Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

OK for child to take, and play, a musical instrument?

145 replies

ThisOldThang · 07/05/2023 09:13

Is it ok for a child to bring and (loudly) play a musical instrument at a birthday party?

This has now happened at both my young childrens' birthday parties.

A child's parents have arrived with child + acoustic guitar and the child has loudly played the guitar in our living room when everybody is socialising.

The child appears to be on the spectrum and is very talented, but I don't think either of those things is a valid reason for inflicting loud, intrusive music onto everybody when you're attending a birthday party.

AIBU?

OP posts:
HecticHedgehog · 07/05/2023 16:06

rookiemere · 07/05/2023 14:16

Well if I wasn't the host I wouldn't have made a big thing of it, but I genuinely struggle to heat when there is more than one noise source in a room. I'm only 53 so I'm a bit embarrassed about it, in these circumstances I'd probably just leave earlier than I had planned.

And the asd child possibly does too. It's very hard to process when several people are having conversations and there's lots going on. Their way of controlling that stress and anxiety is by controlling situations. It's not ideal, obviously. It sounds like Op hasn't even told his parents it's an issue or had a conversation with them around it about how it's annoying others. No one is psychic.

HecticHedgehog · 07/05/2023 15:59

Grimbelina · 07/05/2023 13:52

HecticHedgehog there really is no compromise other than the invited child plays in another room (if this is suitable, not a one bedroom flat etc.) if the family hosting and child having the birthday don't want to listen them all afternoon. Otherwise the child just doesn't go.

My ASD childs' needs really don't trump those of the birthday child, they really don't!

Nobody said they do.

electriclight · 07/05/2023 15:15

It sounds as if you have a plan to deal with it op, so that's good.

But please do understand that rude and contrary are often traits of autism. If he's clever, he'll learn to mask and copy others so that he 'fits in' but he is only 8 so still learning.

Parents will be having so many battles behind the scenes that they'll be letting some things go or addressing them later.

235rssf · 07/05/2023 15:10

ThisOldThang · 07/05/2023 15:05

@235rssf

I've posted here to see if I'm being unreasonable. The poll is overwhelmingly against the guitar.

I'll be making is very clear, the next time we host, that the guitar isn't welcome.

but making it very clear is not talking to family. That's issuing ultimatums not working with the parents of a neurodiverse child. The guitar is a red herring, you remove the guitar and the child might just do something else and then what. If a family member is neurodiverse but you would like to continue inviting them to parties then a bit more negotiation and discussion might be necessary. The question in a way is why has there been so little discussion of this between all you guys. It's sounds a tad black and white.....

ThisOldThang · 07/05/2023 15:05

@235rssf

I've posted here to see if I'm being unreasonable. The poll is overwhelmingly against the guitar.

I'll be making is very clear, the next time we host, that the guitar isn't welcome.

OP posts:
235rssf · 07/05/2023 15:03

I wonder why you havent spoken to the parents. Has this only happened twice? Or more than that. I would caution against making judgements about parenting a neurodiverse child. However and again if this is family - why is no one talking to each other, why is there so much judgement

SummerCycling · 07/05/2023 14:43

ThisOldThang · 07/05/2023 09:13

Is it ok for a child to bring and (loudly) play a musical instrument at a birthday party?

This has now happened at both my young childrens' birthday parties.

A child's parents have arrived with child + acoustic guitar and the child has loudly played the guitar in our living room when everybody is socialising.

The child appears to be on the spectrum and is very talented, but I don't think either of those things is a valid reason for inflicting loud, intrusive music onto everybody when you're attending a birthday party.

AIBU?

Totally selfish and inappropriate behaviour. I agree that asd doesn't justify playing a loud instrument and ruining other people's birthday parties.

I would not invite that child to parties in future because it sounds like parties are too stressful for him/her if they need to constantly play a loud instrument to get through them

Instead of inviting them to a party, I'd invite him/her separately for tea or something calm with fewer people to make sure they're not left out (which could feel a bit mean otherwise considering the asd) and hopefully more at ease so won't need to keep making a racket.

I think the parents are being irresponsible and opening up their child to being avoided, which is sad.

ReadersD1gest · 07/05/2023 14:37

BeerBot · 07/05/2023 14:36

Although it's a young child's birthday. I'm not sure it's a children's party.
OP has said the guitar playing child is disturbing people chatting and socialising. No mention of not joining in with the children.

Oh, ok.

ThisOldThang · 07/05/2023 14:36

I'm not livid.

I do think the parents are unreasonable for doing this twice in a matter of weeks.

I don't think they're doing the child any favours by raising him without appropriate boundaries / social education.

I don't think it's a coping mechanism. I think it's a symptom of him being devoid of empathy and having a dislike of conversations that involve other people's interests.

Incidentally, a cousin is deaf and wears processors, but wasn't present yesterday - we were told the child was ill, but perhaps it was due to the ubiquitous guitar?

OP posts:
BeerBot · 07/05/2023 14:36

ReadersD1gest · 07/05/2023 14:23

God, sometimes the "compromise" is - if you can't join in with the other children at a child's birthday party, don't go 🙄
Maybe the parents need to take him to the park instead.

Although it's a young child's birthday. I'm not sure it's a children's party.
OP has said the guitar playing child is disturbing people chatting and socialising. No mention of not joining in with the children.

235rssf · 07/05/2023 14:26

ThisOldThang · 07/05/2023 14:18

I think the child does it to prevent everybody else chatting, but not to get attention/praise for themselves.

As I previously said, the child is very spoilt and can be incredibly rude. The child delights in being contrarian and saying things designed to offend.

I think the root cause is ultimately (very high functioning) autism, but the child is very intelligent and is easily capable of understanding social rules that are explained to them. I do blame the parents for not explaining and enforcing how to behave - i.e. this is Child X's birthday and it isn't appropriate to take your guitar.

The child has been attending family events since birth and the guitar was a birthday present last year, so I know it isn't an' essential coping mechanism', as some people insist it to be.

So what you are saying is that the child is neurodiverse - seems to find lots of people chatting difficult to handle and is using music as a coping mechanism? So at the root cause - this is their way of handling such noisy and complex social situations? Whilst I get that this is annoying - wouldnt having a chat with the parents and attempt to be sympathetic be more useful? The kid is clearly using guitar/music as a coping mechanism, the fact that they've only had it for a few months doesnt change that. What I find odd is that this is family and you know they are neurodiverse but you just seem livid at them

ReadersD1gest · 07/05/2023 14:23

God, sometimes the "compromise" is - if you can't join in with the other children at a child's birthday party, don't go 🙄
Maybe the parents need to take him to the park instead.

Hankunamatata · 07/05/2023 14:23

If its a family birthday just send them up to a bedroom to play

AngryBirdsNoMore · 07/05/2023 14:21

If they’re family, have you spoken to the parents about the fact it makes it hard to chat and hear anything else?

ThisOldThang · 07/05/2023 14:18

HecticHedgehog · 07/05/2023 13:44

That's a great alternative :)

Op hasn't said the child demands everyone listens to them. Someone already asked and she didn't respond to them but did others so presumably they aren't.

As I said in my first post, I'm sure a comprise could be found, I haven't said it's acceptable the child disrupts everyone. But I'm sure a way around it can be found so everyone is happy (like in your post).

Although tbh if they were my family I wouldn't be visiting at all as it's clear OP is very uneducated about neurodiversity and is only interested in parent blaming.

I think the child does it to prevent everybody else chatting, but not to get attention/praise for themselves.

As I previously said, the child is very spoilt and can be incredibly rude. The child delights in being contrarian and saying things designed to offend.

I think the root cause is ultimately (very high functioning) autism, but the child is very intelligent and is easily capable of understanding social rules that are explained to them. I do blame the parents for not explaining and enforcing how to behave - i.e. this is Child X's birthday and it isn't appropriate to take your guitar.

The child has been attending family events since birth and the guitar was a birthday present last year, so I know it isn't an' essential coping mechanism', as some people insist it to be.

OP posts:
rookiemere · 07/05/2023 14:17

hear not heat Blush

rookiemere · 07/05/2023 14:16

Well if I wasn't the host I wouldn't have made a big thing of it, but I genuinely struggle to heat when there is more than one noise source in a room. I'm only 53 so I'm a bit embarrassed about it, in these circumstances I'd probably just leave earlier than I had planned.

electriclight · 07/05/2023 14:09

"Keeping one DC calm at an event that it doesn't sound like he wants to be at anyway could be causing a lot of distress to the other attendees."

You are quite right but as op didn't mention that anyone was distressed, I assumed it was more of an annoyance than a case of other nd adults and children being forced to suffer.

Really, I think this does not have to be a big deal and is mainly miscommunication.

The child takes pride and comfort in playing, and does not understand the social cues that suggest it might not be appropriate.

His parents think Aunty understands that he is autistic and doesn't seem to mind, and also that he needs social experiences.

Aunty is annoyed but doesn't say or do anything to suggest this.

So surely can easily be sorted?

But of course mn needs a raging, insensitive villain to kick so the parents must be thoughtless show-off types with an obnoxious kid.

CovertImage · 07/05/2023 14:02

Clymene · 07/05/2023 10:17

My autistic kid would bloody hate another kid playing a guitar loudly and would have to leave.

What were you saying about inclusion @anon12093?

I know, "inclusion" BS. I cringe when I see that word these days

Grimbelina · 07/05/2023 13:52

HecticHedgehog there really is no compromise other than the invited child plays in another room (if this is suitable, not a one bedroom flat etc.) if the family hosting and child having the birthday don't want to listen them all afternoon. Otherwise the child just doesn't go.

My ASD childs' needs really don't trump those of the birthday child, they really don't!

WimpoleHat · 07/05/2023 13:48

I think that is quite rude actually. You go to a party to participate not to willfully do your own thing, disrupting everyone else.

Spot on. Very rude and attention seeking.

HecticHedgehog · 07/05/2023 13:46

@ReadersD1gest I have never said it isn't an issue. I have never said it's acceptable. I've tried to explain why it might be happening (a coping mechanism for the child) and said I'm sure a comprise could be found.

HecticHedgehog · 07/05/2023 13:44

ShowUs · 07/05/2023 13:35

If a child was coping by having a blanket, or a quiet fidget toy, or needing some time alone in a quiet room for a part of the party would you still say they're getting nothing out of going so should stay at home? Or is it only the inconvenient disabled kids that you think should be excluded?

I know a few people who use drumming as a way of self regulating.
It is great that they have this as it genuinely makes a massive difference.

But they cannot take a drum kit everywhere they go and start playing whenever they start deregulating as it’s just not physically possible.

They do have a mini foam drumstick/pencil that they will use to tap whenever needed.
It is practically silent and can fit in their pocket.

If it is annoying anyone else then they need to stop or do it elsewhere.
They do not ever expect the entire room to stop everything to listen to them drumming.

That's a great alternative :)

Op hasn't said the child demands everyone listens to them. Someone already asked and she didn't respond to them but did others so presumably they aren't.

As I said in my first post, I'm sure a comprise could be found, I haven't said it's acceptable the child disrupts everyone. But I'm sure a way around it can be found so everyone is happy (like in your post).

Although tbh if they were my family I wouldn't be visiting at all as it's clear OP is very uneducated about neurodiversity and is only interested in parent blaming.

ReadersD1gest · 07/05/2023 13:44

HecticHedgehog · 07/05/2023 13:37

@ReadersD1gest

Who said he was forced to go? It's a family event. Plenty of autistic people do actually like to see family and socialise. Although no doubt we will get a drip feed shortly anyway.

It's not ludicrous at all. Both are coping mechanisms it's just one disturbs you and one doesn't. Hence why I said in my OP I'm sure a compromise could be reached. He isn't in a cinema or a restaurant, he's visiting his own family who I would assume love him and want him to be there. I mean if you can't compromise when it comes to trying to make sure your own family members can be included rather than excluded.... well.

But op (who is his family and undoubtedly loves him) doesn't want him playing his guitar when she's hosting her child's party 🤷🏻‍♀️Confused
It clearly is an issue, however much you declare it isn't.
A compromise maybe that he sits in a completely separate room from everyone else to play, or in the garden, but that kind of gives the lie to him wanting to be there in the first place?

HecticHedgehog · 07/05/2023 13:37

@ReadersD1gest

Who said he was forced to go? It's a family event. Plenty of autistic people do actually like to see family and socialise. Although no doubt we will get a drip feed shortly anyway.

It's not ludicrous at all. Both are coping mechanisms it's just one disturbs you and one doesn't. Hence why I said in my OP I'm sure a compromise could be reached. He isn't in a cinema or a restaurant, he's visiting his own family who I would assume love him and want him to be there. I mean if you can't compromise when it comes to trying to make sure your own family members can be included rather than excluded.... well.