Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel the ‘social model of disability’ is being used against me?

67 replies

Ungratefulorwhat · 07/05/2023 11:26

Short version:
In education and work the words ‘social model of disability is trotted out at me a lot.
I’m being told that because adjustments (quite often the wrong ones) have been made, I’m “no longer disabled by impairment.” And “adjustments have already been made for you.”
So, I’m now not struggling because I’m disabled, just not good enough because I’m ‘impaired’ and that isn’t covered by the DDA?

With PIP and ESA I’m being told that as I’ve been awarded disability aids and a carer “Obviously the effects of your disabilities are now considerably reduced.” This seems to be relying on the same ‘social model.’
Absolutely they’re reduced, from unable to do everything, to unable to do quite enough to please anyone.

Is this a flaw in the ‘social model,’ it being abused, or something else?

OP posts:
storminamooncup · 07/05/2023 18:16

PS and its better to say 'adjustments' rather than 'reasonable adjustments' because the word reasonable tells the employer or educational institution: "just do the absolute minimum required by law". People should seek to go beyond what is reasonable and not just focus on the legality.

storminamooncup · 07/05/2023 18:14

itsgettingweird · 07/05/2023 17:12

What do they mean by impairment compared to disability?

My son has a disability. His disability causes impairments. It's those impairments he needs reasonable adjustments for. You'll never remove his disability because you don't suddenly stop having MS, or CP or MND or any of the 100's of other disabilities there are.

Well firstly, people identify in different ways. Some people prefer disabled over impairment, some prefer impairment over disabled. Some people prefer autistic or dyslexic, over either disabled or impairment. Some people don't even realise they meet the definition of disabled under the Equality Act.
The social model says we are disabled by society. We don't 'have' a disability, disability is something that is done to us. We are prevented from being able - society is DIS abling us. If that make sense. We still have our impairments though, and that's kind of why we say impairments.
But as I said above, we all have different ways of identifying and that's cool. You do you. There is no right or wrong. Some people don't like the social model at all and prefer the medical model. Again, you do you.

Daftnotstupid · 07/05/2023 17:20

The idea of the social model is that just because you have a diagnosis it doesn't mean it's a disability. MS is disabling but with the right aids, adaptations and attitudes an individual can live a long healthy happy and fulfilling life with the disease.

It's the same principles that PIP works under. They ask for how it affects you because a disease means nothing without knowing what impact it has on your life. One of my health conditions some call a disability but I don't because I accommodate for it in my daily life so for me it doesn't disable me to that extent. If I wanted to climb Everest sure it would be a disability and no level of accomodations would enable me to fulfil that ambition.

It's about rethinking attitudes to illness. The medical model makes you a victim because of your body or brain not working well. The social model empowers you and blames society for not supporting you.

itsgettingweird · 07/05/2023 17:12

What do they mean by impairment compared to disability?

My son has a disability. His disability causes impairments. It's those impairments he needs reasonable adjustments for. You'll never remove his disability because you don't suddenly stop having MS, or CP or MND or any of the 100's of other disabilities there are.

BumblingAlonggg · 07/05/2023 17:06

This is really shit and difficult OP, I'm so sorry. It's very hard.

storminamooncup · 07/05/2023 15:06

Happy to signpost to any organisations, including mine, who can train employers on disability and the social model if anyone feels their organisation needs it.

Gtsr443 · 07/05/2023 14:53

storminamooncup · 07/05/2023 13:27

Hi OP, I would disagree that the social model is to blame here. The approach they are taking doesn't appear to be the social model OP, its the medical model. They seem to be misunderstanding it, or perhaps you yourself are.
I'm disabled and a disability awareness trainer.
for those who don't know, there's the medical model of disability and the social model of disability.
The medical model of disability is like disability is a problem to be fixed eg by giving you a wheelchair, hearing aids, medication, and yes these are good things but you're still disabled.
How? By society. If you can't watch the coronation, is it because you are deaf or blind or because there are no captions, no BSL, or no audio description?
The social model says the latter.
You can be disabled by your environment or by attitudes. You are still disabled because the negative attitudes are still there, you are likely still going to experience barriers to travel, to employment, to promotion etc.
The issue here is not the approach, it is how that approach is interpreted.

Thank you so much for this. I have been having raging battles this week about my son's needs still being needs even if they are partially met. Their argument being that if the need is met it is no longer a need.

@smooththecat Absolutely agree.

Good luck with everything OP - and thank you for this thread.

pikkumyy77 · 07/05/2023 14:39

My very long comment was just eaten so forgive me if this one is a bit jumbled!

first: thank you so much for a very thought provoking thread.

second: I think there is a third, embedded, issue that goes beyond the medical vs social disability approach.

the embedded or occluded issue is , perhaps, the locus of responsibility for adjustments to the environment (wheelchair, ramp, table height) and the locus of responsibility for the quality of life afforded to the disabled person as a person vs as a worker.

on the first point what I mean is that the costs of the mechanical or social adjustments are borne, as they should be, by society/trusts/nhs/employers but each of these does so unwillingly with an eye to cost cutting. Why must OP wait until functioning is further degraded before getting an electric wheelchair? Why must OP —and others—be housebound until a personal carer can take them out? Wouldn’t it be more efficient to have a licensed disabled/elderly taxi system in place that would bring OP to the bus or to work?
the administrative cost of metering and means testing to ration care is almost always more than the money saved by preventing the “undeserving” from accessing the benefiit.

to my second point: there is a problematic focus on the OP as worker. The “job” of her supports is done if she can earn money/please employer regardless of the danger to her health and functioning. The description of the OP melting from the heat and endangering her health/completely needlessly in an office environment, should remind us that the worker’s right to a safe workspace is always at risk. In reality no workspace would be safe for longterm work if workers didn’t fight for it. That is as true for ergonomic protections (which are good for every worker) as it is for protections against toxic exposures or contagion or spoiled food in the cafeteria.
so at that point disability rights are just a subset of worker’s rights to a safe productive environment that does not further degrade the worker’s health or quality of life.

LangClegsInSpace · 07/05/2023 14:00

Sorry, I'm aware I'm basically ignoring your original question about the social model, just dropping in some sources of support:

Disability Law Service have a helpline and can help with initial advice for employment issues (they can provide full support to tribunal if you're in the London area):

https://dls.org.uk/our-services/employment/

Disability Rights UK have a student helpline:

https://www.disabilityrightsuk.org/disabled-students-helpline

Ungratefulorwhat · 07/05/2023 13:52

storminamooncup you're hitting the nail on the head with The issue here is not the approach, it is how that approach is interpreted

OP posts:
Ungratefulorwhat · 07/05/2023 13:50

Choconut The table is the thing that has brought it all to a head and given them a reason to say I'm now currently unfit for work, but the whole 'we have already made adjustments for you, so you shouldn't be 'blaming' disability for what are clearly impairment thus questionable capability issues' is a troubling theme.

So many useful, and interesting responses to original question of the social model and how it's being used, as well as the problems it's leaving me with personally, and how it relates to ESA/PIP procedures.

Apologies it's moved faster than I can type to answer all, (didn't expect a big response TBH!) but all are read and appreciated. I have to go out, but will be back in a few hours

OP posts:
Baggingarea · 07/05/2023 13:38

I do sometimes find myself wondering if the social model really only caters to people who need to use a chair but are otherwise unaffected. My disability means I have some symptoms which cannot be catered for.

Choconut · 07/05/2023 13:33

Ungratefulorwhat · 07/05/2023 13:18

I realize it's too late now, but surely the cheap and cheerful answer would be change, or let me change, the workstation legs so i wasn't getting injuries in the first place, rather than have someone who could stand and frequently alter their position (so not suffer injury) be instructed by me to do the job..

Really what they should be doing is listening and being led by you, not telling you what you need and exactly how helpful it must be for you.

The table seems to be your biggest bugbear, is that right? I think you have to just put your foot down and say you NEED this and keep politely insisting that the alternative doesn't work for you.

I was just saying the other day on a thread, that I'd been reading an interview with travel presenter Ade Adepitan who is in a wheelchair and he was saying the lengths he and the team went to to get him to be able to do interviews on some mud islands - I think it was in Bangladesh. All you want is a flipping table that's the right height for you - honestly I think this is a hill worth dying on.

Ungratefulorwhat · 07/05/2023 13:29

LangClegsInSpace Thank you for breaking that down! They've been using this 'social model' to say that I have an impairment, and society then disables me, and they have addressed the disability part of it, so we're just down to me being impaired causing problems.

No reason at all not to change legs on workstation, other that 'we have these three heights' two are disability heights, so you've had reasonable adjustments.

no occupational health, no union.

Education lot doing something almost identical, both referring to social model.

I didn't include this in my OP as I wanted to look at this whole 'social model of disability' stuff, but having damaged myself using the workstation, I've been told I have to get myself a fit note, and sign on to UC for now. (they are going to use the person they had me instruct!)

I suspect I'm about to lose the work, and am about to go through the whole ESA journey all over again under the UC rules, and after my last experiencing of "obviously the effects of your disabilities are now considerably reduced" because you have this equipment and help, am very worried, and trying to understand what exactly is going on with it all.

OP posts:
storminamooncup · 07/05/2023 13:27

Hi OP, I would disagree that the social model is to blame here. The approach they are taking doesn't appear to be the social model OP, its the medical model. They seem to be misunderstanding it, or perhaps you yourself are.
I'm disabled and a disability awareness trainer.
for those who don't know, there's the medical model of disability and the social model of disability.
The medical model of disability is like disability is a problem to be fixed eg by giving you a wheelchair, hearing aids, medication, and yes these are good things but you're still disabled.
How? By society. If you can't watch the coronation, is it because you are deaf or blind or because there are no captions, no BSL, or no audio description?
The social model says the latter.
You can be disabled by your environment or by attitudes. You are still disabled because the negative attitudes are still there, you are likely still going to experience barriers to travel, to employment, to promotion etc.
The issue here is not the approach, it is how that approach is interpreted.

Ungratefulorwhat · 07/05/2023 13:18

I realize it's too late now, but surely the cheap and cheerful answer would be change, or let me change, the workstation legs so i wasn't getting injuries in the first place, rather than have someone who could stand and frequently alter their position (so not suffer injury) be instructed by me to do the job..

OP posts:
smooththecat · 07/05/2023 13:14

Interesting, thanks for posting. I don’t know anything about this. It seems obvious to me that unless it’s a motorised wheelchair, it’s not really possible to move around much, you’d have to be incredibly fit and athletic to do so.

I have long-term chronic illness that impacts my energy levels significantly. There’s no help for me. At the moment I just muddle through working part-time, underemployed, and on those days I can’t do anything else at all, sometimes even feed myself. It’s not a life and at my worst my significant skills and training were wasted, I had to leave an in-demand/shortage profession. I’m better than I used to be though, and hoping to work in a less ridiculous profession in future.

The human is gone out of these systems. It’s awful.

Ungratefulorwhat · 07/05/2023 13:11

MayBeeJuneSoon
That's not a solution it's a list of 'don't wants'
OK, I thought it was a list of possible solutions as each
of those things would change the position for both sides, but I can see I just appear to be whinging.

OP posts:
LangClegsInSpace · 07/05/2023 13:05

The Equality Act protects you from disability discrimination because you have an impairment:

(1) A person (P) has a disability if—

(a) P has a physical or mental impairment, and

(b) the impairment has a substantial and long-term adverse effect on P's ability to carry out normal day-to-day activities.

https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2010/15/contents

Part of that protection is that your employer is obliged to take such steps as it is reasonable to have to take to avoid the disadvantage you face compared with a person with no disability.

Part of what your employer must consider when deciding whether an adjustment is reasonable is how effective the change will be in avoiding the disadvantage you would otherwise experience.

https://www.equalityhumanrights.com/en/multipage-guide/what-meant-reasonable

They can't just chuck random adjustments at the situation and hope for the best, especially as you have yourself identified an adjustment that would help.

Here's an example of an employer who enthusiastically made some 'reasonable' adjustments for a disabled employee but failed to consult her and implemented the changes so badly that the employment appeal tribunal said their actions constituted unlawful harassment on disability grounds:

https://www.bailii.org/uk/cases/UKEAT/2017/0093_17_0911.html

Is there a reason why a workstation at a suitable height for you would not work? (you mentioned it had specialist equipment on it)

Have you had an occupational health assessment and is your employer following their recommendations?

Are you in a union?

namechanger563 · 07/05/2023 13:02

@Ungratefulorwhat

"Recognizing that I know how to reduce worst effects on myself, instead of insisting they know what will and wont work for me."

This. We know what works and doesn't because it is our bodies and disabilities that we live with. Other people come along and think they have solved the problem with their own solutions, then they get frustrated and angry because nothing they do is right. They need to listen and work with us. We already know what we need.

MayBeeJuneSoon · 07/05/2023 13:01

That's not a solution it's a list of 'don't wants'

Daftnotstupid · 07/05/2023 13:00

Have you any experience of trying to actually put this in place? You made it sound so easy.

Yes.

Daftnotstupid · 07/05/2023 13:00

That's not really a solution it's still a complaint.

Unpicking it you want to do your job not instruct a support worker to do it for you. In which case can you work with an employment specialist - there are some attached to charities for various disabilities as well as the DWP - have a frank conversation about the type of work you can do

namechanger563 · 07/05/2023 13:00

Daftnotstupid · 07/05/2023 12:36

That's when you use the DDA to your advantage and go via access to work and ACAS to get the structure in place to facilitate you to work.

If you truly cannot work under any circumstances then you can be signed off and there are claimable benefits to support with this.

Have you any experience of trying to actually put this in place? You made it sound so easy.

I'm 10 yrs in to my journey of being disabled and working full time. The employer I was with for 7 years and promoted multiple times made me 'redundant' after I asked for a lighter laptop they would only issue to homeworkers as an adjustment.

Then another employer called me a dalek for not being able to manage stairs and made me redundant a few months later.

Then I stupidly asked for a fan at another job, because the heat was interfering with my medication - stick on pain relief patches. I was getting too hot and overdosing. Which could have been fatal. They refused to provide a fan, refused to let me use one I bought myself and refused to do anything about the temperature. Then made me redundant.

I've just asked my current employer if I can park in the directors only car park because I cannot cope any more with the alternative on street parking arrangements for the rest of the staff. They've so far said that it won't solve my problems (without asking me anything about why I think it will) and they are taking legal advice. If they wanted to say yes and let me use the car park, they don't need legal advice for it. I'm expecting to loose my job again over this now too.

Reasonable adjustments are a legal requirement but no one polices it. So many employers behave so badly that the only way for me to succeed is to try and blend in and ask for as little as possible.

Ungratefulorwhat · 07/05/2023 12:57

Off the top of my head.

OP posts: