Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think our 15 year old does NOT need a bedtime.

155 replies

NotTonightDeidre · 07/05/2023 09:16

This is a source of much disagreement in our house.

DH thinks teen should have a strict bedtime.

I do not.

He thinks I'm in the minority and that all the parents of teens around us are enforcing bedtimes on their teenage offspring (even at weekends).

I believe that most will be allowing their teens a lwcel of autonomy - especially at weekends.

Who's right? What do you do if you have teens?

OP posts:
Guiltridden12345 · 07/05/2023 13:12

I think it would be a brilliant social experiment for those ‘self regulating’ teens to be asked to go to bed an hour earlier, and see what the consequences are. We live in quite an academically pushy environment - think kumon and tutors etc - but liberal parenting. I can’t help thinking that an hour earlier to bed would help the kids to achieve the academic success the parents so obviously want and save a lot of money! I’m sure tired kids are fine, but imagine how much more/happier/successful they’d be with more sleep?

Teens are not known for their self regulation. many adults I know can’t resist the ping of a phone/watch/gaming, what chance does an undeveloped teen brain have?

Very interested in the unanimous teacher input. They are very much in the firing line of the sleeplessness epidemic.

SparklyBlackKitten · 07/05/2023 13:12

@WomblingTree86 teenage brains and self regulation dont go hand in hand. Their brains are just not wired that way yet. For me I have been a night owl since birth. Still am. But since op said her kid struggled to wake up for school etc indicates that he could benefit from boundaries.

Boundaries. Rules. Etc. Just normal things. The kid is only 15. They still need to be parented

HecticHedgehog · 07/05/2023 13:10

I think it depends entirely on the individual. My eldest didn't have a bedtime from around 14. They were very sensible and able to self regulate. My current two teens still have set bedtimes at 13 and 16 as they have asd and wouldn't go to bed until the early hours.

mummymeister · 07/05/2023 13:04

my children stopped having bed times from when they were 11 and went to senior school. same as I stopped nagging them about their rooms, what they ate etc. they need the responsibility of self regulation. all of them are happy, healthy, not overweight and self reliant. my mother insisted on restricting food, dictating bed times and waking up times etc and I was never going to be that parent. My experience is that they learn to manage their time better. yes, some nights they would stay up late because there was unfinished homework or a book they wanted to read even being awake after we went to bed but similarly there were nights when they toddled off at 7.30pm because they had an exciting day or weekend coming up.

Laurama91 · 07/05/2023 13:01

We used to get send upstairs at 9 but left to our own decision. My dad would make sure we got up for school and if we were tired it was our fault and we learnt

WomblingTree86 · 07/05/2023 12:58

SparklyBlackKitten · 07/05/2023 12:51

You want no bedtime for a 15 yo?
I would have been up until 3am if my parents would have let me have no bedtime.

Teens need rules. And they need their parents to parent them. Meet your dh in the middle and make schoolnights 10pm bedtime. And no electronics obvs

Just because you couldn't regulate yourself at 15, it doesn't mean no other 15-year-old can. There's no harm in seeing if they can be trusted to go to bed at a reasonable hour. You can always impose rules if they don't but by that age many will be quite capable of circumventing strict rules and not sleeping if they don't want to anyway. It's better to come to an agreement in many cases.

SparklyBlackKitten · 07/05/2023 12:51

You want no bedtime for a 15 yo?
I would have been up until 3am if my parents would have let me have no bedtime.

Teens need rules. And they need their parents to parent them. Meet your dh in the middle and make schoolnights 10pm bedtime. And no electronics obvs

BertieBotts · 07/05/2023 12:50

He already takes melatonin. I would like to watch TV series with him or do a puzzle. We do already cut screens at 8:30, I don't find for myself they interfere with my sleep though. I know it's supposed to but it's not my experience.

He did used to find it really difficult to get up and would sleep through his alarm, so I'm not convinced that changing the alarm will have made that much difference TBH.

Ineedsleeprightnow · 07/05/2023 12:33

Two teenagers here… strict weekday bedtime of 10pm, no Technology after 9pm, weekends more relaxed. They need sleep to enable them to focus at school.

Tbf mine are doing sports most evenings so are ready for bed by 10pm. Weekends are full of sports also so they tend to be in bed by 11pm.

DriedFlowersLiveForever · 07/05/2023 12:29

I was the teenager with the 9pm bedtime (even at16/17!) I missed out on so much and promised myself I would never inflict that on my kids.
I remember someone in my class talking about Red Dwarf and I genuinely had no clue what they were on about, it started at 9pm from what I remember so I had never seen any of it. The embarrassment of everyone in my year realising I had a 9pm bedtime still stings to this day!
My 13 and 16 year old have set their own bedtime from yr7 of high-school. The rule is they need to get enough sleep to function when their alarm goes off at 6am......if they stay up late they suffer the tiredness. We have had no problems with this so far so everyone is happy.

rattymol · 07/05/2023 12:26

SummerLover01 · 07/05/2023 09:22

A 15 yo needs 8 - 9hrs sleep a night according to various sources.

You need to make sure this happens, especially midweek. If left to their own devices our teens would be up to all hours and end up getting way less sleep than that!

They do need up to nine hours. But the parents sending their teenagers to bed at nine must be expecting them to get up at six am.

redbigbananafeet · 07/05/2023 11:47

Your child is not getting enough sleep and struggles to get up for school in the morning. Surely that's all the information you need to realise you need to give your child a bedtime?

unsync · 07/05/2023 11:45

Schooldays yes, weekends a bit later. Teenagers need sleep. There's research about teenage brains - google it.

Namechangedagain20 · 07/05/2023 11:36

BibbleandSqwauk · 07/05/2023 09:21

Well I teach teenagers and despair at how knackered and unable to focus some of them are. When questioned, those are the ones who have phones in their rooms and no real bedtime, scrolling and responding to snaps etc at any point through the night. Mine are early teen / tween and have a bedtime of 9.30-10.15 ish on school nights, no tech in rooms overnight and I can't see that changing. Weekends are maybe an hour or so later but not too much.

This! The amount of kids I’ve taught who are up at all hours playing fortnite or on Snapchat. They’re too exhausted to focus properly the next day. Schools nights they absolutely need a bedtime. Teens aren’t exactly known for making sensible decisions. DHs mum never enforced their bedtime (even in primary!) and he is strict with bedtimes for our DC as he’s aware of how much it effects them the next day. If you have teens who are taking themselves off to bed by 10 I’d say it’s fine, but I’d be sending a school age teen to bed by 10 and lights off by 11 if they haven’t already. Teens need more sleep than you think.

Once in college or sixth form I would still be encouraging them to go to bed at a sensible time.

Paq · 07/05/2023 11:34

If he can't self regulate then yes, he needs a bedtime. Split the difference between you/your DH's times and crack on.

WomblingTree86 · 07/05/2023 11:32

JusthereforXmas · 07/05/2023 11:22

My kids have had bedtimes and where good sleeper all through.

I had a bedtime all through childhood.

We where raised 'right'.

We are still naturally 'night owls' though, its fuck all to do with parenting in fact in biology we where be designed to be awake evening and night rather than morning (which was the safest time to sleep with fewest active predators).

Since when were humans nocturnal? I somehow doubt that caveman slept during daylight and wandered around hunting/gathering at night.

2chocolateoranges · 07/05/2023 11:29

By 15 we allowed oUr 2 to choose their own bedtime on the condition they got up no problems in the mornings for school.

dd knew when she was tired so was normally in bed for 10. Ds needs very little sleep so most nights I was in bed and sleeping before him.

they need I learn to regulate and take some steps to independence and we thought giving them this starting point was a good place.

we did ask that hey were in their bedrooms by 10.00pm to give us an hour to ourselves before we went to bed.

WomblingTree86 · 07/05/2023 11:29

I think 15 years is a bit old for a strict, imposed bedtime. Children should be able to regulate themselves by that age although I would nag them to turn the lights off and perhaps give me the phone if they weren't in bed by the time I was (around 11 p.m.). Ultimately you can't make them sleep though. Even if you take away their phone, they could probably find something else to do. I used to read a book or maybe do last minute homework.

CatchYouOnTheFlippetyFlop · 07/05/2023 11:25

My 14yo gets till 11pm weeknights. All devices removed from the bedroom.

Midnight-ish at weekends, not really fast and hard on that rule tho. Still all devices removed for the night when they go to bed.

JusthereforXmas · 07/05/2023 11:22

rattymol · 07/05/2023 11:07

If you have parented them properly then 15 year olds don't need a bedtime. Going to sleep at a sensible time is a skill you need to teach them.

My kids have had bedtimes and where good sleeper all through.

I had a bedtime all through childhood.

We where raised 'right'.

We are still naturally 'night owls' though, its fuck all to do with parenting in fact in biology we where be designed to be awake evening and night rather than morning (which was the safest time to sleep with fewest active predators).

hereiamagainn · 07/05/2023 11:21

”bedtime” no, but I think a rule about lights out before midnight is reasonable. Otherwise teens might be up all night playing games and completely mess up their sleep cycle.

Choconutty · 07/05/2023 11:19

I think there should be guidelines, and as long as they're being fairly well adhered to, and there is no fuss or bother created for anyone, then a 15 year old should be left to manage their own bedtime.

IF however there is difficulty getting them out of bed, or they're keeping the house up mooching around, or they're not keeping up with their work, then the guidelines become rules.

It's what I do with mine (although a few years off 15 yet) - as long as everyone is being reasonable, and considerate, and not neglecting things they should be doing then I'm flexible. The moment there's a problem, the hammer comes down (luckily, that is an extremely rare occurrance)

icanneverthinkofnc · 07/05/2023 11:18

rattymol · 07/05/2023 11:06

I can't believe those who say their teenager has a bedtime of nine.

Lol.. I had a 9pm bedtime a teen, my friend had 6.30!

JusthereforXmas · 07/05/2023 11:18

Of course they need a bedtime... mine would be up until 5am if we didn't tell him to switch the games off.

While he does stay up a bit later on weekends its not a free for all, if we let him stay up all night friday/saturday it would fuck up his body clock for the whole week.

After school age no but while they are GCSE age yes, you are their mother.

Unless your one of the parents with an early bird kid that takes themselves by choice to bed at 8pm and is up at 5am (only ever known 1 like that though, bloody weird lol).

tallcypowder · 07/05/2023 11:17

Nomoreminieggs · 07/05/2023 10:27

@tallcypowder stepson has been like this every since I've known him at 8 years old.

I have a 14 year old son. He is nothing like this and I would not out up ewith him ruining my sleep, potentially waking the 4 year old, demanding I feed him and having no manners, being awake all night and spoiling everyone's day by staying in bed until 2pm.

It's not inexperience. It's basic boundaries and respect.

If you say so. How does it spoil your day teens otten do their own thing ?

Agree not fair waking 4 year old up though or being noisy if awake.