I felt really upset, and even shed a couple of silly tears. What she did felt rather rude and I felt "used". Three hours preparing for her visit, and another hour clearing up, for 40 minutes of her company!

Had it been some kind of emergency of course I would not mind but I don't understand why she told her son to come and collect her at 1.40pm when she knew I'd gone to the trouble of a roast and "all the trimmings."

Isn't there a saying or proverb about "eating and running?"

This was a few weeks ago. We have since interacted on Facebook with lighthearted and witty comments on each others' walls, but she has not asked to meet up again. I'm sad because I really like her and she seemed to like me a lot.

AIBU?

Yes, you are BU -- it only takes 40 minutes to eat lunch so she was right to arrange collection at 1.40pm.

No, you are not BU - she was very rude leaving so quickly

OP posts:
Clymene · 07/05/2023 18:52

@SittingNextToIt - you're in a totally different life phase to the OP and her 'friend'. In 20 years' time, you may find yourself in the same position.

BadNomad · 07/05/2023 18:52

Thighlengthboots · 07/05/2023 18:41

Firstly the OP says she has friends, just no female ones so thats not the case.

Secondly, by the time you get to your 50s you usually have some idea about how its polite to say thank you to people when they make you meals and bring a token gift. Partly this is because you have seen others do it, its shown on tv, in books, in the media, in movies, you would have had time to attend many social events by your 5th decade to observe how society works and this woman has a son so presumably, most people in bringing up their children would teach them about manners and saying thank you etc (or maybe not- maybe he is as rude as his mother). Its ridiculous to suggest that after 50 years of living on planet earth you would have zero understanding of how society works so unless the lady is neuro diverse most people would have picked up this up by their 5th decade

so unless the lady is neuro diverse most people would have picked up this up by their 5th decade

Exactly. You don't know that she isn't ND. Plenty of people are, and plenty of them don't realise they are, so all this "everyone knows x,y and z" is incorrect. Because plenty of people don't know this stuff. Plenty of people can watch shows and read books and still not know this stuff. Plenty of people don't socialise. Even 50-year-olds with ex-husbands and children. Plenty of people go to lunches empty-handed without knowing it's "wrong" according to some people because no one has ever said anything to them. And there are plenty of people who don't expect their guests to bring a gift.

You just need to look at MN to see the number of people who do things other people think is rude because they don't realise other people think it is rude. People have their own rules about things and just assume everyone else has the same. Who pays for dinner on a date? If a guest brings you wine, do you open it? Is it ok to bring your other not-invited child to a birthday party at softplay if you pay for them yourself? There are many "rules" out there that people don't know, don't follow, or don't even agree on.

drpet49 · 07/05/2023 18:47

stbrandonsboat · 07/05/2023 16:03

She's a user. There are a lot of them out there.

This.

Maireas · 07/05/2023 18:47

Oh dear, OP - you're not a freak. Women are really not more complicated than men. We are just as diverse a group! You must get on ok with your house mates?.

ClarissaExplainsSome · 07/05/2023 18:46

Rude. Has she actually said she doesn't want to meet up again?

SittingNextToIt · 07/05/2023 18:46

Tabitha1960 · 07/05/2023 18:31

No she has never messaged to say thank you. She has not sent me any DM at all, just made humorous, lighthearted or complimentary comments on my Facebook wall, and I have done the same back to her.

I’m sorry if this comes across as upsetting but I’m finding all of it quite - intense. Not necessarily what you did - although I wasn’t there - but more what your thought process/headspace is saying and musing. This “need” to have a female friendship, having “friendship” as the goal post - setting out with the explicit intention that a friendship/significant social and reciprocal relationship is to result from your interactions with X - this stuff you see is quite - intense to me.

I am 38. I have a very busy working life with a full on career, lovely colleagues who I meet socially frequently - as often as I can - given that I also have a 7 year old and 3 year old. At their various activities I also meet fellow parents - with whom we do couple meals out, lunches, occasional drinks.

But - are these “friendships” or rather “friendships” which were established with such an explicit intention to make friendships establish? No. These are people I have chanced upon - through work or kids - and we rub along fine - and peace all around.

I think this need/desire to establish friendships - and this becoming a goal post is possibly going to hinder you. I’d quit thinking of friendships and these goals of setting up friendships and just get on with life, work, hobbies etc.

Tabitha1960 · 07/05/2023 18:45

Swishhh · 07/05/2023 16:37

When I was short on friends I tried to make new ones and it was a bit like dating. I had lots of women over for lunch/coffee and met others out for coffee/lunch. Out of maybe 12 ‘dates’ I made 2 friends.
Try not to overthink this and next time stick to a coffee invite.

It's so interesting that you should say that, because some of the responses have made me start thinking, "blimey, it's just like dating, you have take things step by step and do the appropriate thing at the appropriate time."

I now see that, in my desperation to get a female friend I thought we could just jump straight into being mates who could spend hours together.

A male friend is coming to see me tomorrow, likely for the whole afternoon, and I am therefore reminded of how we became mates. It was a work thing. We were complete strangers, thrown together in a work setting for a whole 8 hours. There was almost nothing to do but chat to each other the whole day. We kept in touch and have met up a dozen times since (over 10 years), and because we live 50 miles apart when he visits he always spends the whole day here.

I think this is the kind of experience that has (mis)led me to think that this is an appropriate way to make a new friend. Clearly it is not and I am going to have to work harder at learning how to start things off properly so I don't put other women off.

OP posts:
daisymoonlight · 07/05/2023 18:43

BadNomad · 07/05/2023 18:36

Plenty of people don't understand social norms. And plenty of people don't follow them. So unless someone tells you "you must always bring a gift when going to lunch", you aren't automatically going to know to do that.

The gift on its own I could agree with but when you add this to her leaving after 40 mins plus not even texting thanks etc this shows a pattern and the simplest explanation is usually correct: she's just rude and not very pleasant.

Maireas · 07/05/2023 18:43

@Thighlengthboots - exactly this

Wormwoodgal · 07/05/2023 18:42

You sound lovely and she sounds graceless!
I have recently moved and am making some lovely new female friends. When I meet someone and think we may get along I suggest meeting in a cafe for tea/coffee, and we take it from there. I make sure I'm not the one issuing the invitation each time, and then if we hit it off we'll have more cafe meetings, then an invitation to come to my place (or theirs) for tea/coffee. This ensures that the new friendship is on equal terms, and has worked a treat so far.
Don't give up! Keep on being lovely and you will find some good friends!

TuttiFrutti · 07/05/2023 18:42

She was very rude, no question. Rude not to bring a gift (bottle of wine minimum, and preferably with flowers as well if someone cooks you a meal), and VERY rude to leave after just 40 minutes. Rude not to send a thank you too.

Maireas · 07/05/2023 18:42

BadNomad · 07/05/2023 18:36

Plenty of people don't understand social norms. And plenty of people don't follow them. So unless someone tells you "you must always bring a gift when going to lunch", you aren't automatically going to know to do that.

So this person has had no life experiences that would indicate that? Must have been very sheltered. I have a brother with autism, he learns phrases and polite behaviour. He was once invited to a wedding and I explained what to do and how to behave. He wrote down all the tips on small index cards and kept them in his jacket. This woman must have quite serious problems.
Or is just rude

LDA123 · 07/05/2023 18:42

You are definitely not being unreasonable, it was very rude on her part. At least you will know never to invite her again.

watcherintherye · 07/05/2023 18:41

Sorry I haven’t read the entire thread, but

a) Why did her son need to pick her up, if she is local to you?

b) I think I’d be a bit nonplussed if someone I hardly knew invited me to lunch. I might say yes, out of politeness, then start wondering what the agenda was (I know yours was just to become friends, but usually the process is more…organic than your approach, as I know you’ve acknowledged).

c) Just to say, the U3A is a brilliant organisation with a wide range of interest groups and great for getting to know people. There are branches everywhere!

Thighlengthboots · 07/05/2023 18:41

BadNomad · 07/05/2023 18:34

Why what is it about being 50 and married that means you have lunches in other people's houses?

The OP even says herself she's new to making friends.

Firstly the OP says she has friends, just no female ones so thats not the case.

Secondly, by the time you get to your 50s you usually have some idea about how its polite to say thank you to people when they make you meals and bring a token gift. Partly this is because you have seen others do it, its shown on tv, in books, in the media, in movies, you would have had time to attend many social events by your 5th decade to observe how society works and this woman has a son so presumably, most people in bringing up their children would teach them about manners and saying thank you etc (or maybe not- maybe he is as rude as his mother). Its ridiculous to suggest that after 50 years of living on planet earth you would have zero understanding of how society works so unless the lady is neuro diverse most people would have picked up this up by their 5th decade

LubaLuca · 07/05/2023 18:41

Who knows? It sounds like either she's rude and just wanted a good feed today, or she felt uncomfortable and made an excuse to leave.

I don't know how I'd feel having lunch that seemed to be progressing to a whole afternoon one on one with a stranger, but then I wouldn't accept the invitation to lunch for that very reason.

I'm swinging towards her being rude and a bit of a taker. She could have suggested meeting for a coffee in a café to allow you to suss each other out if she was unsure about lunch in your home.

WomanBitingATowel · 07/05/2023 18:41

Tabitha1960 · 07/05/2023 18:30

I think you are right, Saraclara. I could not see it at the time but I don't understand the process of making a new female friend (which is probably why I don't have many!)

On reflection I suppose I expected to start having the friendship straight away, spending a whole afternoon together as though we were already best mates. I feel rather lost in trying to work out what the rules of a "friendship courtship" are with women.

I note that quite a few respondents on here have called me "lonely". I didn't say that in my OP and I am not lonely. I am too busy to be lonely as I have a very absorbing and time-consuming job, plus I live in a houseshare with three others so there are always others about to chat to plus I have several really friends but they are all male. I find men very easy to get along with and very un-complicated.

It bothers me that I struggle to make friends with women; it makes me feel like a freak so I am making a special effort to make female friends.

But you are (I assume) a woman — you’re not making friends with a different species! Would you invite, or have you previously invited, a male slight acquaintance over for Sunday lunch, and how did that go? Did he spend several hours chatting and help with the washing up?

And surely, if you struggle to make friends, then you recognise that not all new acquaintances will translate into friends, hence it being better to not invest too much time and emotional energy into each new ‘trial’ encounter?

Un7breakable · 07/05/2023 18:40

I think Sunday lunch was a bit full on. I'd worry about Sunday lunch with an acquaintance. She probably arranged the pick up as a get out in case you ran out of conversation. She was rude not to have brought something or send a thank you though.

aloris · 07/05/2023 18:38

I think she was rude. She accepted your lunch invitation knowing she would be leaving as soon as she ate, so was just using you for free food. If she were genuine, I think she would have made the normal reciprocal invitation by now.

Based on the way she blew out of there right after getting her free lunch, I would suspect she's a user (in which case, you've dodged a bullet by finding out quickly). Or, she could be one of those people who are superficially charming and have a very busy social life, but have so many friends that they can never find time to make an effort for you. You only see them when YOU cater to them, ie. when you make the effort, cook the dinner, buy the concert tickets etc. And when they show up to these things, they are always charming but they hop right off afterward because their schedule is booked so solid. They are social butterflies. In their eyes, their presence in your life IS what they are giving you.

It kinda doesn't matter which of these two explanations it is. Either way, you are the one making the effort and spending your money and always feeling like an afterthought. Do you feel good about the social interaction you just had with her? If no, then there's no reason to repeat it.

You've learned something: first time with a new person, just coffee and a chat. See how it goes. That way you can also fit in more people to your schedule. Eventually you'll find a few people who are a "good match" for you.

Roussette · 07/05/2023 18:37

@Tabitha1960

You sound lovely! I would've enjoyed your roast lunch and brought flowers with me, and sent a warm thank you message for the delicious food.

She sounds a bit off

BadNomad · 07/05/2023 18:36

Maireas · 07/05/2023 18:32

Well unless she's never been invited anywhere ever, never been to a birthday party or a wedding, never read books, watched tv or been in a place of work, then there's really no excuse for not understanding social mores.

Plenty of people don't understand social norms. And plenty of people don't follow them. So unless someone tells you "you must always bring a gift when going to lunch", you aren't automatically going to know to do that.

BadNomad · 07/05/2023 18:34

Thighlengthboots · 07/05/2023 18:30

She's divorced and early 50s. I highly doubt she's never been to anyone's house for lunch before. Unless she lives under a rock.

Why what is it about being 50 and married that means you have lunches in other people's houses?

The OP even says herself she's new to making friends.

LoonyLois · 07/05/2023 18:34

I’d call her out on it I think.

Come over to mine I will be your friend. You sound lovely!

Maireas · 07/05/2023 18:34

Tabitha1960 · 07/05/2023 18:31

No she has never messaged to say thank you. She has not sent me any DM at all, just made humorous, lighthearted or complimentary comments on my Facebook wall, and I have done the same back to her.

It's all adding up. Coming empty handed, leaving abruptly, no word of thanks - just rude. She's not your friend, you sound lovely and there are loads of decent people out there. Ditch this one.

Frances0911 · 07/05/2023 18:32

It's extremely rude.
Next time you see her say hello great to see you, then say something like sorry I can't talk I'm in a rush, and keep it like that when ever you see her.